HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

TomMckenny

2,285 karma · joined February 19, 2015

submissionscomments
TomMckenny··on The Myth of the Wealthy Welder
Exactly correct. But valuing education is now as politicized as hurricane forecasts.

This is because education level is a major factor in voting patterns. So conservative pundits have made open war on it, to the nations serious detriment. They could instead work to lower the price of education but that is absolutely not the agenda for the same reasons.

It's not entirely unprecedented, universities have been called communist incubators for decades. What is new is the shift in portrayal from communist to being a bad investment (but with no intention of fixing that). Also new is the willingness to cast off the nations future for political gain which previous conservatives apparently were not willing to do.

There are similar patterns for climate change, guns and renewable energy.

TomMckenny··on Terror Watch List Finally Reined In
What's most disturbing is that it took 17 years. And whatever it is in the culture that uses liberty to zealously oppose regulation of fire arms and corporations but lets this stand for almost a generation. It'd be interesting to learn how these priorities came about.
TomMckenny··on Last German kaiser's heirs fight for riches lost behind Iron Curtain
So Australia, Canada, and the US are going to be returned to their previous owners?

There is zero consistency in these kinds of claims because what is really happening is an influential family with plenty of resources for lawyers is going to grab a shipload of German taxpayer euros using tortured legal arguments.

TomMckenny··on Real-Time maps warn Hong Kong protesters of water cannons and riot police
I hope Taiwan is watching closely, for that and several other reasons.
TomMckenny··on Most Canadians Are Now Better Off Than Most Americans
Actually, in principle larger means more markets and labor supply and more clout on the world markets. Furthermore the US has more usable land, and Canada's vast distances with low populations increases their expenses vs the US.

And indeed the US does have a higher per capita GDP. But because it's concentrated in so few hands, most Canadians are better off than most Americans.

TomMckenny··on Michael Crichton: Why Speculate? (2005)
>his type of rhetoric directly lead to the political environment we have now

Indeed, his examples are comically telling: CNN and MSNBC but not Fox which had equivalent and bigger audiences.

But for our present time, I presume the point of resurrecting a 17 year old speech from a fiction writer is to further reduce confidence in a press that dare criticize the ruling party.

TomMckenny··on U.S. CBP and Israeli Elbit to Persistently Surveil Native American Reservation
The Tohono O’odham predate the border by about 10,000 years. But some powerful people with no knowledge of the land or its people drew a straight line on a map 150 years ago.

Supposedly yet more intrusion and division of their land is the only solution to some new problem someone else caused.

TomMckenny··on Mortgage Market Reopens to Risky Borrowers
Exactly so. That and continuous denunciation of the free press by a certain category of new politicians.

Actually, this article differs in no way from similar articles written since printed news was invented. Which of course means that all the other criticisms, including imprecision, are still valid. It just means that it is not the source of the recent spike in media dislike.

TomMckenny··on Which California waters are listed as impaired for fish consumption?
Scenic LA River isn't listed! Woot! /s
TomMckenny··on Removing Coordinated Inauthentic Behavior from China
Maybe, but one thing is certain:

For the US they have a unique challenge: they can freely attempt to mitigate propaganda and manipulation by the Chinese ruling party and it's backers because they are not physically in China.

TomMckenny··on Google Employee Writes Memo About ‘The Burden of Being Black at Google’
Sure, but not in a work place. That is not the appropriate place to denounce other workers as "inanely inferior".

Even so, there are plenty of workplaces that practice anti-diversity, pro-discriminatory behavior. I believe even US govt contractors are allowed to discriminate on sexual orientation now. So there are plenty of workplaces for those uncomfortable in tolerant environments and preferring a more bigoted work place. But apparently that is insufficient: apparently they want _no_ work place to be diverse.

And indeed, whatever strife there is will end the instant those who resent equality overcome their internal angst.

TomMckenny··on Google Employee Writes Memo About ‘The Burden of Being Black at Google’
Then I imagine they are quite happy since their desire for less diversity would be met by (the imagined policy) excluding those who want less diversity.

Unless of course the objection is not to diversity per-se but some particular groups.

If the anti-diversity crowd are under represented in tech, it's probably for they same reason the highest productivity areas are the most liberal in their countries and formed mostly from those that left other areas.

TomMckenny··on The subversive messages hidden in The Wizard of Oz
Also interesting are the jokes that were removed and added.

The Lion gets his courage from a bottle in the original (the joke being a reference to a common joke at the time that some people get their courage from a bottle of liquor) But 1939 was so close to the prohibition fiasco, it seems the producers did not like this joke.

Likewise, the scene in the field of (presumably opium) poppies that put everyone to sleep was only added in 1939. It's hard to imagine that joke being added in, say, the time of height of the war on drugs: could Bart Simpson play with opium poppies and pass out to audience laughter 1980's?

TomMckenny··on Google Employee Writes Memo About ‘The Burden of Being Black at Google’
Where the call for "diversity" is twisted to mean that more overtly bigoted persons and statements should be brought in and entertained?

The call that claims "diversity" should include movements towards less diversity?

TomMckenny··on The hypersane are among us, if only we are prepared to look
I'm not sure the people you cite were following a Disney formula. But along the lines you're drawing, sometimes they are persecuted (Galileo) sometimes die in poverty (Van Gogh) sometimes killed by a mob (Hypatia of Alexandria) and sometimes they are hounded to suicide (Allan Turing, Aaron Swartz)

But far more often, none of those things. And either way, I never have heard such people say they wish they'd been average.

TomMckenny··on NULL license plate not such a bright idea
> He refused because he didn't do anything wrong.

Cool the DMV fixed it. Just try that with so called "identity theft"

TomMckenny··on Social exclusion fuels extremism in young men
You do realize that the group in the study is highly religious. And that the extremism referred to is also religious.
TomMckenny··on The Problem at Yale Is Not Free Speech
I agree that a focus on economic opportunity might be more effective. And Universities need to stand behind their staff. But the article is not remotely suggesting that students should focus on economic reform. And if there were any doubt on that issue, it is made clear by the authors other articles. Indeed, the author went to Yale, we know she did not participate in any protests. What exactly did she do as her responsibility?

Those students _are_ focused on wide reform in _every_ field. The article and those like it are cynically composed to describe only racial reform efforts in order to drive a wedge between white and non-white working class voters and to demonize the few wealthy who are actually on the side of reform.

Indeed it is the very group doing the anti-racist protests that are the ones _allied_ with economic reform. That's where the Bernie Sanders supporters are. The problem would be the polar opposite students in Yale solely there to learn how to increase hereditary wealth and power.

These exact same techniques and even words were used in the 60s to demonize economic reforms by railing against the "extreme" behaviors of student then. Portrayal of universities as Communist (still a common theme on Fox), focusing solely on pro-integration and anti-war protests to falsely portray disregard for white poor and national disloyalty. They kept two out of three today.

And they found they same audience to stoke the same unjustified resentment then as now by falsely convincing working class whites that powerful liberal economic reformers are only interested in non-whites. And so drove a wedge between working class whites and non-whites. And so Nixon and Trump.

The catastrophic rent seeking and inequality is certainly _not_ coming from those few privileged students who publicly disapprove of that. The one involved in dramatic reform protests (that includes but are not limited to racial items). There are zero students in those protests who oppose dramatic economic reform. The problem is from the actual people causing it: the Koch brothers, the Waltons, Murdoch, people who don't get remotely as many outraged articles as these students.

TomMckenny··on The Problem at Yale Is Not Free Speech
No, the point is an anti-race equality rant which is intentionally blurring a few anti-elite and anti-dysfunction sounds so it would get published. If it were genuinely anti-dysfunction, it would include much lower hanging fruit like admittance practices focusing on wealth and wrongful terminations. If it were anti-privilege it would focus on that privilege and not on race protest or fads.

So yes, in abstraction, if you put on a facade long enough you forget you're wearing it. But that is not remotely the theme of the article. The one and only theme is that racial equality activism should stop on the grounds that it is being done by rich kids

TomMckenny··on The Problem at Yale Is Not Free Speech
>4. Interprets the battles in 3 as at best insignificant and at worst a distraction from real problems of class disparity in America.

Note however that there is nothing in the article describing economic disparity as a problem. There are laments about social position and altering or eliminating traditions but no hint of criticism of economic inequality.

So the claims aren't about inequality, they're about the "wrong" people (in the author's opinion) being rich. In particular, the rich students behavior regarding the culture war.

And the author is annoyed that some of the rich students live austere and ascetic lives. But the implication is they should act rich instead to become more worthy of respect.

Also the article talks about the energy students devote to racial issues as done merely to avoid social responsibility. But this does not make sense for a couple of reasons:

1) The students described believe there are issues around race and are acting in a way they think will help. So what are the other unstated higher responsibilities are they shirking during their time at University?

2) Walking in protests or wearing cheap cloths only works on people who are literally in physical view. Hiding wealth is done through a Cayman island bank account, that is how one would shirk responsibility.

3) The opinions and behaviors of the minority of students described are extremely rare among the super rich so it's obviously not a very good avoidance technique. Or, by implication, the author signals that the behavior of the Koch brothers or Walton family is more appropriate to the responsibilities of the rich.

So honestly, although there is a brief point raised about two wrongful terminations, the article is really just lamenting the culture war and claiming that the students participation in it is wrong minded and fad driven. There is no call that they should be protesting war or helping the poor or anything. Just that they stop taking these stances on culture war issues.

TomMckenny··on How shrinkflation is playing havoc with economists’ models
Instead, toilet paper literally says 12=48 and the like.
TomMckenny··on The Robot economy and the future of work
Because everyone who does not own robots is competing with them.
TomMckenny··on Disney Announces $12.99 Bundle for Disney+, Hulu, and ESPN+
$6 a month to the actual content creators. $100 a month to the monopoly that owns the 30 year old last mile of cable.
TomMckenny··on Why Aren’t We Talking About LinkedIn?
It's nice it's not being used to undermine democracy. But honestly I'm surprised so few have been put off by the astoundingly aggressive dark patterns the site uses, as I was bombarded with them when going through the sign up flow years ago.

I certainly would not provide personal information to any site behaving that way let alone my professional information and contacts. Just the policy of using my name to spam advertisements to everyone in my life, including serious people, is beyond the pale. I'm surprised that alone does not put more people off.

And when these issues are brought up, the only rejoinder I have ever heard is that hidden somewhere is a link to a vast terms of service document. This of course only confirms the companies comfort with the behavior. And when posted by linkedin users, only serves to tell me the attitude of potential coworkers and employers using the site.

I am honestly astounded that it is so widely used: are there so many people that assume this level of dishonesty is innate to the work environment? Do people feel they must use it regardless in order to survive professionally? Because it's hard to imagine people join enthusiastically or what benefit could compensate for a level of behavior no one would tolerate elsewhere.

TomMckenny··on Inflated Bond Ratings Helped Spur the Financial Crisis. They’re Back
>it's hard to tell what's valid anymore.

That's the plan as it turns out.

TomMckenny··on Content Analysis of How Courts Use and Misuse Rap Lyrics in Criminal Cases
They are zealots, but not for free speech.
TomMckenny··on Content Analysis of How Courts Use and Misuse Rap Lyrics in Criminal Cases
Of course, Bob Jones died 20 years ago of natural causes.

And ironically, it was Bob Jones who directly said that student protesters (like those at Kent State) should be shot. Yet he is not cited as evidence in mass shootings.

So while there is some abstract principle about hypothetical fiction vs intentional directive. There is something going on other than rational and even application of a principle. Likewise, I imagine very few young men of color are found not guilty on the Twinky Defense.

TomMckenny··on 8chan goes dark after hardware provider discontinues service
But in these cases there is a blurring of bad national policy with an entire group of people unconnected to it. This is very dangerous.

For example, there maybe those who dislike Israel and even want war. But to then say "all Jews are evil" is incorrect. Most don't even live there to control policy. Of those that do, many object to policy. It's like saying some terrorists are Muslim so all Muslims are evil. Or that North Korea is dangerous therefore all Koreans are dangerous. Or America does some bad things therefore all Americans should die. It's all obviously incorrect.

You can have a reason to want to fight a _country_ but there can never be a reason to annihilate a complex, nuanced group because of their skin color or religion etc. There can be reasons for war (which is bad enough) but there can never be reasons for genocide. Americans might have reason to hate Japan after Pearl Harbor but to lock up all Japanese inside the country is obviously wrong.

More generally, there can be very good reason to stop a group organized around an action (eg Neo-Nazis). But to say "all whites must die" (because all Neo-Nazis are white) is obviously an incorrect expansion.

Unfortunately, it's a common blurring that exploitative leaders take advantage of. Today some Western leaders foment hate against all Muslims and some Islamic leaders foment hate against all Jews. In the past it was other groups. It is these leaders that are the danger.

TomMckenny··on Bill Gates Resume (1974)
Back then they were quite overtly discriminatory about marriage status, gender, having children or not, disabilities, age, divorce. Indeed, apartment buildings often refused to rent to families with children.

In the 70's, people speaking against race discrimination were viewed as center left but people decrying discrimination on these other grounds were considered far left. Even on otherwise "progressive" period TV shows, these positions would be satirized (eg the characters played by Beatrice Arthur and Rob Reiner were satires much of the time. The Mary Tyler Moore character was originally written as a divorcee)

And though legislation had recently curtailed ethnicity and religion from being _publicly_ discriminated, it was still seen as ok to discriminate for public facing positions: Connie Chung's position as news reader was considered definite proof of media liberal bias. Indeed, advocating equality for public facing positions or for persons with disabilities was viewed as completely unrealistic.

TomMckenny··on What If We Haven’t Met Aliens yet Because They’ve Messed Up Their Planets Too?
What if we can't detect them because we don't know what an intelligent advanced species looks like because we aren't one?
← PreviousPage 8 of 24Next →