HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Wxc2jjJmST9XWWL

952 karma · joined August 12, 2020

submissionscomments
Wxc2jjJmST9XWWL··on Case Study: Why you should play Factorio
I tried to make a point, you might call it condescending, I think it's poignant. But I see what you mean. And that probably explains some people's misgivings with my comment.

Computer games are fine. I'm not playing these days, but I've played my fair share (by which I mean _a lot_). It's a perfectly valid use of one's time (not that I try to judge in any way, shape or form), but not as a supposed "virtue" for an individual that is struggling with procrastination.

If you are someone with a day job, active social life, and spend time playing computer games, there are certain games that will give you value, ideas, fun, intellectual stimulation. I'm not arguing against gaming, and for reading. Neither is a "fix" for procrastination. "Start reading a chapter a day in a book to fix procrastination", calling that nonsense is not arguing against the virtues of reading.

If you are someone procrastinating, not doing important tasks and not fulfilling your responsibilities, saying "play this game", as it will teach you to "overcome procrastination" and "how to be productive in real life", all of which is either directly stated or at least strongly implied in the article, then I strongly disagree, and even go so far as to consider the advise dangerous, and laughable.

For someone suffering from severe procrastination, to the point at where it has a strong negative impact on one's life, I think stress management, introspection, reaching out to people, meditation, forming healthy habits, in some cases even therapy, all of that is far better advise than "Play Factorio".

Wxc2jjJmST9XWWL··on Flu has disappeared worldwide during the Covid pandemic
The flu is global, yes? How many cities did your "deep cleaning" (I've heard it for the first time)? Out of a total of how many cities? I decline your notion on those grounds alone.
Wxc2jjJmST9XWWL··on Case Study: Why you should play Factorio
I'm pretty sure plenty of people addicted to MMORPGs don't forget leveling up their character, and going to the "ruins at 7 pm with their teamspeak party to raid for magic staff wand XYZ" ; to peddle the tool they use to procrastinate as a _cure_, because at least you're doing something diligently? Sorry, I am a nice person, but I am able to have strong opinions: This is nonsense.

The implication, that "procrastination" means "no due diligence" in anything is _WRONG_. It's due diligence in things that should take no priority as the very means to avoid the things you should be doing instead!

"Play Factorio, it has benefits for you that help you be productive" in response to someone dealing with procrastination? If that isn't absurd, I don't know what is.

Wxc2jjJmST9XWWL··on Case Study: Why you should play Factorio
The benefits of playing Factorio compared to? Compared to programming on your own project? Compared to reading something intellectually stimulating? Compared to working out or investing time to eat healthy and sleep properly? Compared to spending time with people you love? Compared to fulfilling your actual _responsibilities_?

> "If you’re in a slump (rut), chances are you feel like you can’t complete anything. You feel like you’re unable to finish anything so what’s the point of starting. Factorio is a great cure against that. Especially when you view it as a challenge."

"Why you should play Factorio" ; you absolutely can, it might have more benefits for you than other games, but besides that I really have trouble with such a headline, especially since the URL is called "deprocastination" (the home page sells an e-book, which promises to solve your problems and you can sign up via e-mail, not confidence inspiring). If you want to stop procrastinating, you probably should just delete Steam and get on with your tasks?

I'm not saying it's easy. There are things that can help: Meditation, proper task scheduling, talking to people about your problems, stress management techniques, in extreme cases therapy ...

"Play Factorio!" - Great advice /s

> "You can start taking the skills you learned and use them for anything else that is productive."

FAANG should look for new employees on World of Warcraft servers... /s

There is no technological cure to a spiritual problem. This is selling snake oil.

Edit1: interesting to see the up-/ and downvotes on this. I am not dissing gaming, not dissing the game. But recommending a computer game as a means to deal with procrastination and develop "real life skills you can use being productive" (paraphrased), that notion I do indeed find ludicrous and stand by it.

Edit2: From an answer I gave to a comment below (sorry for the edit, but I think I worded it in a nice way there):

The implication, that "procrastination" means "no due diligence" in anything is _WRONG_. It's due diligence in things that should take no priority as the very means to avoid the things you should be doing instead!

"Play Factorio, it has benefits for you that help you be productive" in response to someone dealing with procrastination? If that isn't absurd, I don't know what is.

Wxc2jjJmST9XWWL··on Apple is sued for telling you that you're “buying” movies
I've bought it on DVD years back, and still re-watch it somewhat regularly. Love that series... both of them (Yes, Minister and Yes, Prime Minister). That said, and as many echo again and again... for the technically skilled: piracy is an option. It's sad, but once you've exhausted a "reasonable" amount of effort to watch something legally, it's up to you how "bad" you feel for reverting to other means. Pretty sure any film enthusiast is faced with that conundrum on a regular basis.

side-note: I'm so happy to have found a reason to talk about the series. So many scenes are stuck in my head and come to mind when reminded about world affairs constantly. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=o861Ka9TtT4 this one for example with Russia and Crimea (just an example off the top of my head)

Wxc2jjJmST9XWWL··on Ubuntu 21.04
> "It's been a long time desire of mine to have a secure Linux laptop without needing to enter my password twice during startup"

Only with regards to that sentence (as I don't know much about TPM): You can simply opt for full disk encryption during install, and then you can also select "automatically log me in on boot" (not exact wording) when creating your user. So you enter the encryption password and that's it. Not sure why you would _need_ to enter password twice with encryption?

That's how I handle it. Screen lock, or returning from suspend still prompts for user password as usual.

Wxc2jjJmST9XWWL··on “They introduce kernel bugs on purpose”
You are free to use Minix or Hurd, not sure if a modern browser will even run, but if you want a microkernel so badly...

So if only Linus would have listened we would have Linux as microkernel equally feature rich and widespread? Stupid Linus /s

https://www.minix3.org/

https://www.gnu.org/software/hurd/

Wxc2jjJmST9XWWL··on Facebook prevents sharing New York Post story on BLM co-founder's real estate
Users, especially those able to flag (meaning somewhat "senior" users, not sure about the exact karma threshold), are often annoyed, because the nature of the discussions some topics provoke are foreseeable and mostly questionable.

"Great, this will lead to half the comments discussing BLM in a questionable and highly politicized manner on hacker(!) news ; this will surely be productive ... /s"

Political and sociological stuff is sometimes here on HN (and technology often overlaps, so they might be relevant of course), but especially those topics that have little chance of inviting meaningful discussion are questionable and might get flagged.

I consider "flagging" part of how this site works, and a meaningful feature. Right to free speech is not the "right to be listened to or read by others." HN also isn't Facebook, or Instagram (size, societal influence, scope in topics which are discussed) and you can still read it, upvote it, and comment on it even though it's been flagged. So I don't think it's as bad as you make it out to be. Posts about the banning practices of Social Media (be it Facebook, Youtube, Twitter or other platforms) are regularly featured on HN.

Wxc2jjJmST9XWWL··on Fastmail to end support for operamail.com email addresses
Running your own mail server, having problems due to shared IP is only one of the problems. Some more:

Spam filtering for one. Uptime and updating without downtime. You would absolutely need redundancy (complexity of the solution required starts building up quickly). Keeping tabs on mail server security and the vulnerabilities discovered in your particular software stack. A 15 second down time means an important mail might not reach you. If your mail server crashes due to unknown reason at 4 am, do you really want it to be your problem to fix? And it will of course happen when it least fits your schedule for the day. On most days I could live with my website being offline for a few hours because I've screwed up, but with E-Mail?

The solution?

The more you think it through, own the domain, yes, but use a mature and reliable (and paid for) provider you trust to do the hosting for you. For someone technical enough to securely own a domain and not let it expire that seems like the best solution really, unless maybe you own your own hosting service? :P (but then, technically, I guess it's not your own private mail server either)

Wxc2jjJmST9XWWL··on Fastmail to end support for operamail.com email addresses
Same setup as the comment you're answering to.

They've just been super reliable and mature for me. No huge updates that force me to adjust. Interface is nice and clean, uptime and service super reliable. Everything just seems to work for me (aliases, forwarding, filters, good Android app), and the pricing is within reason.

I actually use their web interface and official Android app. I'm surely no power user, but have used various providers over the years until I settled with Fastmail (seemingly for good). It's difficult to decide whom to trust with e-mail but to me they seem trustworthy. I still like to have my own domain, so I could in theory take it with me, if I ever started being displeased.

In general: Paying for a service (especially e-mail) is invaluable (my data not being mined), also for potential account recovery (didn't use their customer service often, but when it happened, it was decent).

I can't comment on ProtonMail but especially with e-mail, a proven (long term) track record is gold, and Fastmail has it.

addendum: upon rereading it almost sounds like a Fastmail commercial. I'm only a satisfied user without any further connection towards the company.

Wxc2jjJmST9XWWL··on Ask HN: Would issue “bounties” make contributing to open source more appealing?
I think the following suggestion is most likely extremely naive, so please bare with me.

Reading the valid criticism here of such a scheme, why not just approach some contributors, ask them if they would like to contribute more, and offer them short term contracts / rewards for their work?

"We've seen your activity on our issue tracker and we would like to hire you (short term for now) to help us out (home office work). Are you interested, and if so, considering other obligations you might have, how many hours a week would you be able to contribute to the project so we can ballpark a first payment?"

Alternatively you could simply pay for contributions already made to the project. Cherry-picking the contributors you want to see more of seems to be a good system? Even considering the effort this would cause, I do think your idea would be even more cumbersome, as you would have to set up a system to evaluate every single contribution.

I know of a nice open source project, where the lead programmer used part of the project's funding (plus even some of his own assets as far as I know) and more or less out-sourced a lot of work partly to one of the project's most loyal contributors, who he's been working with. Said individual is somewhere from Eastern Europe, where even a "relatively small" amount of money comes a long way. Everyone involved (project lead, the person hired, the community) benefited greatly.

Wxc2jjJmST9XWWL··on ‘Counter Strike’ Bug Allows Hackers to Take over a PC with a Steam Invite
First sentence:

> I don't find there to be much replay value.

Second sentence:

> I played it once, speedran it a few times, and then played it with the developer commentary.

If that isn't replay value, what is? How often do you replay Single Player games _with_ replay value then?

Wxc2jjJmST9XWWL··on System76 Developing “Cosmic” Desktop Environment
I guess what constitutes a "major screw up" can be debated. I don't have a problem with snaps.
Wxc2jjJmST9XWWL··on System76 Developing “Cosmic” Desktop Environment
As someone who has used too many distributions and window managers to count (over the course of many years), I've settled on Ubuntu and whatever their default UI. And I quite liked Unity as well after a while.

Of course if there was a major reason to switch away from Ubuntu or their default DE, I would, but it's the pragmatic choice. The constant "finding" of the perfect fit gets in the way of actually doing stuff. Once you adjust expectations towards a system, I'm still far happier with Ubuntu I could ever be with macOS or Windows, and don't waste time having a different system to work with every two weeks (slightly exaggerating).

Is it perfect? No. Is it good enough? Yes. Is it great compared to alternatives (factoring in speed of deployment and productivity from the get to)? Definitely yes.

I'm glad popOS uses Ubuntu and Gnome as backbone and tries to give you a customized experience rather than completely reinventing everything. Though for me, as long as Canonical doesn't screw it up in a major way, stock Ubuntu it is.

Wxc2jjJmST9XWWL··on Update on beta testing payments in Signal
If the illusion is that it's Signal's ultimate goal to dethrone WhatsApp (and Paypal for payments?), I think I'm not the one in need of a reality check (forgive the provocative wording, I have no ill will towards you).

Signal's (meaning the app) goal should be to be a long-term, secure, honest alternative for more privacy minded users, no matter their technical expertise? At least that's what I'm thinking.

Wxc2jjJmST9XWWL··on Update on beta testing payments in Signal
I don't think that's honest. Signal has the reach to get plenty of beta-testers on board, enough to maybe grow it from there. I'm not saying that it isn't tougher to do this way, but it's not like a "Signal Payments" App with a similar Logo by the same outfit trusted by many people for secure messaging already, starts at absolute zero. Plenty of outfits would kill for the Signal IP to create something like a payments app.
Wxc2jjJmST9XWWL··on Update on beta testing payments in Signal
Isn't the biggest question: Why not a different app with some sort of signal integration? If that takes off and is successful, it could eventually be merged to be one application I suppose. But leveraging a huge user base from Signal (a messaging app with a sales pitch of a certain purity and no bs attitude to the problem at hand) to push a cryptocurrency payment system?

Don't tell me anyone involved in doing this felt like this was 'the right way to go'. Which makes exact motivation behind it all the more questionable.

Wxc2jjJmST9XWWL··on School custodian refuses to download app that monitors location, got her fired
Kind of surprised almost no comment (no comment I've seen, at the time of writing of course) takes into account the circumstances stated in the very first sentence of the article.

The job was partly about _disinfecting surfaces_ in _schools_ in the midst of a _pandemic_ ; I'm not saying that makes it excusable, or that this case shouldn't have been dealt with better, but in the context of governmental contract tracing apps, lockdowns, constant and various limitations put on freedom of civilians in order to fight the pandemic, I think we can see how even a good willed employer might (wrongly) feel entitled to demand such a thing.

Privacy in the midst of emergencies (we can debate the exact scope of the emergency at hand of course) can be a slippery thing.

Wxc2jjJmST9XWWL··on Just Be Rich
I couldn't find mention of Anand Giridharadas in the comments; He wrote a book called "Winners Take All: The Elite Charade of Changing the World" ; I haven't finished the book yet, and I don't find myself agreeing with him on many things, and his criticism at times is more simplistic than I would like it to be, but I also found it to be an intellectually challenging read.

He argues that the rich do much for the underprivileged, but what they never do is challenge the system which made them so rich in the first place. Philantrophy and the associated virtue signaling has the perverse effect of keeping the very system alive, which is (so he argues) fundamentally broken to begin with, and needs major overhaul. I think it's relevant to the discussion. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Winners_Take_All:_The_Elite_Ch...

I found his conversation with Andrew Yang to be quite interesting https://youtu.be/2Ye-Jkql_jA?t=1742 (not pitching it out of ideological / political affiliation to either).

I personally am torn. From "the left" I think that personal responsibility often gets too little credit. The last thing you want to tell people is "it's not you, it's your situation, the government will fix it". The government is bad at fixing things, and you create a race for handouts, and a perverse game of victimhood claminig, to get sympathy and handouts. "I don't succeed because of X and someone else has to fix it" is not an empowering message. But many rich and privileged people are really blind to the sociological complexity in what determines success. Abundance of wealth doesn't necessarily make one happy, but lack of wealth and financial security makes one unhappy. And stressed. Stress in and of itself diminishes intellectual reasoning, decision making, affects mood, can be associated with psychological disorders, etc. "Well he's a truck driver, unhealthy, fears for his job due to automation? Well, he should become an app developer, or something similar. There are free courses everywhere, there are so many things to do. If he applies himself, he will find something, it's competition and our market system, which has made us so rich to begin with..."

I'm caricaturing ... but I don't know by how much.

Wxc2jjJmST9XWWL··on Quantum computing’s reproducibility crisis: Majorana fermions
Thank you for answering ; good to know.
Wxc2jjJmST9XWWL··on Quantum computing’s reproducibility crisis: Majorana fermions
had the same idea, but I do so as well and link is exactly the same.

edit: it doesn't really matter I guess. HN has some mechanisms which aren't public afaik. How downvoting works exactly, how flagging works, who can, what the algorithms are for sorting. This account I'm using hadn't a successful submission before, but it's not that I spam submissions either. Four submissions in total and the account is 8 months old. But I guess it's just some automatic behavior of the site, well... shrug.

Wxc2jjJmST9XWWL··on Quantum computing’s reproducibility crisis: Majorana fermions
Off-topic: I submitted the exact same article only a few hours before https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26777030 ; I thought someone else submitting the same thing would end up being a simple upvote on my submission instead of a separate submission?

I don't care about the points or credit, glad it's on front page. But apparently there's something I don't know about the workings of HN? Thankful for someone clearing that one up and sorry for taking up the space.

Wxc2jjJmST9XWWL··on Watchmaker Masahiro Kikuno's temporal hour wristwatch, documentary [video]
btw : he has been featured on HN at least twice before

2019 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19011880

2017 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14610110

Wxc2jjJmST9XWWL··on Tusky has been removed from the Play Store
I agree with you on some parts. Don't rely on Google, be available via other methods as well. But that does not take away from the fact, that if you lose access to Play Store and Apple Store as a means of distributing your application, at that moment you will have permanently lost access to 98% of potential users. The few that bother to install a .apk manually or use F-Droid aren't significant. How many people do _ever_ even search for an app outside of these stores? I'm guilty most of the time myself. One more factor: Especially with social apps the network effect is everything. Even the few hardcore lovers of your app stop using it, if not enough 'non-technical' users do. Having 100 contacts, 98 of them on WhatsApp, 4 of them on some social media app you have to tell your contacts to download the .apk from somewhere in order to use it? More often than not you can't even get people to install Signal, and it's one click.

You don't survive something like this and you won't regain your user count outside of these curated app stores.

It's pretty much as simple as that. The dream of "if it happens enough times F-Droid and alternatives will become more prominent" is just naive, it doesn't work like that. There is no level playing field to compete.

"The solution has always been to have a self-hosted backup [...]" - the solution to what? The solution to compete from outside of these curated stores where companies dictate course? No, it's not a solution for that, because it won't do much for you.

Wxc2jjJmST9XWWL··on German man loses 400k GBP about $500k in Twitter Bitcoin scam
It's interesting to ponder 'why' an intelligent human being would do this.

- Him having made so much money on a highly speculative asset, at one point having decided to pour a significant amount of money into it in the first place and it paying off? Almost certainly.

- Musk's seemingly irrational nature, tendency to do crazy things, to the point of that a 'fan' of his would actually deem him capable of doing a bitcoin giveaway? Almost certainly. You most likely wouldn't even believe this, verified or not, if it was a more 'reputable' CEO tweeting this.

- Current social media investing frenzy from stocks to altcoins to everything in between? The speed of social media, hype, buy and dump activism? People desperately trying to find their own 'opportunity' to strike gold? Imagine he wakes up the next morning, the giveaway was real, and what regrets would he have? Urgency forces stupid decisions.

I am not trying to attribute responsibility, but there are quite a few factors at play here, and they explain why he did what he did. Not trying to pass judgement on him, but at that very moment, he was a gambler, a speculator, not an investor or rational person. And then this happens. It happens to people in the financial industry all the time.

Wxc2jjJmST9XWWL··on Tusky has been removed from the Play Store
I do think that solution has a lot going for it. Probably even best to allow for multiple app stores from the very beginning. For example during setup of the device being prompted:

"There are various app stores to install software from. Each comes with their own form of app curation, and policies regarding payments, privacy, updates and more ; please select the app stores you would like to use. If you'd like to learn more, click here."

with a list of app stores given and 'Google Play' being pre-selected for example.

It's not something I've thought about a lot before, so I'm sure we could do better than that. But in principle that doesn't sound too bad.

Wxc2jjJmST9XWWL··on Tusky has been removed from the Play Store
I don't have strong feelings about mastodon or this specific app, but the credo of "It's a private company" is just lazy reasoning and thrown around blindly far too often.

Being banned by big tech (whether apps, social media accounts, major payment processors for receiving donations) is in some cases almost equivalent to being shut down ; "it's a private company" : if the company has a monopoly and there's not a significant number of healthy alternatives for people to use (be it out of convenience and lack of skill, doesn't matter), then how about we take that into account?

It's sad and frustrating we wanted an open internet and companies took over a huge share of it and are not stopping amassing influence and control. I wish this wasn't so, but it is, and we have to open our eyes to it when we're debating such topics.

"You can still distribute your app when not being on the Play Store or Apple Store right?" "In theory yes" "Case closed" ; things aren't so simple! In a perfectly 'libertarian' world, I would be more inclined to be on your side. But we don't live in such a world. We live in a world of politics, extreme lobbying, complicated tax codes, one million parties with various interests locked into a power struggle for political / social control and influence.

Wxc2jjJmST9XWWL··on In-car touchscreens are dangerous
- even in fast cars you often can't turn off the esc (electronic stability control)

- it might actually not allow you to make unusual maneuvers (handbrake turns, etc) ; this actually can trigger the automatic emergency hotline call (been a witness)

- it beeps at you for not wearing your seat belt (even while driving across an empty parking lot going 10 mph, or being on private property)

- it has distance sensors (car beeps at you when driving out of a narrow parking garage constantly)

- it warns you when it's cold, wet, you drive too fast ...

- you can't set height of headlamps manually anymore (good for xeon which burn out everyone else's eyes even with default height settings...)

- it might check whether you are in lane and warn when you go outside of it

you might not agree, but all of that frustrates me (and does, whenever I have a rental), and makes me feel less in control and being treated like a child.

-> add to all that : many electronic pieces are hard to replace, repair, debug if something isn't working ; not even talking about the full blown modern electronic gizmos where you now have to theoretically worry about your car getting (or not getting) software updates.

Being in total control for me includes the ability to shoot yourself in the foot. I realize this isn't what your average 'a car is just a utility for me' driver wants, but what an enthusiast wants.

to maybe come up with an imperfect analogy : average users use windows, power users use linux ; as long as I have linux as an option, I am happy. But the current development goes to a windows only world (in this metaphor), and it's rare to find cars that are exciting anymore.

Wxc2jjJmST9XWWL··on In-car touchscreens are dangerous
"clearly you're not a fan of touchscreens"

"no, I hate the things, I mean in a fast car, actually they shouldn't be allowed in a fast car, they really shouldn't"

legendary f1/car designer Gordon Murray, approximately 30:05, but the complete video is gold :

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K4EIYQ6fkG4

anyone interested in cars, engineering or design (or a combination) should watch it.

there's also a great podcast episode featuring him https://collectingcars.com/podcasts/ (episode 21).

sorry since I don't have much to say about the article itself, wanted to share this though.

I dislike almost everything about modern cars (touch is the least of my problems) ; usability, 'repairability', electronic assistance, cameras, trend towards SUVs (even if only for driving children to school), weight and size increase, technical gizmos, et cetera ... don't want to write that rant in full right now.

Wxc2jjJmST9XWWL··on Total Cookie Protection
Not affiliated with Mozilla, nor do I know, but my thoughts:

A quick check reveals that while ublock origin seems to be the most popular, it's by far not the only popular add-on to block ads https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/search/?q=adblock ; so why include ublock origin specifically? Especially since it has become much more than a simple adblocker (script blocking capabilities for example), why not something else? Why not integrate an ad-blocker developed completely by mozilla?

Why not include NoScript + Containers by default? And some UserAgent Switch capability? And more fine grained cookie storage options (currently available via add-ons), et cetera?

When you start integrating capabilities currently being offered by add-ons, the questions are :

- where to stop

- how to discriminate what to include, what not

- how will users and developers feel (for example the user who wants to use his favorite add-on, which now is not developed anymore because almost no one bothers to install it since functionality X has become part of the browser)

- how to deal with edge cases (the one site which breaks because of ad-block is the reason a non-technical person might simply install chrome and move on with their life)

- is the increasing complexity worth it? to what degree is it?

← PreviousPage 3 of 4Next →