HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Tyrannosaurs

5,407 karma · joined January 14, 2010

Tired, slightly geeky, domesticated generalist based in Glasgow, Scotland.
submissionscomments
Tyrannosaurs··on Tim Cook on iMessage Security: It’s Encrypted, and We Don’t Have a Key
They could add that but as things stand right now that second key doesn't exist - or at least it did then Cook would be out and out lying here. Obviously anything can change in the future but based on what Cook is saying either he is lying or Apple can't read your iMessages - I see no wiggle room which creates a middle ground or half truth.

In terms of what the police and other agencies can request, they have been able to ask for stuff in the past because it was information you had. If someone produces a court order they have to comply with that but there is no way of making you produce information you don't have.

As a result some companies are now setting stuff up so they don't have the sort of information which might be requested.

I may be wrong about this but I'm not aware of any law that says that a company can't do this. Certainly if there is then there are plenty of businesses aimed squarely at this sort of privacy and security which are going to have major issues given that it's basically their USP.

And if a company has to do it then the same law will apply to any individual producing open source software to do the same - any such law would be highly unlikely to be dependent on the product being created and distributed by an incorporated company.

Where there will be a problem (and this is the point Cook was making) is for companies where gathering that data is fundamental to their business. Apple can happily survive without being able to read or track iMessages. Facebook or Google have fewer options when it comes to not recording or storing stuff.

Tyrannosaurs··on Tim Cook on iMessage Security: It’s Encrypted, and We Don’t Have a Key
Not really. He's pretty clear:

"If the government laid a subpoena to get iMessages, we can’t provide it. It’s encrypted and we don’t have a key."

There's no wiggle room there. He's not saying we don't have the users key, he's saying categorically they can't provide iMessage information. I don't understand why you think that can be read as they can't get the information through mechanism X but that they can through mechanism Y.

That's not to say the NSA can't read them - possibly with Apple's help, possibly without - but he's really not in a position to talk about what the NSA can and can't do.

From a corporate PR perspective, he really doesn't have to say anything about this. He doesn't do many interviews, he could have declined this, or declined to talk about certain topics as part of the conditions around doing the interview. If Apple can indeed read your messages then the easiest thing for him would be to shut up and say nothing so it would seem odd to go public with a lie when he has that option.

Tyrannosaurs··on Yes, we’re being bought by Microsoft
The idea isn't really the thing though is it?

The basic idea is the product being worked on in Douglas Coupland's Microserfs released in 1995 (Blockland launched 2004, Minecraft 2011).

As you say, it's the design and execution.

Tyrannosaurs··on I'm Leaving Mojang
Or Steve Jobs.

There was a school of thought that the only reason that Steve Jobs liked being CEO of Apple was so that he could build the products he wanted, how he wanted, without anyone else telling him what he could and couldn't do. He basically created a role where he was a Product Manager with near unlimited resources who didn't have to answer to anyone else.

Tyrannosaurs··on I'm Leaving Mojang
We weren't born in a goofy time. We (the people who frequent this board) largely exist in an industry where in certain markets you have enough leverage to some of the worst elements of wage slavery.

But 98% of people on this planet at this time aren't in the same position and even in our industry if you think you are I suspect you'd be surprised how far you can really push your freedom from your bosses will it before you find you've got problems.

Tyrannosaurs··on Yes, we’re being bought by Microsoft
The MS of 5 years ago, you'd have said it would never happen. The MS of today, it's not impossible (though it is unlikely).
Tyrannosaurs··on A Watch Guy's Thoughts on the Apple Watch After Seeing It in the Metal
I'm being open minded to the idea that my definition of value here isn't everyone's so I'm excluding cents. My own watch is expensive (by my thinking) would meet either criteria but I could see myself maybe one day buying a watch that topped $10,000.

Maybe.

Tyrannosaurs··on Steve Jobs Introduces the iPhone 6 and Apple Watch
> The annoyance I feel when people say "what would Jesus do?" is the same annoyance I feel when reading these articles about "what would Steve do?"

Interestingly Tim Cook has repeatedly said that Jobs' instruction to them when he was leaving was never to ask this, but to trust their own judgement. His fans may ask this but Jobs at least was smart enough to see the folly in it.

Obviously the problem with this is it creates a paradox. If I ask what would Jobs do, then Jobs wouldn't ask what Jobs would do. But if I follow that advice and don't worry about what Jobs would or wouldn't do, I start asking again, what would Jobs do?

Tyrannosaurs··on Steve Jobs Introduces the iPhone 6 and Apple Watch
Doesn't perfect also depend on what you're trying to do?

It's all trade offs but as we increase what we do with our phones, a bigger screen potentially becomes more valuable.

I know a lot of people saying they have no interest in more than 3.5" or 4". Generally those people are fairly casual users. I also know "power users" (horrible term) who have been crying out for bigger screens.

I'm less worried about thumb size and more worried about how it feels in my pocket.

Tyrannosaurs··on Steve Jobs Introduces the iPhone 6 and Apple Watch
This ignores that Apple regularly changed direction under Jobs:

* No-one wants an iPod that plays video * No-one wants a small tablet * The original 3.5" iPhone is the right size (Jobs may not have lived to see the iPhone 5 launch but would have known it was coming and approved it)

He was a notorious flip flopper. He'd be a dick about it (surprise!) and take credit for things he'd previously been against, but he often changed his mind and a larger iPhone isn't out of the question.

Once you get to an iPad Mini being OK with him, I don't see why we think he'd have objected to the large iPhone.

EDIT: Thinking about it, the principal of multiple versions / sizes of a product was well established before Jobs left. MacBook Airs, MacBook Pros, desktop Macs, iPads, multiple sizes of iPod (Classic, Nano, Shuffle, Touch). Frankly the iPhone was about the only product where you weren't forced to take a specific shape / size.

Tyrannosaurs··on iPhone 6 and Android value
Android will almost certainly always be more customisable than iOS, the question for many users though isn't "which is more customisable?", it's "is it customisable enough for what I need/want to do?".

In this regard iOS8 begins to close off some of the more significant constraints iPhones and iPads have. For any given individual it may not go far enough but what's being introduced will almost certainly make it a better option for some people and some of those people may now buy iPhones instead of high end Android.

The point isn't that this brings the two platforms level, it's that iOS now competes for a small piece of the market where it previously didn't.

Tyrannosaurs··on A Watch Guy's Thoughts on the Apple Watch After Seeing It in the Metal
That's an interesting clarification but I'm not sure it changes much.

After all, a 1000 year calendar is impressive, but who really has ever gone, "hold on is it the 20th century or the 21st"? That might have been an issue for a few of us who were a bit drunk on New Year's Eve 14 years ago but it's not going to be a problem again for at least 86 years.

I still think a $2.7m dollar watch has one purpose - to allow the owner to say they have a $2.7m watch.

I should point out, I'm not against expensive, mechanical watches (I own one and love it), I just think there are limits and for me they probably kick in around the point a sixth digit gets added to the price.

Tyrannosaurs··on A Watch Guy's Thoughts on the Apple Watch After Seeing It in the Metal
I kind of agree. The article is kind of right in that it seems to be saying that they're not the same thing and that's right - the only real similarity is that they occupy the space on your wrist but that doesn't mean that it can't appeal to someone who likes high end mechanical watches (I have an IWC which I love but I'm still interested in the Apple watch).

After all, I have expensive leather shoes and trainers. Other than the fact they both go on my feet there is little similarity but I can and do own, use and like both.

Tyrannosaurs··on A Watch Guy's Thoughts on the Apple Watch After Seeing It in the Metal
"The Most Complicated Watch In The World"

How many people have ever walked into a jewelers and, when asked what they wanted from a watch, replied "I want it to be as complicated as possible - the more complicated the better".

A watch at that price does one thing and one thing only - it says loud and clear that the wearer is almost certainly richer than you.

Tyrannosaurs··on A Watch Guy's Thoughts on the Apple Watch After Seeing It in the Metal
It's subjective - there's a reason if you go to a regular watch shop they have as many different watches as they do.

Apple have made a start on trying to work with different preferences with the interchangable straps and clasps and so on but something like this is never going to please everyone.

Personally I wouldn't go as far as ugly but I'm certainly not wow-ed by it in terms of how it looks. It seems to be well designed and well made but lots of things are and it doesn't mean I want to strap them to my wrist.

Tyrannosaurs··on On the Scottish independence referendum and the post-Westphalian settlement
As a Brit (English, living in Scotland), I'd say that there is a way to go before that and would make two points:

1) there is only one party promising that referendum and they're behind in the polls

2) current polls say that we'd vote to stay (http://yougov.co.uk/news/2014/06/17/eu-referendum-record-lea...), even before any renegotiation. There are other polls which have said otherwise but YouGov provide an on-going tracker which I think shows that, while the level of support has changed, broadly we still support EU membership.

Obviously all very uncertain (and until a couple of weeks ago polls were sure Scotland would stay in the UK) but I'd say that you shouldn't confuse the volume of some of the negative views on Europe with them being a consensus - most people are quietly happy with the status quo.

Tyrannosaurs··on On the Scottish independence referendum and the post-Westphalian settlement
As far as I can tell they're currently opposing it somewhat indirectly but they absolutely don't want the precedent of a country separating and being allowed into Europe.

Neither of them are quite European heavyweights but ultimately , unless there is some sort of fudge (not impossible but unlikely), every existing EU nation will have to vote to accept an independent Scotland. For that to happen it would appear that something will have to be done to placate those with similar potential domestic issues themselves if it's too happen. Whether of not such a something realistically exists or not I don't know.

Tyrannosaurs··on On the Scottish independence referendum and the post-Westphalian settlement
Obviously not - Spain in particular (but not exclusively - there are plenty of other counties in the EU who face similar issues) won't want a precedent which could apply to, say, Catalonia.

But that's a separate issue about Scotland joining full stop, rather than the terms on which they'd join. I suspect if Catalonia declared independence then the most sensible starting point for their EU membership is what covers them already (that is Spain's position). No-one really benefits from a position where unnecessary change and uncertainty is pushed onto newly formed countries.

I agree that the yes campaign's approach to difficult issues seems to be essentially "don't worry your pretty little heads about it, it'll all be fine, we've got the oil".

Short version: if it's a yes vote, it's going to be a big ol' mess for a while.

Tyrannosaurs··on On the Scottish independence referendum and the post-Westphalian settlement
The EU may make an exception to Schengen as Scotland is in a unique position - it will claim (with some justification) that it is already in the EU (and outside Schengen) and the starting point for it should be the UK's current position.

More interesting on the CTA is that it would involve signing up to many of the immigration policies rUK and Ireland have agreed to as part of that deal - that contradicts the more open immigration policy the SNP are selling as part of their pitch (which also includes the CTA).

Tyrannosaurs··on On the Scottish independence referendum and the post-Westphalian settlement
An independent Scotland would supposedly join the EU which would give it the basics in terms of a bill of rights. Until the EU the UK as a whole never had a written bill of rights so it would be no worse off.

In terms of the SNP, what happens to them in an independent Scotland might be the most interesting thing. They'd undoubtedly do well in a first election but after the glow has worn off and without their current USP (independence, the only party which is just about Scotland) it'll be interesting to see how they define themselves - after all, politically it's not impossible to view them as to the right of the Labour party (they're not the Tories but they're certainly not socialists), and in another few years time they're going to be very much part of the establishment.

Tyrannosaurs··on On the Scottish independence referendum and the post-Westphalian settlement
Culturally there is actually a great similarity between Scotland and much of England. One of the weaknesses of the No campaign in my view is that they've failed to draw on the massive similarities between Scotland the the industrial north of England.

The differences between London and Scotland are significant, but the same differences exist between London and much of the North of England.

Tyrannosaurs··on On the Scottish independence referendum and the post-Westphalian settlement
It feels to me (in the interests of transparency, I'm another no voter) that there needs to be a second referendum if it is a yes vote where we get to vote on exactly the settlement which is agreed.
Tyrannosaurs··on On the Scottish independence referendum and the post-Westphalian settlement
> There's simply too much handwaving.

Welcome to the Scottish independence debate.

On one level it's been extraordinary - pretty much everyone has an opinion and the turnout rate is likely to be 80%+. On a more depressing level the quality of the debate and information made available has largely been extraordinarily poor.

Tyrannosaurs··on Standard Markdown
Standard implies "normal" or "default" as well as "standardised".

Whatever you may think of Markdown (that is markdown as created by Gruber), it surely isn't unreasonable to suggest that if any version can make that sort of claim, it should be the original.

Tyrannosaurs··on Failing the startup game at Unbabel
It really isn't, trust me, I've been through it a few times (as an employer).

There is a lot of detail hidden behind this:

"If you’re dismissed, your employer must show they’ve:

* a valid reason that they can justify * acted reasonably in the circumstances

They must also:

* be consistent - eg not dismiss you for doing something that they let other employees do * have investigated the situation fully before dismissing you - eg if a complaint was made about you"

There actually aren't that many valid reasons. Cultural fit certainly isn't one (and has the potential to get you in all sorts of equalities issues if there is any possibility that age, religion or anything else can be seen as a proxy for the way you didn't fit).

If you want to claim someone isn't good at their job you need to be able to back it up and show you gave them every opportunity to turn it around (including having given them all the relevant support and training). Generally speaking that would be a performance management exercise (several weeks of monitored performance) which is time consuming and rubbish for all involved.

And that's before you even get into the whole performance is hard to accurately measure in IT issues.

The investigated fully part is also important. If you diverge from your stated policy (or a reasonable policy if there isn't one stated - the ACAS one is usually the template) then you can be found against at a tribunal even if you reasons and evidence were sound.

Obviously people do ignore all this and get away with it (particularly in IT where people can often get new jobs relatively easily) but that doesn't mean you will or that what you did was legal.

Your best shot is if the contract has a defined probation period (3 to 6 months) during which you can pretty much get rid of people at will but after that, even before 2 years is up, it's going to take some work. It's not impossible but it's an exercise which will take a lot of your time and likely have a significant impact on team morale.

Tyrannosaurs··on Failing the startup game at Unbabel
I disagree, there really is little beyond a "he said, she said" type argument to be had here and that really doesn't benefit them (or indeed Andreas). Much of that is subjective and they're not going to publish code to prove it one way or the other so there will never really be agreement. Best case is they reply and he refutes it which puts them pretty much back where they are now.

As a company you want to shut this sort of discussion down as quickly as you can. A detailed rebuttal may appear to do that but doesn't - the more you say, the more you raise questions, invite rebuttals and encourage further debate.

Maybe this doesn't answer some claims and they suffer some very slight damage because of that, but far worse damage is often (possibly even usually) done by detailed replies which keep the story going and fuel the fire.

Tyrannosaurs··on Failing the startup game at Unbabel
In some countries (the UK is one), you need to be very careful with "cultural fit".

For instance, not hiring someone because they don't want to go for beers on a Friday can accidentally become a proxy for excluding certain religions at which point you can be in all sorts of bother legally.

Tyrannosaurs··on Failing the startup game at Unbabel
This highlights one of the risks with going and working in another country - what seems fair, reasonable and legal to you may be very different in another country.

As someone who lives in Europe I find American hire / fire at will contracts terrifying (getting rid of someone in the UK can be a torturous process, in other European countries even worse) but obviously in most states (?) in the US they're the norm.

Lesson to learn - before you agree to work somewhere else, understand the culture and legal framework you're going to be working in if at all possible and set your expectations accordingly.

Tyrannosaurs··on Myths About Working as an Engineer at a Startup
> And: don't worry, you will get your shares.

Can't promise you what they'll be worth though.

Tyrannosaurs··on Russia extends Snowden residency by three years
You don't need to read anyone's mind, he's a world leader with a public history - just a bit of reading will tell you enough about him to make a pretty good guess at what's happening here.
← PreviousPage 4 of 34Next →