138 karma · joined August 21, 2015
The conference is composed of: "the Chief Justice of the United States, the chief judge of each court of appeals federal regional circuit, a district court judge from various federal judicial districts, and the chief judge of the United States Court of International Trade." [0]
You can disagree with their decisions, but don't try and imply that they are duplicitous. I expect better of the EFF.
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Judicial_Conference_of_the_Uni...
Many people understand that taxi regulations (for the most part) negatively affect them, and in many cases are extremely frustrated with them: see Washington, DC. Most people aren't familiar with and don't care about the company that manages their health insurance, and as a result there's little public support.
2. The fourth amendment doesn't apply to data you're legally compelled to surrender to the government. By your logic, every form 1040 that's ever been filed is a fourth amendment violation.
3. The eighth amendment has almost never been used in a constitutional case involving excessive fines. When it has, the court has primarily used it to prevent pseudo-fines that aren't really called fines in order to skirt the eighth amendment.
Sure, FATCA might be annoying, but a legal challenge has almost nothing going for it. Don't get your hopes up.