HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

account73466

259 karma · joined October 5, 2019

submissionscomments
account73466··on The Bus Ticket Theory of Genius
There is a trend to demonize the Chinese and Russians governments (it is always about governments but then it translates to companies and then to people). This trend is very useful to promote different kinds of online censorship and put people into political boxes (e.g., you like this then you are that). Basically, when every single piece of material about a country is negative, you get a set of feeling where hate is not the least common. Then you go full paranoia cycle and expect that these same people also will punish you for what you write about them. One can benefit from these tendencies and ride them to get attention and respect of like-minded people, basically sell hate.
account73466··on AI is mostly about curve fitting (2018)
Very well said. Also, curve fitting is not a corner case. Most relevant and intelligent things we care about can be solved with "just" curve fitting + extrapolation.
account73466··on The Bus Ticket Theory of Genius
If you are too successful at something then you are probably too local in your steps/bets - you should make greater steps/bets by risking more in order to increase your overall progress. It is an optimal rule which was mathematically derived for convex functions, see the one-fifth rule at http://ls11-www.cs.tu-dortmund.de/people/beyer/EA-glossary/n.... The ratio itself is problem-dependent but the core idea is beautiful.
account73466··on The revolution of machine learning has been exaggerated
I don't think that people are ranked by talent. This is also true for academia. You don't have to be more talented than the next guy to show better results according to some metric. Right place + right time + avoid confrontations = a huge boost for your success.

See http://data-mining.philippe-fournier-viger.com/too-many-mach...

Roughly speaking, about 50k papers are published every year in arxiv/ML by perhaps 20k different researchers. Since some people still don't publish there, you may say there exists about 50k ML/AI/DL researchers.

Say 5k of them are pushing the field forward, most of them have a PhD. The remaining 45k deliver various local optimizations/adaptations, many of them don't have a PhD. Now it depends on the size of your normal tech hub employer. If it is big, then you have a few people from 5k and many from 45k. Otherwise, a few people from 45k.

account73466··on The revolution of machine learning has been exaggerated
It can be. Still, he made some contribution to the progress in that field. Personally, I don't like the 'Canadian Mafia', I tend to prefer Schmidhuber.
account73466··on The revolution of machine learning has been exaggerated
True. I edited it to be nicer.
account73466··on The revolution of machine learning has been exaggerated
see here http://data-mining.philippe-fournier-viger.com/too-many-mach...
account73466··on The revolution of machine learning has been exaggerated
>> assuming you're the lab director with the hundred workers

You make wrong assumptions and proceed. I am not that person and thus I don't get why you attack me personally.

While AI does not exist yet, that guy contributed to its development independently of your opinion about it.

Don't attack people on HN.

account73466··on The revolution of machine learning has been exaggerated
"how many compiler experts have you worked with"

you meant CS PHDs? because it is a better analogy. My answer would be with many, because I am one of them.

account73466··on The revolution of machine learning has been exaggerated
"a couple hundred years from now" by whom? He contributed to AI, will not be forgotten by AI.

Edit: if you don't get what I mean by "not be forgotten", he will be the most cited scientist so why AI will exclude all his papers from some of its training sets (assuming that at least some stage of AI's development it will learn how humans do research)? Sounds unlikely.

account73466··on The revolution of machine learning has been exaggerated
This person is the most cited scientist in machine learning (when measured by # citations per year) and is about to become the most cited scientist in the whole world. He has a lab of about 100 people and most of his works are at least good. I just provided an estimated. Once you see his citations count has saturated (probably in 5-10 years), you may guess that the hype is over.
account73466··on The revolution of machine learning has been exaggerated
Deep learning still at least doubles every two years, it can be estimated by https://scholar.google.com/citations?user=kukA0LcAAAAJ .
account73466··on Sacha Baron Cohen Uses ADL Speech to Tear Apart Mark Zuckerberg and Facebook
I watched it entirely. He is arguing for censorship (because terrorism, pedophiles and racism), nothing new here. Attacking Facebook of course helps to gain attention of people who are happy to be separated from freedom.
account73466··on Sacha Baron Cohen Uses ADL Speech to Tear Apart Mark Zuckerberg and Facebook
If you want to win against a view, select a leader from your pocket, make him look plausible and make him take control of the whole view. At any point you desire, let that person discredit himself and take the whole view down.

Here, your view "to provide a free speech public platform" is under attack because such platforms would give people freedom and power. We are about to separate people from freedom. So-called "white" people will go first (they still have some power), the others will follow. Technological evolution is brutal.

account73466··on Tesla Cybertruck
No, it is not ugly at all.
account73466··on China
even with that he failed
account73466··on China
No, I am not. I am a white man living in Western Europe. Yet another time, you are wrong.
account73466··on China
How else to turn HN guys to do illegal and/or immoral privacy-related things if not to make them feel that they are doing the right thing?
account73466··on Happiness and Life Satisfaction (2017)
Seems like you are consuming hate.
account73466··on Happiness and Life Satisfaction (2017)
This is not what I meant. I am talking about the change happening in the last few years might be positive w.r.t. what was happening say 10-20 years ago.
account73466··on Happiness and Life Satisfaction (2017)
>> Actually I know a guy who had in a bar fight after a scenario you just described. He's still fine at his job.

It is not like you are going to be fired if you are a software engineer talking a bit about your life. However, "bringing you shit" and discussing it at work is not always welcomed especially in most competitive environments. I guess that people who worked in such environments know what I am talking about.

As an example, have a look at what two other users reply above.

account73466··on Happiness and Life Satisfaction (2017)
So you would be fine to share at work that your gf cheated on you and left for another dude and so you are a little bit destabilized/unhappy now? (it is just a hypothetical case)
account73466··on Happiness and Life Satisfaction (2017)
Happiness is often about the change of your state rather than about the state itself.
account73466··on Happiness and Life Satisfaction (2017)
>> That implies that not only they are not that happy but they are systemically lying for some reason. I find this scenario hard to believe.

Hmm, I find it believable that people may systematically lie when asked at work whether they are happy with their personal life.

account73466··on Offshore wind will be a $1T industry by 2040, but it's needed now
>> I think your post fell victim to that.

My post raised a question and wasn't based on the papers you mentioned but based on what I was told by wind farm engineers (e.g., that many farms are not green positive when accounting for everything even when accounting for futures years of exploitation). After working in academia for years, I believe that there is a much higher likelihood of a paper being rejected if it shows that large wind farms harm local environment. It is basically $1T of interests and "green-greeen!" people against people who will figure out what happens only years later.

account73466··on Offshore wind will be a $1T industry by 2040, but it's needed now
Thanks for the links! The "green ... greeen!" guys just downvoted me to hell.
account73466··on Offshore wind will be a $1T industry by 2040, but it's needed now
Will wind turbines accelerate climate change?

edit: during its exploitation

I was involved in design of Wind Farms and they affect wind directions at least locally. Naturally, they change climate locally. The question is how local is not global enough.

account73466··on AI-generated fake content could unleash a virtual arms race
>> maybe in the future we will trust again only some "trusted sources" (newspapers? HN?) while everything else will be not taken into account because the quality will be low (like some comments saying the source is not in the industry...)

Do you realize that current conversational NNs are better at making comments than you?

account73466··on Mexican mammoth trap provides first evidence of prehistoric hunting pits
It is hi-story.
account73466··on Twitter wants feedback on its proposed deepfakes policy
nothing to do with America, it is worldwide and thousands years long.
← PreviousPage 5 of 7Next →