HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

TheOtherHobbes

28,514 karma · joined May 16, 2014

submissionscomments
TheOtherHobbes··on Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang's letter to staff about affair
Being seduced by a foreign agent was neither a good decision, nor evidence of good character, nor proof of situational awareness.

Can we assume this was a one-off because she was uniquely persistent and persuasive?

TheOtherHobbes··on Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang's letter to staff about affair
Indeed.

Anyone who believes he personally agonised over this alone in a darkened room is being rather naive.

TheOtherHobbes··on Apple CEO Presses Software Chief to Pursue More Ambitious AI Strategy
The subtext is clearly that Federighi may need to reconsider his position.

Not before time. Apple's software is a bland directionless nothingscape compared to the hardware.

TheOtherHobbes··on Uranium cubes reveal why the German nuclear project failed
The bombs were an atrocity against a nation that had been committing atrocities of its own.

There are no moral winners in war.

But it remains true that if Japan or Germany had had the bomb, they'd have bombed civilians without compunction, discussion, or regret.

TheOtherHobbes··on AI is dramatically accelerating AI research
You don't need perfect prediction, you need good-enough influence on enough of the population. Which is something that adtech, social and trad media, and troll farms have perfected already.

We literally have people running around convinced the earth is flat. And a president who is both senile and delusional with access to the nuclear codes.

Hostile ASI wouldn't look like a rogue individual. It would look like a faction, group, or cult which gradually infiltrated and took over political power.

Or possibly inserted itself into critical elements of the tech industry. A digital adversary could do huge damage just by taking AWS offline.

That's just one possible attack vector among many others, most of which aren't well-defended. Especially if the AI itself is being used to harden their defences.

TheOtherHobbes··on Britain to make salary disclosure in job ads mandatory
If they're truly high impact and high competence they should be able to signal that value in high impact high competence ways.

The reality is that in most industries competence and impact has very little to do with compensation. Compensation is the result of political status games, not demonstrable ability.

TheOtherHobbes··on Britain to make salary disclosure in job ads mandatory
We've had decades of salary suppression already, supported by a culture of "Don't tell your coworkers what you earn." I'm not seeing how making full disclosure mandatory would generally depress salaries.
TheOtherHobbes··on I struggle to believe that AI R&D is ingenious
LLMs are like an athletic child - they can do some basic moves, but in general they're uncoordinated.

Occasionally they do something that surprises you. If you put them inside a search loop and spend huge sums of money you'll get some nuggets of value, but for most hard problems the cost isn't worth it.

And they work best with a lot of steering.

From that POV they're exactly like human culture. Most scientific papers are trash, a few are gamechangers. Same with the arts, etc.

But we've gone from 'Can write sentences' to 'Can do frontier math problems' in maybe five years.

We absolutely do have AGI now. It's not very good AGI, but it's probably better than a lot of people were expecting.

Being better than humans at everything isn't AGI, it's ASI. A lot of the comments here seem to be lamenting that we don't have that yet, which is an interesting data point about how far the goal posts have moved.

Edit: also it makes things like this possible. So...

https://x.com/alifarhat79/status/2118478127202713778

TheOtherHobbes··on Could a modern chess engine on a Pentium have defeated Kasparov in 1996?
There's no way to know. It's impossible for anyone to imagine the AI state of the art in 2056.

But it's a fair bet that any kind of RSI will improve efficiency, possibly by a lot. And it's also very possible that 2056 AI will be running on some other substrate - maybe photonics, or something even more exotic - that wouldn't map cleanly to 2026 hardware.

Unlike chess, AI isn't a constrained problem, so there is no single higher ELO metric that would make performance comparable.

Computing in general has always become smaller, cheaper, faster, more portable, more energy efficient, and more connected.

So there may not even be a concept of discrete computing devices in 2056. Or of discrete software and services. Compute may be everywhere, in everything, all networked, reinventing itself continually.

TheOtherHobbes··on GPT-Rosalind-6 System Card Addendum
I'm one of those people who thinks the models aren't improving.

5.5 Sol would anticipate what I wanted and get it right more than often than not. 5.6 Sol kept anticipating, but would do things that made no sense in context. 6.1 Sol seems to like that but even more so. It spends a lot of time thinking, but the quality of the decisions isn't outstanding.

TheOtherHobbes··on US boy names that became girl names and vice versa
Surnames are gendered in some languages, typically when they're defined as gendered adjectives.

In Polish '...ski' is masculine and '...ska' is feminine. The prefix stays the same, so a brother and sister have slightly different surnames. (Like 'Wolski' vs 'Wolska.')

In the US some immigrants forgot this, so you get American women with a '...ski' surname.

TheOtherHobbes··on Private Jet plane crashes in Florida
It's basically airframe to dust in three frames, so maybe a 1/20th of a second. The moment of impact would have been mercifully quick.
TheOtherHobbes··on Private Jet plane crashes in Florida
https://x.com/Nalanda_index/status/2117064398166777927

The crater shows the road was destroyed. Aircraft skins are much thinner and less robust than road coverings.

TheOtherHobbes··on The future in old computer magazines (1984–2004)
That must be why the birth rate is plunging.

Be realistic - we've gone from "You, yes you, will be able to do an incredibly new and fun thing with Shiny New Technology™" to "You probably won't have a job or drinking water, your TV and phone are tracking you, all creative work is now worthless, the planet is on fire, AI may kill us all, but buy into our IPO anyway" in less than ten years.

TheOtherHobbes··on Patrick Stewart taught us what good men do with power
DS9 took more risks and the characters are more complex and layered. A few of the episodes are up there with the best TV ever made.

TNG is very, very good, but it wears its heart on its sleeve. Picard never struggles with existential moral ambiguity. Even when he (rarely) fails, he's always The Good Man.

The utopian slant is appealing and we can't help cheering for him, but DS9 revealed there was some sleight of hand behind the narrative.

Of the series since, I think only Battlestar Galactica approached similar complexity. Maybe Westworld, which got quite abstract and interesting towards the end.

The Expanse is more by the numbers. It's basically class war in space, with the military, the aristocracy, and the peasants slugging it out, while a dragon rolls in and threatens to eat everything. The writing is very challenge -> response -> partial solution over and over, and for me it just doesn't have the depth or the emotional reach. (Or the acting chops.)

TheOtherHobbes··on AI agent swarms in Minecraft fail to build civilization, drown in bureaucracy
No, bureaucracy also includes elements of social dominance by people who have no other means to assert status (or sometimes outright covert sadism), busywork, and processes that are rule-based - often dumbed down in the hope that people with limited intelligence don't make avoidable mistakes - rather than responsive and reality-based.

Getting agents to deal with their own versions of these issues is an interesting experiment.

TheOtherHobbes··on Simple circuits can create complex behaviors
As usual with these debates intelligence is confused with agency, abstract self-awareness, and subjective human-like consciousness.

Systems can have goal-seeking agency with zero self-awareness. Very simple systems can do this surprisingly well. There's an entire branch of engineering called control theory which has mathematical tools for modelling and building these systems.

Systems can have abstract self-awareness through introspection loops, but no subjective human-like consciousness.

We don't know if a mechanical system can have a subjective human-like consciousness. We likely never will, because there is no objective measurement device for human-like consciousness.

We tend to assume humans have subjective awareness by default, because life would get very complicated it we didn't. But really all we see are behaviours.

Intelligence - which pretty much reduces to pattern recognition and abstraction, and effective modelling of future outcomes from past inputs - is orthogonal to all of these.

TheOtherHobbes··on Casio Watches of the 1980s
I don't understand the allure of something that doesn't do what it's supposed to do.

Time keeping is a solved problem. Why would anyone spend varying shades of fortune on something that is functionally inferior, but explicitly labels itself a "superlative chronometer"?

TheOtherHobbes··on Through Captain Jean-Luc Picard, Patrick Stewart taught us the measure of a man
The Picard series on Amazon, which he had a big say in, was not great.

It's an actor's job to dramatise our projections, so from that POV he did a legendary job with TNG.

But there's a certain amount of learned skill involved. I know someone who used to work backstage at the Royal Shakespeare Company. She said that she'd all these famous names playing cards backstage, they'd get their call, turn on the juice, stride on stage, say their lines with the appropriate presence and gravitas, then turn the juice off again after the scene and pick up the card game where they left off.

Stewart's choice of roles and support for causes suggests there was more than that involved for him.

He wasn't Picard in real life, but he wasn't just acting either.

TheOtherHobbes··on 'Elite North Korean hackers' blamed for $6.3B Binance hack
As soon as you have an entirely new power structure you have a new government.

Different people may be on top, with different aims (...arguable, but let's pretend.)

But there will always be a government of some sort making the big decisions for the benefit of its ruling clique.

TheOtherHobbes··on American views of higher ed decline, once again
The question conflates education as a social good - unarguable, unless you're an authoritarian and/or a cultist - with the value of college education as a consumer product.

The case for a college education as a product has become less and less convincing as the job market value of credentials has dropped and costs have risen.

I would not assume college in its current form is going to be a thing 20 years from now, except - possibly - as a legacy finishing school for the extremely rich.

Everyone else is going to be scrabbling for income in an economy where a lot of what used to be white collar work is done by AI, and a lot of what used to be blue collar work is done by robots.

The critical skills will be creative independence, improvisation, and systems thinking - the ability to hack the social and financial economy to invent paid work instead of applying for it.

TheOtherHobbes··on 'Elite North Korean hackers' blamed for $6.3B Binance hack
The usual "Governments are evil until I need to be rescued" libertarian shuffle.
TheOtherHobbes··on Binance-hacker-1029 – $5.6B stolen from Binance
It's very easy to pick it up, put it in a car or van, and move it to a different location.

It's much less easy to convert it to something you can actually spend. Even if you can get it to a buyer, they'll always offer you less than you expect/want.

Reputable dealers have KYC reporting duties of their own. Disreputable dealers... may have other ideas.

TheOtherHobbes··on Binance-hacker-1029 – $5.6B stolen from Binance
The entire financial system is a chaotic boundary between thieves and opportunists, and people who want to keep thievery and opportunism under enough control to keep the system nominally workable.

It's always been like this. Which is why financial systems blow up and/or collapse regularly.

TheOtherHobbes··on Cuba is skipping its November 1, 2026 clock change and staying on DST until 2027
It would be possible to split the day into shifts and have the night owls providing services for other night owls.

Medical emergency cover is 24 hours already. Some factories run 24 hours. So do some transport networks.

There would be huge benefits for commuting because traffic would be spread out.

The practical issues have more to do with noise and energy use, not the "social contract."

TheOtherHobbes··on AI execs may be too out of touch to build for the general public
The argument is there's not much life training for having kids before you start, and even less for dealing with elderly parents.

So a lot of people are blindsided by the reality of either, and both together can be unimaginably difficult.

Aside from cash and life stability issues - both very real - I suspect that one of the reasons for the drop in birth rates is that because of the Internet, more people are seeing what parenting involves before they start.

Previously it was more of a rosy and aspirational "Let's have kids!", now it's "You mean I'll be severely sleep deprived for years?!"

Robots could help with all of this just by doing basic chores and automating daily bureaucracy.

In the best of all possible worlds that would free up more time for personal relationships, which can get very stressed by unavoidable demands that are basically a full-time job.

TheOtherHobbes··on Dayjob: Tax – evaluating AI agents on 50 professional tax assignments
This seems to be usual. Accountants are liable for crimes like embezzlement, but tax authorities hold individual tax payers responsible. If tax payers want to recover losses they have to go to court, which is often risky because accountants will say the client didn't do A, B, and C.
TheOtherHobbes··on Evidence of a spying operation by ICE against left-wing social movements
That doesn't explain why ICE were notorious for rounding up people attending immigration hearings.

Th policy has just been struck down, but we'll see whether that makes a practical difference.

IME ICE are simply a death squad. Immigration is a pretext.

The goal is political terror against regime opponents, not a rational and proportional response to people without paperwork.

TheOtherHobbes··on Microsoft offers mass buyouts for roughly a quarter of its workforce
The assholes are still there. Complaining about language does nothing to get rid of the assholes. They're completely orthogonal activities.

If you wanted to get rid of the assholes - incredibly difficult, because they take many forms - you'd have to reinvent corporate culture in the US to make it less extractive and performative and more substance-based and cooperative.

TheOtherHobbes··on Meta Employees Denounce Interference in Brazilian Elections
How are lower-level workers supposed to influence a crank like Zuckerberg?

He owns the company and all of its decisions. He is literally accountable to no one, from the board down.

The only viable action here is to do what the Brazilian government are going to do - document the abuses, and fine the company into oblivion and/or ban it if it doesn't behave itself.

If the US ever recovers democracy itself, pass the documentation on to the new US government.

← PreviousPage 2 of 34Next →