HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Spyckie

295 karma · joined January 27, 2008

A college student in the Information Systems department at CMU.
submissionscomments
Spyckie··on Giles Bowkett: Summon Monsters? Open The Door? Heal? Or Die?
Yes, this is the gist of it.

The other aspect is that he thinks there is only 1 type of source that's ok for information consumption, which is the type that spews out brilliance. All the other sources are worthless, including the people that never say anything meaningful and the people that say something brilliant once in a lifetime.

Spyckie··on You Can't Soak the Rich
Thanks, finally someone is pointing to real data rather than just waiving a magic wand in the air.
Spyckie··on Facebook Is Not Really That Special
Google is the 'ahha' tool for introverts. Facebook is the 'ahha' tool for extroverts.
Spyckie··on 40 percent of college students say their next computer purchase will be a Mac
Just wondering - is anyone else seeing this as an entrepreneur opportunity?

This seems to me to be more of a sense of dissatisfaction with the current (aesthetic, quality, speed, you-name-it) of the PC/laptop. The current mindset of the Windows laptop industry (cutting quality of parts and shoving tons of unneeded software on you to cut costs and improve short term sales) is killing the industry from the inside out, and Macs, although much more costly than an average PC laptop, values the satisfaction of the customer more than the price point.

Spyckie··on Disagreeing with Paul Graham
I'm not sure if I'm disagreeing, but what I perceive from the essay is slightly different than your central point.

For instance, if you titled the essay 'the inverse relationship between personal freedom and organization size', I don't think it would elicit such an outcry (or any attention whatsoever). Instead, you state that the loss of freedom makes going into large organizations a bad choice for certain groups of people (namely, programmers, because programming is about freedom).

The programming community is made up of many people with different backgrounds, mindsets, and interests. While I myself may program for the freedom to create things, I know other people who program for the fun of it, and others who program because its what they know how to do. All of these types of programmers exist in the startup community, because a startup can mean much more than just programming freedom to them (it can mean money, prestige, adventure, a challenge, etc). If I am disagreeing at all, I would only do so concerning the scope of people that 'programming freedom' applies to. I think only a small subset of the startup community really thinks this point is meaningful - the rest do not give it much weight.

I think the main point of the essay is to convince people to startup early in their careers, even out of college. (If 'you weren't meant to have a boss', what are you meant to do?) You back it up by saying that corporate culture, from your experience, does more harm than good from a startup's perspective (especially in the matter of programming), and you explore that line until you come up with a good model that explains why corporate culture is harmful in its essence.

In contrast, many people don't think that programming freedom is a powerful incentive to starting up early, and are disagreeing because that is the only evidence that you provide to back up your claim that 'you weren't meant to have a boss'.

Spyckie··on "There are no causes of poverty. It is the rest state..."
My mistake - I read the first two lines and that set the tone for the rest of the article. Those first two lines, though, have no relevance to the rest of the article. You can in no way argue that the lack of wealth (the definition of poverty stated in the article) is caused by a 'rest state of doing nothing' (also a definition of poverty in the article), which is what the first two lines imply.
Spyckie··on Take the Next Step, Paul
I think we need to look at the landscape of the startup community. If you didn't have to grow to survive, then it would be fair to say that the goal is to create opportunities for people to 'live as they should'. However, the fact is that it is hard to stay afloat if you don't grow. Growth, as defined by how big your company gets and how much market share it has, is also an indication of how long the company will last. Ideally, the bigger your company is, the more it can do, and the more market share your company has, the less your competitors have. This means that you need to grow in order to survive - otherwise your competitors will take the market share from you and leave you without a business.

If you manage your successful company like a startup all of its life, then you'll hit failure sooner because startups just have a higher chance of failure because of their risk taking nature. Corporate structure just carries along a lower inherent risk.

Spyckie··on "There are no causes of poverty. It is the rest state..."
This is a woefully ignorant article that fails to include any piece of evidence to back up these claims.

Take, for instance, many countries in Africa. What prevents these countries from not rising in the poverty ladder is not the lazy, dumb people of these countries.

First, they can't sell products to other countries because the majority of countries are land-locked, meaning they have no way to ship their goods out at a reasonable price. They don't have any ports in their country and the neighboring countries with ports are hostile or unsafe.

Second, wealth is not a stable commodity in these countries due to coups and constant political restructuring and military action. Even if you were a very hard ambitious worker, there is nothing you can do about external forces (read: rebels invading your home/shop and stealing all the wealth you have built up).

Third, little of Africa is actually arable, and Africa can't even become an agrarian society because there isn't really the resources for them to do so. And the resources that are valuable to the rest of the world that could generate money for African countries - like, oil and diamonds, become hotly contested and a source of conflict and instability, furthering reducing the value of storing wealth.

Take some time to learn about the world if you have a strong opinion on this matter.

Spyckie··on Coding Horror: Paul Graham's Participatory Narcissism
At one point in time I tried to optimize my writing style like this...

One other reason is that you have a touchy subject. Tell anyone they're doing the wrong thing (implicitly or unintentionally) and you'll get the same response. People are very sensitive about their own choices (stubborn), especially ones that are hard to defend rationally (religion, major, job, etc).

Spyckie··on I quit
I thought you had friends who were willing to help you out...

Take money from whoever you can - friends, families, and fools. You're not at the investor stage yet where people can eat you alive, and you can just refuse it if they try to. Keep well funded if you can; don't wait until you're out of cash, as investors know you'll be in a bind and will use it against you as much as they possibly can.

Taking money from friends would add motivation (or stress, but you seem like the type who can handle tight situations) and resolve to getting your startup off the ground, so I would recommend you pursue those initial starting funds.

Taking money from someone does make you responsible for that money, but doesn't make him your boss. They're called investors precisely because they give you money and hope to make a return on it - they don't have time to boss you around. Also, if you take money from someone, it means that they believe in your product, which is a great boost to morale especially if you're going in alone.

Finally, there are other ways of raising money besides selling your company - I know convertible debt is one choice, but I'm not familiar with any other low-cost routes (besides YC).

Spyckie··on Why Not To Do A Startup
Can someone kindly provide some history of this to those of us that weren't here in 2007?
Spyckie··on Ask YC: Hacker News Feature Request - Gigs Page
I think monetary transactions should stay out of hacker news because money attracts a crowd that is less than desirable and it is hard to keep them out.

Also, I don't think opening it up for help is a good idea either. The only kind of help that I would care about is high level design or algorithm/memory/time efficiency help. However, the only help most people ask for is "my code doesn't run" help. If there was a way to effectively minimize this, then maybe...

Spyckie··on JPMorgan buys Bear Stearns for $2/sh, ~$236mm total
The Fed is covering us - they just cut interest rates by 25 points to 3.25% and they issued a new lending policy for banks. Not like its going to help in the long run...

The Fed is just delaying the date when the whole financial system crashes... The sad thing is that unlike Japan's financial crisis in the 90's, who's going to bail the US out? China?

Spyckie··on Merit-Based News has arrived: Social news fueled by the submitters' puzzle solving abilities.
It looks like this can be brute forced because its in javascript...
Spyckie··on Web 3.0 Demo
If entities were ever to become something big in the web, it isn't going to be by generating random links between entities and hoping that something useful comes out of it.

If anything, someone has to see a useful link between 2 entities and build an application around it. I doubt it will ever happen the other way around.

Spyckie··on Web 3.0 Demo
My thoughts exactly.
Spyckie··on Ideas are not worthless
Instead of selling ideas, I think the person behind the idea is valuable.

Some people have the gift of coming up with great ideas, or shaping existing ideas in a good direction. The evaluation of ideas and solving the details of an idea is something that is an art and has valuable, much more than the idea itself.

People that create ideas that have no vested interest in making it a reality probably don't have a good enough idea.

Spyckie··on Classic math puzzles for job interviews
start small and work your way up?

lets say 1>x>y and x+y<=4...

Spyckie··on Ask Hackers: How to become the best JavaScript programmer? (q by 12yr old)
+2 for Firebug. Firebug should be your number 1 priority to get familiar with.

jQuery... I have mixed feelings about it.

On the one hand, its very good for high level thinking and writing good, readable code. On the other hand, it slows down your javascript code by at least 2x, which is particularly noticeable if you're doing a javascript intensive application. Then again, the future of browsers is speeding up javascript, so this may not be an issue in a couple of years.

My experience with Prototype is that it handles the speed issue much better - however, it is a bloated monster of a framework.

Spyckie··on Ask YC: What Is Your Favorite Board Game?
haha monopoly is great, especially with friends who don't think outside the box. It requires very fine deal negotiation and value assessment skills.

My favorite move in monopoly is to come up with some trading deals that would give everyone monopolies in a single turn, but make it so that I had either a positional (read: my piece is either in jail or far, far away from their monopolies) or money advantage. Then, mortgage/sell all my other properties, build up as much as possible and hope to kill someone quickly. In monopoly, you have to play the 'do or die' strategy. There is no other way to play.

Unfortunately, now they no longer do any deals with me because they know my deals are deadly even though they look fair...

Spyckie··on Homeschoolers' setback sends shock waves through state
Combine this with the recent article on how terribly wrong math is taught in school and we have quite a grim outlook of our nation's future.
Spyckie··on How to Kill a Successful Business: The Slow-Motion Death of VeggieTales
good read.

It's interesting - the author wasn't pressured by external forces (VCs) to grow big - he wanted to grow big as fast as possible. He didn't grow because of demand but because of his dreams, which is the number 1 reason why he failed. It's strange, too, because he wasn't competing to capture market space; nor was he under any sort of deadline to sell the company at a certain valuation.

If the author had just kept on making veggie tales like he had been doing before he wanted to grow big, the company would have been fine. Veggie tales was a solid product that had everything going for it.

Spyckie··on Lockhart's Lament: On Mathematics at School
This is a beautiful article. I hated math during high school, but was very good at it. I even skipped a grade of math so I could free up my schedule to do more interesting classes! It's such a shame - I love math puzzles but really hate math class.

Even the introductory math courses in college are terrible.

Spyckie··on Ask YC: Hacker moms & dads, what do you read?
Please inspire your 2 year old child to obey your rules.

Seriously, though, at least you can understand where it comes from. And discipline is not just smack smack smack and you're done. Discipline involves telling the child what they did wrong and why.

Spyckie··on Ask YC: Should I work for a startup?
For your situation - you are, ultimately, selling yourself not just as an employee but as a package of value contributed to the company. Now, if you are valuable - that means, if you can provide experience, work or code to the company that will drive it forward that not many other people can provide, then yes, you should consider asking for more equity.

Really, its all about selling. You have some goods or services. They want/need it. Is the current deal fair in both parties' eyes? Founders will say all sorts of things like "I bear all the risk", "I've been here since the beginning", and "I've contributed the most work", and many of these things will be true. However, you have cards to play like, "employees need compensation for their efforts", "good hackers are rare" and "I can add value to your company" (we assume you can). There's an argument to be had here about how much employee should get, but really, its all about how you negotiate. You have to show them why you think the deal is unfair to you, and offer up one that you think is more fair to both parties. If you like the deal, just take it. If you don't like the deal enough to take it, offer up your own, and if they reject it, you weren't going to take the original deal anyways.

But I will admit that like everyone else here has said, the negotiation here is skewed heavily towards the founders favor - still try to get what you can.

Spyckie··on Ask YC: What would you do?
I would be more worried if real estate was boring and stagnant. Real estate looks bad right now, I'll admit, but oftentimes a shakeup is useful for companies entering the market space. (Decouples people from old methods and products, and also allows for new business processes).
Spyckie··on Ask YC: What would you do?
The biggest problems in healthcare are bureacratic, but something has to be said about the mindset of doctors, too. They seem to hate change, and right now it seems like the only way the healthcare space will change is through the passing of generations.

No offense to any doctors out there.

Spyckie··on Ask YC: Hacker moms & dads, what do you read?
Further confirmation that you have not tried to reason with 2 year olds.

Hitting children for discipline is a touchy subject because without a proper motivation behind it, it becomes very inhuman. However, sometimes a child doesn't have a large enough sense of the world to be rational.

For instance, "don't stray very far from me" is a very reasonable command to give to a child because of safety concerns. However, what does a child know about kidnappers, careless drivers, or even the feeling of being lost? The child has to have some experience of these things (not direct, could be through stories, etc) in order to be able to reason why parents give that command. Because you don't have 3 years to explain to the child about the world, you have to have a more direct way of making them obey, and it is hard to think of a better way. Most of the ones you can think of involve some form of pain for the child because humans respond the most to pain first (and reasoning as an afterthought). The non-pain alternatives include letting your child do whatever they want to and take the consequences themselves, spending a lot of time enlarging their sense of the world, or making sure they understand that you mean to do good for them. Granted, nothing is perfect in parenting, and you really have to work with what you're given - that said, if your child won't listen to something that affects their wellbeing, you need to give them a reason to listen.

Discipline is also only a part of parenting. You need to give them love, praise, and someone to look up to. Children dislike their parents when discipline is the only thing they remember when growing up. I want my kids to remember me when growing up, not as a family figurehead, but as a role model for them to grow into or beyond.

Spyckie··on Poll: When do you upvote an article?
add "to save an article for future reading."
Spyckie··on Ask YC: Best undergraduate college for hopeful startup entrepeneurs
I would disagree with this, not because it isn't very good advice in general, but because its not good advice for entrepreneurs. The fact is that other people with motivation and drive to start something are quite rare to find in non top-tier schools, and you not only want people who think like an entrepreneur, but you also want them to be able to carry part of the load of the initial work (for web-based applications, code). Don't apply to the top tier schools because its something that everyone else is doing - do it because you'll find the best people there, and anything less is giving yourself a handicap that just isn't worth it. If you're scared about not making it into the top tier, well just remember, wanting to be an entrpreneur already puts you above many, many people.

One thing I do agree on is that starting something requires more than just coding skills - your ability to socialize, to motivate other people, and to get along with others is critically important. However, I would recommend teaching yourself how to socialize and getting academic schooling on code rather than the other way around.

If you're choosing your college based on where you can build a startup, you should look at 3 things:

1) Smart, motivated people. I would say Stanford, Harvard, MIT have taken most of them. Startups are rarely 1 person endeavors, and having a lot of candidates for a partner really helps.

2) Skills. This is why any top-tier university is good, because the skill-sets there are abundant. Plenty of smart people are looking for the next frontier, and you can give it to them.

3) Community. Most people don't get serious about entrepreneurship until they meet an entrepreneur. Make sure you have some sort of VC connection in your school, or a business program in entrepreneurship and a lively entrepreneur community. Also take entrepreneurial classes if you can, and try to connect with the community as fast as possible.

I go to CMU (Carnegie Mellon), and while it has, to some extent, all of the 3 points above, I do sometimes regret not going somewhere better. The difference in the caliber of people and the quantity and quality of the entrepreneurs here is quite apparent. CMU has a lot of old VCs that don't really know the web, and the entrepreneur community here is mostly older people doing older stuff (but still fascinating startups). One thing I'm very satisfied with is the professors here teaching entrepreneurship, as they have their own companies and provide a LOT of advice and motivation (they just are limited in how much help they can give if you're doing a web startup). I would say its a tier or 2 below the top three.

There seems to be a good correlation between the VC money in a certain area and how startup-friendly the colleges nearby are. Its best if you just follow that.

also - business vs CS - do CS.

The business school here at CMU produces the worst slackers-that-look-good-in-suits that I've ever seen. It does wonders to your presentation skills but kills your ability to do any serious work whatsoever.

← PreviousPage 4 of 5Next →