HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

WgaqPdNr7PGLGVW

137 karma · joined June 24, 2024

submissionscomments
WgaqPdNr7PGLGVW··on "Normal" engineers are the key to great teams
> You think Google has 5,000 people working on novel design spaces?

Yes.

Maintaining a bridge is in general not novel. There are clearly established best practices that have stood the test of time.

Maintaining a ridiculous tangle of millions of lines of code is novel. There are no best practices on par with other engineering fields. We are at the stage of rough heuristics in most parts of software dev.

One day there will be broad and consistent over time agreement on how to handle large software projects. But we aren't there yet.

WgaqPdNr7PGLGVW··on “Normal” engineers are the key to great teams
If this were true then software engineering jobs would have all already been offshored.

Software is much closer to a competitive race where small improvements in ability give completely outsized returns.

WgaqPdNr7PGLGVW··on “Normal” engineers are the key to great teams
> I like this article particularly because I think the trope that there's something unique and different about software engineering is pretty toxic

The ratio of software engineers working in novel design spaces compared to plumbing style work is best guess ~1:5.

The ratio in more mature fields like civil engineering is closer to ~1:500.

There are lots of similarities between software engineers and the few folk in civil etc doing actual novel design work.

> Nothing that we do is so unique that another competent engineer shouldn't be able to fill in for you when you are having an off day.

In novel design spaces people are not fungible.

WgaqPdNr7PGLGVW··on TSMC expected to announce $100B investment in U.S.
> would have both required Ukraine to almost entirely disarm and also allow Russia to veto any future military partnerships Ukraine might have including non-NATO ones.

Ukraine now faces almost total destruction because they didn't take the deal.

It should be a clear lesson to other countries - don't be belligerent with your much stronger neighbors.

The US and Europe getting involved simply increased the death and destruction.

I'm not saying it is fair or right or just. It simply is.

WgaqPdNr7PGLGVW··on What's happening inside the NIH and NSF
> I live a 5-minute bike ride away from the Delft Technopolis, and 20 minutes by train to Leiden's Bio Science Park.

Where you live is comparable to somewhere like Raleigh and not comparable at all to NYC/SF.

There is a saying that Europe is better if you are poor and the US is better if you are rich or middle class. I think that is broadly speaking true.

Of course European countries don't allow poor Americans to migrate so the only people who would be better off aren't allowed to move.

WgaqPdNr7PGLGVW··on What's happening inside the NIH and NSF
Most people in mainland Europe are poor by American middle-class standards.
WgaqPdNr7PGLGVW··on What's happening inside the NIH and NSF
> Maybe they think politicizing the whole executive branch is a little distasteful

They believe it has already been politicized by people who hate them.

WgaqPdNr7PGLGVW··on Salesforce will hire no more software engineers in 2025, says Marc Benioff
> Is that just how CRM systems are? Is everybody just doing it wrong? What's the deal?

These kinds of tools cover 80% of what you want to do out-of-the-box.

For the remaining 20% to build it correctly you need to either hire expensive consultants or hire in-house staff to build.

Nobody budgets properly for this, and it isn't in the sales pitch, and so that last 20% is built as horrible spaghetti code by the cheapest possible devs / consultants.

Even if you wanted to pay good salaries and hire people in-house how many great engineers want to be limited to programming in Apex on salesforce?

WgaqPdNr7PGLGVW··on Salesforce will hire no more software engineers in 2025, says Marc Benioff
> in order to catch up in other parts of the business or figure out what markets to put your new productivity toward.

Product can come up with and design features an order of magnitude faster than developers can implement them.

In practice established products have deep backlogs full of bugs and features that never get actioned.

WgaqPdNr7PGLGVW··on There's No Such Thing as Software Productivity (2012)
> I don't think anyone can get numbers, but partial ordering is much easier.

Agreed.

> If Steve and Susan are in different part of organization, the answer is "cannot compare". If they are doing different job, the answer is the same.

These are the situations where we would get the most value from the metrics though.

The team level already has an Engineering Manager or Tech Lead who can directly deal with team level problems.

WgaqPdNr7PGLGVW··on There's No Such Thing as Software Productivity (2012)
> This is moving goalposts.

Then I shall move the goalposts. Can you address my shifted goalpost?

I personally did not interpret the author as literally meaning there is no such thing as software productivity but I agree the way he wrote it was confusing and could be interpreted that way.

Even in his toy example he clearly stated Peter did a better job than Frank.

WgaqPdNr7PGLGVW··on There's No Such Thing as Software Productivity (2012)
> I just don't seem to struggle, as others claim to, in measuring productivity.

Because you are measuring at a very broad and basic level.

Steve is more productive than Susan.

Great. How much more productive? Can you turn it into a number?

Can you still do it consistently when Steve and Susan are in different teams in different parts of the organisation trying to achieve different goals?

I've done DB upgrades that took 10 minutes and I've done DB upgrades that took 3-4 months. What changed was not my productivity but the nature of the problem. Yet from the outside they were both just DB upgrades.

If Susan had done the DB upgrade in 12 weeks could we confidently claim that Steve could have done it in 11 weeks? Steve hasn't even done a DB upgrade since he joined the company. Perhaps Steve could have done it in 10 minutes?

WgaqPdNr7PGLGVW··on There's No Such Thing as Software Productivity (2012)
> Don't you think that giving up after n=1 attempts at measuring software productivity might be a tad too fast to draw a generalized claim of impossibility?

Software developers should look at anyone claiming they can measure software productivity as a snake oil salesman.

We have seen hundreds of attempts over the years and they have all "failed". More accurately they all have large error bars and biases.

Researchers can and should continue looking into how to measure software development productivity. It is likely over the next few decades we will start to understand how to measure it appropriately.

WgaqPdNr7PGLGVW··on U.S. math scores drop on major international test
So how do you stop this from happening?

The OP pointed out a highly informative and important point and the majority of the negative responses to it have been from people who want to bash the American education system.

They are using cries of racism and bringing in irrelevant topics like IQ intentionally so that they can shut down legitimate conversation because they want to continue to bash the American education system.

WgaqPdNr7PGLGVW··on California's most neglected group of students: the gifted ones
That is not true either.

There is very little innovation happening in European countries where college is low/no-cost.

They have less innovation than the US does despite our terrible college debt.

It takes a certain kind of person to innovate and they make up a small % of the overall population.

Measures aimed at helping the general population are very unlikely to help them.

WgaqPdNr7PGLGVW··on California's most neglected group of students: the gifted ones
Completely incorrect.

We have made incredible improvements in alleviating poverty and suffering over the past 50 years and yet innovation across almost all fields has slowed to a crawl.

WgaqPdNr7PGLGVW··on The AI reporter that took my old job just got fired
Can current techniques be scaled/improved/optimized to do this or do we need new techniques?

It took 30 years in the generative art world to move from cave paintings to the level that we have today because we needed new techniques.

For podcasts we are at the cave paintings level.

If we can get to professional level quality podcasts with the current techniques then we might only be a few years away.

I think it is more likely we will need new techniques which puts us potentially decades away.

If we look at LLMs the improvements over the last 18+ months since gpt4 was released have been minor despite incredible levels of investment.

WgaqPdNr7PGLGVW··on The AI reporter that took my old job just got fired
> Give it time. Progress is fast.

Why pick 2020 as your starting point? That is simply around the time the current set of techniques came about.

We had generative art back in the late 90's - my screensaver has been generative art for over 20 years now.

Obviously generative art has come a long way but people have been working on various approaches to it for at least 30 years.

WgaqPdNr7PGLGVW··on A counter-intuitive guide to better leadership
> Honestly, you're trying to claim that intuition is the foundation, when it's almost as bad as blind luck.

Why do you think this?

WgaqPdNr7PGLGVW··on A counter-intuitive guide to better leadership
You misunderstand.

I'm saying intuition in a complex space we don't understand is less reliable than intuition in a simple well understood space.

Recognising that someone is angry is simpler than discovering how gravity works.

Science has a high failure rate and scientists heavily lean on their intuition.

This does not imply that it is intuition that causes the high failure rate.

WgaqPdNr7PGLGVW··on A counter-intuitive guide to better leadership
I suspect the scientists intuition is less reliable because the scientists are acting at the limits of our understanding. Even then it is still a critical component.

For those of us writing glue code to connect services for the 100th time or a manager dealing with our 20th PIP is our intuition likely to be as faulty?

WgaqPdNr7PGLGVW··on A counter-intuitive guide to better leadership
> Entire science is basically testimony of how our intuition lead us astray and why we need to be disciplined about looking at data, evidence and crafting experiments.

This is not really the case. If you look into how a lot of great science is done it often starts with intuition followed by testing / experimenting in order to validate.

WgaqPdNr7PGLGVW··on A counter-intuitive guide to better leadership
> Your gut feelings want you to slam down McDonalds cheeseburgers one after another, day after day.

Are we talking about the same thing here? When the article is talking about gut feelings it is referring to intuition.

Your intuition is probably telling you eating McDonalds cheeseburgers day after day is a mistake even while the scales are telling you it is fine.

WgaqPdNr7PGLGVW··on A counter-intuitive guide to better leadership
> My gut tells me to do stupid shit all the time

Does it? Can you provide some examples?

My intuition rarely lets me down. Perhaps you don't have enough experience in the areas where you are trying to listen to your gut?

I'm sure if I was trying to apply my intuition to an area I didn't understand at all it would let me down.

That is different from listening to my intuition in a field I have been working in for almost two decades.

WgaqPdNr7PGLGVW··on Trump wins presidency for second time
> Otherwise, immigrants are generally taking jobs that Americans won't do.

Because the pay is terrible. Start paying well and plenty of Americans will want the jobs.

Working a low skilled job like fast food should be enough to pay for college so that it is possible to lift yourself up out of poverty.

We have created a two tier system and the educated class just makes excuses about why the system has to work the way it does today.

WgaqPdNr7PGLGVW··on GitHub cuts AI deals with Google, Anthropic
Yeah. You can fit a lot of business logic into a 100kloc monolith written by skilled developers.

Once you start shifting it to micro services the business logic gets spread out and duplicated.

At the same time each micro-service now has its own code to handle rest, graphql, grpc endpoints.

And each downstream call needs error handling and retry logic.

And of course now you need distributed tracing.

And of course now your auth becomes much more complex.

And of course now each service might be called multiple times for the one request - better make them idempotent.

And each service will drift in terms of underlying libraries.

And so on.

Now we have been adding in LLM solutions so there is no consistency in any of the above services.

Each dev rather than look at the existing approaches instead asks Claude and it provides a slightly different way each time - often pulling in additional libraries we have to support.

These days I see so much bad code like a single microservice with 3 different approaches to making a http request.

WgaqPdNr7PGLGVW··on Ask HN: How can tech help with mental health?
In general tech is extremely bad for mental health.

The best advice I have for people is to minimize computer use and get a dumb phone.

WgaqPdNr7PGLGVW··on GitHub cuts AI deals with Google, Anthropic
I suspect it will go a different direction.

Codebases are exploding in size. Feature development has slowed down.

What might have been a carefully designed 100kloc codebase in 2018 is now a 500kloc ball of mud in 2024.

Companies need many more developers to complete a decent sized feature than they needed in 2018.

WgaqPdNr7PGLGVW··on GitHub cuts AI deals with Google, Anthropic
Yeah there is a big disconnect between the devs caught up in the hype and the devs who aren't.

A lot of the devs in my office using Claude/gpt are convinced they are so much more productive but they aren't actually producing features or bug fixes any faster.

I think they are just excited about a novel new way to write code.

WgaqPdNr7PGLGVW··on Ask HN: Learning to interact correctly in online communities as a neurodivergent
> In online communities, honest curiosity is often punished

Because "honest curiosity" is so often used as a DDoS vector.

This is not the case in real life when people know you and there is real investment in the relationship.

> rational - means to convince the opposing party.

Most people are not convinced by rational argument. Aristotle covered this more than 2000 years ago and human nature has not changed.

Page 1 of 2Next →