HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

VK538FY

105 karma · joined August 8, 2018

submissionscomments
VK538FY··on Global Passport Power Rank 2019
The ability to enter another country as a tourist without a visa (or with some electronic visa) is cool. Obviously problematic for a citizen of a country with few such agreements.

What I find far more interesting personally is the ability to reside or do business meaningfully in another country in virtue of the bilateral agreements between the two countries.

Some examples of which I have read here or elsewhere. - US citizens can establish their own business in NL - US citizens can overstay Schengen limits in PL due to anterior bilateral agreements - reduced time to permanent residency in CH for CA or US citizens.

VK538FY··on Claims that breakfast is a health panacea may be unsupported
Absolutely painfull. And completely USA-centric. Not a reference to the rest of us. Reminded me of a USian article that was making the rounds a while ago. https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2014/10/08/magazine/eate...
VK538FY··on Ask HN: Where to go for the cheapest EE degree in the U.S.? In the World?
Some have mentioned Germany. I haven't noticed Canada. I know both university systems, though not for electrical engineering specifically.

Germany is a solid choice. Far better conditions than in some neighbouring countries (cough cough France). Depending on the state (Bundesland), the fees can be very low to none. Again state-dependant, but in many cases foreign students must lock a yearly amount into a bank account and can only withdraw 1/12 or so each month. Quite rightly so: unless you're a monk, you'll need a bit more than they force you to lock up. Bachelor level is almost exclusively in German (exceptions may exist) and I suggest learning German: there are specific avenues granting university access and it's an investment of 6 months to 1 year at least. Living expenses are fairly low from my perspective.

Canada is a good choice because even if most foreign students pay _much_ more than Canadians or provincial residents, it's still several times cheaper than the equivalent in the US. What I've seen in Québec is of very high quality. Language (French or English) depends on the university. Linguistic questions aside, and here I speak specifically of Québec (other provinces may vary), you may be obliged to complete a series of pre-university college classes to bring your maths to level. The university generally offers these. Living expenses are probably a bit higher than Germany but still comparable.

Other things to consider, especially since we're talking about engineering: recognition and professional orders. Recognition: diplomas from countries known as diploma mills are like a stone around the neck whereas diplomas from others are generally well regarded. Professional orders: if engineering jobs in your target work country require membership in a professional order and your diploma is foreign, well, good luck with that -- in the best case, it can take months to join, in the worst case, they make you take corrective classes.

Finally, medium term. When you need a job. Canada vs Germany is a harder question. I changed careers and moved between the two so my perspective is skewed. I know that an EE diploma in Germany will definitely get you a good first job that will teach you a lot. The thing is, unless you're German, you're unlikely to want to stay there (some odd cultural issues, high taxes, relatively low salaries for talented people -- those are the general complaints of, let's say, North American and European foreigners). Canada has a relatively good labour market with better social protection than the southern neighbour. If you work in Canada, flexible people tend to fit in quickly (unless problems with the linguistic divide), but the taxes are also very high in some places, starting salaries are sad, and the brain drain to the US is unfortunately real. The winter in most parts is highly subjective.

VK538FY··on A Soviet-era airport, once the height of luxury, faces demolition in Armenia
I also have a soft spot for Tempelhof. The shape of the structure and the interior are magnificent.

https://www.fotocommunity.de/photo/im-flughafen-tempelhof-ho...

I know that it probably wouldn't work as a modern airport but I wish that there had been a way. It's so weird and... Berlin. Love it.

VK538FY··on The language the French forbade
We agree: it depends on the willingness of people to learn. I'm just saying to myself that it's pretty stupid not to want to learn the language of one's immediate neighbours, especially when it can eliminate spells of unemployment or double or triple one's salary.

I had heard of the Belgian example and am all too aware of Romands and Allemanics speaking English with each other because most don't care to learn another official language enough to do business in it. A couple of other examples that I've seen...

- Basel, CH: the German speaking Baslers are litterally glued to a now essentially francophone French city. Every one that I've met speaks better English than French. Of course it's clear that they have little economic motivation to do so.

- Wrocław, PL: many of the graduates of that city's fine universities may end up working in Germany (which is about 100 km away) but almost none of them come out of high school or university speaking fluent German. The system even discourages it, maybe because Wrocław (Breslau) was previously in Germany.

VK538FY··on The language the French forbade
If you're Greek, that _might_ be a dilemma, I suppose. :-)
VK538FY··on The language the French forbade
Not just a couple, but many European countries offer two or more foreign languages. (The level of success varies wildly of course.)

The configuration is even more complicated in French schools where there is the optional immersion in the regional language. That immersion generally begins at the earliest ages. But my point was that this regional language in no way limits the choice of the first foreign language later on. Therefore: I don't believe that Occitan is in any way menaced by English, but English may be chosen over other European languages later in one's scolarity.

As an aside, I don't quite agree with your statement that the foreign languages offered cover your travel needs. Well, that may be true, but I don't think that the most important element is mobility for travel, but rather mobility for employment and trade, especially in border regions. And I can name a LOT of countries where proficiency in the neighbour's language is severely lacking. Neighbours that are sometimes just a kilometre away. I've seen it myself.

VK538FY··on The language the French forbade
Are you referring to the bulldozer effect of English against other major languages?

If so, I'd say that English and Occitan (for example) are not in the same league, therefore not competitors. For example, no school pupil will choose to do part of his schooling in Occitan unless he lives in that region and even then it doesn't really replace a 'real' foreign language -- you need to learn one of those anyway. (Right?) But in Europe, when one decides between English and another major European language, the easiest answer is not always the best answer. And the easy answer demonstrates the bulldozer effect of English.

(I'm not a fan of English BTW. I use it when it's useful to me, like any other. Others have proven themselves far more useful to me at times. Just not when I read Hacker News!)

VK538FY··on The language the French forbade
True, but I think of the French author who visited Québec in the 19th century long after the conquest and noted that the purity of the language was better than in much of France at the time. Or something like that, I can't find the reference right now. Was the author talking of the division north-south or of a greater diversity than you suggest? Hard to tell.
VK538FY··on The language the French forbade
I'd like to know more. In New France, the majority was from northwestern France (Normands, Poitevins, etc.) but somehow they managed to settle on a language that is surprisingly similar to Parisian French despite the accent and informal terms whose northwestern roots are clear (according to the linguists that I've read). So did the colonists of New France build on the efforts of François 1er?
VK538FY··on The language the French forbade
True, the 'French republic' was never a friend of regional identity and it continues today. Unfortunate that the policies have diminished the mosaic that is France and also for intergenerational links and the economic opportunities that were lost.

I think of my Alsatian colleagues that learnt their regional language mostly from their grandparents. That skill is still very useful on the other side of the border but you wouldn't know it if you ask the ministry of education in Paris: the dialect of the Haut-Rhin is relatively close to Baseldüütsch and for those that didn't learn at home, bilingual school opened the doors of employment to a lot of people there. There is a net regression of Alsatians who are functional in German, either dialect or standard. Good job opportunities in Basel are being increasingly filled by Germans as the generations progress, while the economy stagnates in France. Back at home, the regional reorganization of France under Hollande is unlikely to help efforts to preserve the regional language since Alsace has been incorporated into a mostly francophone eastern megaregion that has little interest to spend money on the promotion of some 'backwards' regional language or even the foresight to encourage a second language that is not English.

Anyway, the discouragement of regional languages is not only a problem in France, as others have noted. Next door in Switzerland, the regional patois like arpitan (a variety of franco-provençal, perhaps related to Occitan) were discouraged for a long time. Completely different to the approach adopted in Alemanic Switzerland.

My personal opinion: the desire to 'live together' starts on the local, not national level so more efforts are needed in that direction for a functional society and regional languages help.

VK538FY··on Is the iconic Parisian bistro dying?
This is an interesting question because there are significantly different national attitudes towards spending on food, I see it every day.

For example, https://www.vox.com/2014/7/6/5874499/map-heres-how-much-ever...

Attention, such statistics don't answer all the questions though. Does the average person in country X spend more than in country Y because he wants to spend more, or because food is simply more expensive? That and many other questions. But I take it as a pretty clear sign that there are simply different cultural attitudes towards this spending when I compare the average supermarket in three neighbouring countries like France, Germany, and Switzerland.

VK538FY··on Is the iconic Parisian bistro dying?
I'll check the book. I'm relatively interested in health insurance and the financing thereof because I haven't quite identified the system that works the best and even the most successful countries need to tighten their game given the imminent demographic challenges.

As to bistros, well I've been to a hundred different restaurants in Paris, they don't all have 'bistro' written on the window but I'm sure that some were. For the money that I was willing to spend at the time, nothing stood out so much. The Bouillon Chartier was great since I'm a fan of the Lyon-style bouchon and I find them comparable. Generally, I wouldn't go to Paris for affordable and good food. I'm not particularly looking for innovation either, just some intelligence in the menu and ingredients.

VK538FY··on Is the iconic Parisian bistro dying?
Good explanation and I've read a number of articles about private health insurance under this angle. It's not an imaginary phenomenon.

I'm curious to know if a study has been done about the similar effects of restaurant tickets. The idea seems quite plausible, would go a long way towards explaining the doubtful quality of many parisian restaurants and, anecdotally, I remember a lot of use of restaurant tickets and incentives based on them when I was in the city of lights.

VK538FY··on Is the iconic Parisian bistro dying?
I understand the parent's idea. An employer gives his employees Tickets Resto. It's a 'social advantage' that may cost the employer less than simply paying the employees more because exempt from certain social charges. As a result, there are more of these scriptural Tickets Resto floating about than real money that people want to spend on restaurant meals. Which could lead to an inflation of restaurant prices in a fashion not so different to the inflation of the prices of medical prestations paid by private insurance.
VK538FY··on Is the iconic Parisian bistro dying?
This thread 'triggered' me and I must say that you have identified what is in my opinion the problem: natural human greed and the increasing cost of rent in touristic cities flooded by low cost travel.

I experienced something similar as a (francophone) tourist in Venice recently. Seafood pasta with a total of one chopped prawn and one chopped scallop, really? 'Italian receipe!' cries the Venisian waiter. But mass tourism wants cheap and it wants fast. I'm sure that the locals would have been ashamed.

As a further anecdote, I didn't repeat my mistake and the next day went to a restaurant recommended by the Michelin guide (instead of by the colleague of nationality X who recommended the first), paid marginally more for a truly inspired menu and stellar service. And across us sat a table of tourists of nationality Y who frankly would have been better served in the first restaurant.

← PreviousPage 5 of 5