HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Tadpole9181

1,897 karma · joined September 27, 2023

submissionscomments
Tadpole9181··on Cue AI
After going to the official website, I actually spent a couple of minutes looking around and checking certificates to see if it was a scam. The page makes it sound like it was built by a single guy who isn't incorporated, but if you go to the Terms, it says Sophon LLC - who seems to do AI document processing? But then going to their About page and "Our Team" is some cagey "experts from leading companies".

Combined with the Apple button reading "Download for Windows" on a Windows machine, and basic HTML issues like `we're`, I'm not inclined to have this software running my entire PC.

Tadpole9181··on I'm Done with Mullvad
To be clear, did or did not the party leader say he would like to deport people born in Sweden to legal immigrant parents because they are not "naturally Swedish"?
Tadpole9181··on Claude Code uses Bun written in Rust now
> I'd remind you the current new version is not an improvement compared to the previous one, both in terms of correctness and maintainability.

Except, you know, multiple real companies saying that it is and using it in production. And the fact it closed all known memory leaks. And that nobody has a really pointed to a single actual issue the new version introduced after two months of endless, ceaseless bitching.

I'm also fascinated by all these people upset at Jarred for harming the readability of a codebase they've literally never cared about before it become drama. Bun has almost exclusively been maintained by Oven employees since it's inception.

> Deno for instance have ~0.2x as many unsafes.

A project written ground-up in Rust idiomatically, with a smaller surface area, still has an unsafe footprint within an order of magnitude compared to this automated rewrite from an unsafe language with different practices and known bugs? That's not exactly the slam you think it is.

Tadpole9181··on Claude Code uses Bun written in Rust now
It isn't disabled, it has exclusions. Now that they have it, they can close the gaps. It was literally impossible to have ANY coverage before, now they are mostly, covered and have an avenue for remediation.

I don't understand why folk are having such a hard time understanding why you do large projects in multiple steps? 80/20 rule? Perfect is the enemy of good?

Was nobody here for moving billions of lines of JavaScript to Typescript? It starts with declarations, then turn on type checking gradually inside the codebase: piece by piece until done.

Tadpole9181··on Claude Code uses Bun written in Rust now
Just so everyone know, Bun is and has always been owned by a YC funded org with full time employees. The overwhelming majority of commits came from them.
Tadpole9181··on Claude Code uses Bun written in Rust now
This feels like such an absurd, bad faith take I keep hearing.

In Zig, every single memory operation is unsafe.

And Bun must interface with C code that has no safe interface, necessitating a ton of boundary-level unsafe behaviors.

There's too much, sure, but can we at least be honest and reasonable?

Tadpole9181··on Claude Code uses Bun written in Rust now
The canary build has been Rust for over a month, available to anyone. In that time it has been used in production for Claude Code and Prisma Compute.
Tadpole9181··on Claude Code: Anatomy of a Misfeature
> and from my own experience it's very frustrating to leave a Claude session running and come back to find it did nothing because it got stuck on a question.

I cannot fathom implementing and shipping a feature to hundreds of thousands of people without even asking basic questions like: "what types of questions does Claude ask users".

Literally one of the most used plugins in their entire ecosystem, provided via their official plugin marketplace, is Superpowers. A plugin whose very first operating step is _asking numerous questions about product requirements_. Of course those prompts can't be skipped!

It wasn't even parameterized for Claude to tell the prompt what severity of question was being asked to allow at least _something_ to categorize urgency or expected response time.

Even more egregiously, 60 seconds!? The first time I noticed this happened was when it asked me a question, I turned to my second monitor to go look at some product documentation to get an answer, and by the time I turned back it had skipped me. How can I possibly provide any kind of informed answer in under 60 seconds? I can barely read some of its context for a question in 60 seconds!

I don't think they did this with malintent, but I do think this shows an enormous gap in judgement in how they handle the idea to delivery pipeline.

Tadpole9181··on Trump Media to sell instant access to 'market-moving' social posts
Trump fired all members of the Election Assistance Commission this week. His head of the USPS confirmed they have a proposed rule to not deliver mail-in ballots in select states. Last night, as we approach midterms, Trump gave a speech saying US elections are illegitimate and only he can fix it (by controlling the voting machines and who gets to vote).

I'm really sorry, but it really does look like we may have had our last actual election already.

Tadpole9181··on Schema Harness Achieves ~99% on Arc‑AGI‑3 Public
FWIW: "Baba Is You" is 7 years old and heralded as one of the greatest puzzle games of all times, with guides and solutions shared all over the internet. How to beat this game is 100% in the training set.
Tadpole9181··on Schema Harness Achieves ~99% on Arc‑AGI‑3 Public
To quote the people who make it:

> ARC-AGI-3 is an interactive reasoning benchmark which challenges AI agents to explore novel environments, acquire goals on the fly, build adaptable world models, and learn continuously.

This harness does nothing to actually accomplish those goals.

It's a clever trick, sure, but you aren't allowed to use a calculator on your basic algebra tests in school for a reason.

Tadpole9181··on Schema Harness Achieves ~99% on Arc‑AGI‑3 Public
This is not actually running the Arc-AGI-3 anymore. To summarize TFA:

1. The AI plays the game and records outputs.

2. The AI does TDD using those outputs to create its own copy of the game.

3. The AI then uses it's copy of the source code to understand the rules. This bypasses the intent for Arc-AGI-3 to test the underlying model's ability to intuit game rules naturally, like a human.

4. The AI then runs simulated moves on the copy of the game before playing them in the "real" game. This bypasses the intent for Arc-AGI-3 to test the underlying model's ability to plan and predict moves, and track world state in its "head" over time.

To make an apt comparison... You go to get your chess ELO. You don't know chess at all and you're really bad at it, so you pull out your laptop and write a chess engine. Then when you go to get ranked, you just copy the moves from the software. Now you're a grand master.

Tadpole9181··on Schema Harness Achieves ~99% on Arc‑AGI‑3 Public
The point of Arc-AGI-3 is to measure model performance. We already know that models can one-shot and iterate on very rudimentary game implementations. And, naturally, once it effectively has a copy of the source code, it can use that to play the game better.

This harness is really moving the goalpost by defeating the entire point of the test. Instead of seeing the strength of a model's world view, its ability to internally derive and intuit rules, and its ability to keep track of game state over time, we're just letting the AI cheat. This is just the LLM equivalent of running a chess engine to the side.

And this harness would not work in a remotely complex game and relies on the fact that Arc-AGI-3 is a focused test that only made the games as complicated as they needed to be for current model performance.

Tadpole9181··on The End of Creativity
> If it's something that anyone could do, without skill, why would anyone be impressed by that?

Gifts aren't supposed to be impressive. Nor is their value measured by effort or cost.

Nor does this reply answer their question of "is hiring a professional to to it any better?" It seems you would have to argue no, though.

Tadpole9181··on C++20 Improved the For-Loop Syntax
What exactly is your complaint with it?

`auto&&` has been standard syntax in C++ for going on 15 years now and has a very clear, irreplaceable meaning - a type-deduced forward reference - to any remotely competent developer.

Tadpole9181··on Zig Creator Calls Spade a Spade, Anthropic Blows Smoke
Except the blog post shows that they fixed a hundred or so known issues, patching several memory leaks and making the project viable for Prisma Compute's adoption - which it wasn't before. It's now running in production in two places just fine.

Can you point to an equal number of issue tracker tickets showing novel bugs or regressions in the canary build?

Tadpole9181··on Zig Creator Calls Spade a Spade, Anthropic Blows Smoke
You're not helping your case.

So if I use Zig, I need to do all of that perfectly from day one and I don't get any help from static analysis to do it. Or else I've poisoned my whole program in scary ways and will require a total refactor where I still won't have any help and once again can't make a single mistake.

Tadpole9181··on Zig Creator Calls Spade a Spade, Anthropic Blows Smoke
Which is still a step ahead of Zig, which requires an entire rewrite to have the tiniest shred of RAII or borrow checking. What's your point, that if we can't do everything perfectly in one step we can't do it at all?
Tadpole9181··on Migrating a production AI agent to GPT-5.6: 2.2x faster, 27% cheaper
The problem I always run into with subagents is that they are isolated. This is a double-edged sword, as it keeps context down and lets them "focus", but it often means they must do their own research to continue to do work given to them, which eats uncached tokens.

So depending on how heavily agents are used on what tasks, it's entirely possible that you get worse work for more cost.

Tadpole9181··on My thoughts on the Bun Rust rewrite
So you don't have any. And after reading all of Jarred's posts and responses you found that he repeatedly thanked Zig and said he respected Andrew but that, after donating over a hundred thousand dollars to their work, his project had different needs than before and needed to change stack?

Incredible display of bad faith discussion. You should be ashamed.

Tadpole9181··on GPT-5.6, Grok 4.5, Claude, and Muse Spark build the same 4 apps
And it uses the word in weird ways I have never experienced. I'm genuinely curious what's in the training set that caused this tic.
Tadpole9181··on 45% of Enthusiasts 'Seriously Considering' Leaving Sony for PC
So they switch to Steam, a digital-only platform? In what world does that make sense?
Tadpole9181··on TypeScript 7
I've never used bun on production for this very reason. But nevertheless, tens of thousands of people and businesses do.

And I'm not sure how you're responding to my comment. The parent said "this is a marketing stunt" derogatorily, as if it's slop that doesn't work. This is already the canary build, it's more stable than the current stable, and is actively in production products in wide use.

The parent is objectively wrong, whether or not I personally use Bun.

Tadpole9181··on My thoughts on the Bun Rust rewrite
Please, enumerate them.
Tadpole9181··on My thoughts on the Bun Rust rewrite
Jarred, reasonably and publicly, did not expect a 1.2 million line rewrite to finish, fix a hundred bugs, and have no noticeable regressions in 11 days of experimenting.
Tadpole9181··on My thoughts on the Bun Rust rewrite
I'm curious and would love to hear more. In long?
Tadpole9181··on My thoughts on the Bun Rust rewrite
The rust port is the canary build now, being actively deployed to production in Claude Code and Prisma Compute (Beta).
Tadpole9181··on My thoughts on the Bun Rust rewrite
If the majority of those are at an FFI boundary to a language without lifetime analysis, I don't really see how they could be fixed without rewriting all that downstream software?
Tadpole9181··on My thoughts on the Bun Rust rewrite
I mean, case in point. (One of?) Zig's largest adopted projects who was donating $60,000 a year made by a contributor that worked directly with Andrew... Was not "stinky" engineering.

If Bun can't get it right starting in 2026 with all of Zig's tooling and someone who worked on the language, what hope does my random team have?

Especially when we could, instead, use Rust. With a larger community to boot.

Tadpole9181··on My thoughts on the Bun Rust rewrite
When did Jarred say anything but kind things to Andrew?
← PreviousPage 7 of 34Next →