HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

TraceWoodgrains

205 karma · joined May 17, 2019

submissionscomments
TraceWoodgrains··on The FAA’s Hiring Scandal
Of course not. Multiple things can be (and are) factors at the same time. I'm not asking people to ignore COVID, I'm asking them to not ignore this.
TraceWoodgrains··on The FAA’s Hiring Scandal
When the methods of selection aren’t selective at all (the “qualified” bar on the AT-SAT only eliminated some 5% of candidates), “qualifying citizens” is a bit misleading.

Yes, academy attrition.

I don’t disagree that the 2013 sequester played some role, but to radically change hiring practices in the wake of the sequester and then blame radically higher washout rates primarily on the sequester doesn’t pass the sniff test.

My basic case is simple: when articles and reports considering the reasons haven’t even mentioned this massive change in hiring practices as one contributing factor, shifting to including this as a contributing factor is a genuinely major change, and while it would be convenient for people if it didn’t impact anything I don’t think you can disrupt the pipeline that much and then shrug and attribute all issues to other things. That just doesn’t make sense.

TraceWoodgrains··on The FAA’s Hiring Scandal
This is really helpful. I take something different from it than you do (it looks like attrition starkly increases after 2014, in ways I'd strongly argue it's reasonable to attribute to the new hiring methods), but I'm grateful you posted it. Do you know if more complete/precise numbers are available anywhere (hiring counts, hiring+attrition, etc?

I'm aware of this but it leaves attrition to be inferred. https://www.natca.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/04/FY23-Staffi...

TraceWoodgrains··on The FAA’s Hiring Scandal
To clarify, I picked those two questions not to imply a focus on bad academic performance but because they are both a) absurd/arbitrary and b) the highest-weighted questions by far.
TraceWoodgrains··on How Wikipedia Admin David Gerard Launders His Grudges into the Public Record
Hm, I'm disappointed that this was flagged. This is my third article that's been flagged here recently, after my FAA article a few months ago (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39184451) and my deep dive into the backstory of a fight several months before that (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37390961).

My older articles didn't get flagged and were often quite successful on HN:

https://news.ycombinator.com/from?site=tracingwoodgrains.med... https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32898573

I don't submit my own articles here but always appreciate when they reach the HN audience. I admit I find the system here quite opaque and have a hard time understanding what gets flagged and why. Is it because my articles often explore controversies and might get undue attention over some of the more technical content here? Is there some way I could reach out to someone for more info on why my articles keep getting flagged?

TraceWoodgrains··on Math Team
The author and I have discussed this elsewhere, but we had dramatically different experiences with competitive math, and I think part of the key is that he experienced it as a part of the college admissions grind, while I experienced it as an escape from the classroom to go do cool puzzles.

My major takeaway from his article was "The things we do in the high-stakes holistic admissions structure we've set up are insane" more than anything to do with competition math in specific.

TraceWoodgrains··on The Wikimedia Foundation spends Wikipedia donations on political activism
He means this: https://freddiedeboer.substack.com/p/please-just-fucking-tel...
TraceWoodgrains··on Viral “racism in academia” story deleted when I started asking questions
I’m always happy when my writing gets noticed here, but culture war–connected content has a natural edge in environments like this, so I respect the site’s commitment to manually deweighting things like this to keep the overall focus more technical. It looks like this article has had further spread on HN than the initial hoax, which is all I personally was really hoping, so I’m more than satisfied.
TraceWoodgrains··on Viral “racism in academia” story deleted when I started asking questions
His name is public and visible on the archive page etc, but he is not prominent and at least deleted the thread rather than letting it continue to spread. I’d rather not unilaterally make this the defining moment in his public life long-term, so I’m keeping the name out of a Google-able permanent article.
TraceWoodgrains··on Viral “racism in academia” story deleted when I started asking questions
He’s real enough to have appeared as the first author on a couple of apolitical peer-reviewed publications in his field. I don’t know what possessed him to do this but he definitely looks to be real.
TraceWoodgrains··on Viral “racism in academia” story deleted when I started asking questions
Author here. Many were! I noticed nothing original, and my direct question was only part of the picture. It was striking to me how quickly he started making things disappear after I asked, though, and so far as I can tell the timing is consistent specifically with that question being the immediate precipitating factor.
TraceWoodgrains··on PhD gets 5x increase in postdoc interview invitations by just changing his name
Context on why the Twitter thread was deleted: https://twitter.com/tracewoodgrains/status/15716489346947563...

He nuked his account from orbit after confirming he copied from a reddit thread in response to closer scrutiny. Without extensive documentation of a sort that seems unlikely now, it seems best to treat this whole story as a fabrication.

TraceWoodgrains··on PhD gets 5x increase in postdoc interview invitations by just changing his name
He acknowledged his wording was taken directly from the story, then immediately deleted his acknowledgment: https://twitter.com/tracewoodgrains/status/15716306207442452...
TraceWoodgrains··on PhD gets 5x increase in postdoc interview invitations by just changing his name
When I asked the author of the viral thread, he said he took the wording directly from a reddit thread a few days ago, then deleted his acknowledgment, hid my question, and locked down further replies within minutes. Something is very off about this story. https://twitter.com/tracewoodgrains/status/15716306207442452...
TraceWoodgrains··on /r/antiwork: A tragedy of sanewashing and social gentrification
I did link the original piece coining the term and quote the specific definition given. I think that's a sufficient standard to meet when introducing an unfamiliar term.
TraceWoodgrains··on /r/antiwork: A tragedy of sanewashing and social gentrification
Hm? Would you mind expanding on why and how you feel my piece is hyperpartisan? I'm neither a leftist nor particularly sympathetic to them; my own economic preferences usually lie pretty firmly in the neoliberal camp. Your comment seems to be calling my piece a "communist diatribe", and I'm struggling to see where you got that impression.
TraceWoodgrains··on /r/antiwork: A tragedy of sanewashing and social gentrification
Author of the article here. The user above you is correct. My claim that Ford is indisputably the best representative of the space has nothing to do with its current user base and everything to do with its history. The user base shifted, but I don’t hold that a place’s present is so extricable from its past that 7 years of history become irrelevant when the space grows.
TraceWoodgrains··on /R/Antiwork: A Tragedy of Sanewashing and Social Gentrification
Ha—yes, guilty as charged.
TraceWoodgrains··on An alarming trend in K-12 math education: a guest post and an open letter
Really, you’re objecting to rarity after the emphasis you presented? I went with 4 sigma because you claimed truly gifted kids would take care of themselves. As you note, you can’t get much more extreme than that. My point was to directly refute that specific claim of yours. The same principles absolutely apply for the one in a thousand, or one in a hundred, or one in twenty; they’re just proportionately less extreme for each.
TraceWoodgrains··on An alarming trend in K-12 math education: a guest post and an open letter
This is incorrect. Their explicit goal is to remove fast tracking and options to take more advanced topics for gifted students. The vision is for uniformly paced classes for all same-aged students.
TraceWoodgrains··on An alarming trend in K-12 math education: a guest post and an open letter
It comes from a real place of privilege to claim schools holding advanced students back never happens. To name one specific example with the most capable, Miraca Gross ran a longitudinal study with children scoring above 180 on IQ tests and found stark differences in motivation, satisfaction, and accomplishment depending on their level of academic acceleration[1]. (Terence Tao was “Adrian” in this study and was one of the models of successfully educating an advanced student). Kids might do something more with math out of sheer boredom, or they might just devote their energy to Pokemon instead—believe me, it’s not just the below average students who feel the urge towards everything else you mention.

Every student, no matter how capable, benefits dramatically from instruction tuned to their level and ability. Claiming advanced students will take care of themselves is an absolute failure in an instructor’s duty of care towards them, an excuse to make the teacher feel better about not having the time, interest, or knowledge to provide proper instruction. There is no merit to the notion.

[1] https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ746290.pdf

TraceWoodgrains··on Trolls convinced journalists they were “abortion bounty hunters”
Reasonable advice; I'll see about applying it in the future. Cheers!
TraceWoodgrains··on Trolls convinced journalists they were “abortion bounty hunters”
Dismiss anything that sounds unusual outright? No. Apply extra scrutiny to things that sound unusual? Absolutely. If they had even googled /r/txbountyhunters, they would have found a rDrama thread early in the results talking about it. If they had looked through the accounts at all, they would have found indications that they weren't conservative pro-life Christians from Texas. Same with the trans one. A number of the pictures were re-used from random sources. Commenters in both often had absurdist/troll-ish usernames, they would make extreme and erratic comments - the signs were all over the place.

More to the point, the satire is obvious because the posts are absurd, over-the-top, and deeply implausible. Spray-painting your baby's mouth and crushing hormone pills to put in your teenager's food, then bragging about it on reddit, are not things people do. Writing a meandering post in southern vernacular about bounty hunting your sex partner is not a thing people do. Do people do insane things sometimes? Yes. But when you want to use a genuinely insane thing as evidence for any sort of political message, you should put more work into it than just assuming whatever outlandish story someone's spinning online that happens to be perfect culture war fuel is truth.

A minimal level of fact-checking and scrutiny would have been enough in this case.

TraceWoodgrains··on Trolls convinced journalists they were “abortion bounty hunters”
Oh hey, cool to see my article here. If anyone has questions or wants further details on anything, I'm happy to stick around this thread for a bit. I've paid altogether too much attention to this saga; glad it's going to some use.
TraceWoodgrains··on Trolls convinced journalists they were “abortion bounty hunters”
There's been plenty of discussion on the Texas law, as indeed there has been on trans issues and the other bait they use. I'm much more interested in focusing on stories nobody else is covering, and "a bunch of low-effort trolls convince hundreds of thousands that people are gathering on reddit to plan bounty hunting" is a fascinating story that nobody was covering. Sorry it wasn't to your liking, but it's a story I think people should hear.
TraceWoodgrains··on Microsoft begins showing an anti-Firefox ad in the Windows 10 start menu
Hm. It may have been as part of something temporary, but I definitely ran into that message recently. Good to see it's back.
TraceWoodgrains··on Microsoft begins showing an anti-Firefox ad in the Windows 10 start menu
Have you tried using Translate for a web page recently, instead of just a couple sentences of text? Some time ago, they removed that functionality, instead instructing users to use a browser with native translation capabilities to translate pages. It's a pretty blatant push to get people over onto Chrome.
TraceWoodgrains··on Old CSS, New CSS
One of the few add-ons I've installed that's been worth its weight in gold has been "Form History Control (II)", which passively saves every comment as I type it. It's saved me no end of grief in these scenarios.
TraceWoodgrains··on I'm Resigning as a Stack Overflow Community Elected Moderator
There are legal-related concerns, but not precisely due-process ones. Monica goes into it more on her blog, particularly in the comments of this post [1] where she discusses the possibility of taking legal action against the company. She feels that StackExchange libelled her by making public accusations of specific & evidently inaccurate bad conduct to the press [2] while making themselves unavailable for any sort of communication and resolution.

As far as due process goes, there was an established process on the website for removing moderators, which StackExchange did not follow in her removal. Nothing legally questionable about it since they can run their site how they will, but certainly questionable enough to burn goodwill.

[1] https://cellio.dreamwidth.org/2019/10/15/stack-overflow-dela...

[2] https://www.theregister.co.uk/2019/10/01/stack_exchange_cont...

TraceWoodgrains··on IQ rates are dropping in many developed countries
This is mostly a definition game using "intelligence" to mean "reaching the peak of a narrow skill." That sort of peak takes a tricky-to-nail-down combination of innate ability, practice, and environment to reach. When people are talking about IQ, they use the word intelligence to describe, essentially, fluid problem-solving and reasoning aptitude. A lot of disagreement in this domain can and should be resolved with clearer terminology.

IQ says little about the specific skills someone has trained, so more specific tests are useful for that, but it provides a lot of information on the general aptitude it is intended to assess.

Page 1 of 2Next →