HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Zimahl

1,480 karma · joined August 19, 2011

submissionscomments
Zimahl··on MIT Wristband Could Make Air Conditioning Obsolete
Thomas Jefferson designed his bedroom with ventilation in mind.[1]

[1] http://www.monticello.org/site/house-and-gardens/bedchamber

Zimahl··on Yelp reviewers claim to be employees in lawsuit
YouTube most likely decided to pay for videos to encourage more and better content. Without paying their content creators, YouTube would just be the place where you get started and then moved somewhere else to profit.
Zimahl··on Why women lose the dating game
Well, we certainly live in a very weird time. There's a level of expectation of dads now that there wasn't for my dad. There is now an expectation of 50/50 in raising children even with stay-at-home moms. That means cooking, cleaning, laundry, entertainment, etc., falls on the dad a lot.

Whereas even 30 years ago this certainly wasn't the case. My father was a good dad but certainly didn't clean anything other than the garage. He didn't bathe any of us kids or tuck us in. He sure as hell didn't buy groceries. What he did do it kept the yard clean, the roof clear, the garden growing, the cars running, and coached baseball.

I think too many dads these days are too busy being mom #2. And women think that's what they want but in reality it emasculates their husband in their eyes.

Zimahl··on Why women lose the dating game
Let me rephrase what I was saying. Not every woman out there is settling on a least-common denominator. Some women are single because they were too picky (like the text I quoted) but some are just single because of bad luck.
Zimahl··on Why women lose the dating game
While I am happily married, I have seen the 'sexual-market-value' change first hand now that I'm in my mid-30s. The women my age who are attractive but unmarried and childless seem to now be with men who they would've probably never even considered 10 years ago. They've been passed up for whatever reason - bad relationship choices, too picky, etc. - but still want a family so are willing to lower their standards.

I thought this was funny:

Naomi explains: "He's 36 years old and is definitely someone who falls into the alpha-male category: excellent job in finance, PhD, high income, six feet two, sporty and very handsome. And he's an utter sweetheart."

Just clueless. That guy, if he even exists and isn't already married, has the resources to date a nice girl in her late-20s. Again, it's a symptom of the problem. Many women waited for the perfect situation and never found it. And even if they found their white whale we all know how that story ends.

Zimahl··on LinkedIn ‘Intro’duces Insecurity
In case you signed up using your work email, like practically everybody does

1) Why would anyone use a temporary email to sign up to a social service?

2) Why would anyone use their work email for a job networking social site knowing full well that work emails are not private?

Zimahl··on Debt ceiling: Why the Great American Ponzi scheme might just keep running
Well, one would assume that had the US not stumbled into 2 expensive foreign wars we probably wouldn't be in the situation we are in now. We went into massive debt during WWII as well we just weren't able to borrow the money from foreign markets, we had to settle for US war bonds.
Zimahl··on Hacking the Olympics
I'm not sure the IOC's requirements but I think you can compete for a country if you have just familial or racial ties with a country. Technically, the country just has to recognize you as theirs.
Zimahl··on What is the best way to programatically detect porn images? (2009)
Definitely true. Facebook had a dust-up when a woman posted a topless photo of herself after she had had a double mastectomy.

That said, not all sites are like Facebook and we aren't talking about filtering all the images on the internet, just ones on specific sites. One example I can think of is that a forum for a sports team might not want NSFW pictures posted as it would be irrelevant.

Zimahl··on What is the best way to programatically detect porn images? (2009)
I'm actually annoyed that you got modded down. Your post brings up an excellent point although I don't think it's intended.

These days, it comes down to exposure and access. Back when I was a teen (early 90's) we didn't have the internet as it is. Sure there were BBSs but that was about as convenient as trying to get a dirty magazine. While I may had idle curiosity when I was pre-teen, I had zero access to it (my father didn't have any magazines, etc) and therefore it would've taken way too much effort to see it, so it was easily dismissed. In context, it was equally difficult to even see an R rated movie.

These days, my 8 or 10 year old self could be exposed to literally anything within a couple seconds. It's free and prevalent, and can show up in unexpected places. I don't have kids (will soon) but I don't look forward to dealing with those situations.

As for Janet Jackson, I agree that was overblown. If anyone needed therapy for that it was because their parents were overbearing. However, we aren't talking about a bare breast here, we are talking about simulated rape, bestiality, and some other things that just aren't my thing. But, hey, if they are someone's thing that's fine - let's just try to keep that stuff out of the hands of the kids until they are old enough to reason for themselves about what's really going on.

Zimahl··on How the .0001% Made Its Money
That's certainly a possibility, and it certainly is done by the wealthy all the time. At least in the US it is very difficult to transfer large sums of money out of the country without accounting for it, so these end-arounds of taxation are quite difficult to pull off.

Inheritance taxes are better because they force the rich out of a hording mentality - either leave your family with sustaining businesses, which help the middle class by providing jobs, or lose half and have that reallocated. Right now, without an inheritance tax, there's no appeal to take risks on building anything. Just invest at moderate returns and the family fortune will never run out (except in extreme circumstances).

Zimahl··on Should we stop believing Malcolm Gladwell?
I think I'd still rather be around people who argue with statistics and logic than people who don't. Step into a Yahoo news comment section with any article that mentions the US gov't or Obamacare. There's so much bullshit and stupidity thrown around it makes you lose faith in humanity.
Zimahl··on If Java Is Dying, It Sure Looks Awfully Healthy
Back in college when I was interviewing for jobs sometimes interviewers would first ask you to write any executing Java class because some interviewees said they 'knew' Java and couldn't do even that simple task.

A couple years later when Eclipse came out I told a coworker this anecdote and he joked that it was 'main' + ctrl-spacebar followed by 'sysout' + ctrl-spacebar. I lol'd.

Zimahl··on Mark Cuban makes Shark Tank remove equity clause in contract
I knew about the 2%/5% but thought it was a pretty fair deal. The amount of advertising that this brings to a many of the companies on the show is worth a ton. Some of the food or plain merchandise companies where all the sharks passed have updates where their sales have grown enormously.
Zimahl··on Children aren't born smart. They're made smart by conversation
That's a nice thought but not a fact. Some who are held down search for what they were deprived, some don't. I would assume the many examples of this are all anecdotal since they make great stories. The flip side is not that uncommon and thus not celebrated and reported about.
Zimahl··on A 3D printed toothbrush for all your teeth
You know, I see that argument all the time - 3 minutes here, 1 minute there. But I just wasted 5 minutes of my life where I zoned out staring at the ceiling. Sometimes you can justify 'wasting' 18 hours per year.

Also, it's not like you stop thinking in those 3 minutes per day, you can still use that time for something constructive, even if that something isn't using your hands.

Zimahl··on Looking back on the game 'Myst' on its 20th anniversary
Without Myst there's no Grand Theft Auto V or Assassin's Creed

Really? That's a bold statement. I don't agree with it, but it's bold nonetheless.

There's going to be some big publishers out there who will want to do this [too]. There's big money here for them. And I don't think they went after it.

Off the top of my head I can think of 'The 7th Guest'. There were plenty of rendered CD-ROM games just none as successful as 'Myst'.

Zimahl··on Is College Worth It?
It very well might be worth it

Therefore, you answered the question of 'Is College Worth It?'. It is, for some professions. Thank you for agreeing with me.

Given that electrical "engineering" (i.e. you won't become a PE) is taught at the community college level, I'm not sure why you would think that way. Clearly there is a demand for people in this sector without the college education and degree that goes with it.

Is community college not college? Are associate degrees not degrees? Hence, you'd still need a professional education to get your foot in the door.

but that is a long way from saying it is required, which is the context of this discussion.

At no point did I, nor the article, argue that degrees should be required for any specific profession. I'm having trouble arguing with someone that doesn't understand what is being argued in the first place. At this point I think you are simply trolling so I bid you good day.

Zimahl··on Is College Worth It?
I feel like you are moving the posts again to support your argument. ... An electrician's job is deeply rooted in the research done by physicist and electrical engineers, so why does it not count?

Moving the posts? The posts for this entire argument start and end with college. You can't argue that college is worth it for a profession if a college doesn't teach the profession to begin with.

So, if one were to become an electrician is college worth it? No. If one were to become a physicist or electrical engineer, that is the question.

Agriculture comes to mind as a university accredited program, and while I'm sure it can be useful, you do not need a degree in agriculture to be a successful farmer.

The degree from universities for agriculture is typically more of an agri-business degree. No, you probably don't need it to farm and be successful. But, once again, to the root of the article, is college worth it to gain some insight into the business of agriculture?

Speaking of electrical engineering, there was an article in a national newspaper a month or two ago about the top jobs (pay wise) for people without degrees, and electrical engineer was near the top of the list. Programming and IT work did not even make the cut at all.

It's hard to comment on the validity of an article without a link. I find it hard to believe that many people could get their foot in the door without a degree. I assume you are remembering incorrectly and the job was electrician since that is typically a top non-degree profession.

Zimahl··on Is College Worth It?
Even still, when ~70% of the population do not have degrees, it seems insidious to say that programming is one of the few professions that do not require a degree.

I never once said that few professions do not require a degree. The article is about whether college is necessary and I said it was necessary for a number of professions due to the difficulty of getting instruction outside of a university.

You are getting hung up on the word "require". Yes, being a doctor requires a license which is vetted by degree. I'm saying that being a chemist (a US chemist, not the UK version of a pharmacist) doesn't require a degree per se, however, you are going to need to head to a university to be able to get the instruction and resources to be able to properly learn as they are both prohibitively unavailable externally.

Again, I struggle to think of more than a few professions that actually do require a degree, even if arbitrarily.

If you are able to think of very few that require a degree (both directly or indirectly), outside of IT, what are those? And please limit yourself to professions that are spawned from degrees. A carpenter, electrician, etc., are not taught at colleges.

Zimahl··on Is College Worth It?
Is that assertion based on more than emotion?

Emotion? It's based on honest assessment.

Please show me one architecture firm who will hire a self-taught architect or an aeronautical company that will hire a self-taught aeronautical engineer. Other careers are simply unable to attain without the resources of universities because you can't practice the craft to even begin to be proficient.

The offset in the percentages has a lot to do with IT. I do not consider much of what IT does to be STEM. It's skilled labor with respect to (T)echnology but a lot of it is no more skillful than a carpenter using math to cut a 2x4. Yet some articles put the carpenter as a STEM job[1]. I'm sorry, I just don't consider a mechanic or electrician as a STEM job in most situations.

[1] http://www.usnews.com/news/articles/2013/06/10/study-half-of...

Zimahl··on Is College Worth It?
One would be hard pressed to learn chemistry or physics without the resources of a university. I don't want a building designed by a self-taught architect or a bridge designed by a self-taught mechanical engineer. I don't want to fly in a plane designed by a self-taught aeronautical engineer.

While 50% of STEM jobs don't explicitly require a degree, it would be prohibitively difficult to get a career in those fields without one.

Zimahl··on Is College Worth It?
Certainly, and some people would be better served by not going to college. The point is that you can't just call it a life after high school and expect to earn a respectable (in a financial sense) income. Unskilled union mill work is no longer going to feed a family of 5 and pay for a nice mortgage.
Zimahl··on Is College Worth It?
I'm not sure what you're saying. Of course I see that the axes have different scales but both are linear. State schools (blue/purple/green) are at about $75k in cost but span the same '30 Year Wage Premium' as the private schools (yellow/orange/red) with the only significant difference being in the highest of high-end engineering schools (MIT, Cal Tech, Carnegie Melon).

I sincerely question the data however after looking at it more closely. My alma mater (Washington State) apparently costs more than University of Washington. From a purely tuition perspective this is not true since I've compared them many times. If you add in room and board this should be quite different due to UW being located in a major metropolitan city, and WSU being located in rural eastern Washington.

Who knew BYU was such a good deal? All my cousins I guess (had 4 who went there, with a child of one cousin (second cousin) now attending).

Zimahl··on At 77 He Prepares Burgers, Earning in a Week His Former Hourly Wage
At 64, when an 800 square foot manufactured home he’d seen in Plant City, a Tampa suburb, became available for $21,500, he purchased it with a credit card to amass frequent flier miles. He then sold his New Jersey home for $180,000, kept what he needed to quickly pay off his credit card debt and divided the rest among his children so they’d have down payments for their own homes.

Selling the house was smart, but dividing the rest and giving it to his children was a terrible move. Homes in the US are used a proxy savings accounts - sold at retirement or later to gain retirement funds, or used as a (hopefully) no-rent living space.

Zimahl··on Is College Worth It?
College is probably worth it but that's not what this graph is really showing. It really should be entitled 'Is Private College Worth It?' because it appears that the only significant cost:wage value is to 'Private Engineering' and even then arguments could be made that state engineering is good enough.
Zimahl··on Is College Worth It?
Yes, I know that college was worth it 30 years ago, and even 15 years ago. That is not the real question. The question is will this continue to be true in the future?

I know this gets brought up all the time on here but HN is not a good indicator of college worth. One of the few (if not the only) disciplines where college might not be necessary is software and this board is primarily software. Even then looking at the difference between the definitions of software developer and a software engineer may make this moot.

That line of reasoning is irrelevant if we are in fact at an inflection point. ... Arguments based on trend lines from 30 years ago miss the heart of this subject.

Not really. Until there is a real, tangible way for the average individual to get an accepted post-secondary education, we aren't at an inflection point. And other than software development, I personally can't think of another engineering or science profession that could be replaced by self-study and/or experience.

Zimahl··on The Case Against High-School Sports
Completely anecdotal but I played two sports seasons out of three in high school and my grades were always better during those seasons. While I did see some students who weren't exactly killing it academically during those seasons, they probably wouldn't have done any better without.
Zimahl··on The Case Against High-School Sports
To be fair, this typically doesn't happen for the tennis players, track athletes, swimmers, etc. Most of the time the teams that are aggrandized, like for football, basketball, and sometimes baseball, are the ones what get the free pass.
Zimahl··on The Case Against High-School Sports
As someone who didn't play one of the glory sports (football/basketball/baseball) in high school (I played water polo and swim team), I understand the lack of accolades. Our swim team was undefeated, had won our district, and many of us were on to state and our district trophy was used a prop for what the basketball team was going after - but had not yet won. Earlier in the fall the football coach at the same school mocked my (successful) water polo team because the sport was perceived as not as 'manly' as football.

As for cost, the article mentions that the school that shutdown sports was paying $1300 per football player - which just means they have poor accountants. At my high school almost all athletic costs were covered by student sports passes and event tickets. The problem is in the South where 'football is life' and they pay huge salaries for winning coaches and cathedral stadiums. Yet the South is the location of some of the worst school districts.

← PreviousPage 5 of 21Next →