HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

TheCoelacanth

8,636 karma · joined February 15, 2013

thecoelacanth@gmail.com
submissionscomments
TheCoelacanth··on Award-winning AI literature
Because there are a million literary awards and some of them are awarded by people who are bad at recognizing quality.

Additionally, many of these cases were only partially created using AI or aren't proven to have actually used AI or used AI in a creative and non-conventional way and that's what they won for.

TheCoelacanth··on Judge Orders Meta to Name Employees Who Approved Torrenting
Probably too busy sending anti-trans tweets from her private jet to say anything about piracy.
TheCoelacanth··on SCOTUS couldn't take up a copyright case because four justices have book deals
Yeah, you have a lifetime appointment to one of the most powerful jobs in the world and it pays >$300k with a great pension. You should not be allowed any other sources of income full stop. Same for the president. No outside income, no investments other than target date retirement funds.

If your neighbor offers you $50 to mow their lawn, turn it down. President and Supreme Court justice aren't side-jobs.

TheCoelacanth··on The Elizabeth Holmes documentary “You Can See Everything” is deceiving
Yeah, they are splitting hairs. She's in prison for investor fraud instead of patient fraud for because investor fraud is drastically easier to prove (the same reason Al Capone when to jail for tax evasion and not something else).

She told well-documented lies to investors that made it a much more attractive investment. They invested and lost money. It's basically public information who the victims are. Clear-cut fraud and very easy to prove.

For patient fraud, you probably need to track down the people who were actually harmed in a material way (attempted fraud isn't a crime). That's going to be a small subset of the people who got tests and it's going to be hidden away in private medical records. Doable if they really had to, but why bother when you have a slam-dunk case for something else.

TheCoelacanth··on The Elizabeth Holmes documentary “You Can See Everything” is deceiving
I'm thoroughly baffled by this story. Digger was non-stop laughs when I saw it. The End of Oak Street I don't remember as well, but I'm pretty sure there were some moments that got big laughs.
TheCoelacanth··on New Withings Users Must Pay $99/Year for Apple Health Syncing
The entire economy is a grift now.
TheCoelacanth··on Apple's new 'Switch to Safari' campaign details why you should ditch Chrome
It's a balancing act.

Lack of browser diversity is bad because it puts too much control in the hands of the only browser vendor.

Lack of browser choice is bad because it puts too much control in the hands of whatever browser vendor they use.

We need both for a healthy web.

TheCoelacanth··on Example.com just launched the biggest redesign in decades
To minimize their hosting costs. They get a large amount of automated traffic that won't actually render the content, so moving as much content as possible out of the initial HTML document is more efficient.
TheCoelacanth··on FTC is investigating OpenAI, Anthropic and other AI companies over product risks
Using a car on public roads at the speeds they typically go now would be (and was) considered grossly negligent without special laws allowing it.
TheCoelacanth··on FTC is investigating OpenAI, Anthropic and other AI companies over product risks
Name one other multi-ton object that you can move through public spaces at high velocities without the law considering it inherently grossly negligent.
TheCoelacanth··on FTC is investigating OpenAI, Anthropic and other AI companies over product risks
Judges making their own interpretation is the entire problem with anti-trust law.

The law is very explicit: no mergers or acquisitions where the "effect may be substantially to lessen competition". Not "will" lessen competition, "may" lessen competition.

The law as written should prevent basically any merger between large competitors. Judges have watered that down with bullshit about customer harm that appears nowhere in the law.

TheCoelacanth··on FTC is investigating OpenAI, Anthropic and other AI companies over product risks
They pretty much did. Cars get an insane amount of special legal treatment. It's basically legal to kill people with a car as long as you aren't drunk or grossly negligent.

I will be shocked if I live to see a year where AI kills more people than cars do legally.

TheCoelacanth··on Why the Bronze Age Collapsed
Because other people learned to make iron weapons and fought back.

Bronze weapon technology had a moat because it required scarce, imported resources. Even if they learned the techniques, most people couldn't make them.

The resources for iron weaponry were readily available; they just needed to learn the techniques.

TheCoelacanth··on Why the Bronze Age Collapsed
I think that's only correct when looking at the time period immediately before Rome.

Many Bronze Age empires had complex centralized bureaucracies and are generally considered states.

TheCoelacanth··on Burning Man death rates – A short lesson in statistics
It's not pointless to figure some things out just because you can't figure everything out.
TheCoelacanth··on C's Flexible Integer Sizes Were Not a Design Mistake
I would argue that flexible integers aren't the design mistake; the naming of them is.

There should never have been a type `int` that holds a variable amount of bytes; it should have been the modern aliases like int_least32_t and int_fast32_t that actually communicate the possible size of the value.

TheCoelacanth··on Feds Target AI Critics as "Foreign Agents"
The constitution doesn't apply to the foreign nationals on foreign soil; it applies to the people working for the US government who are doing something to those foreign nationals.
TheCoelacanth··on The End Of Upward Mobility – AI is coming for the meritocracy
You just claimed that AI will eliminate the cognitive elite.

All that leaves is born wealthy and small business owners. The small business owners aren't going to last long if their only potential customers are the generationally wealthy and the working class.

TheCoelacanth··on The End Of Upward Mobility – AI is coming for the meritocracy
Not at all. It destroys the only aspects of the economy that don't simply hand everything to the people who were lucky enough to be born wealthy.
TheCoelacanth··on US coal 'biggest contributor by far' to rise in global emissions
Certainly not per capita.
TheCoelacanth··on US coal 'biggest contributor by far' to rise in global emissions
The past is the past. I think it's more important what choices they are making now. China is aggressively replacing fossil fuels with renewables. The US should be doing the same but instead is actively trying to increase fossil fuel usage.

When the crossover will happen is impossible to say because future US administrations probably won't pursue such mindbogglingly stupid policies.

TheCoelacanth··on Writing a better reality: The case for optimistic sci-fi (2022)
Terra Ignota is one of the most unique and extraordinary series I've ever read. It's so rare to find something that combines meticulous and expansive worldbuilding, deep exploration of big ideas, strong emotional resonance and finely crafted prose.
TheCoelacanth··on Writing a better reality: The case for optimistic sci-fi (2022)
Yeah, and you have to keep in mind that "human" in the Culture is an extremely broad category. A Klingon or a Ferengi or even something substantially weirder would count as human to the Culture.

When they visit 1970s Earth in State of the Art, they have to be very selective about who they send because many of them would stick out like a sore thumb even after cosmetic surgery.

TheCoelacanth··on Writing a better reality: The case for optimistic sci-fi (2022)
It's not explicitly stated, but I get the impression that Culture citizens are generally very pro-social and willing to sacrifice for others' benefits and may well have been engineered with that aim.

They were willing to sacrifice nearly a trillion lives in the Idiran war, which was voted on by the entire population. Even after that vote, it was very easy to opt-out and I get the sense that most of those who did were motivated by genuine pacifism rather than personal fear.

The most dangerous and uncomfortable jobs like Special Circumstances and Contact seem to have an enormous surplus of volunteers and it's even hinted that there might not be any need for humans to do most of those jobs; they exist just because humans want to do them.

TheCoelacanth··on US coal 'biggest contributor by far' to rise in global emissions
This is more about the trajectory. China is all-in on building renewables while the current US administration is pushing hard for more coal even when it doesn't make economic sense.
TheCoelacanth··on US coal 'biggest contributor by far' to rise in global emissions
Nuclear made a lot more sense back when solar panels and batteries were less mature.

With how insanely cheap solar and batteries are getting, it doesn't make much financial sense to build new nuclear plants anymore (for grid generation, they're still great for things like military ships).

TheCoelacanth··on US 10-Year Breaches 5% as Inflation, Supply Worries Mount
Genuine question: I think making things worse to motivate later making them better is a relatively common idea. Are there any historical examples of it actually working well?

To me, it seems more likely to concentrate power among people who don't want to make things better and make it easier for them to resist ever changing.

TheCoelacanth··on 25 years of mass surveillance is enough
Yeah, you have to conjure a really weird scenario for there to be any advantage.

Something like waiting until male puberty is already pretty far along and doing extensive strength training and then transitioning and competing immediately in a sport that puts a heavy premium on strength. I think most sports already have rules that would prevent this.

For someone following a more normal transitioning trajectory, there would be zero advantage; probably a significant disadvantage.

A blanket ban is just pure bullying, especially for childrens' sports (which are primarily a social activity, not a consequential competition). Individual sports can have rules to prevent the (primarily hypothetical) abusive cases without preventing children from participating in normal social activities. No one is saying that someone who's 200 lb of solid muscle and started HRT a month ago should be able to compete against girls in football or powerlifting, but pickleball, sure go for it.

TheCoelacanth··on Proposed Rule: Eliminating the Discretionary 60-Day Grace Period
It's insane to expect people to move to a different country with zero days notice.
TheCoelacanth··on Growing proof that autonomous cars save lives
Railways have always been prone to failure, even in back when rail was the hot new technology transforming the economy and minting fortunes.
← PreviousPage 2 of 34Next →