HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

VengefulCynic

832 karma · joined July 5, 2010

Embedded real-time operating systems. And stuff.
submissionscomments
VengefulCynic··on YouTube Flags Democrats’ Convention Video on Copyright Grounds
The worst part of this and the Ustream debacle (http://hackerne.ws/item?id=4471213) is that many of the takedowns on major video-streaming services to date have been entirely voluntary. You can only imagine what would happen if the government gave the MPAA/RIAA a bigger stick (i.e. SOPA and/or PIPA) than the business deals that they're currently leveraging for this sort of thing.
VengefulCynic··on Apple Never Invented Anything
Whenever I'm using "enterprise" software or some equally-awful tool that's sold using a feature checklist, I can't help but think about Steve Jobs's line about how innovation is saying no to 1000 things.

edit: Well, a feature checklist and $50,000 worth of sales dinners, games of golf and "gifts that do not violate the professional ethics rules of the company buying said tool."

VengefulCynic··on Please learn to write
Communication skill is a proxy for critical thinking skill - if you can't communicate effectively, your critical thinking skill is either going to be undervalued or underutilized.

For the lack of understanding, communication inputs are misinterpreted, ignored or incorrectly responded to. For the lack of clarity, precision and understandability, communication outputs suffer the same fate. And, as we've learned in networking, inefficiencies in a system (such as the engineer whose emails make no sense, when he/she bothers to reply at all) get routed around.

VengefulCynic··on Google share split is naked power grab
They're essentially reducing the value of the shares of stock. Each share of Google stock has a value as a portion of the overall company and also includes the right to vote in board elections and exercise voting rights on any measure put to shareholders.

To simplify, let's say I own 10% of Google, what this stock split does is leave me with a 10% ownership stake in Google, but only in possession of 5% of the voting rights in a board election - effectively taking away half of my oversight of the company by fiat.

VengefulCynic··on Dear DoJ: You Need To Sue Apple Again
Anti-competitive behavior doesn't become a violation of US law until it involves the abuse of a monopoly position, involves market collusion, or breaks some other law. While anti-competitive, Apple doesn't currently exercise a meaningful monopoly in mobile device operating systems: either one looks at handsets where they are actually not even the market leader or one looks at tablets which is hardly a developed market.

Apple's actions with regard to the Agency Model aren't prosecutable because of any Apple monopoly but because it involves market collusion. Now, if Google and Apple colluded to prevent eBooks from being sold on mobile OS marketplaces without a 30% cut, THAT would be prosecutable.

VengefulCynic··on Yahoo announces 2,000 job cuts
There are essentially two kinds of layoffs: "We're getting rid of Division X and everyone in it" and "We need to reduce expenses and so we're laying off people." In this case, it sounds like a little bit of each.

There are entire companies dedicated to executing (pardon the pun) layoffs "correctly" and there are as many ways to do it as there are managers, but they essentially fall into three categories: cost-based (get rid of the most cost), skills-based (get rid of the people who don't have skill X that we totally need) and performance-based (get rid of the people who suck). Most of what you're talking about sounds cost-based, in which case there's two philosophies: get rid of the most senior people who charge the most (hello, age discrimination lawsuits) and get rid of a lot of junior people whose productivity is lower and expect the senior people to pick up the slack.

And yes, I have had the privilege of working in a Fortune 500 company and helping put together a layoff list - worst job of my life.

VengefulCynic··on Android Economics
While they certainly have incentive to downplay revenue for the purposes of paying Oracle, let's not forget that all of the contributing revenue factors would be legally discoverable. I think that we can assume that the numbers contributed in court reflect the revenue fairly accurately - Fortune 500 companies tend to have lawyers whose degrees don't come in specially-marked boxes of cereal. Also, Google has a lot of very good incentives to state their revenue exactly as is legally relevant (albeit, not a penny more, in this case).
VengefulCynic··on Why I Tearfully Deleted My Pinterest Inspiration Boards
This is one of those areas where the legalese proclaims that the emperor has clothes and all of the marketing copy indicates otherwise. The article's follow-up clearly shows that the Pinterest founder is aware of the conflict, and it's clear that we're at a watershed moment in terms of the legal outcomes.

To my mind, the real question is whether Pinterest pivots like Youtube did and turns into a service where at least a sizable percentage of the usage doesn't violate existing copyright laws or whether it goes the direction of Napster and the lawyers get to it. I wish Ben Silberman all the best... I just don't see a lot of success stories in our space once the lawyers show up.

Edit: Obviously existing copyright law sucks - very few people on HN disagree on that point. My interest is in seeing startups succeed within the context of existing copyright law as I fear it won't be changing for the good any time soon.

VengefulCynic··on California Proposes Rules For Autonomous Cars
I would really love this if it creates a minimally-invasive legal framework to enable innovation and curb nonsense like pedestrians jumping in front of cars and trying to sue the manufacturer when they get hit (hopefully while providing a mechanism where manufacturers can indemnify their vehicles without too much liability danger in such cases).

On the other hand, I have to say that I don't exactly have the greatest level of faith in the California Assembly based on past performance. Here's hoping they buck the trend and establish a framework to encourage rather than inhibit innovation.

VengefulCynic··on Learning from competition
Marco goes to some length in the most recent episode of his podcast Build & Analyze (http://5by5.tv/buildanalyze/67) to grapple with the reality of Readability as (to his mind) his first competitor with a design ethos that seems to be in direct competition with his own. It's fascinating stuff, especially from the perspective of a developer with relatively little formal background in design.
VengefulCynic··on Frequent, Intense Mature and Suggestive Themes
Uneven enforcement and a lack of transparency are (to my mind) the two leading causes of a perception of unfairness. If Apple is going to continue with a relatively low level of transparency (which seems to be almost a given, considering its corporate culture to date), it is even more beholden than most to try to stamp out uneven enforcement.
VengefulCynic··on Overrated: Bully's R Rating Should Mean the End of the MPAA
"Doesn't make sense since this assumes that all teenagers speak like the 'bullies' depicted in the film."

The only thing materially communicated by this R rating is that someone says "fuck" more than once in the movie. To call that speaking like a bully is incredibly reductive to the point of turning your argument into a straw man.

VengefulCynic··on Anger for Path after Privacy Breach: So Many Apologies, So Much Data Mining
I'm confused as to how Apple's lack of regard for the privacy of its users is a story, but Path's lack of regard for the privacy of those same users is a non-issue. One of the parties failed to protect the users' data, another one of them took it without asking. Both should be held to account in my mind
VengefulCynic··on Car Dealers Wince at a Site to End Sales Haggling
While I agree with you that the change brought on by progress can be very damaging to the elements of a society that have been made redundant, I think you have to step back and take a look at the big picture.

As I see it, when you are presented with a change that adds efficiency to an area of the economy (and thus reduces the amount of labor required to get to the same level of output), you've got a choice to make. Either you can attempt to maintain the inefficiency (in this case, redundant car salesmen) in order to keep those workers in a job or you can attack the root of the problem and put those workers to work doing something that adds value to the economy.

I'm not saying that there aren't moral and ethical arguments in trying to keep a job for those workers, because there, especially from a societal standpoint. But from an economic standpoint, maintaining those inefficiencies typically leads to systemized exploitation of artificial inefficiencies (case in point: smuggling to bypass protectionist tariffs) and that wastes additional effort that could be adding value to the economy.

VengefulCynic··on Car Dealers Wince at a Site to End Sales Haggling
The real interesting point in all of this to me is how hard it is to innovate in this space on account of state legislatures essentially subsidizing car dealerships.

"So, after several dealers’ associations complained that TrueCar was violating various laws, regulators from several states told TrueCar that they questioned the site’s business practices. Honda Motor Company also protested loudly, threatening to cut off marketing dollars to dealers that did not follow its guidelines when promoting its brands on TrueCar’s site."

While I know that there are a lot of people employed by local dealerships in the sales department, I can't help but thinking that a lot of these jobs essentially add a percentage cost to new cars with no value added. Which, of course, means that since innovation is a threat to these old business models, most of these dealerships will only be doubling down on legislation and protectionist policies that stop or slow genuine innovators like the guys at CarWoo and TrueCar.

VengefulCynic··on With 8.7% market share, Apple has 75% of cell phone profits
As of Q1 2010, Apple uses reporting that accounts for the revenues and profits of phones in the quarter that they're received. (http://investor.apple.com/financials.cfm - the Form 10-K/A explains the changes on accounting principles on the Form 10-K from how they used to be (amortized over 8 quarters) and how they are now (all reported in the quarter where they're received.))
VengefulCynic··on Why Android isn't gaining on Apple in the Enterprise
I've often heard it said that (nearly every time Apple in the Enterprise comes up) the conventional wisdom is that Apple doesn't experience larger gains in the enterprise because of the culture of secrecy whereby it doesn't give advance information to large corporate buyers any more than it does to the average consumer. It's something of a surprise to me that this wasn't mentioned in this article.

Doubly so because a number of the other vendors of Android devices (Samsung, Sony, LG, ASUS) have a much more favorable history on releasing information about upcoming products so that enterprise support can be ready for them. Also, a lack of that culture of secrecy would seem to be more favorable for sharing more technical information up-front for deeper integration with corporate partners. Whereas I don't get the impression that Apple really views any enterprise customer as a partner, but rather as another customer.

VengefulCynic··on [dead]
While I agree that this is slightly cynical, you're approaching this as though it's also exploitative and one-sided. If you're a good tipper and frequent diner, there's a strong financial benefit to the employee and it turns into a mutually-beneficial business relationship.

If not, then you're an obviously-manipulative asshole who tips poorly. A regular who's transparently manipulative and a poor tipper has a good chance that someone on the other side of the relationship with a similarly exploitative value system will find a way to settle the score.

VengefulCynic··on Stop using AdBlock
A couple of years ago, I remember Ars Technica ran an experiment for a day or so when they blocked end users who run Ad Blocker. (http://arstechnica.com/business/news/2010/03/why-ad-blocking...)

I recall it generated a lot of negative feedback, but at the same time, I'm surprised it hasn't been copied more widely: If you're the kind of person who's willing to use Ad Block on a site that's providing content financed solely by advertising, I would imagine you're also the kind of "customer" that at least some of those sites would prefer not to have.

VengefulCynic··on Developer: “Losing Control of Our Destiny to Apple”
To my mind, the far more concerning part of this is that Apple isn't even ready for sandboxing. As Jalkut says, "the only things we know now that we didn’t know [at WWDC] is that there are some sandbox entitlements that exist in the shipping OS X Lion that we know are available to us."

Apple was going to require sandboxing at the beginning of November, even as the entitlements system that would power it isn't even ready to support it (which is, to my mind, the real reason that they pushed the deadline out by several months).

If I have a beef with Apple, it isn't that they're taking my control away, it's that they're demanding that I sandbox my app without implementing the controls to make it work outside of the most basic apps.

VengefulCynic··on Teachers write their own online textbook, save district $175,000
Have you ever been party to textbook adoption time? The textbook companies are buying dinners and drinks for the teachers, "conferences" for the department chairs and offers of all manner of paid amenities for the school district.

Obviously, with a pricing model that can afford sales costs like that and a price tag like $175,000 for district-wide adoption of a single textbook, the industry is ripe for disruption. At the same time, the industry probably has lobbyists poised to protect their model with "think of the children."

I know that my wife (who has been through several of these textbook adoption periods) is frustrated beyond belief based on the cost/benefit ratio of these textbooks as opposed to what the district could probably pay its teachers to produce themselves. I can only imagine that if this sort of thing spreads beyond a negligible percentage of schools making their own texts, the textbook makers will probably become more actively involved in stopping it.

VengefulCynic··on Why Hulu’s Owners Couldn’t Find A Buyer
The most puzzling part of this to me is that the content studios honestly thought it would work.

"We're going to sell you a company with assets which vanish in two years, after which time, you have a company with no assets and the right to negotiate for the right to use of the aforementioned assets at a price to be determined by us."

Yahoo may exhibit tremendous inability to derive value from acquisitions, but not even they were willing to take this time bomb.

VengefulCynic··on The Unfamiliar (Objective-C & Cocoa)
I'm largely in agreement with Gruber insofar as development environments are largely a matter of taste.

On the other hand, I'm rather surprised that Gruber is looking to defend reference counting, especially in light of how well it went for legacy programming languages like VB Classic.

John Siracusa is by far the more well-reasoned Apple advocate in terms of programming language design and his Copland 2010 articles are definitely worth checking out if you want to read a cogent argument as to why Cocoa is NOT the way of the future. http://arstechnica.com/apple/news/2010/06/copland-2010-revis...

VengefulCynic··on China state paper urges Internet rethink to gag foes
Actually, the argument from the reactionaries in the article is very much aware that it's hard to go back and add censorship after services launch. Their argument is that before allowing any services to launch, censorship tools and suppression capabilities need to be already in place.
VengefulCynic··on A Simple Explanation for Why HP Abandoned Palm
Have you been to Autonomy's website? Seriously... go have a look... have a look at the 'Introduction to Autonomy' page: http://www.autonomy.com/content/Autonomy/introduction/index....

"Organizations already benefiting from Autonomy technology include Avis, BAE Systems, BBC, BMW, Coca-Cola, CNN, Ericsson, Fiat, Financial Times, GlaxoSmithKline, Isabel Healthcare, KPMG, Linklaters, Lloyds TSB, NASA, Nestle, Oracle, Philips, Safeway, Schneider Electric, Shell, T-Mobile, The European Commission, The U.K. Houses of Parliament, The U.S. Department of Homeland Security and The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission."

If Autonomy isn't enterprise software on the order of SAP (if not exactly the same business), they sure write confusing marketing copy.

VengefulCynic··on Own Your Identity
And, as discussed in his podcast - Build and Analyze http://5by5.tv/buildanalyze/18 (ep. 18), this has nothing to do with Marco developing a sudden aversion to Tumblr and everything to do with his desire to be able to roll his own CMS as he has been doing since far before that CMS turned into Tumblr.
VengefulCynic··on Inspired by XKCD:903, Wikipedia steps to philosophy
The current version appears to dislike unicode characters.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Petar_Dobrovi%C4%87 causes an error.

VengefulCynic··on Apple’s iOS 4 hardware encryption has been cracked
It would seem that this "crack" could simply be circumvented by using an alphanumeric password and/or setting the iPhone to shred its crypto key after 10 consecutive password failures. Obviously, neither of these are standard features, but both are available.
VengefulCynic··on Full text: Apple Legal's letter to Lodsys
Hardly. Apple isn't claiming the patents are invalid or that software patents in general are invalid - they're simply claiming that Lodsys is trying to get iOS app developers to pay for something that Apple has already bought (and been given rights to license to the iOS developers).
VengefulCynic··on The Politician and the Engineer: Why Managers Hate Themselves
I should note that this is a discussion of engineering managers: I'm pretty sure that if you're the manager of a field that doesn't traditionally involve critical thinking, relatively little of this would apply.
← PreviousPage 2 of 4Next →