100 karma · joined May 16, 2021
Maybe the real answer is both, though - try to consciously avoid tribal thinking, but also acknowledge that it's likely to creep in anyway, and be aware when it does.
The danger is when you make the fiction of "not having an identity" a big part of your actual identity, which can make you even more blind to your biases than everyone else.
I think a much more productive route to being a more effective thinker is to accept you have an identity just the same as everyone else - and invest time and effort into interrogating what that identity is and what biases and blind-spots it might lead to. This is still far from perfect, of course.
Many people will have already decided before they are 26 that they aren't cut out for leadership because they don't fit the prevailing idea of what a leader is/does.
But imagine saying to an alcoholic: "I can have a few beers on a Friday night and then stop, and so can the majority of my friends, so I dont see what the problem is."
However I would say that a lot of your argument seems to be based on the fact that senior leaders / top performers like to meet in person, so therefore there must be benefits. Have you considered the possibility that the causality is reversed here? The current generation of senior leaders came up before working from home was really possible, therefore are by definition going to be the people who thrive in face to face environment. Conversely people who work more effectively from home (including all the intangibles) are much less likely to currently have reached senior positions. But now working from home is so much more convenient, is there a reason to think that there couldn't be a rebalancing here?
Nobody in the UK (or in England at least, i'm not as familiar with devolved policy) gets paid for full rewilding (in the sense of taking land completely out of production and leaving it, a philosophy most famously espoused in England by the Knepp estate). English agri-environment policy expects some kind of active management of the land taken out of production. There are a range of options farmers can choose which they have to discuss and agree based on the land type and context with a specialist adviser. For bees this might be cultivating a plot of plant species chosen for pollen and nectar, for example.
The payment is calculated on a model based on "income foregone plus costs" so in theory should be worth exactly the same as an equivalent crop on that patch of land (although in practice this obviously varies a bit depending on how marginal the land is and fluctuations in the market). Generally the amount of admin and time required, and the limited funds available, means that nobody is making very much money off this.
The much more broken UK subsidy is the Basic Payment System - a leftover from the EU Common Agricultural Policy. Here farmers are paid a flat rate per hectare for any land used for agriculture - just cash handed over with no incentive to either improve productivity or manage for the environment. For obvious reasons this disproportionately benefits massive landowners. This is thankfully currently being phased out and the funds shifted towards the agri-environment model, which has its problems but at least delivers something.
A and B here are religion and wealth/technology I understand (sort of) the points you are making about wealth, but how does any of this stuff link causally with religion?
If you want to lead a team, or eventually a large organisation, there are worse things you could do than spend 3 years learning about people.
Cost benefit analysis for big complex issues like coronavirus requires the identification and quantification of things that are really difficult to identify and quantify, and there's no easy way to do that without some form of subjective value judgement.
CBA done properly is a good way to make these judgements explicit and transparent. CBA done badly is a good way to hide those judgements behind a load of figures. Neither is dispassionate.