HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

TomMckenny

2,285 karma · joined February 19, 2015

submissionscomments
TomMckenny··on My name causes an issue with any booking
They did not test-run the code change against a database of the names of previous fliers?

Because if the change reduced some passengers to "can't be booked" I think that should raise some flags.

TomMckenny··on Is Inequality Inevitable?
>The GDP would be 10 times higher. It wouldn't be a lie.

That would mean Venezuela, top in the world for printing money, has the highest GDP growth. Zimbawe and Argentina would be next.[1] In the event one might claim they are, here[2] is the actuall GDP growth rate by country.

>As for GDP it is generally accepted that setting up a free market and leaving it alone maximises the GDP.

The highest per-capita GDPs are in exactly those countries which monitor and adjust the market, for example the Scandaniavn countries. And in the US, the period 1945-1980 saw vastly more regulation and taxation than 1980-today yet vastly greater growth. So evidentilly, modest regulation and taxition and zealous anti-trust enforcemnt are actually good for an economy. Far from generally accepted, very few economist disregard all evidence and assert zero regulation means maximum growth.

> Inequality is not a problem - people can't even detect inequality!

The existence of inequality is not remotely controversial and is trivial to measure, for example with the GINI and even the absurdly blunt Elephant Curve. And indeed, vast swathes of the population very much feel the decline in their quality of life and say so loudly and are electing lunatic politicians as a consequence.

Actually, if you happen to have a reference, I'd be interested in where one hears that printing money increases the GDP, inequality is undetectable and ending anti-trust enforcement et al makes a market healthier.

>doesn't involve confiscation and redistribution of some form or another

One could call gasoline tax "confiscation" bridges toll "redistribution" and, on the other side, call rent "theft". Calling stimulus spending "confiscation" is as extreme as saying that wealth was "stolen from the proletariat in the first place". I humbly suggest it is not helpful. At any rate, as further proven by this paper, the solution to both QoL declines created by inequality as well as a stagant GDP is a wealth tax used to increase consumer spending power.

> the elephant curve can reasonably be interpreted as a massive success story that we can all be proud of as millions are lifted up to a better standard of living.

Then how is ridiculing its reality a refutation of this paper? And the rise of devolping countires is not in dispute. The problem at hand is the preciptous decline for those who lost out and who are still loosing. And who, as it turns out, are the middle and lowerclass members of the richest countries which also contain the people that benefited by far the most.

[1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_inflation...

[2]https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/ny.gdp.mktp.kd.zg

TomMckenny··on Is Inequality Inevitable?
How would printing money improve the GDP anymore than just lying about the figures? And since no one is suggesting that, I think it's kind of a straw-man.

But surely these can't seriously be the best rebuttals to the paper: that straw-man, anecdotal opinion about college campuses and physics professors and a statistics joke about, but certainly not refuting, the elephant curve. I really can't tell if these arguments are genuinely considered valid or is this just a semi-polite troll technique to shout down unpleasant information.

TomMckenny··on Is Inequality Inevitable?
There is no philosopher involved, in this case there is the wealth expended to produce an item. In your idealized example both parties are better off but the one that traded the item and took less effort to make it is comparatively better off. He will have advantages in future trades which will further increase. Not to mention a bigger voice in societal structure. (which is a tldr; of the article)

Anecdotally you met some college kids whom you perceived as not understanding economics. But the knowledge of increasing wealth inequality and the current deficiency of private investment is uncontroversial. Regardless of what the impression those kids gave, there number of techniques to address it and _increase_ GDP through the stimulus.

TomMckenny··on Is Inequality Inevitable?
Exactly so. For evidence and details there is the weighty and data packed book "Capital in the Twenty-First_Century" by Thomas Piketty
TomMckenny··on Tech and Liberty
The decision to run ads for money is itself highly political: it completely undermines the idea of free competition of ideas solely on their merits by heavily advantaging those ideas backed by money.

And if a lie can win out over the truth, this would be the mechanism that does it. It is certainly not coherent to complain about a "mob" "shouting" down an idea while trying to out shout them through money.

The points on monopoly are valid and serious. But the focus on a single de-facto monopoly, Facebook, undermines and muddles the point.

There are other de-facto and even real monopolies in broadcast media that are more influential and far more restrictive in content, Sinclair for one. I can not see how one could coherently oppose Facebook's de-facto monopoly while ignoring others that are actual monopolies, unless we make some arbitrary distinction on the technology used: radio and TV can monopolize but not web based technologies.

And lest one think that there are orders of magnitude difference between the TV/radio monopolies and Facebook, I will point out that:

1 We (the users of this site) are self selecting technologists and are much more focused on web issues while being far less dependent on non-web based media than the vast bulk of the population.

2 The intentional effects of broadcast monopolies on voting patterns are so large as to be easily measurable. Facebook's intentional influence, if it even exists, is certainly not obvious.

3 Twitter is in fact only read by a tiny segment of the population: The number of US man-hours spent listening to talk radio on monopoly owned stations vastly exceeds the number spent on Twitter where at least there is some possibility of accidentally seeing a contrary opinion.

So yes monopolizing is a serious problem and desperately needs fixing and it is vastly wider than web.

TomMckenny··on The Money Farmers: How Oligarchs and Populists Milk the E.U.
So you're saying:

1)US corruption is as bad as Russia and the other Eastern European dictatorships and....

2)...this excuses the appalling autocratic behavior of Orban

I would like to see fans of a US leader who has been caught in some scandal try to say "but the Easten European dictators do it"

I suggest that these points are not only completely fallacious but actually the exact kind of distraction that oligarchs promulgate to keep their power: rather than discuss their own oppressive corruption, which the public might do something about, find something foreign to make people mad at.

And apparently it's trivial to push these intentional distractions to the top of discussions and prevent even the first steps of removing the Kleptarch's mob.

TomMckenny··on High-skilled workers in small towns are a ‘waste of resources,’ says study
I agree with the sentiment: people are too often regard as mere tools. But I believe (hope) the paper was a theoretical exercise. In the same way one might discover human flesh is nutritious. And I image no society (expect maybe China) would view the paper as a how-to manual.

Rather than using this information to create a dystopian (and kinda click baity) future, it could be used to examine current social forces and make predictions and, ideally, prepare/compensate for them.

Indeed it would be just as easy spin the paper in a multitude of ways. For example, one might use it to justify taxation earmarked to aid the rural poor by saying it's not only ethical but also efficient.

TomMckenny··on Gaggle monitors the work and communications of almost 5M students in the US
The worst of it is that kids learn being monitored is normal and "a good thing". Something far too many adults are already comfortable with.
TomMckenny··on What Is a Nation? (2015)
I believe you two have different definitions of "elite". I am guessing that you define "elite" as the powerful (and therefore rich) and he defines it as the cosmopolitan-intellectual, the anti-nationalist and liberal minded (but not necessarily the top level of power or wealth).

I'm also guessing there's a difference of opinion as to whether nation-hood is a transitory social construct or an intrinsic unalterable eternal reality.

TomMckenny··on GitHub tries to quell employee anger over its ICE contract
Perhaps you start here and not stop until a government and it's agencies cease abusive practices.

The counter question is how much should a person turn a blind eye (and so implicitly endorse) the uses of your product?

In this case at least, there was a donation made that would not have happened otherwise.

TomMckenny··on BZFlag
Alternatively, a 90's style site in keeping with the aesthetics of the game would be cool in its way.
TomMckenny··on Twitter to ban political advertising
No need to even think of controlling speech. But certainly ban political advertising which amounts to bribery both in theory and practice.

No one could genuinely believe that probating de-facto bribery is indistinguishable from censorship. Indeed it's very telling that banning _all_ political ads is objected to as being allegedly "biased".

TomMckenny··on Banksy's Fake Store Is an Attempt to Abuse Trademark Law to Avoid Copyright Law
Indeed. And if we assume he does not want money to be made from his works by him _or other people either_ then it is all pretty consistent.

Indeed it's a strange world if he, on principle, refuses to profit by his work but other people must be allowed to.

TomMckenny··on Microsoft Wins Pentagon’s $10B Contract
> Chomsky has been railing against it ... they're controlled by five rich men

That is a real problem, certainly in normal times. And likely decades of derailing reforms in the interest of consumers and employees is what led to the frustration that created the current catastrophe. I note even now broadcast media certainly dwells on the trade war far more than other more pressing problems.

So stories should be confirmed by looking at serious publicly owned and overseas news sources. And if a particular series of stories is in the WaPo and NPR and BBC and the Guardian and Der Spiegel and FAZ and NHK and Le Monde and El Pais then we know it is not a rich man's plot. And if privately owned media has a pro-wealth bent, maybe an autocratic kletopcray is a bit much for some of them. Especially for non-hereditary billionaires many of whom really do want to make the world better (within certain economic constraints of course)

TomMckenny··on Microsoft Wins Pentagon’s $10B Contract
The Post runs the same stories seen in essentially all papers in the world. A lot of them implicate the president negatively. But how does precluding the pentagon from it's first choice on these grounds good for the country?

In a free and uncorrupt country, you don't allow leaders to intervene in national security issues because they are embarrassed by a paper's coverage. Thus few people are directly saying that amazon should loose the bid because their CEO has a paper the president doesn't like.

More common and to be consistent with the notion of a corruption free democracy, the defense for this is the claim that, despite significant pressure, this surprising turn of events would have happened anyway. This is the story being promoted more but it does require a improbably interpretation of events that only supporters could really ever internalize. Especially since Trump's own secretary of defense flatly said the goal was to screw Amazon over the Post.

TomMckenny··on Don't Use VPN Services
It would be nice if there were an independent auditing organization that could confirm an ISP's claims.
TomMckenny··on Jack Ma Says 12-Hour Work Week Could Be the Norm
Possible indeed, Keynes pointed that out a couple generations ago. And as always it depends solely on whether society is run such that people benefit from or compete with technology.
TomMckenny··on California power outage triggers chaos in science labs
The problem is lack of investment in the infrastructure. And that damage to customers or economies is not a concern compared to lawsuits damaging the bottom-line.

In particular, if you only take into account the revenue made on a given day vs the likelihood of a lawsuit and nowhere is economic damage accounted for, then you will turn the power off a lot more often and a lot more widely than you should.

Also, since SoCal Edison is geographically adjacent to the DWP but Edison is investor owned while DWP is municipal owned, I believe you are adding support to my point.

TomMckenny··on California power outage triggers chaos in science labs
Note on the blackout map, the county in the dead center has continuous power and it has a municipal source.

Likewise the 2000 crisis where LA's DWP customers had power when PG&E did not.

Although I'm sure it makes me a "socialist" for pointing these things out, it almost seems that having private monopolies in utilities is a bad idea

TomMckenny··on U.S. widens trade blacklist to include some of China’s top AI startups
There is actually a psychological difference. There maybe some digging in but generally nations can put a literal price on trade which they can not easily do with loss of life. Likewise national honor is less at stake. I suppose we're lucky that economic enticement/force usually gets better results than violence.

Whether it works in this particular case, indeed whether the goal of tariffs/sanctions is even remotely what is announced are both unclear of course. If it were humanitarian, it would be nice to mention Hong Kong in the process.

TomMckenny··on The GM strike is really about the switch to electric cars
Yes of course cars now are vastly superior. I was responding to the claim that the shift to electric will reduce gross revenue which reduce the sticker price and so explain any workforce reduction.

So we clearly agree, sticker price has not gone down since the assembly line. So to say it is happening now is not really justified. Especially since, far from say the Yugo approach, electric currently is very much billed as an improvement over petroleum (correctly imo). But while cost of ownership maybe less, nowhere is the sticker price pitched as a cheap alternative to petroleum. And this is what affects manufacturers and the point I was addressing.

TomMckenny··on The GM strike is really about the switch to electric cars
>There are two important actors left out of this analysis: consumers and parts suppliers.

This is indeed plausible and has happened for other commodities but note: 1) since the model-T, inflation adjusted consumer prices for automobiles have never dropped and 2) car manufacturers have historically replicated or bought any serious profit centers in their supply chain.

>Evil

Shareholders act in their interest, employees act in theirs. Often everyone ends up fairly satisfied. Is that not how the system is supposed to work and is describing it plainly without effusive praise now automatically suspect?

TomMckenny··on The GM strike is really about the switch to electric cars
No it's about money and who gets it. Unless electric cars are going to generate less revenue than petroleum based, which they won't, the pie is the same size.

That manufacturing becomes more efficient is no surprise: it always has. The question is whether they have fewer workers at the same compensation level, fewer workers at a higher compensation level or the same number of workers with fewer hours.

Owners are pushing for the first, labor wants anything except the first. And while Keynes envisioned the last, that has clearly no been allowed to happen. It is an archetype case of who benefits from technical improvements and forces driving inequality.

TomMckenny··on Hundreds of Propaganda Accounts Targeting Iran and Qatar Removed from Facebook
Even though both the Sinclair/Murdoch TV/radio web have vastly greater influence and audiences, explicit cultivate and advertise their bias and run stories uncorroborated anywhere else in the free world, they are not mentioned. This is because the complaint isn't about objectivity, it's about silencing information sources not in-step with the ruling party.
TomMckenny··on Facebook Now Allows Politicians to Lie in Paid Ads
And the calls for breaking them up dissipate accordingly.
TomMckenny··on Facebook, WhatsApp Will Have to Share Messages With U.K.?
This becomes more true the further a country moves away from democracy: in a vibrant popular democracy, people will honestly work for their nation's good and corruption is viewed as evil.

Further away from democracy, leaders are purely self serving, successful corruption is seen as a sign of intelligence and whistle-blowers, far from being heroes for pointing out maleficence, are threatened with execution.

And indeed, institutions eventually shift to working solely for the benefit of themselves and the people in charge. Mostly because any that don't are undermined until they do.

TomMckenny··on The Internet Archive is waging war on misinformation
What one fact checker says (or is rumored to have said) does not invalidate fact checking by everyone everywhere. In fact it does not even alter whether any given statement is true or false.

But incredibly there are those who very comfortably dismiss things they acknowledge as true solely because they dislike the politics of the source. That overlooking falsehoods is acceptable in the scope of a larger political cause. That those who point them out too zealously are political enemies.

TomMckenny··on The Internet Archive is waging war on misinformation
That main witness "bombshell" is not remotely what is written in the NYT. It is what Fox news _says_ the NYT wrote knowing the audience will never actually read the article. And is in fact a rather blatant example of undermining reality based media as an "enemy of the people"

>Considering the frequency of retraction

What, even approximately, is the rate of retraction?

And more generally, note the irony that if honest journals correct errors, it is portrayed as proof of conspiracy yet those outlets that don't (or "double down") are considered reliable. Perhaps the NYT should follow politicians and the lower grade media and aggressively deny anything that makes them look bad.

TomMckenny··on The Internet Archive is waging war on misinformation
> These days, I don't trust...

The goal of the new style autocrats and their advocates is not a particular propaganda line but to create doubt in reality based information sources. Individuals can follow rabbit holes until the find the story that matches their previously held world view and so guarantee supporters never defect.

For example, you can always find an obscure website "proving" climate change is a hoax. If you now distrust reputable sources and weight every site roughly equally, you could easily convince yourself that no one knows if there is climate change or not.

← PreviousPage 7 of 24Next →