HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

ThoAppelsin

283 karma · joined February 15, 2018

submissionscomments
ThoAppelsin··on A Wikipedia editor's long-running campaign
> I'm pretty sure everyone knows it's edited by strangers on the internet

I can assure you that there are at least some who are unaware that even they can edit a Wikipedia article. My housemate (a computer engineering student) didn't. My girlfriend seeking her doctorate degree didn't. My 2 roommates who managed to get to the first 100 at our national examination, also didn't.

ThoAppelsin··on A Wikipedia editor's long-running campaign
... which pretty much catches nobody's attention unfortunately. If Wikipedia does have the goodwill, then something has to be made to bring the average user's perception of trustworthiness down to the level of how much trustworthy they really are, and maybe even less. In the context of trust, false positives are worse than false negatives, since an individual may simply build up trust by referring to other resources and relieve their scepticism.

I'd say Wikipedia is really to blame for creating this false sense of trust on their platform. Not that they are completely unreliable, but they are less so than they seem to an average user.

ThoAppelsin··on A Wikipedia editor's long-running campaign
The important difference here is that this platform claims to be an encyclopedia, and any random vandal may not simply make an edit on an article of the conventional encyclopedia.

It would only be natural for us to take this resource as not-so-reliable, for that it is as easy a man to spit on the floor to infiltrate Wikipedia with false information. Yet, we usually don't. We usually just go ahead and trust what we see on Wikipedia, and maybe that's because it looks so convincing and reliable.

If Wikipedia cannot handle vandalism, maybe it should then warn it's users to realize that there is some higher chance than they might expect that the article they are about to read might have been compromised in terms of correctness, or has never been correct to begin with. Instead of displaying full-page banners, perhaps they should spare a couple of lines to such disclaimer statistics.

ThoAppelsin··on A Wikipedia editor's long-running campaign
You can see the "File usage on other wikis" section to see Wikipedia pages in which any commons file is being used. I see a list of couple pages for the particular resource linked there, and verified that the resource exists in those pages.
ThoAppelsin··on How a domain registrar can kill your business
While this statistically might be true, I believe that this is completely dependent on one's personality. Having extra chances to remedy a trouble (which, as can be seen from the article, may occur due to reasons completely out of hand) has notable benefits, such as eliminating such prolonged downtimes.

It is like having replacement toothpaste ready for your bathroom. It is such a nuisance to go out and buy it on the day it runs out, and more likely to have a day without if you do not keep replacements ready.

ThoAppelsin··on Introducing Surface Hub 2
You are not alone. I don't just hope, but more like depend on it. I probably will fall back to an old-style phone if my Lumia 950 dies out. It will be hard for me to get used to the underutilized screen estate iOS and Android offers.
ThoAppelsin··on Memory transfer between snails challenges view of how brain remembers
Finally a childhood dream of the many can be established through this alleged innovation: Learning math, physics, etc. through simple injection, information pills, etc.
ThoAppelsin··on Ascii Art Generator
For Windows users, I strongly recommend trying this beauty: https://ascgendotnet.jmsoftware.co.uk/screenshots/

It has numerous features for customization, such as specification for characters to be used in the art, font face, size. It mat export to text or png of the text in color. It allows you to adjust the color levels of the source image, or crop it on the fly.

It is not exactly the same type of software, as it actually generates using a source image. I use it sometimes to make gifts for friends.

ThoAppelsin··on YouTube Stars Being Paid to Sell Academic Cheating
You should care. It is your responsibility to care from the point on when you've decided to take a part in these events. You shouldn't have initiated with them if you wanted to be so careless.
ThoAppelsin··on YouTube Stars Being Paid to Sell Academic Cheating
It seems like she meant to say that it is wrong not to give that credit, i.e. it is not just a good practice, not only a moral obligation that you become only immoral for not complying, but a requirement, a must that if you do not do it, then you are in the wrong.
ThoAppelsin··on Ask HN: Has anyone switched from being a night owl to being a morning person?
I can second to waking up with the sun part and even more. I have been waking up like that for over 4 years now, started after I have realized my brain is capable of even waking up 3 minutes before my alarm rings, almost consistently. Without an alarm to rely on, it ticks even better, and even without the sun I can wake up the time I want.

I think everybody can do this, with just a little courage, and perhaps less caffeine. It doesn't hurt if you set an alarm to a time that is absolute latest you should be getting out of bed, requiring you to take a cab in a rush without shower or anything alike, and then even being 5 minutes late to your appointment. That assumes you commute via some slower/cheaper means. This is what I do when there is something really important and I never had to take a cab.

It is all about trust in yourself, and getting rid of kind assurances (grace alarms) and self-restrictions helps.

ThoAppelsin··on Microsoft attempts to spin its role in counterfeiting case
> And before anyone brings up the straw man of "he profited"... on 25c per disc?

Sorry, I could not find any resource where it says that he was profiting 25c per disc. I have found some others stating that he would be covering his expenses if he were to sell them for 25c each, and then the blog post from Microsoft states that he was selling them for $3.5 each. It really makes more sense that each disc costs 25c when mass-duplicated in China, than $3.25.

You already have already shunned this argument with your "straw man" talk. Would be a shame to step back just because you've laid that trap-threat to whoever replies. Here it goes: From what I've found, I'd say he profits $3.25 per disc and not 25c. The blog post from Microsoft also states that he made a revenue of $92,000 from this counterfeiting business. Here comes your straw man: $92,000 * ($3.25 / $3.50), approximately $85.500 is what he profited.

I don't know how much an average HN user is gaining, but that is a lot of money for me.

The argument on him being a selfless recycler is impossible to believe in, as the evidence shows that he labelled those discs to look like original Dell recovery discs. This leaves us either nothing but him being an "idiot with delusions of grandeur" as you've said, or he really was simply just making money out of this.

ThoAppelsin··on Microsoft attempts to spin its role in counterfeiting case
> If I managed to find someone to pay to get a copy of your post, would that mean you'd lose money?

Indeed, I would be losing a non-negative amount (call it X) of money that I could have earned, if you were to commit that crime. You should rather ask me for my permission. I will then have my options to lend you my copyright either for free (X = 0), for $y (X = $y), or not allow you to do so at all. If you do it anyway, then my losses would be at least the amount you sell it for; I might have been planning to sell it for more when the demand rises.

I am not sure if I am immediately granted such a copyright for my comments here, though.

ThoAppelsin··on Microsoft attempts to spin its role in counterfeiting case
Excuse me for choosing the word robbery. I was not aware that it meant something different than theft. Did not realize that the different words for stealing implied different contexts. I have edited my comment accordingly.
ThoAppelsin··on Microsoft attempts to spin its role in counterfeiting case
> No one has been deprived of their property.

On the contrary, money is a means to property, and Microsoft loses $3.5 (minus the production cost) for each copy Eric sells to his buyers, since otherwise Microsoft would be the one earning that money. The crime of theft, however, predates even this buying & selling.

Software is a non-depleting product. It is like the fruits that immediately regrow when plucked off of its tree. Now, just because Microsoft doesn't lose any fruits when somebody plucks a fruit from their tree without permission, shouldn't make this person not guilty of their theft. Eric, I would say, has committed this crime of theft at the point of copying the software. Microsoft may not have been deprived of their property, but that is merely due to the fact that their miraculous tree was capable of immediate replenishment, not because a fruit from it was not stolen.

Eric later benefited from his crime by selling it, which damaged Microsoft by saturating the demand for their product as a side-effect.

In the end, it really is hard not to think counterfeiting as a form of stealing, when any form of counterfeiting most definitely devaluates the properties owned by the genuine owners. I am not an expert on law, economics, or business, but I would say counterfeiting in any form would most likely indirectly equal to stealing, and doesn't look like it at the first sight because the translation is too convoluted.

ThoAppelsin··on Microsoft attempts to spin its role in counterfeiting case
It is not useful to discuss about the law on a forum on the internet, at least not yet. Still...

Counterfeiting is an act that is similar to theft, apparent from the fact that this guy has succeeded in making money from what Microsoft gave birth to, and therefore owned [1]. The relation between the guy and Microsoft is clearly a parasitic one.

Microsoft would be compensated justly if they were simply just awarding the monetary damage back by the damaging parties, here Eric Lundgren and his co-defendants. However, it would not be just against the community* (which includes Microsoft, but also everyone else) to let the damaging parties go away without deterring them from doing such actions further. Otherwise, the damaging parties may continue living off their lives through damaging, simply because it is almost certain that there will be cases where they will make profit without being detected and required to award the damages back.

Another way to explain the situation is this: If they are not made to pay more than the damage they have caused, their worst-case (for them, not us/community) profit is 0, and for all the other cases they will be making profit. Should this really be the justice cast upon the individuals causing monetary damage?

[1]: Declaring creators as the (copyright) owners benefits the community, hence we do. The relevant example Windows is a product of Microsoft that benefits the community, evident from the fact that it has a userbase. Microsoft would not create and offer Windows to the public, if the law allowed everyone to freely redistribute their products, and compete with Microsoft using their creation, as it would render their novel efforts meaningless against the much simpler effort of copying products created by the others.

[*]: Edited from "robbery".

ThoAppelsin··on New Windows 10 Features
> (Surprised this has taken so long; the speech recognition libraries have been in .NET since 2014.)

Dictation already was available on Windows 10, although not so streamlined.

In Windows, there are various forms of on-screen keyboards and some of them have this microphone button somewhere right above the top row of the keyboard flushed to the left. When activated, it starts listening you and dictating whatever you say. So, it's not brand new, more like an improvement to the UI, and also to the AI (as far as I know, recognition has also been improved).

Same goes for the Focus Assist, it was available under the same icon, different nane, "Quiet Hours". I keep it always-on on my PCs for several months now, and use it intermittently on my phone. It also got improvements, but allowing some people to bypass is not one of them.

The rest are new. I'm not saying that they are dishonest, they probably just do not mention it over and over everywhere.

ThoAppelsin··on Keep VS Code from Becoming an IDE
This is a great insight, thanks!

I wonder if there also is a place we can view the activation events of an extension from within VS code. If there isn't, I guess I can always find that info out from the hopefully available repository of the extensions.

ThoAppelsin··on Java SE 8 business users must buy a licence from Jan 2019 to receive updates
How is it baiting when it perfectly summarizes the whole news, with no misguidance, no unbased speculations? "Java SE 8 business users must buy a license from January next year" is not a luringly reworded way that (mis)guides the reader to think that something exciting is going on which -- this part is very important for something to be a bait -- actually is just a speculation or is not happening at all. It rather exactly is what is happening.
ThoAppelsin··on A rundown of the new Gmail
Exactly. It is almost a mis-feature for bringing fake sense of security to their users, since receivers actually can very well take a screenshot or even a photograph.
ThoAppelsin··on The Many Ways Google Harvests Data
> These companies are just as much to blame, if not more, than Google itself.

However, exact same thing applies for Facebook and all the likes. If a website is entirely self-contained, nobody other than your ISP or your browser/OS may track you over there as you directly type its name out to the address bar.

If Facebook is to blame more than the websites putting their like button on their websites, then so is Google.

On top of this, many people use Google as a gateway to the Internet. Even for the websites that they are pretty sure about their domain names, people rather search for it on the google.com, and follow the link from there. This allows Google to track them, even when they do not use Chrome. Yet, many even do use Chrome, very likely tracking you even when you do not visit a website through google.com.

So Google isn't even dependent so much on the other websites using their analytics, definitely not as much as you state with:

> Google's ability to track users is 99% entirely due to companies like [...]

It would be interesting to know the breakdown of contributions of Analytics, google.com, Chrome, etc. to Google's tracking capabilities.

ThoAppelsin··on First LED cinema screen in the U.S.A. officially opened
This comment implies that the conventional cinema screen setup is more preferable over a TV screen when it comes to watching movies, and I have to agree. Maybe not for other content, but staring against any more powerful illuminating surface in a dark room for 2 hours would strain the eyes too much to be pleasurable.
ThoAppelsin··on First LED cinema screen in the U.S.A. officially opened
> [...] which Samsung estimates could display roughly 88 foot-lamberts.

Without WA and with more of the article, 88 / 14 approximates 6.29.

ThoAppelsin··on Google and Microsoft Push Websites to Go Password-Less
Unless system vendors discriminate other browsers from their own browser in terms of the said restrictions, I would say that it is fair game.

Following your example, if Microsoft were to require browsers use UWP framework to utilize the biometric authentication API, implementing the feature to Edge and not to Internet Explorer, would that be problematic?

ThoAppelsin··on Java is Pass-by-Value
> I don't know what you mean by "really pass-by-reference".

I was wondering if `int &a2 = a;` allocates memory in stack to make `a2` refer to `&a`, or does `a2` somehow truly become an alias for `a` in symbol table. As you've said that the assembly would look the same as pointers being dereferenced, then I suppose C++'s reference types are just a syntax sugar around the C's way of achieving the pass-by-reference concept through passing the address and then dereferencing it.

ThoAppelsin··on Java is Pass-by-Value
While C++ is a whole lot of different language with operator overloading amd everything, I don't think the pass-by-reference in the C++'s way with &'s before the variable/parameter identifiers is much different from how Java handles the objects behind the curtains.

In Java with no explicit pointers available to its users, the way objects are handled are explained better with the pass-by-reference concept than (whooosh!, magic in) pointers (and out) passed-by-value reality. Pointer is a foreign concept to Java, so it really makes more sense to its users that object variables start referring to other objects when they are reassigned, instead of the old object being changed in-place. Things get funky with equality comparison via == operator, but still, it is better than pointers.

I also wonder, does C++ really pass-by-reference when parameters have &'s behind their identifier declarations, or does it internally pass a reference by value and dereference it every time it is used within that scope? Are 4/8 bytes allocated for the reference variable or not?

ThoAppelsin··on $10,000 Stack Overflow Toxicity Challenge
> an unreasonably high goal post

I wouldn't say unreasonably high for 10% for a single man offering that much money. I would even say that it is rather very risky.

Besides, claiming a platform is "a toxic wasteland" puts that platform on par with the ones like 4chan, and that does seem to require 20% toxicity to me, maybe even higher. For it to get more strict like 3-5%, the claim should be lighter, something like "slightly toxic". It is nice of him to empathise and assume that the claims are probably exaggerated, and to set the threshold to something in between.

> No one wants your paltry prize money, Ted.

Lastly, I definitely would enjoy an extra 10K, but I don't really think I can beat that requirement, since I don't think Stack Overflow is even slightly toxic.

ThoAppelsin··on $10,000 Stack Overflow Toxicity Challenge
I believe it is just a manner of speech to talk about the extremes to claim the innocence of your defendant. Without such examples, declaring Stack Overflow as a saint would sound dull.
ThoAppelsin··on What Bill Gates was doing at 20 years old
> rich white kid

Excuse me, but was Bill Gates back then or is the article right now being discriminative against the people without the privileges he had? The article rather depicts him as an influential figure that encourages all people to have "self-confidence", not confidence in their wealth or whiteness.

This comment, on the contrary, suggests people with the privilege to think twice before establishing any business, which is rather discouraging for those people, and detrimental for the community's well-being.

ThoAppelsin··on Windows 10 works incorrectly with Large memory pages
Rather unconventional, but Windows 10 on desktop and mobile do have a Feedback Hub [1] where Windows 10 users are able to provide all sorts of feedback, either as a suggestion or a problem. All the feedbacks are public and users can freely vote them up to draw more attention on them. The more vote they have, the more likely they receive a response from the developers and also get the priority in the queue of issues to be resolved.

I use it every so often when I notice something peculiar. None of my feedbacks actually became so popular. Even then I know one of them has been fixed. The fix probably didn't come because I have pointed it out, but I was happy about it regardless.

I couldn't find a web-link to the Hub, so I think it is not entirely public, but surely available to the Windows 10 users.

[1] https://support.microsoft.com/en-us/help/4021566/windows-10-...

← PreviousPage 2 of 3Next →