HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

_qulr

4,776 karma · joined May 23, 2020

submissionscomments
_qulr··on Apple removes first-party firewall exemption in macOS 11.2 beta 2
> The ones they consider less important are put in a backlog.

True, but this just proves my point. It still doesn't take 6 months to fix this issue... if they wanted to fix it. Deprioritizing it was a deliberate choice by Apple. The reason the exclusion list shipped to the public in Big Sur wasn't technical, the reason is that Apple's priorities are messed up.

From my perspective, the explanation is simple: ContentFilterExclusionList wasn't a "bug", it was a deliberate "feature". So from Apple's perspective, there was nothing to "fix". At least one developer was told it "behaves as intended": https://twitter.com/david_ddw/status/1329017113709842437

Only the public backlash caused Apple to remove it.

_qulr··on Apple removes first-party firewall exemption in macOS 11.2 beta 2
There's no link because the tweet was deleted soon afterward. The tweet seems to have been very ill-advised.

I don't know how anyone can describe this as a "bug", because as the linked article describes, there's an explicit "ContentFilterExclusionList" in the Info.plist file with a list of the specific Apple services excluded. That's not by accident, it's by design.

_qulr··on Apple removes first-party firewall exemption in macOS 11.2 beta 2
> Sure, why not 6 months?

Because the first WWDC preview version of Big Sur was released to developers on June 22, 2020, and Big Sur was released to the public on November 12, 2020, so Apple needs to be able to fix issues identified during the beta period much quicker than in 6 months.

_qulr··on Apple removes first-party firewall exemption in macOS 11.2 beta 2
I've been a professional Mac software engineer for 15 years.

I've also lived my entire life in the North (which for some reason is called the Midwest).

_qulr··on Apple removes first-party firewall exemption in macOS 11.2 beta 2
> This happened so quickly

This was your claim. What is the justification for the claim? The comment seemed to imply that it was the OCSP problem. Otherwise, no other explanation was offered by the comment.

_qulr··on Apple removes first-party firewall exemption in macOS 11.2 beta 2
> the gigantic majority who never touches the betas

I was replying to a comment that literally said, "That's why Apple has the Developer and Public Beta releases for iOS/OSX", so maybe you should argue with that comment instead of with me.

_qulr··on Apple removes first-party firewall exemption in macOS 11.2 beta 2
There was a ContentFilterExclusionList key in the /System/Library/Frameworks/NetworkExtension.framework/Versions/Current/Resources/Info.plist file. macOS 11.2 beta 2 removed the ContentFilterExclusionList. Does that take 6 months?
_qulr··on Apple removes first-party firewall exemption in macOS 11.2 beta 2
Who else would Apple take feedback from during the betas? Who else would even notice that there was a hole in the firewalls except the firewall developers?
_qulr··on Apple removes first-party firewall exemption in macOS 11.2 beta 2
> That's why Apple has the Developer and Public Beta releases for iOS/OSX so that external users can provide feedback. And on this occasion just like on many other they will take action if necessary.

Except that Apple did not take action. Firewall developers such as Little Snitch did become aware of the issue during the beta releases and gave feedback to Apple, which Apple ignored and shipped it anyway to the public. https://blog.obdev.at/a-hole-in-the-wall/

_qulr··on Apple removes first-party firewall exemption in macOS 11.2 beta 2
The imagined timeline of this comment doesn't seem to align with reality. The exclusion list was already present in the first WWDC builds in summer 2020, as the Little Snitch developers noticed: https://blog.obdev.at/a-hole-in-the-wall/

The Mac "OSCP appocalypse" occurred in November on the day that Big Sur was released to the public, with the exclusion list still present, and a number of firewall developers were already aware of the exclusion list and had reported bugs to Apple.

_qulr··on Distributing Mac apps outside the App Store, a quick start guide
The $100 fee is no barrier at all to professional criminals. Whereas it's a huge barrier for open source developers.
_qulr··on Distributing Mac apps outside the App Store, a quick start guide
Developers can switch to a different platform, but the problem is that their customers won't switch. The customers for boutique indie apps simply do not exist on Linux. And they don't exist on Windows to the extent that they exist on the Mac. The Mac has always been by far the best platform to find customers for boutique indie apps, long before Mac code signing existed, and that equation hasn't changed even though Apple is now getting worse and locking down the Mac.

In general, I find the idea strange that developers can simply avoid being dependent on Apple. Look at two of the largest corporations in the world: Google and Facebook. They are themselves platforms. Google has its own mobile OS, Android. And yet... these companies still have big problems with Apple. They still need iOS apps, they still have to go through App Store review, etc.

The world is such that it's extremely difficult for anyone to avoid being dependent in some way on the BigCos. If you think the web is independent, just consider Flash-based web sites. Not so independent anymore, eh? Turns out Google and Apple also control the web browsers. Consider physical product producers and Amazon. And look at how Parler was simultaneously deplatformed by everyone. These BigCos are the elephants in the room, you can't ignore them.

_qulr··on Distributing Mac apps outside the App Store, a quick start guide
> Apple only notarizes those in the App Store.

To be pedantic, this is not notarization. The term notarization only applies to software distributed outside the the App Store. The developers themselves sign the software with a Developer ID code signing certificate, and then Apple notarizes the signed software.

Whereas software distributed in the Mac App Store is all signed by Apple itself rather than by the developer.

_qulr··on Distributing Mac apps outside the App Store, a quick start guide
> Is it possible to sign and notarize an app for macOS without paying $99/year?

Almost certainly not. Apple does technically have fee waivers for eligible organizations — note the term organizations, not individuals — but the red tape required effectively (and ironically) puts this out of the reach for most individual open source developers:

https://developer.apple.com/support/membership-fee-waiver/

_qulr··on Distributing Mac apps outside the App Store, a quick start guide
> Another reason is that it is another level of QA for my app. Sort of a “peer review.” I’m fairly obsessed with Quality.

In my experience, don't expect much from App Store reviewers. Their primary concern seems to be simply protecting Apple's own intellectual property. If you want testing, distribute your app to beta testers.

_qulr··on Lulu – Mac open-source firewall that aims to block unknown outgoing connections
"Objective-C" is the name of a programming language used for Mac development, previously the primary programming language before Swift and still popular among Mac developers.

"Objective-See", the name of the maker of LuLu, is a pun on Objective-C.

"Objective Development", the name of the maker of Little Snitch, is likely also based on Objective-C.

_qulr··on U.S. Capitol Locked Down Amid Escalating Protests
> But that's just the beginning of the radicalization pipeline. No reasonable person just starts on Rush.

This sounds more plausible. However, it's in direct conflict with the claim "I can pinpoint it to exactly when my dad started listening to Rush Limbaugh".

I feel that there's a whiff of "Reefer Madness" in the hysteria against partisan media, as if mere exposure will drive unsuspecting innocents mad.

_qulr··on U.S. Capitol Locked Down Amid Escalating Protests
> I blame the internet.

The irony of this ahistorical claim is that it comes very close to "Make America great again".

Think about the Vietnam War. The civil rights era. The McCarthy era. The list is almost endless. The Civil War, of course. The US has almost always had major polarization. If anything, the internet reveals what had been hidden by the whitewashed corporate Big Three TV network monopoly, which was itself an historical anomaly.

You know the Pulitzer Prize for journalism? Well, Joseph Pulitzer himself was unapologetically partisan. As was William Randolph Hearst, et al. The whole idea of "objective journalism" is not much more than a naive blip.

_qulr··on U.S. Capitol Locked Down Amid Escalating Protests
> By that argument you could say the cigarette industry isn’t the cause of tobacco addiction.

The crucial difference is that cigarettes are targeted at children, and the majority of smokers become addicted before they become adults. Whereas the audience for Limbaugh, Fox News, etc., skews much much older. Everyone is complaining about how their dad was brainwashed, not about how their child was brainwashed. How many smokers start as dads rather than as teenagers?

(To further clarify: Alcoholics are a minority of alcohol drinkers. The majority of drinkers drink simply because they enjoy drinking, and they could quit if they wanted to without withdrawal symptoms. In fact I quit drinking entirely when the pandemic started, for several reasons, and I'm fine, I feel like I could continue abstaining indefinitely with no ill effects. Thus, I don't consider the purpose of the alcohol industry to be hooking junkies, whereas that's almost unavoidable with nicotine, which is medically established to be highly addictive.)

> we’ll have to agree to disagree about whether my dad was a good person who fell into the sway of bad influences or was a bad person all along.

I don't believe in such black and white, good and bad people. As I said, people are complex. "It's almost always nuanced. You may only see side one side of a person". I think we're all flawed, just in different ways. My claim is that Rush Limbaugh is not a magical snake charmer, he's a guy who tells some people what they want to hear, otherwise how do you explain how you yourself are "magically" immune to his charms?

This is the missing piece in the explanatory puzzle about propaganda. It's easy to point out, but you can't jump to conclusions about its effectiveness without explaining why you who are pointing it out were not affected.

_qulr··on U.S. Capitol Locked Down Amid Escalating Protests
> that’s not unlike saying a good person would never abuse alcohol

It's more like, I wouldn't say that the vodka distillery is the cause of alcoholism.

_qulr··on U.S. Capitol Locked Down Amid Escalating Protests
> He was curious, smart, kind, and optimistic, then came Rush Limbaugh.

This is the story I never believe. My reaction to hearing Rush Limbaugh is the desire to shut it off ASAP. Don't you have to willingly invite him into your life? To listen and enjoy and want to listen more, to even "experiment" with the drug of anger with an object of blame, is not very indicative of kind and optimistic IMO.

The thing is, people are complex. They can be very kind... to their own kind, if you know what I mean. Alternatively, some parents can be kind to everyone else's kids and be abusive toward their own. It's almost always nuanced. You may only see side one side of a person, even if you think you know them better than anyone else.

_qulr··on U.S. Capitol Locked Down Amid Escalating Protests
There are other factors though that can't be discounted. It's indisputable that he's older now. It's quite natural that many people get "worse" when they get older, a phenomenon that has always existed. Also, people raising children at home have different priorities and interests than "empty nesters" whose children have grown and left home. It's unsurprising that your father's behavior around you would be very different now as an adult than when you were young.

How exactly did he get into listening to that stuff? Were there no other choices? Not music? Not NPR?

_qulr··on U.S. Capitol Locked Down Amid Escalating Protests
> All goes back to Reagan's repeal of the Fairness Doctrine

Reagan himself was an FBI informant and was involved with blacklisting so-called Communists way back when he was President of the Screen Actors Guild, during the McCarthy era. So any story that says "It all started on such and such a date" is completely arbitrary.

You can talk about Barry Goldwater. The National Review. Jerry Falwell and Pat Robertson. There was already a strong conservative movement growing that got Reagan elected in the first place. Not to mention the October surprise conspiracy theory of his 1980 election.

The 1960s, the Vietnam War, the civil rights era, these had a huge impact socially, started political realignments, and caused much internal turmoil in the United States.

The Gingrich "Republican Revolution" occurred in 1994. Hillary Clinton claimed there was a vast right-wing conspiracy in 1995. Government shutdowns. Impeachment. Oklahoma City bombing. All of this occurred before Fox News even went on the air.

Will anyone acknowledge that Timothy McVeigh and Terry Nichols were radicalized before Fox News existed, not to mention before Twitter, Facebook, and YouTube?

_qulr··on U.S. Capitol Locked Down Amid Escalating Protests
Correlation does not imply causation. Moreover, when hasn't there been polarizing media? There are countless radical publications that did not imminently result in a political revolution. Also, today's afternoon riot doesn't really compare with the aforementioned historical events.
_qulr··on U.S. Capitol Locked Down Amid Escalating Protests
> I asked her whether she will accept a paper without sound academic bibliography. She said no. Then why would she believe in extremist videos with shady citations and outright lies?

This is very common. I would even say the norm. No person is fully rational. Rather, people may think rationally about certain things — their "speciality", perhaps — but not about others. Everyone is irrational in some ways.

> But if what we see today has never been seen in history

Which part do you think is historically unprecedented? The technology of course is unprecedented, but I don't see anything about the beliefs of people today that's unprecedented.

_qulr··on U.S. Capitol Locked Down Amid Escalating Protests
> I was bombarded with recommendations of barely concealed white supremacists, and bizarre conspiracy theorists. I know that if I clicked on even one of them, then my recommendations will be full of that crap.

You were offered the recommendations, but you declined. It's still a matter of self-selection and self-exposure. How many recommendations would it take to turn you into a white supremacist? How many video viewings? If your answer is that no amount would, then the algorithms don't seem to be the real problem.

_qulr··on U.S. Capitol Locked Down Amid Escalating Protests
How do you know your dad wasn't always that person? Children tend to be pretty naive about their own parents. Children very rarely have a sophisticated understanding of issues such as politics and race, so they wouldn't even notice problematic aspects of their parents until they become adults themselves.
_qulr··on U.S. Capitol Locked Down Amid Escalating Protests
> 20 years ago these people would have had much less opportunity to speak and reach followers, not more, and things were better then.

20 years ago was the disputed 2000 election, 9/11, Department of Homeland Security, Gitmo, invasion of Afghanistan, lies about WMD, invasion of Iraq, etc. So no, I wouldn't say things were better then.

_qulr··on U.S. Capitol Locked Down Amid Escalating Protests
> the adults who are "doing it to themselves" are, in fact, doing exactly what I described above to their children

To an extent, yes. However, there are a number of mitigating factors. (1) Individual parents vary widely in their persuasive skill. (2) If there are 2 parents, those 2 don't necessarily agree in their beliefs, which means mixed messages for the children. (3) The child's friends, neighbors, schools, and community are also important influences on the child. (4) Genetics guarantees individual differences regardless. (5) Kids have a natural tendency to rebel against their parents, regardless of the parent's beliefs.

A lot of kids turn out a lot like their parents. And a lot of kids don't. Some even become the opposite of their parents. So the parental influence is definitely a factor, but it's not inescapable.

In any case, most kids pay very little attention to politics or "hard news" before they reach voting age (or even after). The news consumption itself tends to occur mainly in adulthood.

_qulr··on U.S. Capitol Locked Down Amid Escalating Protests
You're correct that the reality is much more complex. To expand, I would say that people are indeed susceptible to propaganda, but only propaganda of a certain kind. It has to reinforce their preexisting biases. You can't just force any propaganda on any arbitrary person, that's not going to work. That's why I say people do it to themselves. They come to trust the public figures who tell them specifically what they specifically want to hear, and then this trust and good feeling can be exploited for other purposes.

That's not unique to any one political party. All political partisans are susceptible to propaganda, but only party-specific propaganda. There are different forms of propaganda on different sides that would never work on the other side.

← PreviousPage 8 of 31Next →