HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Zimahl

1,480 karma · joined August 19, 2011

submissionscomments
Zimahl··on Apple Literally Stole my Thunder
I didn't get that he was hinting at that. The problem is what Apple thinks is significant to the platform when they develop it versus when it's an outside developer.
Zimahl··on Apple Literally Stole my Thunder
Your definition of 'monopoly' is not helping your argument.

Apple controls a very big portion of the handheld market and that portion is completely roped off by iTunes. Worse, if they see something they are doing, whether it's better or not, you can't get your competing app onto their device. Was this not the same issue with Sun's Java and IE back in the 90s?

Meanwhile, crazygringo has a website. Sure he controls the content of the site but doesn't prevent anyone else from publishing on the internet. If 'mjbaldwin.net' was one of only a couple portals on the internet, you might have an argument there.

Zimahl··on Poll: How many HN iOS users actually use Siri?
These are completely valid use cases. I think the problem with Siri is that it was billed as some insanely useful tool that would radically change how you use your phone. Obviously it's limitations outweigh it's strengths.
Zimahl··on Confirmed: The NSA is Spying on Millions of Americans
It's a lot like Andrew Jackson's "John Marshall has made his decision; now let him enforce it!"[1]

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Worcester_v._Georgia

Zimahl··on The entrepreneurial adventures of a coder living in a tent in the forest
Apparently the plant poisoning in the movie (and postulated in the book) weren't correct. If you read the Wikipedia on McCandless[1] research into how he died has made it clear that it was just plain old rabbit starvation[2].

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Christopher_McCandless

[2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rabbit_starvation

Zimahl··on MySugr diabetes management app heads to the US, Tim Ferriss new advisor
I was originally going to post something similar about the Tim Ferris name drop and you beat me to it. I also don't get the point. His credentials seem very irrelevant to the app. I would rather see the names of the doctors who's research is making sure this is the best app possible.

My wife is also an insulin-dependent diabetic and will probably try this out and see if it fits her lifestyle.

Zimahl··on Breeze is closing on August 1
It's still on my list of possible projects. I kick it's tires every once in a while.
Zimahl··on Breeze is closing on August 1
I had a similar idea to this about a year back and didn't get out of the feasibility stage. After crunching the numbers I just couldn't make it work as a free service. Maybe I wasn't doing it right, but the bandwidth of attachments becomes the killer. Mail-list.com seems to have the pricing in just about the right spot, and I'm not sure that is something the common user is going to go use.

It appears that Fiesta.cc had this issue as well. From their blog they were going to shut down about a year ago but managed to figure out how to keep it running. Their site is a little short on details - I'm not sure what the limits on the mailing lists are.

Zimahl··on Police admit they're 'stumped' by mystery car thefts
Or they are just really smart thieves. Better to get caught with petty theft than grand theft auto. Also, maybe keeping the crime as just theft is keeping it under the radar - the cops aren't going to throw up any road blocks for that level of crime.
Zimahl··on San Francisco median home hits $1 million
As an American, I don't seem to understand Canadian currency at all. I've watched 'Love It or List It' on HGTV knowing that it's a Canadian show but the prices of the houses are all typically anywhere from $700k-$900k for 1600 to 1800 square feet. Trying to convert it back to a price in US dollars I guess isn't quite right. What's the median income in Canadian dollars that makes home prices so high?

Side nitpick: do Canadians primarily use square feet as a measurement? Is that a real estate standard even though Canada is mostly metric?

Zimahl··on San Francisco median home hits $1 million
Agreed, but the OP's point was that while obviously desirable it wasn't at the price that it currently stands.
Zimahl··on New Mexico's 'Atari Dump' to Be Excavated
Oh man, the Atari 5200. I'd almost forgotten. We didn't have a 2600 but my folks got duped into the 5200 being 'the next big thing'. I guess I should be grateful, without that failure my folks wouldn't of had a reason to buy the Commodore 64 later on which not only had games but also could be used for a lot more.

Also, when talking about E.T. and the landfill you are obliged to link to the music video made by an indie band about the fiasco[1].

[1] http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8Rt_3_bQVJU

Zimahl··on Show HN: The Choice – An online programming puzzle RPG
Thanks for giving me a course about game design and asking questions obviously not answered in Chapter 1. Where can I send you money? <3.

Did you not post this expecting constructive feedback? Snark aside, chapter 1 of what? You haven't made it clear what this really is. Is this python? Do you want to use a game to teach the language or is this just a game and the language is irrelevant?

On the question I was having trouble with I was over thinking the isTrue method. It just wasn't all that clear to me until I did some pseudo debugging with it.

Zimahl··on Show HN: The Choice – An online programming puzzle RPG
I'll be honest, I don't understand the logic I need to get through the truth-teller/liar test since it isn't quite clear what I'm allowed to do. If you just want me to do a ton of embedded if/else statements, meh, I've lost interest.

If the goal it to teach programming, increase an interest in programing, or expose a language that others might not be exposed to, the worst way to do it it to make your target audience feel stupid. The initial questions to show the answer command aren't very easy - frankly they are seriously flawed riddles. Second, showing variables isn't described well enough to intrinsically know what to do unless you've already been exposed to programming.

I guess it all depends on the target audience, but it's not all that clear who that is.

Zimahl··on Show HN: The Choice – An online programming puzzle RPG
I could use a checkbox to shut off the voice. It gets a little annoying after a while.

Very nice. Somewhat fun and interesting. Xzoor isn't a very good guard if he's telling you specifics about your prison!

Zimahl··on Letter To A Young Programmer Considering A Startup
There are plenty of small to medium sized business where you get to learn and have an impact. I tend to favor those - I have the autonomy to contribute without the overhead of 6 different managers.
Zimahl··on Letter To A Young Programmer Considering A Startup
But coming to SF and floundering around is no better than aimlessly moving to LA to become a movie star.

Not to be nit-picky but getting start-up experience isn't quite the same as going to casting calls while working at Olive Garden to make ends meet.

Zimahl··on New software could have ID’d Boston bomber
The title is a little over-reaching.

The software could've given a clearer image of a suspect which would've aided police in finding said suspect. Figuring out who actually placed the bomb in the first place was bottleneck #1 and probably took the bulk of the time. Bottleneck #2 is finding out who that person is and this is made easier with the crowd-sourcing that is local news. Bottleneck #3 is physically finding the person which they even had trouble doing with Boston on lockdown.

It's a neat solution to a very real problem, so technically very cool just not what the article is billing it as.

Zimahl··on A Terrifying, Fascinating Timelapse of 30 Years of Human Impact on Earth
I feel you're just repeating industry misinformation.

Industry misinformation or the actual laws for the states of Washington and Oregon, which follow countless other states and provinces in the Western US and Canada? You on the other hand are stuck repeating misinformation from the 80's anti-logging spotted owl rhetoric.

BTW, it's hardly an ad hominem. I'm not attacking you personally to discredit what you are saying - what you are saying is just factually wrong.

Zimahl··on A Terrifying, Fascinating Timelapse of 30 Years of Human Impact on Earth
Snark aside, you are showing your spots and how little you know. Forks is not a pulp and paper town. It's a logging town. Thus, I didn't grow up in Forks.

You're just plain wrong about automation, that isn't what is killing the pulp and paper mills. If that were the case the mills and the companies associated with those mills would be doing fine - just with less people. No, the mills themselves are in decline due to a lack of use for their product.

E-books, electronic documents, decline of newspapers. This isn't the 70s, this is a paperless world and only going to get more so.

Zimahl··on A Terrifying, Fascinating Timelapse of 30 Years of Human Impact on Earth
I care little what timber companies do with the land we gave them last century. But if they're cutting down OUR trees on OUR land, then they have to replant that acreage. If they can't do that profitably, then too bad. There is no right to profit.

You have shown you know very little of the timber industry. Private landowners are under the same laws with respect to replanting as the public lands are. Public lands are logged, sold, and the profits returned to the public in the same free market system. No matter, it ALL has to be replanted.

On what planet do you think someone is just letting perfectly good land that can support a forest just sit barren? Unless it's re-zoned into something else, that's not profitable nor sustainable. Our forests are very sustainable.

Timber, pulp, paper are all cyclic. Always have been, always will be.

If you think the pulp and paper industry will ever be what it once you are fooling yourself. In the electronic age paper is far down it's not even funny. I grew up in a pulp and paper town that is a shell of what it once was.

Zimahl··on A Terrifying, Fascinating Timelapse of 30 Years of Human Impact on Earth
So obviously you didn't read my original post where I said I was talking about the US and Canada exclusively, which the parent comment was responding to.

Go into Canada and the US and camp. Railroad logged anywhere from 150 to 100 years ago, second growth logged from then on. Birds. Deer. Elk. Insects. Owls (even Spotted ones!). Fish in the streams.

The US and Canada isn't Europe. This continent has been largely undisturbed until about 300 years ago, and most of it untouched until the last 100 years. We've seen Europe's folly and fortunately didn't make the same mistakes or at least have had time to correct the problem. We also didn't have 2 world wars march across our lands, no trenches, no mustard gas.

Much of N. America from just east of the Rockies to the Pacific Ocean is amazing forests. We've made our mistakes with forestry but have atoned and things have healed up nicely. Now we manage the forests for the good of everybody - everyone can have what they want without sacrificing the quality of that resource.

Don't be so blind as to just blanket all logging in the world as 'logging bad'.

Zimahl··on A Terrifying, Fascinating Timelapse of 30 Years of Human Impact on Earth
Tree farms are not habitat.

How is a 40 year old forest not habitat?

My problem is when timber companies must extract every board foot from every acre, threatening critical habitat, from public forests. To add insult to injury, we (the public) build the roads, and sell the timber at a loss.

Lies, lies, and more lies. Have you even been to a cut down forest within the last 20 years? Streams have required easements, there are requirements for leaving a number of trees per acre and any logging roads are paid for by the landowner. The roads are a cost of the harvesting.

...actually paid fair market price for the resources they're stealing.

You act like it's a quick turn around. We are talking decades after replanting, there are very few industries that have to follow this. And then, after waiting all that time, you need to hope that the market isn't in the state that it's currently in. Domestic timber is in the dumpster right now due to foreign logs and a lack of new housing.

Zimahl··on A Terrifying, Fascinating Timelapse of 30 Years of Human Impact on Earth
Lake Mead is artificial. It will 'ebb and tide' as those who control it see fit. Therefore, it's not a great indicator of environmental collapse.
Zimahl··on A Terrifying, Fascinating Timelapse of 30 Years of Human Impact on Earth
I can't speak to the forest practices of S. America or other continents but regarding US and Canadian forest practices that article is complete FUD.

First, it equates 'forest loss' to legitimate forest management - grow, cut, replant. Second, there is more forests now than there were in 1930 (I'll find the source in the morning). Now that's a slightly dubious stat since post-railroad logging there was only natural regrowth but we manage our forests very, very well these days.

The last place for environmental concern in the US and Canada should be to the forests. It's in everyone's interest to have healthy forests - from the logger to the landowner to the mill worker to the multinational.

Zimahl··on The Fallacy of Money As A Means
I think for me what it comes down to is 'F U money'. I will feel successful when I have enough money earned and saved that any storm can be weathered, even if I decide to walk into said storm (leave via an 'F U', hence the name).

It might not be a reality. It might not even be attainable (maybe the bar keeps moving), but that's my criteria.

Zimahl··on Star Trek, tech companies, and the death of futurism in cinema
Is that really true? Avoiding spoilers apparently this most recent movie has proved otherwise.

Vulcan being destroyed doesn't stop VGER and it doesn't stop the monolith. It probably does change the Klingons so maybe 'Undiscovered Country' doesn't happen.

Zimahl··on Star Trek, tech companies, and the death of futurism in cinema
Let's talk about this thin wedge (hopefully without spoilers). I understand that this is a relaunch of the series but I think they did it wrong. It probably would've been blasphemy to throw it all out the door, and 'historically' the same things can happen but they really should be ignoring everything from TOS.

Will we see VGER? The monolith from 'Voyage Home' (ST4) must make an appearance, right? I mean we have to assume that whales are still extinct in the alternate timeline. Will Praxis explode resulting in 'Undiscovered Country' (ST6)?

Zimahl··on I was struck by lightning yesterday—and boy am I sore
I know that he didn't receive any scarring externally. My point was that anything that can do things like that externally could have resulted in very bad things internally.
Zimahl··on I was struck by lightning yesterday—and boy am I sore
I was going to say that too - those Lichtenburg scar pictures that are linked don't look good. While they might seem 'cool' aren't those just 3rd degree burn scars? You have to wonder about the 3rd degree burns on the inside that you can't see.
← PreviousPage 10 of 21Next →