HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

SyzygyRhythm

451 karma · joined April 17, 2023

submissionscomments
SyzygyRhythm··on Why so many control rooms were seafoam green (2025)
> that's why they were the color they were

That doesn't seem right to me. Sodium (and mercury) vapor lamps are the color they are due to physics, and were chosen because they're very efficient (and long lasting). Low-pressure sodium is the best and worst of these; essentially monochromatic but fantastic efficiency. Their only advantage, color-wise, is that the light can be filtered out easily (they used to be widely used in San Jose because Lick Observatory could filter out the 589 nm light).

SyzygyRhythm··on Show HN: Duplicate 3 layers in a 24B LLM, logical deduction .22→.76. No training
If running twice is good, then is running N times even better? I wonder if you could even loop until some kind of convergence, say hitting a fixed point (input equals output). I wonder if there's even a sort of bifurcation property where it sometimes loops A->A->A, but other times A->B->A, or more, rather like the logistic map fractal.
SyzygyRhythm··on Mathematicians disagree on the essential structure of the complex numbers (2024)
Is it two, or is it infinite? The quaternions have three imaginary units, i, j, and k. They're distinct, and yet each of them could be used for the complex numbers and they'd work the same way. How would I know that "my" imaginary unit i is the same as some other person's i? Maybe theirs is j, or k, or something else entirely.
SyzygyRhythm··on A battle over Canada’s mystery brain disease
Getting an EKG seems very prudent. I had one done for a non-heart related procedure, and afterwards was basically asked: - Ever have any heart events? Heart racing, palpitations, that kind of thing? - Yes, a few times a year I've noticed events like that. Resolves in a few minutes, though. - Well, your EKG shows a slurred delta wave. Sign of Wolff-Parkinson-White syndrome. Might want to get that checked out.

I did, and it was. Fixed with ablation. No issues since. Other types of supraventricular tachycardia can also be cured with ablation.

SyzygyRhythm··on Inverse Parentheses
If you do both (use flipped parentheses around the operators), it makes even more sense, and makes the parsing trivial to boot: just surround the entire expression with parentheses and parse normally. For instance: 1 + 2 )( 3 Becomes (1 + 2 )( 3) Which is actually just what the author wants. You might even want multiple, or an arbitrary numbers of external parentheses. Say we want to give the divide the least precedence, the multiply the middle, and the add the most. We could do that like: 1 + 2 )/( 3 ))(( 4 Surround it with two sets of parens and you have: ((1 + 2 )/( 3 ))(( 4)) I haven't just proved to myself this always does what you expect, though...
SyzygyRhythm··on CO2 batteries that store grid energy take off globally
Many people think of driving in time rather than distance. I'd say it's actually more common to say a city is 3 hours away rather than 200 miles.

What makes kW less useful is really just that most EVs don't advertise their capacity very prominently. But if you knew you had an 80 kWh battery and the car uses 20 kW at freeway speeds, then it's easy to see that it'll drive for 4 hours.

SyzygyRhythm··on Economics of Orbital vs. Terrestrial Data Centers
We know the upper bound for most of those numbers. SpaceX already achieves internal marginal launch costs of ~$1000/kg, for instance. We know their rough costs per satellite. In contrast, we know little to nothing about the inputs to the Drake equation.

The numbers don't quite work out in favor of orbital datacenters at the current values. But we can tell from analyses like this what has to change to get there.

SyzygyRhythm··on String theory inspires a brilliant, baffling new math proof
I wouldn't downplay the opportunity cost of that much human capital. It really is quite a lot, given the obvious talents of the physicists.

I'm not saying I fully agree with the position, but one way of looking at it is that thousands of incredibly smart people got nerd-sniped into working on a problem that actually has no solution. I sometimes wonder if there will ever be a point where people give up on it, as opposed to pursuing a field that bears some mathematical fruit, always with some future promise, but contributes nothing to physics.

SyzygyRhythm··on Running on Empty: Copper
I'd suppose the fashion goes somewhat with the price of copper, though I haven't tracked it. The heatsinks themselves have gotten far larger as CPUs and GPUs have gotten more power hungry, not to mention RAM and SSDs. A material that's a good tradeoff at one scale isn't necessarily one at a different scale.

At any rate, one should expect many of these trades to go the way of Al if Cu gets more expensive (which it might not). Not all of them, but we'll probably see a bias towards physically larger systems in cases where space isn't at a premium. And also a bias towards active systems over passive, liquid cooling over air, and so on.

SyzygyRhythm··on Running on Empty: Copper
Indeed.

Aluminum is actually a (far) superior conductor to copper per unit mass. It would be used on transmission lines even if it was the same price as copper, because the towers can be cheaper and farther apart. It's in increasing use in EVs due to the lower mass.

Copper is still used when the conductive density matters, like the windings of an electric motor. But if copper prices increase further, manufacturers will make sacrifices to efficiency and power density in order to save cost. And they'll figure out how to better balance the use of Al vs. Cu, perhaps using Cu only for the conductors closest to the core.

We also use copper for transformers, which are fairy "dumb" in their usual design. Solid-state transformers exist, which use much less copper, but are currently more expensive. They will no longer be more expensive if the price of copper goes up too much. And they'll probably get cheaper in the long run anyway, regardless of copper price, in the same way that switch mode power supplies have totally replaced linear supplies in the consumer space.

I've seen increasing use of copper in fairly mundane uses, like computer heat sinks, that used to be aluminum. The performance is a little better, but it won't be worthwhile if copper gets way more expensive. They'll just go back to aluminum, or use some other innovation (carbon heat spreaders, etc.) if price becomes an issue.

SyzygyRhythm··on Max Number of Simultaneous Key-Press (N-Key Rollover, NKRO, Ghosting) (2010)
I've found that quite a lot of cheap keyboards cannot register a T when shift-R are being pressed. If I always used the standard QWERTY finger positioning, this wouldn't be a problem, because my index finger could not be on both R and T at the same time. But when typing a word like (all-caps) SMART, I tend to use middle-index to quickly type the RT, and R is still depressed when I hit the T. So the T does not register.

Most decent keyboards don't do this, but even there I've seen exceptions. Very annoying.

SyzygyRhythm··on Mathematicians have found a hidden 'reset button' for undoing rotation
This is important. The mechanism doesn't really work the way you want most of the time. I occasionally see a claim that you can power a carousel with this method, but it doesn't work. You would have to have the cable go out and around the carousel structure, and then into the top. And the cable would still move relative to the ground and the carousel.

You could, in principle, have a totally internal system, but with arms that grab and release the cable at intervals so that the looped portion can pass by them. You could arrange the timing so that electrical contact is never lost. But you are still making/breaking contact and it starts to lose some apparent advantages compared to a slip ring.

That's not to say it isn't still useful for some purposes, like maybe a radio antenna that isn't too impacted by a cable moving in front on occasion. But it doesn't eliminate all uses for a slip ring.

SyzygyRhythm··on How to check for overlapping intervals
Even with the visualization, I found the minimal solution hard to visualize. I came up with this instead:

Suppose you start with two separated intervals. The left one starts sliding rightward. At what point do they contact? That's easy, it's just when (end1 > start2).

As it continues sliding, at what point do they lose contact? Again, easy: it's where (start1 >= end2).

So the solution is the first condition and the negation of the second, i.e.: (end1 > start2) && (start1 < end2)

SyzygyRhythm··on Eliminating contrails from flying could be cheap
The article mentions that some flights produce a net cooling effect. I wonder if it could be cost effective to divert flights toward contrail formation when it's predicted that they'll produce cooling (I also wonder what the actual circumstances are when they produce cooling--low surface temperatures, maybe?).
SyzygyRhythm··on Omnimax
I went to Space Camp in Huntsville in '89 or so. One of the perks was a daily showing at their Omnimax theater. Felt absolutely incredible at the time. The most memorable moment was a scene where they filmed the Space Shuttle tower escape system--basically a basket on a zipline that goes into a sand pit. Everyone in the theater instinctively leapt forward when the basket hit the sand. The difference, I suppose, is that the screen filled your peripheral vision as well. I didn't experience the same level of immersiveness until VR, much later on.
SyzygyRhythm··on Mustard Watches (1990)
You can prove it easily by induction. If Wm(n) is a mustard watch containing n micrograms of mustard, then it suffices to show that Wm(0) exists, and that if Wm(n) exists then Wm(n+1) must exist. Obviously a single additional microgram of mustard could not overload the structure of a watch. Therefore, Wm(10^100) or any other size must exist.
SyzygyRhythm··on Starship Flight 9 booster explodes on impact [video]
We don't know all the things they did to the Booster, but among them were deliberately not igniting some engines as well as taking a more aggressive angle-of-attack on descent (the rocket is a fairly effective lifting body, as it turns out!).

There may be more things, but between those two I think the latter was a bigger problem. It would have gotten hotter and more physically stressed. And then weakened to the point to where re-igniting the engines caused it to fail.

They also used a new hot-staging maneuver, where the gases were directed out one side so that it flipped more rapidly in the other direction. It was a really fast flip! A rocket the size of a small skyscraper turning 90 degrees in just a few seconds. That could have jarred something loose, too.

Hopefully we find out in the post-mortem. SpaceX doesn't typically give the public as much detail as we'd like, but they're pretty good at sharing the high-level reasons why something failed.

SyzygyRhythm··on Starship Flight 9 booster explodes on impact [video]
It's the original definition of "pushing the envelope." You start with a known flight envelope, then push a little past that. Sometimes you learn that the real envelope is bigger than you thought. Other times you find that the envelope is exactly where you thought it was.
SyzygyRhythm··on Computer Architects Can't Find the Average
I disagree with the article's claim that the geometric mean lacks physical meaning.

Say you have two benchmarks with different units, frames/second and instructions/second. You can't take the arithmetic mean of these unless you divide by some baseline first (or a conversion factor).

But the geometric mean has well-defined units of (frames * instructions)^.5/second. And the reason you can divide by another geometric mean is because these units are always the same.

Having coherent units isn't exactly the same as "physical meaning", but it's a prerequisite at the least.

SyzygyRhythm··on It’s not mold, it’s calcium lactate (2018)
The article says that the crystals don't affect the taste or scent. The crystals are a signal that you have a good cheese, but not the cause of a good cheese. Adding them to a bad cheese won't make it a good cheese, so in that sense I'd call it a fake.

There is some gray area in that they affect the texture, which is a part of the whole experience. But that's again mostly signaling--we like the crunch because we associate it with good cheeses, not because there's anything inherently better about it.

There are some interesting philosophical questions here. If you put a fake label on some wine, and people perceive it as higher quality than it is, is it really fake? On one hand, obviously yes. And yet there was a real effect on the perceived quality.

SyzygyRhythm··on Geothermal power is a climate moon shot beneath our feet
Drilling the well is the expensive part. It heats at a relatively constant rate depending on the geometry. You could size the plant to be exactly matched to the well output--but the generators and such are relatively cheap. So instead you make that part of the plant slightly oversized, so you can run at over the well's capacity when electricity is expensive, and under the capacity when it's cheap. The thermal mass of the rocks allows you to average this out over time.
SyzygyRhythm··on The number line freaks me out (2016)
I would say instead that math is a game. A universal game with no predefined rules at all and only one guideline: if the rules you make up lead to a contradiction, then the rules are probably boring. If your rules say that 1+1=3, then you can prove anything and the whole thing becomes uninteresting.

Mathematicians have come up with various rules (axioms) that seem to work pretty well. And they spend a great deal of time figuring out their consequences. But it may still happen that the rules have a contradiction and they need to come up with a different set.

Sometimes mathematicians add extra rules when they run into a roadblock. And part of the meta-game is to come up with the minimum set of extra rules they need to keep going. Sometimes they spend time figuring out if the existing rules aren't needed.

SyzygyRhythm··on Multiplicative Infinitesimals
Infinitesimal calculus is the old-fashioned calculus! It was what Newton and Leibniz invented. Limits only came into play later when mathematicians wanted a more robust foundation. But then Robinson proved that infinitesimals were perfectly rigorous. IMO, non-standard analysis is more intuitive than limit-based calculus.
SyzygyRhythm··on Ending our third party fact-checking program and moving to Community Notes model
Tim Walz claimed there is "no guarantee to free speech on misinformation or hate speech, and especially around our democracy." That's false--the First Amendment has no such carveouts for those things. So it's concerning that Walz would think otherwise.

Hillary Clinton has made similar comments, saying "But I also think there are Americans who are engaged in this kind of propaganda, and whether they should be civilly, or even in some cases criminally, charged is something that would be a better deterrence, because the Russians are unlikely, except in a very few cases, to ever stand trial in the United States." But again, there is no First Amendment carveout for propaganda, Russian or otherwise.

There are some limits to protected speech, but they're rare and mostly limited to direct incitement of a crime or other threat.

SyzygyRhythm··on In 1870, Lord Rayleigh used oil and water to calculate the size of molecules
For that to happen, you would have to be very unlucky: all of your measurements would have to be 2e, 4e, 6e, etc. If a 3e or 5e sneaked in there, you'd realize that the charge was e, not 2e. With enough measurements, you can be confident that you've hit all the expected multiples of the quantum.
← PreviousPage 3 of 3