HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

TameAntelope

5,096 karma · joined July 12, 2020

thetameantelope@gmail.com
submissionscomments
TameAntelope··on NYC releases PSA for what to do in case of nuclear attack
> IIRC, the radiation levels that soon after a nuclear war could be in the "dying within a week" range (depending on the local fallout conditions).

The whole point of the advice here is that you remember incorrectly. It only takes 24 hours for the worst radiation, the kill-you-in-a-week radiation, to subside.

Don’t you think the source here would know better than you about this? What arrogance it would be to think you know better, from a vague recollection, no less…

TameAntelope··on Google slowing hiring to “technical and critical roles” only
And yet labor participation is above pre pandemic levels, wage growth is accelerating, we just hit three year highs on new jobs in June, gas prices are finally dropping…

If you think companies are some kind of accurate leading indicator here, you’re being highly selective in the data you’re evaluating.

The economy is complex, it’s safe to slow down hiring, no one will remember a company that left money on the table when the storm clouds started forming, but they will remember a company that ignored “obvious” signs of a problem.

TameAntelope··on NYC releases PSA for what to do in case of nuclear attack
What's more lethal; dying in a week because you didn't organize with the people who are left, or dying in a decade because of radiation poisoning?
TameAntelope··on Thoughts on the potato diet
Then why does my source use it as a measurement? Why wouldn’t they be more specific, if being more specific were very important?

I’m very familiar with the “BMI is not good!” argument, but if it’s good enough for Harvard’s School of Public Health, it’s good enough for me.

TameAntelope··on NYC releases PSA for what to do in case of nuclear attack
I’m assuming the “24 hours” thing is a math thing where staying inside additional time will be more harmful than getting outside and finding out what to do next.

If you can do both, yeah do that, but if you could never leave your home, and your home is a clean room, also definitely do that.

TameAntelope··on Writing: A misunderstood activity
Does this count as "Writing"? I write comments on HN, am I doing the "good" kind of writing?

* Nobody (and I mean nobody) is asking me to write comments,

* I'm not documenting anything (perhaps my opinion on something), and

* I am vastly under-qualified to write about the topics I "write" about.

Does tweeting count? Does commenting on Reddit/Facebook/LinkedIn/MySpace/etc. count?

If so, I think maybe it's time we give those platforms (and indeed this one) more respect; they're places that encourage people who wouldn't ever write for its own sake a way to express themselves through the written word.

TameAntelope··on Writing: A misunderstood activity
> Two problems with writing: first, it looks easy because it uses the same symbols of speech; second, everyone who was taught the alphabet and basic sentence structures can produce something similar to writing when it’s not. Writers, however, know it’s painfully hard to produce one readable, unambiguous paragraph. On the other hand, casual text producers (read: the majority) think it takes nothing special to write. This amateur attitude makes writing the most misunderstood activity.

There's some irony in this first paragraph being not-so-well written, right?

> first, it looks easy because it uses the same symbols of speech

Same symbols as... speaking? as other writing? There's a comparison made here that isn't completed.

> second, everyone who was taught the alphabet and basic sentence structures can produce something similar to writing when it’s not.

Same problem; "when some writing is not actually similar to other writing" I assume was the intent, but this is a stilted way of making that point. A better (though longer) way of saying this might be, "Anyone taught the alphabet and English sentence structure can produce 'writing', but what those people produce bears little resemblance to what 'good' writing actually looks like."

I don't really want to go through and pick this whole article apart, I just thought it was interesting the author "chose" to start their article on "good writing is hard" by writing a poor opening paragraph!

TameAntelope··on Thoughts on the potato diet
> Excess body weight can put stress on your joints, but doesn't generally have any other negative effects.

That seems to contradict the Harvard School of Public Health's article[0] that says:

> The results showed that participants with BMI of 22.5-<25 kg/m2 (considered a healthy weight range) had the lowest mortality risk during the time they were followed. The risk of mortality increased significantly throughout the overweight range: a BMI of 25-<27.5 kg/m2 was associated with a 7% higher risk of mortality; a BMI of 27.5-<30 kg/m2 was associated with a 20% higher risk; a BMI of 30.0-<35.0 kg/m2 was associated with a 45% higher risk; a BMI of 35.0-<40.0 kg/m2 was associated with a 94% higher risk; and a BMI of 40.0-<60.0 kg/m2 was associated with a nearly three-fold risk. Every 5 units higher BMI above 25 kg/m2 was associated with about 31% higher risk of premature death. Participants who were underweight also had a higher mortality risk.

These findings don't seem to discriminate on the source of the BMI, only on its existence.

[0] https://www.hsph.harvard.edu/news/press-releases/overweight-...

TameAntelope··on Few people grasp the amount of effort Daniel Gackle expends running HN (2020)
Haha, your comment is exactly the comment I'd expect to get moderated, but won't because it's long and dang won't read it (and he is spread too thin).

Any comment citing "newguidelines.html" should probably get flagged for review, for example.

I also am not new here, but imagine why I might seem to be...

TameAntelope··on Few people grasp the amount of effort Daniel Gackle expends running HN (2020)
Look at his post history, you can see plenty of examples.

A pattern he follows very commonly is seen here [0]: "Can you stop doing $thing?" However, it's dang's opinion that $thing is occurring, and he makes zero effort to understand why $thing could even be happening, and further entertains zero challenges to his interpretation of what has taken place. It's, "stop doing $thing, which is definitely happening, or else I will ban you."

Here's another good example of dang handling moderation poorly [1]: he spends zero time explaining the situation, zero time listening to the perspective of the "accused", and simply, curtly, dismisses that person from the site.

Ironically, dang's intervention is often the most toxic behavior in a comment chain, and these examples are what I found in just the past two hours.

There are thousands, or more, people treated this way, and instead of concern, praise is constantly dumped on him, like what he's doing is some incredible or even desirable behavior! The assumption is the site is better off without these people he treats poorly on it, but I doubt any rigor has been placed on that assumption whatsoever.

[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32039759

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32039501

TameAntelope··on Few people grasp the amount of effort Daniel Gackle expends running HN (2020)
I get a very different sense from the reading of his comments to users; curt and inconsiderate. He tends to make declarations about behavior that sound objective but are really just his very casual read of a situation, and there’s no appeal or redress possible.

Additionally, he tends to favor the original aggressor, ignoring the concept of instigation to fix the proximate cause of the negative interactions here. Don’t get caught punching second, in other words.

It’s classic utilitarianism; if 1% of users get shat upon by dang, and 99% in any way benefit from his negative behavior, I suppose the folks here would be alright with that?

TameAntelope··on HN is up again
Danger: that is decidedly not what HN is, at all.
TameAntelope··on Met Police UK Live Facial Recognition
> And in this thread, today, you are talking against concerns that a government running Live Facial Recognition could result in overreach as the "Slippery Slope Fallacy".

I did not do this, you inferred my position, but all I wish to discuss is whether or not the person I replied to had a problem with this already-happening use of facial recognition, or if they were indeed okay with this use, but not some other, imagined, use.

TameAntelope··on Met Police UK Live Facial Recognition
Pardon? Where did I say any of that?
TameAntelope··on Met Police UK Live Facial Recognition
I'm honestly confused about what your point is, because so far it seems like you're suggesting that since people sometimes act irrationally, there's no such thing as the logical fallacy called "Slippery Slope"...
TameAntelope··on Met Police UK Live Facial Recognition
Not the same thing, but it does explain your confusion.
TameAntelope··on Met Police UK Live Facial Recognition
A substantial part of my job is to eliminate scope creep, so yes you absolutely can “just stop”.

Irrational people can use things like momentum and inertia in their arguments, but that’s quite easily stopped by a rational argument outlining the differences between the thing that was allowed and the proposed thing.

TameAntelope··on Met Police UK Live Facial Recognition
You can’t hate the slippery slope fallacy out of existence; it’s real, it applies here, and it means the argument being put forward, that allowing one thing must mean we allow something similar but worse, is not a valid one.

It’s not magic, it’s simply rational. Allowing something doesn’t mean you must then allow something else, that isn’t how it works, and it’s probably more noxious and damaging to society that such a thought is allowed to propagate such as what you’ve written here.

TameAntelope··on Met Police UK Live Facial Recognition
A "Slippery slope" argument is a fallacy; when the thing we don't want to "slip" to comes, there is absolutely nothing stopping us from simply, well, stopping.

What you're really saying is that you don't have any problem with this. One thing at a time!

TameAntelope··on SOC2: The screenshots will continue until security improves
Yeah I was trying to make a joke that didn't land I guess.
TameAntelope··on SOC2: The screenshots will continue until security improves
Okay cool; but where is the report?

Surely you didn't write all of this just to make me sign an NDA to see your report...

TameAntelope··on Meta Accounts: A New Login for VR
FB/Meta tracking your usage isn't even discussed in the article, and nothing about not tracking is suggested at all in the title.

This just seems like an excuse to rant about disliking Facebook.

TameAntelope··on Meta Accounts: A New Login for VR
Oh get over it, your hate for FB is noted. The title is accurate, the information is news, and IMO HN users are smart enough to know what a PR release is when they read it.

What are you worried about? That folks will walk this earth thinking you have to use a Meta account instead of a Facebook account to log into your VR app?

TameAntelope··on Delayed Messages on iOS
Yeah, "This guy is great but we will have a hard time contacting him spontaneously after hours so I guess it's back to the hiring pool!"

...is not a sentence that'd be said very often/ever.

TameAntelope··on Why can't we have raw UDP in JavaScript?
Small point of order, but shouldn't this be retitled to, "No really, why can't we have raw UDP in the browser?" since you definitely can do UDP in "JavaScript"?[0]

[0] https://nodejs.org/api/dgram.html

TameAntelope··on Ask HN: Would it make more to sense to learn more SQL or another language?
If it's interesting to you, go for it! You'll probably learn a ton more about anything if you're interested, even if it's not 100% relevant to your job, than you would forcing yourself to learn something you feel certain would be relevant but isn't sparking your interest.
TameAntelope··on Delayed Messages on iOS
The negative consequences of making the wrong choice are both extremely low and extremely loud, so I urge you to just take a guess, with a strong bias for every technology platform being async.
TameAntelope··on Ask HN: Would it make more to sense to learn more SQL or another language?
SQL doesn't sit in a category that's similar to "other" languages. You often need to know how to construct SQL queries in addition to working in another language.

Honestly, learning a language to "improve" yourself is probably a waste of time. Learning a kind of language is more valuable. Not SQL, but declarative. Not Haskell but functional. Not Java but object oriented.

Additionally, it'll be more useful to understand programming concepts, like SOLID, flow control, data structures, etc.

As a developer for ~15 years, I don't generally fear projects using languages I'm not familiar with anymore. I know I'll pick up the basics to start contributing, and I'll grow into mastery over the ensuing months.

Which brings me to my real advice; learn how to be productive while learning. If you can do that, you'll have a long and successful career as a developer.

TameAntelope··on Delayed Messages on iOS
I disagree; a message sent on an async platform is not expected to be responded to immediately, it's simply meant to be removed from the sender's "to-do" list.
TameAntelope··on Delayed Messages on iOS
No. Manage your own messaging systems, don't put that extra work onto others, as not everyone has the same schedule as you.
← PreviousPage 4 of 34Next →