Combined with the Apple button reading "Download for Windows" on a Windows machine, and basic HTML issues like `we're`, I'm not inclined to have this software running my entire PC.
1,897 karma · joined September 27, 2023
Combined with the Apple button reading "Download for Windows" on a Windows machine, and basic HTML issues like `we're`, I'm not inclined to have this software running my entire PC.
Except, you know, multiple real companies saying that it is and using it in production. And the fact it closed all known memory leaks. And that nobody has a really pointed to a single actual issue the new version introduced after two months of endless, ceaseless bitching.
I'm also fascinated by all these people upset at Jarred for harming the readability of a codebase they've literally never cared about before it become drama. Bun has almost exclusively been maintained by Oven employees since it's inception.
> Deno for instance have ~0.2x as many unsafes.
A project written ground-up in Rust idiomatically, with a smaller surface area, still has an unsafe footprint within an order of magnitude compared to this automated rewrite from an unsafe language with different practices and known bugs? That's not exactly the slam you think it is.
I don't understand why folk are having such a hard time understanding why you do large projects in multiple steps? 80/20 rule? Perfect is the enemy of good?
Was nobody here for moving billions of lines of JavaScript to Typescript? It starts with declarations, then turn on type checking gradually inside the codebase: piece by piece until done.
In Zig, every single memory operation is unsafe.
And Bun must interface with C code that has no safe interface, necessitating a ton of boundary-level unsafe behaviors.
There's too much, sure, but can we at least be honest and reasonable?
I cannot fathom implementing and shipping a feature to hundreds of thousands of people without even asking basic questions like: "what types of questions does Claude ask users".
Literally one of the most used plugins in their entire ecosystem, provided via their official plugin marketplace, is Superpowers. A plugin whose very first operating step is _asking numerous questions about product requirements_. Of course those prompts can't be skipped!
It wasn't even parameterized for Claude to tell the prompt what severity of question was being asked to allow at least _something_ to categorize urgency or expected response time.
Even more egregiously, 60 seconds!? The first time I noticed this happened was when it asked me a question, I turned to my second monitor to go look at some product documentation to get an answer, and by the time I turned back it had skipped me. How can I possibly provide any kind of informed answer in under 60 seconds? I can barely read some of its context for a question in 60 seconds!
I don't think they did this with malintent, but I do think this shows an enormous gap in judgement in how they handle the idea to delivery pipeline.
I'm really sorry, but it really does look like we may have had our last actual election already.
> ARC-AGI-3 is an interactive reasoning benchmark which challenges AI agents to explore novel environments, acquire goals on the fly, build adaptable world models, and learn continuously.
This harness does nothing to actually accomplish those goals.
It's a clever trick, sure, but you aren't allowed to use a calculator on your basic algebra tests in school for a reason.
1. The AI plays the game and records outputs.
2. The AI does TDD using those outputs to create its own copy of the game.
3. The AI then uses it's copy of the source code to understand the rules. This bypasses the intent for Arc-AGI-3 to test the underlying model's ability to intuit game rules naturally, like a human.
4. The AI then runs simulated moves on the copy of the game before playing them in the "real" game. This bypasses the intent for Arc-AGI-3 to test the underlying model's ability to plan and predict moves, and track world state in its "head" over time.
To make an apt comparison... You go to get your chess ELO. You don't know chess at all and you're really bad at it, so you pull out your laptop and write a chess engine. Then when you go to get ranked, you just copy the moves from the software. Now you're a grand master.
This harness is really moving the goalpost by defeating the entire point of the test. Instead of seeing the strength of a model's world view, its ability to internally derive and intuit rules, and its ability to keep track of game state over time, we're just letting the AI cheat. This is just the LLM equivalent of running a chess engine to the side.
And this harness would not work in a remotely complex game and relies on the fact that Arc-AGI-3 is a focused test that only made the games as complicated as they needed to be for current model performance.
Gifts aren't supposed to be impressive. Nor is their value measured by effort or cost.
Nor does this reply answer their question of "is hiring a professional to to it any better?" It seems you would have to argue no, though.
`auto&&` has been standard syntax in C++ for going on 15 years now and has a very clear, irreplaceable meaning - a type-deduced forward reference - to any remotely competent developer.
Can you point to an equal number of issue tracker tickets showing novel bugs or regressions in the canary build?
So if I use Zig, I need to do all of that perfectly from day one and I don't get any help from static analysis to do it. Or else I've poisoned my whole program in scary ways and will require a total refactor where I still won't have any help and once again can't make a single mistake.
So depending on how heavily agents are used on what tasks, it's entirely possible that you get worse work for more cost.
Incredible display of bad faith discussion. You should be ashamed.
And I'm not sure how you're responding to my comment. The parent said "this is a marketing stunt" derogatorily, as if it's slop that doesn't work. This is already the canary build, it's more stable than the current stable, and is actively in production products in wide use.
The parent is objectively wrong, whether or not I personally use Bun.
If Bun can't get it right starting in 2026 with all of Zig's tooling and someone who worked on the language, what hope does my random team have?
Especially when we could, instead, use Rust. With a larger community to boot.