HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

WoodenChair

8,915 karma · joined August 31, 2013

- https://davekopec.com

- https://classicproblems.com

- https://computersciencefromscratch.com

- https://x.com/davekopec

- https://github.com/davecom

I'm a computer science professor at a teaching college with a background in software development. I also build indie apps, have a few entrepreneurial ventures, write technical books, and co-host the podcast Business Books & Co. My latest programming book is "Computer Science from Scratch: Building Interpreters, Art, Emulators and ML in Python" with No Starch Press:

https://nostarch.com/computer-science-from-scratch

If you want to find out about my upcoming book, media, or software projects then join my very low volume newsletter:

https://buttondown.email/kopec

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

submissionscomments
WoodenChair··on After 10 years, Yelp gave my app 4 days
It's just not worth working with a partner that will shut you off at 4-days notice.

In addition though, they shared the following pricing deck with me: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1Cb_8laDpxZdfwJPtYBmibZgvLZ8...

Which seems to indicate a base price of $229 per month. I have no idea why that doesn't line up with the pricing on their website. But the fact that they shared it with me indicated to me that my use case fell under some kind of "enterprise" usage. Regardless, I would not continue to work with them after 4-days notice and the threatening email. It's too small and app for it to be worth it to me.

I did ask in one of my emails about the pricing discrepancy and got no reply.

WoodenChair··on After 10 years, Yelp gave my app 4 days
Absolutely. You wrote it better than I did myself in the original post.
WoodenChair··on After 10 years, Yelp gave my app 4 days
The gist I got from my communications with them 10 years ago was that they were encouraging me to finish it.

I agree with you there was no expectation of it being free forever. I never said there was. What was unreasonable was the 4-days notice that it was coming to an end. That's just not enough time.

WoodenChair··on After 10 years, Yelp gave my app 4 days
Not only would that violate their terms of service, but the monetary stakes are also too low for it to be worth it to me even if it didn't.
WoodenChair··on After 10 years, Yelp gave my app 4 days
> It sounds like the monetary stakes are pretty small, but depending on the author's desire, it might be worth doing some research and potentially going to small claims court and claiming damages for those customers that requested refunds.

Yes, the monetary stakes are too small for it to be worth it for me to pursue. I could probably dig up some old emails from 10+ years ago but it just wouldn't be worth it. Exposing this kind of bad behavior (4-days notice!) is enough.

WoodenChair··on After 10 years, Yelp gave my app 4 days
That's fair, but you'd think their admin interface would show how long an app had been active for and any notes about the app from the beginning.

Regardless, even if it had been active for 10 months not 10 years, 4-days notice is unacceptable.

WoodenChair··on After 10 years, Yelp gave my app 4 days
I guess you didn't read my blog post because I addressed everything you wrote. The issue is not that it went paid, it's the 4-days notice. They are perfectly in their right to start charging for their API, they just can't give us 4-days notice.

Well they can do whatever timeframe they want of course. And I can write about how rude it is. 4-days (really 1-business day in the original email Friday->Monday) is not a reasonable timeframe within which to threaten to cutoff an app with real users.

WoodenChair··on After 10 years, Yelp gave my app 4 days
I would be surprised if it were much more than a database lookup.
WoodenChair··on After 10 years, Yelp gave my app 4 days
Sorry to hear that. What was your product?
WoodenChair··on After 10 years, Yelp gave my app 4 days
To be fair there wasn’t much scale. We’re talking about an app that sold 467 copies over its 10 year span. But it was an app I really liked, the people who paid for it really liked, and just drove traffic to Yelp, so they should’ve liked too. It was also a nice portfolio piece for me.
WoodenChair··on After 10 years, Yelp gave my app 4 days
Well the thing is they gave me 25000 per day, but the actual use was less than 100. The 25000 number is almost a red herring to the rest of the story.

It’s understandable they went to paid. What’s not understandable is the 4 days notice and tone of the email.

WoodenChair··on Ask HN: Is there any software you only made for your own use but nobody else?
Yes, I run a daily hyper-local email newsletter that is custom built. It's called BTV Daily: https://btvdaily.com

I wrote the newsletter generator in Python. It uses all kinds of different APIs (news, social media, MailChimp, scraping, weather, even some LLM for summarizing some of the news, etc.). It runs every day at 8 AM on a little server.

It's not a super long script, but I've changed and refined it over the years many times. It's like I've spent many dozens of hours editing the same <1000 lines of code as I've modified, removed, and added features to the newsletter.

WoodenChair··on Intel's bad year worsens, with analyst decrying company as 'profoundly broken'
This is a 2 month old article; the company has had significant progress since then and the specific price information is no longer as relevant.
WoodenChair··on Graham Essays: Full Collection of PG Essays in ePub, PDF and Markdowng
Is this done with permission from Graham? What's the license?
WoodenChair··on The economics of writing technical books
> If you look at Google's documentation of Android now, you don't need to supplement it.

Which speaks to the lack of need for books in certain elements of the Android market, but not to technical publishing more generally.

WoodenChair··on The economics of writing technical books
I took the liberty of looking up your books from your Hacker News profile. Perhaps they are not all listed there, but the most recent one you listed I think is on a much more niche topic ("Enterprise Android" as opposed to say your prior title "Programming Android") than the prior ones. Even if it's a better book, that won't outweigh that there's just a much smaller audience.

Personally, I think my first book, 10 years ago, was my best book but it sold much worse than my later books because the topic was too niche.

Also, there are many, many more programmers now than there were before. Maybe they don't read books as much as their predecessors did, but to say Stack Overflow and open source platforms killed technical book publishing is highly inaccurate. I honestly think you're projecting a "you" situation to talk about the whole market. Please don't take that as an attack, but just as an additional perspective.

WoodenChair··on The economics of writing technical books
I've had four technical books published and I've finished writing my fifth which I'm in the midst of negotiation with publishers about distributing.

I've seen many similar articles to this one before, but I want to complement the author by saying that this one rings the most true and is the most comprehensive of all of them.

However, I want to emphasize a paragraph from his article, that I think needs more emphasis:

> I heard from publishers that 10k copies sold is considered a success, and the publisher may ask you to write another one. According to this blog, 96% of books (mostly fiction) sell less than 5000 copies per year. For technical books, it may be worse.

I've heard that 10k number before. I've also been told by one of my publishers that 2k copies is the break even point for them. While I've had the fortune of three out of four of my prior books selling more than 2k copies (and one selling many, many more), it seems that a significant number of traditionally published programming books do not. And I'm sure that ratio is even worse for self-published books.

In fact, I think the "Reality Check" section of the article is not harsh enough. The author cherry-picked some data on very well selling technical books, which doesn't make the point well. The reality is simple: the vast, vast majority of programming books do not sell "well" (let's consider "well" 10,000 copies) and many don't even break the 2,000 copy barrier, even from traditional publishers.

So, what are the economics of technical book writing? Not good. And it's only going to get worse as the market gets flooded with LLM-generated garbage.

So, do it because you really want to do it for another reason (career, teaching, etc.). Not to make money.

WoodenChair··on Atkinson Dithering (2021)
This was the article that inspired me to study the MacPaint format. I ended up writing first a Python program that can do Atkinson dithering of a modern image and then save it as a MacPaint file for display on a retro Mac. That code is a chapter in my upcoming book. I then added 9 more 1-bit dithering algorithms and turned it into a Swift/AppKit app so it's easy to use if you want to Atkinson dither your own images and transfer them over to your retro Macs:

https://apps.apple.com/us/app/retro-dither-b-w-is-beautiful/...

WoodenChair··on PyPy has been working for me for several years now
I actually think you're the one misunderstanding the quote:

"One of the not so secret goals of Armin Rigo, one of the PyPy founders, was to use PyPy together with some advanced partial evaluation magic sauce to somehow automatically generate a JIT compiler from the interpreter."

He is saying one of the founder's original goals was to automatically generate a JIT. It may not be the "main" goal but it is certainly one of the original goals per this quote.

WoodenChair··on How to copy a file from a 30-year-old laptop
They sorta did in the Apple world. Maybe not quite a standard, but quite common. Apple shipped several Macs with (optionally) built-in Zip drives in the late 1990s.
WoodenChair··on Lithium-free sodium batteries exit the lab and enter US production
What's the best way to invest in sodium batteries? Is there a publicly traded company that is helping Natron Energy bring this to market?
WoodenChair··on BASIC turns 60
There's a really good documentary on the creation of BASIC at Dartmouth (made by Dartmouth):

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WYPNjSoDrqw

If you don't want to watch the documentary, we did a shorter podcast episode about it:

https://pnc.st/s/kopec-explains-software/6d99d278/basic

WoodenChair··on The Internet Archive's last-ditch effort to save itself
> You don't consider it to be a right to revolt against tyranny?

Do you think not being able to download all the free stuff you want is tyranny?

"Tyranny" is defined as a "cruel and oppressive government or rule."

How are you being oppressed and/or treated cruelly?

You can think copyright terms are too long without the hyperbole.

WoodenChair··on A brief history of web development, and why your framework doesn't matter
In 2014 I wrote a "History of Web Programming" that's a good accompaniment to this article since it goes into some more detail on some of the older technologies:

https://www.observationalhazard.com/2018/06/history-of-web-p...

WoodenChair··on Bloomberg: "Strong possibility" of M4 debuting on May 7 with new iPad Pro
> Unless Mark Gurman has a record of making reliable predictions about Apple, I wouldn't give this much credence.

He does have a great record.

WoodenChair··on Stop Acting Like You're Famous
It’s true you’re not famous. But the rest of this is pretty bad advice. If you’re an indie app developer and you don’t care about design, nobody will use your app—not just the people who care about design. If you’re a blogger and you don’t care about grammar, some people will be turned off by your terrible writing. I assume anything you do you want to do well. If that’s not the case then definitely take the advice in the original post.
WoodenChair··on I stumbled into a hobby business of building the ultimate Mac OS 9 machines
Full thread from X: I stumbled into a hobby business of building the ultimate Mac OS 9 machines for #RetroMac enthusiasts.

It started with my son...

I wanted him to have a classic Mac to play some of the great educational games that I grew up on. I considered various models—as a pseudo-collector, I had a bunch of classic '80s and '90s machines lying around, but I thought why not get the fastest PowerPC machine possible?

The issue is the last few years of PowerPC machines (2002-2006) boot only Mac OS X, not Mac OS 9. So I was thinking of a late '90s iMac, but then I stumbled upon something cool—a bunch of ROM hackers at https://macos9lives.com created a way for mid '00s Macs to boot Mac OS 9.

These machines came out after Mac OS 9 was discontinued so they're faster than anything that natively ran Mac OS 9. The most convenient to get due to space/shipping is a laptop or Mac mini G4. And they can be made even faster...

You can also upgrade them with an internal IDE to mSATA SSD adapter. So, you can basically put an SSD inside one.

There was only one model of PowerPC Mac mini (A1103) so you have to be careful which one you're buying. Make sure it has a Firewire port and only 2 USB ports.

So, I bought three of them that said they were untested on eBay. After getting one working, I decided to fix up/upgrade the same way the other two and try selling the upgraded ones on eBay.

I thought I was done then, but I saw a lot of 13 untested ones on eBay. Now that I knew the ins-and-outs of upgrading them so well I was like, well I could just keep doing this, so I bought the lot and another lot of 2 more.

So now I have 15 of them in my home. I'm cleaning and upgrading them one at a time. This is typically

- Clean

- Install SSD

- Install more RAM

- Put a new clock battery in

- Install Mac OS 9

Most of them don't come with power adapters so I'm now buying a bunch of parts in bulk:

- Power Adapters

- IDE to mSATA Adapters

- SSDs

- RAM sticks

- CR2032 clock batteries

- screws (yeah some are missing screws)

So far I'm not really making much money (pretty much breaking even) but it's kind of a fun hobby at this point and I think some people who need fast Mac OS 9 machines for their actual work (yes some people still use these for music production and print stuff) are benefitting.

Anyway, my latest one is up on eBay now if you want to bid: https://ebay.com/itm/126433161881

WoodenChair··on I stumbled into a hobby business of building the ultimate Mac OS 9 machines
Sure, I'll repost as a top-level comment.
WoodenChair··on I upgraded my iBook G4 to have an SSD
Sorry, I would've but it's already on eBay: https://www.ebay.com/itm/126406855301

That one I unfortunately broke the plastic on while upgrading (pictures of that on eBay too).

The 1.25 Ghz one (1.25 Ghz G4, 120 GB Kingston SSD, 1 GB RAM, new clock battery) which is intact I have not listed yet. Feel free to contact me through X, email, etc. which you can find in my hacker news profile if you want to make an offer to buy that one directly.

WoodenChair··on I upgraded my iBook G4 to have an SSD
Yes exactly and no Internet access.
← PreviousPage 6 of 34Next →