(Conversly, when I used GMail, it didn’t work that well with Apple Mail.)
196 karma · joined August 27, 2010
(Conversly, when I used GMail, it didn’t work that well with Apple Mail.)
This philosophy of putting consistency on this giant pedestal reminds me of the strict non-expressive philosophy of 60s modernist graphic design. They use Helvetica for everything, because Helvetica is neutral, believe that type should never be expressive because the meaning is in the content. Today many like the style, but very few share the philosophy that design should not be expressive.
Today graphic design is expressive. You can look at a poster and guess the content based on the typeface, colors, texture, etc. I think we are seeing a similar development in the world of UI design. Having the notes app actually sort-of look like handwritten notes gives people visual cues to what this application and makes it easy to understand. I would not be surprised if such visual cues makes the app disappear than a pure consistent app would. These apps are only different visually, in behavior they are often very consistent. You also have apps that take things much futher, such as Convertbot, Clear or Paper. I think breaking UI conventions is completely acceptable if they make the experience better. Personally I find Paper to be far more invisible than the other more consistent sketching-apps for iPad.
I think there is more than enough room for both philosophies (and everything between). Vote with your wallet and buy the apps that work well for you.
Remember that A didn’t start as an A, it started as a sign for ox. That’s right, our writing system had skeuomorphic origins.
Someone growing up today might not know what a handset it, but I’m pretty sure they recognize the handset icon. This is true for a lot of stuff in our culture (think of non-textual road signs).
Both design and coding are both huge fields. I am not merely talking about becoming a good designer and developer at once, but becoming one with a lot of knowledge in both.
Just take the long lists of things that that relate to each field: Design: interaction design, information architecture, illustration, visual design, interface design, user testing, typography, color theory, composition, accessibility, different design processes, brainstorming techniques, using grid systems, cognitive psychology, sketching Coding: HTML/CSS, various programming languages ranging from low level to highly abstracted, various libraries, understanding of good software architecture, algorithms, maths, understanding how computers work, understanding data structures
There is probably more stuff I forgot to mention. As I wrote in my previous post: I think the key is to choose a subset of both sides.
However, I am not sure if you really need to be super knowledgeable to benefit from knowing both sides of the fence. I’m sure it’s possible to become really good at a subset of coding and design.
By the way: these are just my musings. I’m very early in my career myself. Personally I’m aiming to become effective at programming relating to the user interface of things, and design wise I focus my efforts on interaction design, information architecture and visual design. I want to learn more than what I just mentioned, but this I what I aim to be my core.
Pixelmator has a UI that rivals Photoshop in many areas.
This doesn’t seem to be isolated to Rails though, Django seems to have gotten harder. I actually gave up installing Django due to a localization bug.
However: I think today we have more beautiful design that we would have had if the design tools had not become democratized, maybe not in percentage, but certainly in amount.
My speculation: programming --> more programs. Both crap and great ones.
Maybe it’s a case of something that is confusing at first, but people learn fairly quickly?
The app works great, really cool!
The download link seems be down though (internal server error).
Apple might still me a influence, but I don’t think it’s minor.
Developers might respond that they created a great product that solves a problem without any designers. To that my reply is that you then you have designed as well.
This is exactly what design is.
(Seems like different airlines are the most punctual depending on how you measure it…)
1. They hired a designer to work with them. 2. They have become good at design themselves.
It’s kinda obvious when you think about it.
While I disagree with his pretty extreme views he is at least consistent in them. Also, even though I'm not a huge FOSS-proponent myself, I think the world is better for having some of them.
Will Miner spoke about web designer as a hybrid between designer and developer at Build: http://vimeo.com/7835308
I feel like I’ll probably be a designer at heart, but I still want to learn as much dev-stuff as possible. I’m going to use Django for my personal portfolio, simply for the sake of learning it. I’m really looking forward to it. :)
Generally people need people of other disciplines. Developers need designers as well, and we all need copywriters for instance.
Design is how the cup looks, and more importantly feels in your hand. Engineering is making sure the cup don't fall apart, keeps the cofee in the cup and don't leak. The coffe is the content.
I would actually say Hacker News and Stack Overflow have very good design. They have design that meets the goals of the sites. That is what design is, meeting the goals of your product.
Sure, design can look good, but looking good is only one part of design. It’s not all of design.
I think the main problem is not that programmers are programmers… but that they are not designers. I think anyone who is not a designer can make similar mistakes. Ask someone (who is not a programmer and not a designer) to design a interface and you could probably find many of the same problems.
So basically: people who are not designers make mistakes when doing design. Who would have thought?
The only big design problem with Hacker News is the measure (width of the text blocks), which sizes according to the browser. Resizing measure without resizing font-size is just crazy IMHO. Actually, adding a max-width to Hacker News wrapper (which oddly enough seems to be a table) would go a long way.
(I know I should stop complaining, and start building an extension myself.)
A selected with one ID will outweigh a selector with two classes for instance. This can quickly lead to complexity because you need to use a ID many places in order to override a selector that used ID.
A class only used once serves the same purpose as ID (CSS-wise), expect that you avoid a lot of problems.
I might use IDs for anchor purposes (site.com/foo#section), but I never reference it in my CSS.