HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

TFortunato

778 karma · joined January 23, 2011

I build robots.

Current: Staff Robotics Engineer at Chewy

Prior: Atlas @ Boston Dynamic; Robotics and Embedded Systems Engineering @ Amazon Robotics, Rethink Robotics, iRobot; Automation Engineering @ Ginkgo Bioworks.

Early Career: Electrical Engineer in Semiconductor Industry @ Applied Materials, Analog Devices, Allegro Microsystems

submissionscomments
TFortunato··on A Robotics Startup Wants to Be the Boston Dynamics of China
Quick correction. Google bought Boston Dynamics at the end of 2013. Atlas was in development long before that, and publicly shown in July 2013.
TFortunato··on A Little Story About the `yes` Unix Command
Passively cooled. The thing was originally meant for extended use in "extreme" industrial environments (eg at a power substation, inside a wind turbine, etc..), so it had no vents or moving parts at all. Everything was heatpiped to the metal case, which looked like a heatsink.

Similar looking model from same company: https://selinc.com/products/3355/

TFortunato··on A Little Story About the `yes` Unix Command
Hah, nice! Somewhat related, I once worked on a project that used a high reliability PC meant for extended use in "extreme" outdoor environments. One of the issues they (manufacturer) worried about was the pcb and solder joints experiencing thermal fatigue fron lots of seasonal and night/day temperature cycles.

Their ingenious solution was to always run the system towards the warmer end of its spec, and so it included a program that would monitor the temperature inside the case, and would spawn/kill a bunch of threads doing compute intensive math in order to keep the temperature constant when the users workload wasn't enough!

TFortunato··on How Emotional Labor is Dragging Down Gender Equality
You caught me off-guard a bit saying my post is sexist. To be clear I am NOT saying that this is how things are in all relationships, or how things should be. I'm very much in the camp of partners needing to be full partners, and for open and health communication.

I'm also not blind to the fact that there are still some deeply ingrained stereotypes, however subtle, about gender roles in our society, and I'm trying, perhaps poorly, to rephrase some points from the article (and others like it), in which the author very clearly names this: "the mental load bore almost exclusively by women."

This isn't a personal attack on you or your relationship. On the contrary, it sounds like you have a pretty healthy relationship, and I'm happy for you!

But the fact that this concept resonates with many people though, men and women, probably means there is something here that warrants more conversation for a lot of people, even if it isn't something that is a problem in your particular relationship.

TFortunato··on How Emotional Labor is Dragging Down Gender Equality
I think you are missing the forest for the trees a bit here by focusing just on cleaning standards. As the author said, part of the emotional labor is the management of the household but also the management of relationships within the house.

This isn't about forcing a man "to fully adopt her perspective." This is about the idea that women are more often expected to be the ones to suggest a compromise, or to be the ones which have to point out these rifts in the relationship. More generally, to do the actual work of being in a relationship and keeping it healthy.

To flip around what you just said a bit: Why doesn't the husband notice that his wife is always picking up after him, or that she is not recieving acknowledgement of the work she has done, work that he feels should be acknowledged when he does it? Why must the woman be the one to notice there is a problem, to articulate it and to come up with a solution, as if the problem is her problem to solve and not a problem with the relationship, which consists of two people who are supposed to be partners?

TFortunato··on Jacquard by Google transforms clothing
On that, if you aren't familiar, the name refers to the Jacquard Loom, one of the first "programmable" looms, perhaps most famous for giving us punched cards! Cute name for a project tying computing and fabric goods!

EDIT: Link - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jacquard_loom#Importance_in_co...

TFortunato··on PixelNN – Example-Based Image Synthesis
Hopefully never, but I'm sure someone will see this and try!

(Because these kind of techniques aren't really enhancing the images in a way that gives you new and useful information: they are taking the low-res images as input, and giving you a plausible high-res image as output, based on it's training data. It is NOT however trying to say "this is the ACTUAL high res image that generated this low-res image"

TFortunato··on LimeSDR Mini – An open, full-duplex, USB stick radio for femtocells and more
Cats already out of the bag on that one... The term femtocell isn't exactly new -- it's been used in the wireless world for some time now.
TFortunato··on The Equifax disaster points to a much bigger problem
I'll give you the point about the way it was worded w.r.t. when the breach was announced. On that though, I did want to point out that if you look at the list of co-sponsors, the last person to sponsor it was Rep Williams of Texas, ON 9/7/17, the day Equifax announced the breach, which is probably just really bad timing that day on his / his staff's part, but also looks LOOKS really terrible, regardless of the actual reason behind it.
TFortunato··on The Equifax disaster points to a much bigger problem
Sure they aren't all the same, but I guess I would ask what's your threshold on whether using the party name is weasel-y?

Because it has 13 Co-sponsors, all republicans and no democrats. https://www.congress.gov/bill/115th-congress/house-bill/2359...

TFortunato··on The Equifax disaster points to a much bigger problem
Of course frivolous lawsuits are a thing, but this law is a fucking joke. It limits the TOTAL recovery of the CLASS to $500,000, not just for the lawsuit, but also of any following "series of class actions arising out of the same failure to comply".

Meaning that if they lose their court case, they can still continue to behave badly, and not face any additional fines once they hit that measly total.

Oh, and just in case that $500,000 might hit some small "mom-and-pop" credit reporting agency, the total damage that can be awarded (again IN TOTAL TO THE ENTIRE CLASS), is the lesser of $500,000 or 1% of the net worth of the person/corporation the suit is being brought against.

Meaning we are basically saying "you can't actually bring a suit against them that could cause them enough damage to actually change their shitty behavior"

TFortunato··on A new kind of map: it’s about time
That is absolutely true, and I fully admit that there isn't going to be a perfect way to do this unless you are very lucky. I'm only curious if you could use a method like this to make maps like shown above at http://www.spiekermann-wegener.com/mod/time/time_e.htm where it's approximately correct in a somewhat useful way.

My gut says it's probably more realistic to do this for large scale maps (say between major cities, 100s of miles, where distance is pretty proportional to travel time). Once you get down to the city / street level, yeah it probably gets real dicey with high variation in travel speeds depending on the particular road and how routes are laid out, and you just aren't going to get pretty triangles fitting together nicely :-P.

In any case its a fun problem to think about!

TFortunato··on A new kind of map: it’s about time
I think as far as figuring out the transformation to use on the a generic map I would:

0) ignore stuff like "infinitely quick" since that isn't realistic for what we are doing :-)

1) For the map I am displaying, pick a handful of points of interest to hse as controls, as well as my current location.

2) Use existing data we already have for stuff like direction routing to get travel times between all the pairs in our points of interest.

3) Draw a weighted graph, where each vertex is one of our points of interest and each edge is weighted by travel time. The initial position of each point should be it's geographic position, but we can then use an existing graph layout algorithm that uses an energy-based method (e.g. pretend the edges are springs) to deform the graph. This way each point will end up with its distance being proportional to travel time.

4) Using initial points as our input control points, and their location in the graph as output cobtrol points, use any number of image warping algorithms put there to calculate our warp / morph / deformation field.

5) Apply to initial map image.

I don't know how well it would work in practice but seems like a reasonable first stab at it! :-)

EDIT: Apologies for typo, fat fingers on mobile!

TFortunato··on DuckDuckGo vs Google
Ugh. GO. :-P
TFortunato··on Building a working game of Tetris in Conway's Game of Life
In the hardware section of the post, they actually do show / talk about the need to construct a wire crossing, and it was used in the design..
TFortunato··on I don’t know who the Web Audio API is designed for
I can't tell if your being pedantic because you agree with the parent, or because you missed their point entirely
TFortunato··on Row over AI that 'identifies gay faces'
I never said anything about rainbow flags in the background, nor that we should ignore this study. And fine to be pedantic, it wasn't throwing a bunch of photos at a NN classifier, it was throwing a bunch of photos through a NN to get a descriptor of facial features, then training a logistic regression on that. (Note: they did also train a DNN specifically for this, which they used for example to say things like: "Male facial image brightness correlates 0.19 with the probability of being gay, as estimated by the DNN based classifier. While the brightness of the facial image might be driven by many factors, previous research found that testosterone stimulates melanocyte structure and function leading to a darker skin." which some might argue is quite a jump given the data at hand.

What I am saying is that the authors may have been a bit far-reaching in their conclusions, and that "trends in dating site photos" doesn't just mean "is there a rainbow flag present?", but also things like how photos are taken w.r.t angles, and lighting, and retouched, makeup, expressions, etc. (and yes VGG-Face is supposed to be resilient to some of these things, they also used Face++ for studies having to do with morphology, such as using facial contour features. But saying they are resilient to these things and quantifying that are two very different things).

To get to even a more fundamental question - Does the population of gay and straight individuals on a dating website necessarily reflect the gay and/or straight populations as a whole?

And once the authors start talking about the femininity or masculinity of faces, and whether certain features are gender atypical or not, they are entering very murky and ill-defined territory, which the authors even acknowledged when relating previous results on this front.

To be very clear about it: I am not saying that the study should be ignored completely, or that there were no interesting findings. Quite the contrary! What I am saying is that the conclusions being reached ("Our results provide strong support for the PHT, which argues that same gender sexual orientation stems from the underexposure of male fetuses and overexposure of female fetuses to prenatal androgen responsible for the sexual differentiation of faces, preferences, and behavior") are quite a bit of a leap from what was found in the research given the input data and methods, and I think should have been more accurately reported as: "interesting differences in social media photographs of gay vs straight individuals.", with a little less speculation by the authors on what might be causing these differences.

TFortunato··on Row over AI that 'identifies gay faces'
Not one of the downvoters, but did want to respond to a few points.

On peer review: 1) The uploaded version of the preprint that was linked is currently version 7. Version 1 did not contain the "this is a peer reviewed article" boiler-plate at the top. It's very possible that GLAAD/HRC saw the original manuscript without this notice. 2) Given that all 7 versions have been posted in the past 9 days, one might reasonably conclude that this is still a work-in-progress and peer review is still currently on-going, (the boilerplate being added in anticipation of the review being completed. Again, the paper is very clearly still being worked on.)

On misinformation: Yes I will give you that some of the criticisms might seem over-the-top to the HN crowd, but I think they are understandable given what GLAAD's / HRC's focus is, plus the fact that they aren't addressing "trained scientists." That being said, I don't think their criticisms are completely baseless. I think anyone with technical training, particularly in data analysis / machine learning, is familiar with the phrase: "Garbage In - Garbage Out." And I think it is absolutely correct to point out that maybe if your training data is dating site photos, predominantly of white people in a narrow age range, that you may not have exactly proven your claims that you have "advance[d] our understanding of the origins of sexual orientation and the limits of human perception." That maybe you've just learned some interesting features of current trends in dating site photos.

The tragic thing is that both sides (GLAAD & HRC vs. the researchers) claim to care about the privacy and safety of individuals. And kudos to them for thinking of the social implications of this kind of research! (We all know how good phrenology turned out) Because of these implications, I absolutely think it's right for us to question the conclusions of this research (that you can detect sexual orientation from facial morphology, and that this is evidence of the prenatal hormone theory of sexual orientation), given their actual methods (we threw a bunch of dating site photos at a neural-net classifier, and compared to self-reported sexual orientation)

All that said, I do think that the paper is likely to be more nuanced than the conclusions reported / the abstract make it out to be (have not finished reading the paper yet). But unfortunately, because of the way science is reported, where the headline is going to be some bombastic "AI can tell if you are gay or straight from just a picture!", there is probably some pressure to voice their criticisms just as loudly.

TFortunato··on California bans drones from delivering marijuana
Completely spitballing this one, but I can imagine that a bike might be argued to not be a safe way to transport drugs or any sort of high-value delivery, since they are less easily secured and more easily stolen than a locked motor vehicle when it's parked outside an apartment building (for example).
TFortunato··on Why I Stopped Using Multiple Monitors
Hey now, I do "low-level" programming, and you can pry my extra monitors from my cold dead hands!

As much as I love printed materials for reference, unless it came that way, I'm not going to use a ream of my own printer paper for every reference manual or datasheet I have, when I could just have 1 monitor for coding and 1 with all my documentation readily available!

TFortunato··on These Robots Are Using Static Electricity to Make Nikes
Just as a little fun fact -- in the semiconductor industry, this has been a major method of wafer handling for quite a while, where the wafer handling bit is known as an "electrostatic chuck." If you google that term, you can find a LOT of info on how this type of system works since it's been around, used in production and studied for quite a while!
TFortunato··on The Death and Life of Helicopter Commuting [video]
Well played! (Though I would argue that the parent is still technically correct about multirotors / quadcopters being very inefficient compared to other flight methods)

That said, I am really curious at actual lifetime costs of a system like this, and if it makes up for lack of efficiency by being simpler mechanically (leading to lighter weight, less maintenance costs, etc.) I think thats going to be the big thing that determines if this is a viable commuting option vs. rich person's toy.

TFortunato··on Disabling Intel ME 11 via undocumented mode
While I too wish it was able to be disabled easily, I'm surprised the parent poster is getting down voted. Having worked for hardware companies, and chip companies in particular, I can very easily see the benign answer being that this isn't even on their radar as something to do. That they are providing the ME features because Sales Guys say that some big enterprise customers want them, and once it was designed in, there wasn't a convincing proposal to make it an optional / opt-in feature, because there simply isn't someone on the engineering team who is voicing the concerns of the "home PC user who cares about this-kind-of-thing."

And even if there is, the "non-evil" reason for keeping this as is might be that "enterprise customer doesn't want something that is easily disabled, and we can't justify cost of a separate design / fab run for a small minority of customers", vs. "Haha, now we have a backdoor into EVERYTHING!"

(Hell, even the proposals about disable via hardware switch, or having the ME on a separate component probably boil down to money. To an outsider, hardware companies are funny beasts in that they really start caring about things like counting pennies and minimizing BOM cost as much as possible. I've been in worried meetings where we were literally counting and debating pennies, and wondering how I got there, but it makes sense at a company level since those pennies add up when you are building thousands or millions of something! This may have boiled down to "motherboard manufacturer doesn't want to have to put another mechanical part on the board, and they are looking to buy a shitload of our parts, let's keep them happy")

Please note: I'm not saying, or even advocating, that this is a good thing, or results in ideal outcomes when I say "benign". I'm just using it in the sense that this likely wasn't a malicious decision, but probably one motivated by money at some point, by people who didn't necessarily see the harm in it.

TFortunato··on Metformin Promises to Extend Life for a Nickel a Pill
Citation needed on metformin "making you stupid", and "interfering with anything requiring effort", especially given the multiple studies showing metformin to improve exercise tolerance, and preventing cognitive decline in patients who have taken it.
TFortunato··on What Is Trump Worth to Twitter? One Analyst Estimates $2B
Seriously -- Everyone knows that all tweeters are equal, but some tweeters are more equal than others!

(...With apologies to George Orwell)

TFortunato··on Examining a vintage RAM chip, I find a counterfeit with a different die inside
Yep, absolutely still done, and for the same reason (in my experience), especially with Intel, and other companies who develop their own processes.

What typically happens is that engineers do the best they can before release to model the process and experiment with building devices at different process "corners". This gives an idea of what the distribution of different electrical parameters will look like over the range of expected process variation (logic levels of FETs, sheet resistances, etc. etc.).

Obviously this data is imperfect, because there are a TON of steps in a modern semiconductor process, and a TON of variables in each one. (For example, I worked on Ion Implanters, and we recorded hundreds of variables for our customers during the run, from vacuum levels, to gas dosages to voltages and currents in the various accelerator stages).

As parent said, there is another group, who IMO are probably the original "big data" folks, usually called manufacturing or process engineers. They monitor the yields, binning and specific electrical measurements of all the wafers and parts coming off the line, along with process data for all the nanufacturing steps the wafer has gone through. These guys do the black magic of figuring out what needs to be tweaked in the process. At the higher levels it involves a mix of knowledge -- not only statistics and optimization, but also the semiconductor physics of how these parts actually operate, (since experiments can get expensive, you want to justify the knobs you are going to tweak!)

TFortunato··on Examining a vintage RAM chip, I find a counterfeit with a different die inside
There absolutely is test hardware for the functioning of chips. After all, those datasheet numbers have to come from somewhere, right? ;-)

Before I got into robotics, I worked in the semiconductor world as a test and product engineer for a couple of IC manufacturers. A lot of my job involved figuring out how to test every parameter we were going to put on the datasheet, writing code to test it quickly, and then doing statistical analysis of the results over thousands upon thousands of devices to make sure they met requirements. It was an interesting experience. We used some very high end test equipment, made by companies like Teradyne, and for each part (or family of parts in some cases), we would make a custom board which would mate to the test equipment on one side, and had sockets for the part we were testing, along with any support circuitry required.

I think the problem with doing some sort of acceptance testing is that unless you buy the parts directly from the manufacturer or their distributors, it's very hard to verify that the part meets it's specs, unless you already have this kind of dedicated testing equipment and code, especially when you want to start measuring analog parameters (current consumption, logic levels, etc.), and don't think it would be worth the trouble in most cases.

(Military / Space may be a special case, where critical parts may stop being manufactured by the original manufacturer and they do have to do this sort of thing, but as far as I know, it isn't typical).

TFortunato··on Python Practices for Efficient Code: Performance, Memory, and Usability
Out of curiosity, is there any overhead to the python exception mechanism if you don't hit an exception (ie just by wrapping things in a try block)

I come from an embedded background, where in some c++ projects, we would disable exceptions for various reasons, including the memory overhead, which is why I ask..

TFortunato··on Living on Mars: The Stuff You Never Thought About
To play devil's advocate - there are a lot of people who would argue that the view: "Why would you do something with so many known and unknown dangers, when you could focus your energies on making a VR simulation of it instead?" also very sad.
TFortunato··on The Daily Stormer: A Hurricane Alerting Service
Is that the "White Power" alert?
← PreviousPage 6 of 9Next →