Independent relays can exist, which is better than the fully centralized options.
There is no financial incentive to bear the cost of running a public relay.
364 karma · joined July 28, 2022
Independent relays can exist, which is better than the fully centralized options.
There is no financial incentive to bear the cost of running a public relay.
[0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/On_the_Cruelty_of_Really_Tea...
A belt-mounted split keyboard on my thighs, and limitless screen space in a serene setting provided by VR. Won’t need a standing desk at all!
The relativity.com domain could not have been cheap, even if leased.
I’m surprised they are making a new brand, “Unai”/unison.co, instead of continuing with Relativity.
I’ve heard Zig has convenient facilities for it.
[1] https://blogs.ubc.ca/etec540sept09/2009/10/31/unintended-con...
The results of public funding of weapons programmes and surveillance satellites are understandably concealed, this museum situation is analogous despite the risks being significantly less consequential.
Think of how often dedicated walking and cycling routes need to be repaved—almost never.
Car owners only pay about half of the cost of road maintenance in the US[1].
I probably get about one amber alert per quarter, and severe weather alerts a few times a year. I’ve never gotten a “blue” alert in my life.
I think it would feel hollowed out, disingenuous.
It feels too close to being a rat with a dopamine button, meaningless hedonism.
I haven’t thought it through particularly thoroughly though, I’d been interested in hearing other opinions. These philosophical questions quickly approach unanswerable.
The public perception seems to be against him, and managing public perception is important.
WP Engine was banking on the free stuff from Wordpress.org, and they got burned because they bit the hand that was feeding them.
If they want to play hardball about what’s required instead of acting generously, like Matt has done for decades, then they are getting their just deserts.
Matt isn’t obligated to be nice to dick heads. WordPress.org isn’t obligated to provide service for free.
WP Engine decided that they would only do what’s good for them. Fine. If they piss in the pool, they can’t be mad when everyone else gets out. It is irrational for WordPress to continue acting like there isn’t an extractive entity in their midst.
If WP Engine had acted in good faith, Matt wouldn’t have had to come up with terms unilaterally.
Especially if they have a fraught relationship with the provider of those free services.
System76 provides the PopOS repos that are based on Ubuntu. They don’t freeload.
Canonical provides the Ubuntu repos that are based on Debian. They don’t freeload.
WP Engine is freeloading, no doubt about it.
The ultimatum Matt made in the texts highlighted by WP Engine appears short, but it seems unlikely this was the first time Matt brought up these issues.
The omission of that suggests that he does have a financial stake.
Given the lack of reliable information right now, I’m going to believe the individual that has a decades-long track record indicating that they care about open source over the private company that is legally obligated to pursue profit as its only objective.
1. The author claims dozens of other companies behave similarly and claims that Matt has not taken any action against them. However, the author makes no claim of what level of contribution to WordPress, cost to Wordpress.org, or any contractual agreements those companies may have with WordPress entities. Multiple companies do pay for trademark licenses. Scale is also an important factor here. Estimates are in the hundreds of millions of revenue for WP Engine. They are one of the largest companies in the ecosystem, of course they should be contributing more than smaller players.
2. The author claims that Matt attempted “extortion” and refused to give WP Engine more time to address his demands. It does seem true that Matt refused to give them more time. However, Matt claims this conversation has been going on for more than a year. A deadline seems appropriate if your counterparty keeps delaying.
3. The author claims that trademark confusion between WordPress and WP Engine is an unfounded concern, citing confusion Shopify and Spotify. This is ludicrous on its face, those companies serve completely different market needs, compared to the WP Engine literally offering the product produced by the trademark holder. The author claims that WordPress.com and WordPress.org is confusing the trademark, but doesn’t state whether WordPress.com has a license to use the trademark.
4. The author claims that Matt’s dissatisfaction with WP Engine’s contribution is unreasonable because there aren’t terms and conditions or a contract. This is missing the point entirely. The point is that good members of the community shouldn’t need to be forced to contribute. If they want to play by the letter of the law, Matt isn’t obligated to provide the free services that their business relies on, just as they aren’t obligated to give back. It cuts both ways, and if they won’t operate in good faith, it is self destructive to continue to enable them.
I’m out of energy to continue, so I’ll stop here.
I doubt it, and it would be wrong to do so.
If he didn’t have a financial stake, he would have listed it in his myriad reasons to trust him.
2. All those products have no marginal cost for users, WordPress.org does.
3. Just because bad behavior has been tolerated for a time doesn’t mean it must be tolerated forever.
Matt claims he has been privately discussing with WP Engine for ~18 months about their level of contribution. Automatic contributes the equivalent of 75 full time employees to WordPress and WP Engine contributes 1, despite the companies being comparable in size.
Matt’s actions may have been bad for optics, but I do not fault him for using the resources at his disposal to correct what he sees as injustice.
Also note that the author doesn’t disclaim any financial stake in the company he used to work for, WP Engine, after his company was acquired. He merely claims that he isn’t a “fan of either party”, so we should value his opinion and trust that it is impartial.
As for myself, I’ve never used WordPress or any CMS, I’m a lowly embedded software engineer. If Matt, the progenitor and steward of one of the most successful open source products in the world, asserts that an entity in the ecosystem is a leech, I’m inclined to believe him.