HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

account73466

259 karma · joined October 5, 2019

submissionscomments
account73466··on The AI Index 2019 Report
Go to Google Scholar, type your favorite company and "deep learning". If you find no paper from that company, chances are high their stock price is not beating S&P 500 over the last 5 years.

Also, top S&P 500 companies by market cap are "AAPL","MSFT","GOOG","AMZN","FB","BABA".

account73466··on The AI Index 2019 Report
You see that from papers published at top ML conferences. Top contributors are often from FAANG. Some papers are clearly applications.
account73466··on The AI Index 2019 Report
AI is the term used by marketing division and clueless public. Researchers don't use that term without a special need. FAANG engineers actually use ML approaches.
account73466··on The AI Index 2019 Report
>> Many of the doctoral candidates I knew in school couldn't find positions in academia because of market saturation.

The situation is now drastically different compared to say 40 years ago. That is why so many PhDs leave for industry to be better paid. The latter is possible for CS guys but in other domains the situation is pretty bad since they don't have easily accessible highly paid industry jobs.

account73466··on The AI Index 2019 Report
True but I am not sure "nanotech" was used by top S&P 500 companies and their engineers on a daily basis.
account73466··on The AI Index 2019 Report
>> Diversifying AI faculty along gender lines has not shown great progress, with women comprising less than 20% of the new faculty hires in 2018.

I am wondering what is % of women doing PhD in the same field and whether it is growing. Without the latter number growing it would be hard to have a greater % of women among new faculty hires.

account73466··on Jeff Dean interview: Machine learning trends in 2020
Buying renewable energy does not make your footprint zero. You can twist the definition until it suits your needs but if you properly count footprint of the chain, it cannot be zero.
account73466··on Jeff Dean interview: Machine learning trends in 2020
>> all the stuff we trained in our Google Data Center — the carbon footprint is zero

That is a lie unless Jeff Dean lives under different physics laws.

account73466··on GM’s Former President Calls for the End of Car Ownership
The technological revolution is going to make the top appear to be gods while the bottom, well, the bottom will prey :\
account73466··on GM’s Former President Calls for the End of Car Ownership
Historically the trend of things we don't/won't own: land, house, data, right to have kinds, your body.

Why? One argument that is cooking right now: "you don't know how to properly manage these things to support sustainable progress of humanity (and because you are broke)"

account73466··on Ant Colony Optimization Visualization for the Travelling Salesman Problem
If you will even need to solve TSP, this guy solved it almost optimally for millions of cities

http://webhotel4.ruc.dk/~keld/

This is from my experience of dealing with it more than a decade ago.

account73466··on To Understand the Future of AI, Study Its Past
>> Maybe this time it's different, imho because of Google translate.

Sounds like you are not from the field.

account73466··on To Understand the Future of AI, Study Its Past
>> There is no standalone AI/ML etc... capability that makes money on it's own

You can do trading, no need to have clients in that case.

account73466··on To Understand the Future of AI, Study Its Past
(ii) sounds like a version (iii)+(iv) but it is not because you will not be truly free. If you go (iii)+(iv) via a start-up line, you will not be free either because you will have to deal with customers.

Should come up with something smart and make money. Let's call "be truly smart" (what a smarter AI would do) and not just "academic smart" or "coder smart".

account73466··on To Understand the Future of AI, Study Its Past
>> who have those traits that machines lack, i.e. creativity and vision

I would go further and say that once machines will be able to lie better than humans, we are done.

>> produce high powered tools rather than true autonomous agents

including tools which will help to tell a compelling story and/or lie to people. We can see precursors of these tools appearing during the last few years.

account73466··on To Understand the Future of AI, Study Its Past
We should view AI in the context of the technological revolution. You all have a good approximation of what might happen. The question is what to do.

I believe that since the population size of intelligent agents will grow exponentially fast and pretty soon, one should consider one of the following options

i) Do pretty much the same as before.

ii) Join a FAANG company.

iii) Do PhD+ level research in ML/CS/AI.

iv) Make money as fast as you can.

v) Some option I didn't think about.

If you pick (i), it seems likely that your kids (if any) will have no money or/and power to remain relevant. Pick (ii)+(iv) or (iii)+(iv). The latter seems preferable but it is harder.

account73466··on Police conducted search in the Nginx office due to a copyright claim
Then they would definitely advertise it by attacking the company so that the whole world would know about their secret backdoor. Very smart, indeed!
account73466··on Police conducted search in the Nginx office due to a copyright claim
or maybe or maybe ...
account73466··on If Bitcoin Looks Like It Isn’t Trading, It’s Because It Isn’t
Read again "The currency component of USD doubles every 10 years."

Therefore,

"they do not include any lost money"

is irrelevant unless you believe people lose about half of their money over a single decade

"Not a single person on this planet does any educated decision based on that value. It's completely irrelevant. And that was my whole point."

That is false. Smartest people do take into account the fact that the market cap of USD doubles every decade. Printed money have to go somewhere, they do go in US stocks with the smallest loss on the way. Therefore, US stocks also double every decade. Therefore, it does not make sense to search for investments which deliver less than 8% a year since you are basically losing money relatively to the actual total amount.

>> If you trade fiat/precious metal or similar assets no chart will ever show the mcap of said asset.

Seems like you never traded in your life. First, look at Interactive Brokers, the most popular retail platform. For any stock you click, you see its market cap. Investor do invest differently depending on whether it is large cap or low cap. Google it, learn something. Even Yahoo Finance shows market cap.

You basically have no clue what you are talking about. Not need to reply, you are wasting my time. Cheers.

account73466··on Show HN: Kong – Physical Cryptocurrency
In your paper, why you acknowledge people by their name but you don't disclose your names?
account73466··on If Bitcoin Looks Like It Isn’t Trading, It’s Because It Isn’t
>> Whats the mcap of USD?

Start here https://fred.stlouisfed.org/graph/?id=CURRSL,

and here

https://fredblog.stlouisfed.org/2014/09/how-much-money-is-th...

The currency component of USD doubles every 10 years.

account73466··on U.S. Says Accused Apple Secrets Thief Had Patriot Missile File
>> who is more likely to take American state secrets at company X and give them to China

This sounds very similar to sexist arguments like "who is more likely to better score at work" used to then discriminate. You cannot use just a single feature to classify people in this highly non-linear problem, you will get mostly false-positive predictions.

account73466··on U.S. Says Accused Apple Secrets Thief Had Patriot Missile File
tell them to hate something and they will run their shallow neural networks in a highly predictable manner
account73466··on U.S. Says Accused Apple Secrets Thief Had Patriot Missile File
Do you think it will prevent people here from being racist?

Edit: it will not, I am not Chinese btw

account73466··on If Bitcoin Looks Like It Isn’t Trading, It’s Because It Isn’t
>> Mcap is just a multiplication of the price.

Who claimed the opposite?

account73466··on If Bitcoin Looks Like It Isn’t Trading, It’s Because It Isn’t
Bitcoin is not a currency in its common sense, it is a speculative asset. Call everything meaningless is pretty meaningless as well.

>> Comparing it to the marketcaps of companies is even more meaningless

Wrong.

>> And comparing Bitcoin trade volume with stock trade volume is another meaningless thing.

Wrong.

account73466··on If Bitcoin Looks Like It Isn’t Trading, It’s Because It Isn’t
>> To someone who isn't thinking through what the numbers and their resulting ratios mean, I suppose it sounds authoritative.

Is it an insult, Arnav? Thousands of scientists use my research and they would probably disagree that I am "someone who isn't thinking through what the numbers and their resulting ratios mean".

account73466··on If Bitcoin Looks Like It Isn’t Trading, It’s Because It Isn’t
fixed, thanks
account73466··on If Bitcoin Looks Like It Isn’t Trading, It’s Because It Isn’t
More than 90% of Bitcoin volume is fake, there is no question about that.

However, if you believe Binance's figures then these figures alone are sufficient to support Bitcoin's current market cap in the sense that its volume / market cap is about the same as for well-traded stocks from S&P500. In other words, the claim that the volume is too small is not well supported because it is as small as for other financial assets, e.g., between 0.2-1% of market cap per day.

account73466··on If Bitcoin Looks Like It Isn’t Trading, It’s Because It Isn’t
Returns of top S&P 500 stocks would be around 6-8% annually when computing over say 10-20 years. When dividends are included, you end up with something like 10-12%. However, I don't think it impacts volume by more than some one digit percentage (when average over the whole year) since it happens very occasionally.

>> does that mean you accept that Bitcoin's value is in speculation and not as a currency?

Today, it is a speculative asset.

← PreviousPage 3 of 7Next →