HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Tharkun

3,342 karma · joined February 11, 2011

Gone fishing
submissionscomments
Tharkun··on Linus’s rules on keeping Git history clean (2009)
Sure. But many users of git don't know (or care) about the workflow of the git team. They know github. Maybe gitlab. Or bitbucket. They could go their entire development careers without ever sending a patch as an email, instead relying on feature branches and pull requests.

This could be completely alien to them, and it seems wrong to downvote srg for pointing that out.

Tharkun··on Linus’s rules on keeping Git history clean (2009)
I suspect you're overestimating the number of developers who know or use Linux. Many developers use Git on Windows and don't know anything about Linux, let alone about the workflow of the kernel team.
Tharkun··on Flight risk: can we take the carbon out of air travel?
Indeed. But sadly that's not how plane tickets are currently priced.
Tharkun··on Flight risk: can we take the carbon out of air travel?
Europe's train network isn't quite as wonderful as many would have you believe. Connections in cities like Paris are terrible and slow (they sometimes require crossing the entire city, which can take a very long time, especially with luggage). Sleeper trains have been mostly retired, only to be replaced with very expensive "high speed" connections which aren't quite as fast or as convenient as closing your eyes and waking up at your destination. Not to mention they're nearly always more expensive than cheap flights.

There has been some talk of reviving some sleeper trains, but so far I haven't seen any new sleeper routes. Of course, Europe is a big place, but as far as I can tell, not much has improved over the last decade. If anything, cheap airfare has been on the rise and rail has been declining.

Don't get me wrong, I love trains, and I would like nothing more than a fast and cheap inter-European rail network worthy of the name.

Tharkun··on TSV Utilities: Command line tools for large, tabular data files
Thanks for these. I've rolled my own implementation of many of these over the last 20 odd year, most of them living in ugly shell scripts embedded as aliases in my env. This will make my life easier!
Tharkun··on BMW unveils car sprayed with Vantablack
Car crashes are a major cause of death. Actively making cars harder to see should be a crime instead of a stupid marketing gimmick.
Tharkun··on Show HN: Zepel, a Jira alternative for product teams
I wish I had. Been looking for that holy grail for some time.
Tharkun··on Show HN: Zepel, a Jira alternative for product teams
A subset of engineers hate Jira. A lot of us love it. It's orders of magnitude better than any other issue tracker out there. It's an absolute powerhouse with its "Jira Query Language" query support. It scales from tiny one man shops (in which case it costs you a tenner), to massive organizations like the Apache Software Foundation.

It's got bells and whistles to spare, including several kitchen sinks, which can make it a bit daunting to configure. But you can configure it to suit your needs, instead of having to conform to some harebrained workflow someone else decided was Good Enough.

What I really hate is that, even after all these years, it doesn't come with a good planning tool. Portfolio is terrible. I've evaluated several Gantt plugins, which were all terrible. A closely related problem is the missing calendar integration. Atlassian has a calendar plugin for Confluence (wiki), which makes zero sense to me. In my world, issue tracking and planning go hand in hand. And you can't plan shit without a calendar. Surely I'm not the only one who feels that way?

Edit: while I'm out praising Jira, have you seen their SDK? You can roll your own Jira plugin in 15 minutes. Bam. Frictionless. Engineers hate it? Those are some weird engineers.

Tharkun··on Thunderbird 68.0
Ah thanks for clarifying that. That does seem like a useful feature.

If there isn't an option or plugin for this already, it sounds like relatively low hanging fruit. Might even be a good first project for someone who's interested in contributing to tbird.

As an aside, back in the days of dialup, I would compose a batch of mails offline, give them all a read-through, and then connect and send. My mails contained significantly fewer errors back then.

Tharkun··on Thunderbird 68.0
Undo send? That always struck me as a silly feature. It just sends another email, one politely requesting the removal of the first.

Also, TBird does have a unified inbox. I've been using it that way for years.

As for search, I have 20+ years worth of mail in thunderbird. Search works. I mostly rely on the quick filter (which filters sender/subject), and occasionally switch to the full-fledged search feature, which can take a while depending on the complexity of my searches and how far back I want to search.

Tharkun··on Study identifies main culprit behind lithium metal battery failure
This argument doesn't hold much water. Sure, it might be technically correct for Balinese ecomomy. But lots of people fly lots of places for very capricious reasons. If vacation is the goal, then everyone can go on a trip a bit closer to home without flying. Certain major tourism centers will lose out, but on average, there will be just as many tourists, just in different places.

Air travel is far too cheap, everything else follows from that.

Tharkun··on North American versus European distribution systems (2011)
I'm seeing some broad generalizations in this thread, and some downvotes in disagreement. Please remember that Europe is a big place, and is not necessarily homogeneous. There are large differences between countries, and sometimes between smaller regions within countries. Just because A has 3-fase power cookers, doesn't mean B does too, for example.
Tharkun··on North American versus European distribution systems (2011)
Belgium does, in fact, not have electric heating in most houses. The most popular heate sources are gas and oil (diesel, often incorrectly referred to as mazout). Electricity is very expensive in Belgium.

Air source electric heat pumps are on the rise, but it'll be decades before they catch up to gas.

Tharkun··on Pronunciations for hexadecimal numbers (1968)
Belgian French uses septante/nonante. Huitante would be a great addition.
Tharkun··on Ha-ha wall
The popularity of freerunning/parkour makes me doubt their usefulness as a security device, unless they're made significantly wider & deeper than the wikipedia examples.
Tharkun··on Apollo Guidance Computer switching power supply works after 50 years
It's a common misconception that a good kitchen knife will last forever. It won't. Repeated sharpening will make the knife smaller and smaller. Here's a picture of a sushi chef's knives: the knife on the bottom right was once the same size as the top left one. http://i.imgur.com/EiQnGu3.png
Tharkun··on A person has died from a vaping-related condition
I also remember reading about the heat of the coils causing "nano" copper particles to be released/inhaled, might be a contributing factor.
Tharkun··on List of military tactics
There's a battle sequence in Frank Herbert's Dune (probably Chapterhouse, maybe Heretics) where a commander (Miles Teg) directs the battle by giving real time commands to individual soldiers, where the deepmind you mentioned resides in his head.

It's a great little sequence, worth a read if you're into that sort of thing.

Tharkun··on Plastics: What's Recyclable, What Becomes Trash and Why
Belgium allegedly had an 85+% recycling rate, though I have no idea what all this stuff gets recycled to, and I suspect it gets downcycled to useless garbage.
Tharkun··on Startups from Y Combinator’s S19 Demo Day 2
The Custom Movement sounded really interesting for a moment. I was already having fantasies about getting a pair of sneakers with thin soles, wide toe boxes, plenty of air holes and one the left shoe one size larger than the right.

Alas. It's just about printing designs on sneakers.

Tharkun··on Open Location Code: An Open Source Standard for Addresses
Thanks for clearing that up!
Tharkun··on Open Location Code: An Open Source Standard for Addresses
The docs also seem to indicate that 3mx3m is the smallest grid they can address, but at the same they use addressing in slums as a use case...who has that much real estate in the slums?
Tharkun··on Making email more modern with JMAP
> we need something better than IMAP/POP to have a fighting chance in challenging google

How's that? I don't see how messing with IMAP/POP/JMAP will make a difference there. Mail delivery, over SMTP, is what the Gmails and Outlooks of this world are so nasty about. They claim to protect their users from spam, but small mail servers get killed in the crossfire. Mail clients downloading mail over whatever protocol is a trivial problem by comparison, and they have zilch to do with SMTP abuse.

Tharkun··on The most frequent 777 characters give 90% coverage of Kanji in the wild
Give it time. Compulsory Latin education was very common for a very long time in large parts of Europe. In parts because the catholic church had a lot of influence. Now people barely even remember it. Many schools now offer Latin as an elective subject, and those who are into that sort of thing can study it to their hears contents, without wasting everyone else's time [1].

Something similar will probably happen to Kanji. They'll become more and more useless. And, eventually, education will adapt. Give it another generation or so.

[1] I realize that whether or not studying Latin (or Kanji) is a waste of time is a contentious point. If it's your cup of tea, go for it, but don't force it on others. Force them to learn maths instead.

Tharkun··on Making email more modern with JMAP
The real positive thing that needs to happen to email, is putting an end to near-monopoly of gmail. Email is great. It's decentralized. You can simply roll your own. You can use whatever client you like. Apparently even using HTTP/JSON.

But you can't send mail to anyone using gmail, which is nearly everyone, unless you play by Google's rules. And even then they'll still put you in their spam folder, or just randomly blackhole you without any explanation or recourse.

JMAP vs IMAP vs POP is moot as far as I'm concerned. As long as my mail client continues to work, I'm good. If this gains any traction, I'm sure dovecot and the likes will add support for it (if they haven't already). But no amount of protocol fiddling can fix the fundamental issues of email centralization.

Tharkun··on Making email more modern with JMAP
> every programming language in existence has easy to use HTTP and JSON parsing libraries

That argument doesn't hold much water. Every programming language in existence also has easy to use socket libraries. Are you implying that HTTP and JSON are less error-prone than whatever-over-TCP? There's nothing magical about either HTTP or JSON that makes them the right tool for every job. But I guess when all you have is a hammer ...

Tharkun··on The most frequent 777 characters give 90% coverage of Kanji in the wild
The good news is that this is a problem that's solving itself. Kanji, especially complex kanji, are dying out in favour of katakana. An anecdotal example, as little as 20 years ago, all the fish markets had signs for each fish, in kanji. Now all of those signs are in katakana. Many young people can't read the kanji for specific fish anymore. They can probably manage tuna, but hake? Pollock?

Most written communication is typed. Which involves typing each word phonetically (and then picking the correct kanji from a list). This is orders of magnitude easier than writing a kanji by hand. You can get by without knowing stroke order or without knowing exactly how to write it. As long as you're even vaguely familiar with a kanji, you'll be able to pick the right one from the list.

Give this another generation or so, and I expect the coverage of those "777" will increase to ~100%, and the number of kana-only words will increase dramatically. National pride and linguists be damned, convenience always wins out in the end.

Tharkun··on The Impact of Meditating Every Day
I can't speak for meditation apps in general, but Headspace managed to introduce millions to meditation. They have a bunch of guided meditations for beginners, but as you progress the amount of guidance is gradually reduced.

Headspace certainly helped me pick up meditation again after a decade long hiatus, in part because of their excellent & gentle progression.

Granted, it's a bit silly to keep paying for a daily 30 minutes of silence.

Tharkun··on The Impact of Meditating Every Day
Do you usually sit in seiza posture, or do you prefer agura for such lengthy sessions? I can put up with an hour in seiza, but four hours must require a fortitude of mind that I can't even begin to fathom.
Tharkun··on How close are we to 3D printing the human heart?
Page won't load, so I can only speculate based on the title. Barring miracles, the answer is "very far off". Sure, the macroscopic structure is relatively simple. And sure, it's just a pump. But it's a pump with its own frequency generator (SA node). Which supplies blood to itself. Which is self-repairing to a large extent, in spite of the insane volumes of blood it pumps every living moment and the stresses that puts on its own blood vessels. It's an electromechanical Swiss watch, where timing is crucial and various types of tissue have various conductive properties.

Good luck with the 3D printer. Maybe start with a valve that lasts longer than a pig valve, move up from there.

Edit: nerve replacement would be a nice next step. Or simple muscle replacement. Lots of people would benefit from that, and both are likely prerequisites to "printing" a heart.

← PreviousPage 3 of 34Next →