HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

TomGarden

460 karma · joined November 19, 2025

submissionscomments
TomGarden··on OpenFatigue™ – Open is the new closed
Brilliant. Laughed out loud
TomGarden··on Discover vibe-coded alternatives to popular software
Someone steal this idea for OSS for vibe coders please:

Stop making full apps. Make modular, well optimized pieces of functionality taken from established apps others can pull into their vibe coded software.

I believe this is what Google wants to do eventually once they big data-crunch the most common vibe code cases, and the new OpenAI Intelligent UI seems to be this as well.

Let's end the endless churn of tokens for subpar todo-app back ends etc and make something streamlined for vibe coders that they can build on.

TomGarden··on Discover vibe-coded alternatives to popular software
I see no value in specifically looking for vibe-coded software. The ones that are straight copies are going away soon anyway no doubt, once the lawsuits start hitting
TomGarden··on Attack of the Vibe Coded Photoshop Clones
I've been looking at the posting history of the creator and I think we differ in terms of philosophical perspective. His reddit account was 'ai_art_is_art' which feels shock jokey-ish even if you agree with that, and I also don't think there's legal longevity in copying Adobe's products 1:1. I might put some development time into another open source editor
TomGarden··on Attack of the Vibe Coded Photoshop Clones
Ah I think I misunderstood you! We agree
TomGarden··on Attack of the Vibe Coded Photoshop Clones
My team are and the full Adobe plans and for our use cases it's also not important. We do have a few workflows that dive deeper into niche tools only Photoshop has though, but I can see competitors making streamlined apps for specific use cases that can compete. It's actually kind of tempting to see if I can get something done over a couple nweekends and see if it'd be usable
TomGarden··on Attack of the Vibe Coded Photoshop Clones
This is a fair point, and pretty much the only one that holds any merit in this weird rant. I hope we'll find a way to economically reward excellence as we move into this new era
TomGarden··on Attack of the Vibe Coded Photoshop Clones
Isn't it a poor perspective? We all know AI assisted coding needs review, practical testing and refining, especially for functionality in different use cases that cannot be easily verified by a model. Practical testing and verification remains a bottleneck even in automated systems
TomGarden··on Attack of the Vibe Coded Photoshop Clones
> One or two guys in a Discord chatroom cannot support a global user base, especially when those two guys are hunting for underage children to speak to on Discord (yes, I have seen what vibe coders do).

Too insane of a thing to throw in as a generalizing aside that isn't expanded upon. I have to conclude the author is upset about the current situation to the point of unhinged

TomGarden··on Attack of the Vibe Coded Photoshop Clones
Almost every AI project has a discord to build community, including OpenAI, Midjourney...
TomGarden··on "Robot" Is a Social Construct: Why Your Dishwasher Is Not a Robot
I just don't think we'll be able to agree (and that's okay). I'll just put my thoughts here, not expecting that you'll meet me anywhere.

Human judgement in itself is not uniform or defined enough for it to be useful, but dispersed and more random than just situational. And yes, universal definitions in general are extremely rare outside of a subset of definitions in hard sciences. The only reasonable thing we can do is agree on a definition in a certain context, ie definitions in a scientific paper or in a conversation. But 'I know it when I see it' or some vague idea of human judgement doesn't even work as a definition within a defined context, and therefore doesn't help us find common ground or make a conversation useful. Which is why I characterize it as a thought-terminating cliché.

In a way, this entire back-and-forth is an example of us 'knowing what a thought-terminating cliché is when we see it' which unsurprisingly, to me, is unhelpful.

TomGarden··on "Robot" Is a Social Construct: Why Your Dishwasher Is Not a Robot
What I mean is that throwing up your hands and saying 'I know it when I see it' is entirely pointless. There's a reason scientific papers have an (often long) section for definitions.
TomGarden··on "Robot" Is a Social Construct: Why Your Dishwasher Is Not a Robot
Yeah. It's really bothersome.

I think the modern day equivalent is the constant huffing and puffing around where to draw the line for tech legislation, with the implicit message that 'if a line is hard to draw, we should not draw it' and a constant bad-faith battle for perfectly defined legislation.

The answer to 'where do we draw the line for this thing that has widespread negative effects' is always "somewhere".

TomGarden··on "Robot" Is a Social Construct: Why Your Dishwasher Is Not a Robot
"I know it when I see it" has to be up there in terms of useless thought-terminating clichés together with "no smoke without fire" and "if he wanted to he would"
TomGarden··on 2D Vehicles
This feels incredible to play, even with the simple graphics. Wow. Top class
TomGarden··on No Man Is an Island
Very well written. I tend to forget how important the people around me are, and as you say, force myself to act with the "high status" intrinsic motivation.

Recently, I'm in a context with extremely talented people I respect and want to impress to some extent. The difference is night and day

TomGarden··on Programming Isn't Special
I instinctively want to agree with this but I feel like there's some pretty jarring logical jumps made to equate programming to the more obvious art forms that people put time into ~because~ they want to artistically express themselves.

What the author really wants to say isn't "programming isn't special" but that "programming is art to the same extent as music or painting because people do both things for money within capitalism" which I just don't think holds up.

TomGarden··on OpenAI, the Partition Principle, and Mathematics
No idea why you're downvoted, my intial thought was that I would like to see some of this supposedly widespread sentiment as well.

I even think it's plausible a lot of mathematicians are excited by it, but the sweeping confidence of the comment you replied to without anything to back it up leaves some to be desired

TomGarden··on OpenAI annualised revenues $20B less than previously signalled
lmao oh no, I've been spelling it like that for years. Thanks for the playful correction
TomGarden··on Whistle: Speech to Text in 16.9 MB
The Qwen STT model that's leading the open weight leaderboard right now is excellent. Parakeet v2 is blazing fast and accurate enough on English. I feel like STT gains from this point on will be marginal, especially given that you can do a quick LLM pass afterwards with a small model
TomGarden··on OpenAI annualised revenues $20B less than previously signalled
Yes, This is the one thing he says that generally resonated with me. A lot of his talking points (harnesses as elaborate rude goldberg machines) read more as exaggerated negative statements supporting a pre-concieved narrative
TomGarden··on Claude Haiku 5.5
At one point they definitely turned it off and gave us a one-time credit to claim for -p, after which Claude -p was billed as extra usage
TomGarden··on Claude Haiku 5.5
I've been operating under the pretense that claude -p was removed ages ago in the OpenClaw era, it's back now? What a mess of contradictory information, hope yall can figure it out
TomGarden··on Google Playground: Create and play custom games
I feel like this is true with most media such as music and movies too - generally consumers don't understand exactly what they like.

I imagine AI will be making semi-complex indie-style games before we see an AI movie worth watching

TomGarden··on Open source 160 sound visualization experiments
Overall I agree I don't "see" a lot in most of these, but there are actually a few spectral visualizations in there that are a bit more telling
TomGarden··on Claude Haiku 5.5
For prompts under 100k tokens, it's priced the same as Luna - $0.10 in, $0.50 out.

For prompts over 100k tokens it's 5 times more expensive - $0.50 in, $2.50 out.

TomGarden··on Claude Haiku 5.5
From these selected benchmarks, it looks like it smokes Luna capability-wise. Excited to put it through its paces
TomGarden··on Google Playground: Create and play custom games
Agreed!

And I genuinely hope there will be some categories of games/music/books/art where human input is still needed and preferred. Currently I'm already a handful of bulletpoints down on the list of stuff I thought AI would never be able to do, and it's been kind of destabilizing

TomGarden··on Google Playground: Create and play custom games
You may be right, at the same time a lot of "AI will never solve X" takes have aged pretty poorly, and I'm not confident what's fun about existing games cannot be codified and shown statistically somehow. Some genres seem more accessible to AI than others
TomGarden··on Google Playground: Create and play custom games
For anyone getting a 403, it's US only right now and fails rather ungracefully. I just tried out a few games, framerates where strange/choppy, even in a match 3 game, and the games I tried were quite bad overall. I'm sure this type of thing will get good very soon though
← PreviousPage 2 of 6Next →