HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

a3camero

689 karma · joined April 21, 2011

Programmer
submissionscomments
a3camero··on Copyright King: Why the "I Have a Dream" Speech Still Isn't Free
Here's an 1883 US Supreme Court case on licensing a patent: http://scholar.google.ca/scholar_case?case=85702692636686956...

Licensing law has really only taken off in the 20th century I believe, but there's older stuff that's very related.

Courts have long been troubled by licensing/assignment issues. IP is a "chose in action", and it's something that's more general. The older issue is about assigning debts. Here's an old Ontario law based on a UK statute I believe that allows for a certain kind of assignment after 1897: http://www.e-laws.gov.on.ca/html/statutes/english/elaws_stat....

a3camero··on How to write a Hacker News comment
There's also some very useful personal observations on HN that add more detail to a story when people have more knowledge about it than the article. I think this is a valid place for first person.
a3camero··on Poll: As a freelancer, how much do you bill per hour?
I wouldn't let it accumulate. Those extra hours are your profit.
a3camero··on Poll: As a freelancer, how much do you bill per hour?
I think your definition is the more standard one. I think the parent post meant to say "deposit". Retainer is usually "$2000/month for up to 20 hours of work".
a3camero··on Reflections of a "Book Pirate"
I think buying a shirt is different from buying a book. The author got exactly what he wanted. He wasn't expecting a different book, or even one with a slightly different colour, or a different fit.

The real problem is that merchants can't state that they don't accept refunds in cases where people bought and received what they asked for but they didn't actually want the think they bought. Kind of a corner case I'd think, but one that led to the disappointment of both people in this transaction.

a3camero··on Even as Zynga slides, bankers reap big fees
If that's all Zynga paid in underwriting fees they got a good deal.

There's usually a 7% commission for underwriting in the US: http://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2011/06/is-under.... Odd to be criticizing the underwriters for making too much money when they seem to have cut Zynga a rather good deal.

a3camero··on I went to the same school as Julian Assange, but we learned different lessons
If they had been enforcing the law more vigorously he probably wouldn't have had a chance to be an illegal immigrant. He'd have been deported.
a3camero··on I went to the same school as Julian Assange, but we learned different lessons
"We don’t suffer from too much governance, we suffer from too little".

It's funny that someone who was an illegal immigrant would support more governance when that's exactly the sort of thing that would have kicked him out of the country and led to him not having much interest in how the US is governed!

Perhaps he means "his sort of governance" is what's needed because I'm fairly sure he wouldn't like the consequences of ramping up regulation of everything. See all the SOPA posts for details.

a3camero··on Dear Congress, It's No Longer OK To Not Know How The Internet Works
The problem you've raised is one that actually is addressed by the way that bills become law in the US (whether it works or not is a whole different question...). Congressional bills go through a committee process where in theory people who've dealt with similar laws before learn about the particular subject matter, hear from experts and then decide on whether the bill should proceed: http://www.whitehouse.gov/our-government/legislative-branch#....
a3camero··on India’s missed call culture
In Canada you generally pay long-distance rates (~$0.40/minute) when you: -Call a number with a different area code (and sometimes the same one because some area codes are very large and actually have multiple zones) -When you call a number in your own area code but you aren't in that area code (when you're in another city) -Receiving calls when you're outside of your area code

Most people are on multi-year contracts with substantial break frees (in the $200 range). There are also charges to change your number and so on and so on...

a3camero··on RIM is rotting from within
Also, RIM isn't just in Waterloo. There's a fairly substantial Mississauga office that is in the Greater Toronto Area. RIM also has offices in Ottawa, the US and Britain.
a3camero··on The $150k Solution
I meant the "darling" thing, but I'm from Ontario where that would be an unusual thing to say and probably sexist.

Maybe it isn't in Texas, in which case, my apologies. Texas is on my list of places to visit and if darling is actually used in a way that isn't sexist, well you just bumped it up a bit more on my travel list!

a3camero··on Idea: an open platform for generating custom legal contracts
To make that task even more complicated, people don't agree on what many of the rules are. Your "law compiler" would have to take in input and have output that's maybe this, or more likely this, but it could also be this...
a3camero··on The $150k Solution
Although you may have just figured out why there aren't more women in tech in Austin.
a3camero··on No Copyright Intended
If by broad strokes you mean "don't kill" then sure, but the actual details of how the legal system treats killing people is rather complicated. There are a variety of exceptions and different penalties depending on how the death happened. You might be surprised to find out how complicated the "don't kill" regime really is.
a3camero··on No Copyright Intended
It's hardly a surprise that people don't know how Copyright law works. People don't understand any major aspect of our legal systems. The rules are so incredibly complicated that even lawyers who specialize in these areas may not understand them and may even disagree on what the rules are (this is is where at least some litigation comes from, people disagree on what the rules are that applies to the situation).

I'd be surprised if most renters knew what the laws about renting are, despite most of the rules being written out and not squirreled away in court cases (re: case law) and renting being a major expense they incur every month.

a3camero··on Obama Announces $2B Fund for Startups
Canadian here: Your post is kind of at odds with the final question you posed.

You can have the money AND not sacrifice health outcomes. As you said, Cdn and US governments spend the same amount of money for the same outcomes.

a3camero··on Tell HN: You said not to. So I quit my job and started. 5 mos later: OpenPhoto
You're living the HN dream by quitting your job to do your own thing, so how's it going? Are you better off doing this than working at Yahoo?

I'm sure other people are curious too.

a3camero··on Amazon Will Pay Shoppers $5 to Walk Out of Stores Empty-Handed
Although the millions spent renovating the stores will make them even less competitive and drive more customers to shop with Amazon.
a3camero··on Behind RIM’s $485M Write-off
I'm a Waterloo graduate. A Microsoft recruiter told me of any school they hire the most from Waterloo.

There were endless tech company visits when I was there.

RIM isn't the only company in Waterloo either: Sandvine, Sybase, etc.

a3camero··on Be careful what you put in an email
Things tend to look like that when you take the most damning possible statement out of tens of thousands of documents that you received in discovery!
a3camero··on Convert Any Webpage to an Image
I thought at first it was some sort of service for porn sites! Porn companies need service providers too...

I think it was for one of my clients that has a directory service for green service providers in Ontario (http://www.greatgreendirectory.ca/Group/Windfall-Ecology-Cen...). For any sort of directory it would be useful to show the website linked to.

a3camero··on Convert Any Webpage to an Image
When I went to this site it showed a thumbnail for YouPorn on the right. Maybe not a good idea to show the most recent thumbnails generated!

Useful service though. I had a need for this a year or so ago.

a3camero··on Seasteading: Cities on the ocean
I'd take this book with a grain of salt. I don't think they've consulted with an IL/maritime lawyer (or a lawyer at all?). Seasteading might sound like a hacker's dream but there are a lot of issues not explored in this book that would be incredibly important for anyone considering investing in this idea.

1. EEZ is not 200nm from the territorial sea. It's 200nm from land, they didn't read the UNCLOS definition properly "The exclusive economic zone shall not extend beyond 200 nautical miles from the baselines from which the breadth of the territorial sea is measured." (Article 57, UNCLOS).

2. The contiguous zone is not "pretty much the same" as the territorial sea.

3. They don't really seem to understand what sovereignty is or how the international legal system works... a common theme of people who've previously tried to start their own countries. It's important to understand how flags work WRT sovereignty.

a3camero··on Seasteading: Cities on the ocean
This has happened before. Check out the history of pirate radio in Europe. The European countries responded by creating national laws that embargoed the pirate radio stations. The Spanish were never apart of it and British citizens just ignored and resupplied illegally. Decades after the embargo was passed there were still radio stations opening.

Still annoying and likely if you're successful, but probably not killer.

a3camero··on Seasteading: Cities on the ocean
Although this post is rather off the HN path, people might appreciate a draft of a law paper I've coincidentally just written on the legal issues with doing these sort of things: http://private.summerhilldesign.com/SeaLawPaper.pdf (3rd year law student).

If this is too long, pg. 17 has a chart that shows how far out the different boundaries on the ocean. Starting at pg. 12 you'll see what things you can't do and pg. 24 has some conclusions. Might help take some of the "but that's illegal!" and "I don't think you can't do that" out of this discussion. Cheers!

a3camero··on NYC Man Earns $55,000 A Year Peddling Candy On Subway
I don't know about "breaking the law intentionally" but here are some examples of things startups have done that other people have thought were illegal. In some of the cases people have thought that so strongly that they've filed lawsuits.

Groupon selling coupons for alcohol in Massachusetts: http://articles.boston.com/2011-03-18/business/29351154_1_gr... (here are some other suits: http://www.portfolio.com/business-news/2011/03/29/groupon-fa...)

Facebook not living up to privacy promises: http://online.wsj.com/article/BT-CO-20111129-710865.html

YouTube/Google not paying royalties/failing to control copyright infringement: http://paidcontent.org/article/419-music-publishers-settle-w...

AirBNB's operations in New York: http://www.betabeat.com/2011/05/31/airbnb-takes-manhattan-wi...

a3camero··on Sen. Scott Brown: Creating A Nation of Venture Capitalists Through Crowdfunding
To be fair to big banks (this doesn't sound like me...), the boiler room operator steals all of your money and the bank doesn't. You might not get the return you're expecting but at least they won't straight up steal from you. It is different.
a3camero··on I regularly hire women for 65% to 75% of what males make
If you're curious about other jurisdictions; in Ontario you generally get 17 weeks pregnancy leave and then both parents can take 35-37 weeks of parental leave: http://www.labour.gov.on.ca/english/es/pubs/guide/pregnancy.....
a3camero··on I regularly hire women for 65% to 75% of what males make
He did say that this was in "2000".
← PreviousPage 6 of 12Next →