HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Xylakant

13,469 karma · joined June 3, 2011

submissionscomments
Xylakant··on People want platforms, not governments, to be responsible for moderating content
If you read the guidelines, there’s quite a bit about being polite and not inciting flame wars, not only off topic items. It regularly happens that posts or even users get removed for that reason.

There are platforms that have much less strict standards with regards to that - yet you consider this the more agreeable platform. Maybe the reason is that it’s actually nicer to have a conversation in a place where you don’t need to deal with an asshole that starts yelling and insulting everyone at the table.

Think about this in real life: would you want to frequent a place where the loudest asshole gets to insult everyone present or would you rather go to a bar where at some point the Barkeeper steps in and sorts things out?

Xylakant··on People want platforms, not governments, to be responsible for moderating content
The post I’m responding to explicitly states that platforms should not moderate content.
Xylakant··on People want platforms, not governments, to be responsible for moderating content
Are you implying that there’s no posts on social media platforms that are plain and verifiably wrong and that any such decision needs to be made by a government created ministry of truth? There’s no middle ground? Maybe such a thing like a court?

If I state here plain and as a fact that golieca eats little children for breakfast and slaughters kittens for fun, could @dang not look at both a statement from you and one from me and see if I have sufficient proof?

Xylakant··on People want platforms, not governments, to be responsible for moderating content
What if someone posts slander and libelous statements on a platform that you do not frequent? What choice do you have? What recourse do you have if someone posts something along this proud OpenAI demo with your face on truth.social? https://bsky.brid.gy/r/https://bsky.app/profile/did:plc:j5fb...
Xylakant··on People want platforms, not governments, to be responsible for moderating content
You are posting on a platform that has a moderation policy and takes active measures to to moderate away problematic content. The guidelines are here https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and they clearly state what content is off limits.
Xylakant··on Vertical Solar Panels Are Out Standing
So your problem is that during summer, average solar production is much higher than in winter in the first place. So to ensure that you have sufficient energy in winter, you can either overprovision heavily for summer use (lots of flat panels facing south) or you can sacrifice summer efficiency to gain winter efficiency - vertical panels do that.
Xylakant··on Tesla influencers tried coast-to-coast self-driving, hit debris before 60 miles
Even if this were the case, it would still skew the statistics in favor of Tesla: The Autopilot gets to hand of the complicated and dangerous driving conditions to the human who then needs to deal with them. The human to the opposite cannot do the same - they need to deal with all hard situations as they come, with no fallback to hand off to.
Xylakant··on Tesla influencers tried coast-to-coast self-driving, hit debris before 60 miles
The statistics on this are much less clear than Tesla would like us to believe. There's a lot of confounding factors, among them the fact that the autonomous driver can decide to hand over things to a human the moment things get hairy. The subsequent crash then gets credited to human error.
Xylakant··on Tesla influencers tried coast-to-coast self-driving, hit debris before 60 miles
We do have road tolls for trucks in germany. It's been like that for quite some time.
Xylakant··on Why your outdoorsy friend suddenly has a gummy bear power bank
I believe the parent means you can charge the powerbanks in parallel.
Xylakant··on Chatbox app is back on the US app store
The license does not bind the original copyright owner, who can do anything with the code - fee example relicense and distribute under another license.

The license only binds the licensee that received the code under the respective license.

Things get more complicated if there are external contributors that may have contributed under specific legal arrangements, but in the simple case there’s no legal way to force the original copyright owner to publish sources.

Xylakant··on Google: 'Your $1000 phone needs our permission to install apps now' [video]
The iPhone 13 mini is a faceID device - but I’m holding onto it until the bitter end. But we’ve been using iPhone SE as company phones until they were discontinued- the devices are perfectly usable for all basic use cases.
Xylakant··on Why insurers worry the world could soon become uninsurable
The linking doesn’t need to be perfect to have real-world consequences: as the article explains, dues to increasing heavy weather events, home owner insurance is harder or even impossible to obtain. Without HOI, you won’t get a mortgage, because that would mean the bank partially enters into that risk. No mortgage means a lot of people cannnot afford to own a house or flat.
Xylakant··on Why insurers worry the world could soon become uninsurable
Insurance is supposed to average out small probability high impact events across a large number of smaller payments from more people. It is entirely expected to loose money on insurance as a single customer - that's usually great. It means your house hasn't burned down, you're in good healt and you bike hasn't been stolen. If we're now moving towards a world where due to man-made climate change certain classes of risks are no longer insurable, everyone looses.
Xylakant··on Exit Tax: Leave Germany before your business gets big
If your company bylaws are set up properly, you can do board meetings via video calls just fine.

Very few acts require actual presence in the country. What is required is that you can, at any time, enter Germany to perform those acts - which shouldn’t be a problem if you are German Citizen.

Xylakant··on Helsinki records zero traffic deaths for full year
If you look at outcomes, 50km/h (30mph) is much less safe than 30km/h (20mph). If you look at the physics, that’s not surprising - stopping distances increase super linear. At the point where a 30km/h car would have come to a stop, a 50km/h car still impacts with 30km/h.

On the other hand, average speeds in populated areas usually are way lower than 30km/h, so lowering the top speed to 30km has negligible effect on travel times.

If you consider 50km/h the sweet spot, you prioritize vehicle speed over the very real risk of bodily harm for all other traffic participants.

Xylakant··on Tesla must pay portion of $329M damages after fatal Autopilot crash, jury says
It happens all of the time. Cars veering off the road and maiming pedestrians is a fairly common occurrence.

Sorry to cite German sources, but google translate should help you out

August 2024: 8 Year old “caught by a car on the pavement” https://www.swr.de/swraktuell/baden-wuerttemberg/ulm/kind-be... October 2024: A Mother and two children killed by an SUV that “veered off the road” https://www.merkur.de/deutschland/baden-wuerttemberg/erfasst... May 2025: 2 Children injured, on their way home from school https://www.focus.de/panorama/welt/20-meter-von-schule-entfe... July 2025: 2 pedestrians injured https://www.sueddeutsche.de/muenchen/starnberg/starnberg-aut...

Xylakant··on When we get Komooted
That depends on what you consider noticeable. A lot of things are noticeable (and noticed) on the local level. The folks that organise reading sessions with the kids a my sons school. The people managing the local hockey club. People doing local education in IT. Organizing the neighborhood meetup. The people that do hack and tell. Blog about what they’re doing by as fun projects.

They may not be known beyond their local communities, but they have impact on society. Most of them are contend with that. If you’re looking to change the world, then that’s likely not good enough, but then again, if you’re looking to do that it’s unlikely that you will achieve that as a rank and file employee in a corporation.

Xylakant··on Windsurf employee #2: I was given a payout of only 1% what my shares where worth
You are misrepresenting how dilution works - and dilution usually is not what fucks you. Dilution is fairly straightforward - someone ponies up money and gets a share of the company. The valuation that gets handed around is usually what’s called “post money” - how much is the company worth after investors have paid in their money. In a simple example, matching your numbers, a company that is worth 10 million, with 10 million shares, each valued at 1 dollar with a 90/10 split finds someone who invests a billion dollars at 1 dollar per share. These shares are created as part of the acquisition. The value of the shares doesn’t change - the company, post money, now is valued at 1 billion 10 million and has 1 billion 10 million shares, each worth 1 dollar. It also happens to have 1 billion in cash at hand. No change in value for anyone here, but dilution happened - the person that owned 10% of the company pre-investment now only owns 0.1% - but the value of each share is still the same, which means they still own the same number of shares, each at the same valuation with the same total value.

The problem tends to be elsewhere - as part of the deal, the investor asked that his share get preferred treatment in the next round - a liquidation preference which grants them the right to first take their investment of the table and then, whatever is left is distributed. The company gets sold for 1 billion. The investor takes the billion that they invested off the table. There’s nothing left to be distributed. Your shares are suddenly worthless - just as the founders.

Xylakant··on Windsurf employee #2: I was given a payout of only 1% what my shares where worth
They could, but the shares represent value - and that money needs to come from somewhere. Simple, but extreme example: A company is valued at 10 million gobbledoks, and the C-Suite holds 10%, representing 1 Million valuation. Now the company takes 10 Million gobbledoks Investment that end up in cash on the companies bank account. This raises the the valuation to 20 Million.

Under simple dilution rules, the Investor takes 50%, and the existing shareholders are diluted to 50% of their stake - the C-Suite owns 5% of 2 Million, 10 million as before.

If the C-Suite demands that their equity proportion remains at 1%, they’d suddenly own a stake representing 2 million valuation. That difference needs to come from somewhere.

Xylakant··on Windsurf employee #2: I was given a payout of only 1% what my shares where worth
Legally speaking, it’s probably possible. Practically speaking it almost certainly a guarantee that the company will never see outside investment. On every round someone would need to pony up the cash to fill that employees stock. Anti-dilution clauses exist, but they never work like that.

Such a privilege is also likely to be almost worthless - if the company succeeds and the round makes it worth more, you’ll win even with dilution. If the company doesn’t, then other clauses such as liquidation preferences will make your stock worthless, regardless of how much you own.

Xylakant··on AI overviews cause massive drop in search clicks
Kagi has an extension to add itself. https://help.kagi.com/kagi/getting-started/setting-default/s...
Xylakant··on Does showing seconds in the system tray actually use more power?
The test setting is important here - the test is on an otherwise idle machine. This means that the update ensures that some thread wakes on a timer every second which may explain the large drop. This test is interesting, but not very representative of a real world usage scenario. It’ll be interesting to compare it to the results of the other test they running, where they keep a video running in the background.
Xylakant··on A Virginia public library is fighting off a takeover by private equity
Do roads turn a direct profit? Water works? Canals? Flood Dams? Dikes? Are public parks profitable? Should schools be profitable? Is the police profitable? Does the fire department charge for every blaze they contain? Is the congress profitable? Are the courts? The president? The government as a whole?

Society funds a lot of public services because they cannot reasonably be billed to the individual, but enable the society to function and are the underpinning of economic activity. They are profitable because they allow society and the individuals to engage in economic activity which they otherwise could not.

We should strive to make public services efficient, but aiming for profit is against their very nature.

Xylakant··on New Linux udisks flaw lets attackers get root on major Linux distros
Rewrites by engineers can also uncover cases where the original tool does not conform to its own spec, this rewrite uncovered two issues with the original sudo.

One of our engineers involved in the project wrote about the testing approach they used and about the issues they found here https://ferrous-systems.com/blog/testing-sudo-rs/.

Later, a dedicated security audit for the rewrite was performes which uncovered three issues, one of which also affects the original sudo implementation. https://ferrous-systems.com/blog/sudo-rs-audit/

I generally support the notion that rewrites of large complex code bases are usually a bad choice, but sudo is not a particularly large codebase not is it particularly comples - it's just particularly sensitive. In those cases, I believe the tradeoff can fall the other way - rewriting old, feature-stable codebases (to a reduced scope) can lead to improvements on all axis.

Xylakant··on New Linux udisks flaw lets attackers get root on major Linux distros
I think it's pretty reductive to boil down linux' success to the choice of license. There's governance model, development model, institutional inerta, ... - and the linux ecosystem contains tons of permissively licensed pieces of software, some of which massively contributed to its success (the once-default webserver that came with its own permissive license, the APL). Even the kernel includes APL, BSD-2 Clause and MPL'ed code.

To the contrary, GNU Hurd is GPL'ed and is much less successful than the linux kernel.

Xylakant··on New Linux udisks flaw lets attackers get root on major Linux distros
> It's permissively licensed, unfortunately. Wonder why.

I've been loosely involved in setting this up, so I can say a little: The people that funded the initial work wanted it permissively licensed. My (somethwat informed) conjecture is that they rank making things secure - even in closed source apps that now could take the code - higher than barring closed forks. It also tracks with the Rust ecosystem in general - APL or derivates are very common in that ecosystem.

Xylakant··on Riding high in Germany on the world's oldest suspended railway
That’s much more common than one would think. The London tube began operation 160 years ago. The U1 line in Berlin was constructed between 1902 and 1926. The central railway lines are substantially older. The Paris metro began operation in summer 1900.

Bridges in old cities are very often much older than a century.

The ship lift in Niederfinow that connects the Oder-Havel Canal to the Oder river went into operation in 1936 - the canal that it serves dates back to 1743. https://de.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schiffshebewerk_Niederfinow

The Hoover hydroelectric dam is now 90 years old.

Xylakant··on Reviving a modular cargo bike design from the 1930s
Better (more expensive) Engineering. Different frame geometries, different materials, better quality control on the welding. One of the main reasons for the recall was that babboe did not follow up on reports of frames breaking until a regulator stepped in. And by then, it was too late to contain it to a few batches.

Babboe is a rather budget brand that uses a single round lower tube under the box. Compare that with the frame of an urban arrow or a R&M load that use multiple tubes and a proper stiff platform under the box. Even if an Urban Arrow Frame would crack, it would bend out of shape instead of failing catastrophically like the Babboe did.

Xylakant··on Reviving a modular cargo bike design from the 1930s
Yes, but due to unrelated issues (the frames would break)
← PreviousPage 5 of 34Next →