House ruling is fine but shouldn't that level of challenge (either through an enforced time limit or some other means) exist in the vanilla game?
5,407 karma · joined January 14, 2010
House ruling is fine but shouldn't that level of challenge (either through an enforced time limit or some other means) exist in the vanilla game?
The first half says "this is why Piketty is (probably) wrong about there being a problem" and the second half saying "and he's wrong about what we should do about it, here's what we should do instead".
Surely if there is no problem, the there is nothing which needs to be done about it?
Saying Piketty is jealous may or may not be true, but it says nothing about whether what he says in his book is correct or not (and if not in what way he is incorrect).
If someone disagrees with what he says then saying things about Piketty himself is really rather by-the-by as it's his analysis that needs to be critiqued. He may be an idiot speaking truth or a genius speaking nonsense, but the truth or nonsense (rather than the idiot or genius) is the significant matter.
EDIT: I've not read either Piketty (life is too short - at least mine is) or Greenspun's analysis of it (would be rather pointless as I've not read what he's talking about).
I'm only saying that if something can be genuinely summarised as "Piketty is jealous" then that sounds like an attack on the author rather than the work.
Remember, he was in the UK on bail for months before he went near the embassy.
If the UK sent him to Sweden both countries (the UK and Sweden) have to agree to the extradition as the law is set up to prevent exactly this sort of thing happening.
The claim you outline doesn't really make sense if you look at what's really involved.
If the claim was that it was some sort of backhanded punishment - that he's going to be stitched up for rape and go to prison as some sort of punishment beating from the US because they know they're not going to get him convicted of what they want to get him convicted of, I could understand that, but how does it aid or enable an extradition to the US?
No US citizen was involved, the crime didn't happen in the US, the Swedes would want him to serve any prison sentence before they'd release him elsewhere, the extradition from Sweden will be more complex than from the UK (as if he's been extradited from the UK the UK also have to agree to him going to the US) and it's not as if the UK aren't massively friendly (indeed in cahoots with) US intelligence.
I can completely see the idea that the US want Assange on US soil to try, but I don't see how this helps them to that end.
Let's also remember, the UK has spent years being the US's bitch when it comes to foreign policy, defence and intelligence matters. I can't think of a single nation in the world who have been more willing to do America's bidding than the UK. It really makes no sense for the US to involve a third party.
A bunch of the newspapers here (the UK) looked into this at the time and the short version was there was no realistic, workable way of getting him out without the UK co-operating.
"A person who is convicted summarily of an offence under subsection (1) or (2) above [which outline not attending without good reason] and is not committed to the Crown Court for sentence shall be liable to imprisonment for a term not exceeding 3 months or to a fine not exceeding level 5 on the standard scale or to both and a person who is so committed for sentence or is dealt with as for such a contempt shall be liable to imprisonment for a term not exceeding 12 months or to a fine or to both."
The court and / or the CPS may view that there is no public interest in that, though similarly they may view given the cost to the tax payer of the round the clock surveillance of the embassy he should be made an example of.
I'd be inclined to believe the later.
DAG isn't a man you can easily accuse of being the sort who would be rabidly anti-Assange - almost the opposite.
My understanding is that it's bits of the GIMP processing engine with a nicer UI.
Ideally I'd live closer to work but I like living rurally and that's not ideal of IT jobs. As I work in management remote working is a relatively limited option, at least for most of the opportunities around here.
Parking further away is possible but really I'm just adding more time to the commute - 15 minutes walking rather than 3 minutes driving. If I could free up that time I'd probably be better off just taking it off as a 30 minute chunk and going for a walk a lunch.
Walking meetings have been a good solutions - I have a few informal one to ones which can be done walking in the nearby park. Similarly I'll sometimes do calls where I'm not expected to be taking notes or doing anything else on my mobile phone.
My experience was that I found the data initially interesting (mostly that the idea anyone was under the Nike "average" staggering - I have a desk job and don't consider myself massively active but easily hit it most days) but the problem I had was that in a busy life I found relatively little room to flex what I was doing in any substantial way.
My week day routine essentially goes - get up, get ready for work, get kids up, leave, drive to work, work, drive home, get kids bathed and into bed, tidy house, get dinner, eat... and by that time it's about 9pm and I've either got to do whatever jobs need doing or relax. In itself that routine is relatively active outside the desk job (kids...) but there isn't a lot of wiggle room.
My commute isn't easily changable (I live in a rural location so anything other than driving is out), I can sometimes get out and go for a walk at lunchtime and I try to do walking meetings if possible (maybe once a week) but generally speaking my day is my day and I can't really change much.
As a result measuring it didn't feel like it had much point - the number was the number and it was relatively rare I'd look at it and think I could have done better.
Not really.
If you have massively powerful devices and massively fast connections then you move to a situation where you've still got to address differences between the programming models and and the feature sets on the various devices.
For a web app to have parity with a native app there are still significant technology gaps which need to be closed - offline working (moving in the right direction, still not great), native look, feel and functionality (difficult if you want it to run on multiple device types) and so on. Some of those will close over time, some may not.
But harder to close off - I struggle to see how cross platform will every be much more than lowest common denominator given the consensus required on how to adopt new features as they arrive on phones. Apple launches TouchID, Samsung launch fingerprint scanning. How long before the W3C define a standard for that and the companies adopt it? How much time is that where native developers are at an advantage?
The web is great and web apps will definitely be a bigger part of things going forward, but I think it's simplistic to assume that they'll take over.
As for a present day Microsoft, I don't see that happening. Back then interoperability was a nightmare - if the person I wanted to work with wasn't running the same OS as me I was basically screwed. Right now I can collaborate with someone and generally speaking I don't care what they're running and it really doesn't matter.
I know a friend who is a published, relatively successful author (makes a solid but not spectacular living from it) makes most of his money from the old fashioned business of selling actual books.
A few years ago DC Comics decided to sue DC Shoes over their logo which, like DC Comics logo at the time, used the letters DC and a star.
Turns out DC hadn't trademarked the logo, despite having used it (and variants) for decades so they lost.
DC Shoes HAD trademarked it and successfully counter sued and DC Comics, despite having used a similar logo for a lot longer, were forced to pay DC Shoes for the rights (at least until they ultimately changed their logo).
My concern is for authors, game designers and others for whom there is no such substitution possible.
While we'd all like a situation where those who've added most value get the lions share of the reward, this solution takes us from them getting a small percentage to them getting nothing. That seems to me to be worse rather than better.
That's genius because scammers would never say something like that because that would be lying and people don't lie because it's naughty.
That said, my 3 and 4 year olds cause no problems with my iPad so I'm not sure how big a deal it is.
I can understand why that frustrates developers but I can understand why Apple do it.
I don't necessarily agree with affirmative action, but if you believe that many of the factors which contribute towards easily measured ability (attending a good school, work experience) may be skewed, then you presumably also accept that there is untapped potential out there - people with the ability to be as great but who have been in some way - fairly or otherwise - disadvantaged.
In IT in particular, where everything changes rapidly, you want to be hiring for potential as much as skill the candidate has today.
I don't think it's about picking someone because they're part of a minority, it's about thinking about how you look for and judge candidates to take into account that potential which so far hasn't been tapped.
What it says is fundamentally true but I'm curious about the allocation of "maker" and "manager". As someone who has worked as a manager and a developer, I value uninterupted time in both roles. It doesn't matter whether I'm planning, or writing a proposal, or coding - large chunks of uninterrupted time are good, a broken up day is bad and less unproductive.
Certainly managers might more often have to respond to changing situations (though if you're a developer with any involvement in support you might question that) but if they opt to plan around frequent task changes when they don't have to that's just odd.
To me it just feels like a difference between people who manage time well and those who don't, rather than a maker / manager distinction.