HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

acslater00

1,569 karma · joined November 13, 2010

Twitter: @acslater00
submissionscomments
acslater00··on Uber-Style Flight-Sharing Service Shot Down by U.S. Court
I'm of two minds on this one, but the mind that says 'glad it's being shut down' is winning.

I'm a private pilot / IFR with around 250 hours of pilot-in-command time in single engine planes (I'm guessing that's square in the middle of this company's target pilot demographic). I have a full-time job and fly recreationally. On numerous occasions I've flown friends and relatives e.g. from Palo Alto to the LA area and asked them to split flight costs. Also, while I've never done this personally, it's pretty common for pilots to seek out other pilots on message boards and the like to "split time" on some flight, where cost is split and both pilots can log some flight time.

So on the one hand, if this app were just an enhancement of that same basic pattern ... I'm flying to LA who wants to look down at I-5 traffic from 4500 feet ... then I would think it's great.

The problem is that this service is clearly intended to be more than that. And when you start getting customers who don't understand general aviation and have expectations that my Flyte(?) will run like an airline (or at least air taxi) when it will not be, you have a bad situation.

To give one concrete example, once after promising to take someone on a tour of the golden gate bridge area, dragging her to the airport, doing a pre-flight inspection, and taxiing all the way to the runway, I made a last minute decision to cancel after a new weather report freaked me out a bit. She understood, and we rescheduled. If the person next to me were not a close friend but in fact a "paying customer", perhaps business person with a meeting that afternoon in LA, would I have felt pressured to fly into an unsafe situation? Probably! This is one of several scenarios where the service just seems like a bad idea, from both a pilot and passenger perspective.

I really hate being on the side of 'regulators' in any dispute, but flying is meaningfully different from driving a car. General Aviation already has a reputational problem with sloppy, low-experience pilots putting themselves and their families in danger, and frankly I don't think adding unwitting customers to the mix is going to help the situation at all.

acslater00··on Bernie Sanders' 404 page
I'll bet we've got a lot of "political experts" but probably not that many political experts.
acslater00··on California has about one year of water left
This is not true. Demand for water is inelastic in the short term only.

The (obvious) effect of increasing water prices over the medium and long term would be the displacement of water hungry crops such as almonds and rice, as it would no longer be economical to farm them in California. The equilibrium level of water consumption would be much lower as a result.

acslater00··on Detecting duplicate images with Python
Here is my question for OP. It seems like the image shrinking step coupled with the transformation to +/- values loses so much information that the hash would suffer from big false positive problem. I would have loved to see some data on this based on their own dataset.

To give a concrete example, I noticed recently that a lot of app store icons within a category look pretty similar. See for example this:

https://twitter.com/acslater00/status/450127865682489344/pho...

All of those checkmarks certainly seem to my naked eye like they the binary diff transformation would result in a very identical hash. It seems like the rounded corners in 'Finish' would blur out, and the texture in 'OmniFocus 2' would blur out, and the gradient in 'Clear' would look identical to a flat gradient on the right side of the checkmark.

Anyway, clever algorithm but curious how it works in practice on small icons?

acslater00··on The Founder Visa (again)
I completely respect that, and I'm certainly not about to argue with a YC alum about the value of YC on the YC community forum. But there is a world of difference between trading equity for mentorship vs trading equity for a visa [+ mentorship]. It will obviously never happen, but if it did the program would be unrecognizable.
acslater00··on The Founder Visa (again)
This is a great idea, can I do this too?? The government can give me 100 visas to allocate, and I'll give them to international entrepreneurs whom I consider to be deserving and who incidentally and in a totally non quid-pro-quo fashion agree to sell me a 7% stake in their companies for a nominal fee.

I'll also buy them pizza once a week, if that sweetens the pot.

acslater00··on The Couple That Pays Each Other to Put Kids to Bed
"Danny paid Bethany about $30,000 in various costs to have their first child while he worked a full-time tech job"

I wonder what her bid was for him to have the baby.

acslater00··on How Silicon Valley CEOs conspired to drive down tech engineer wages
Yeah hate to spoil the party, but this is not 'wage theft'. Wage theft is very specifically the act of withholding wages that an employee is entitled to according to the terms of his or her employment agreement.

What happened here is not even 'price-fixing', it's a fairly weak attempt at 'collusion'. Yes, it seems improper at first blush and the email exchanges are almost comically incriminating, but my guess is that it didn't really have a substantial effect on the engineer salaries write large (or even executive salaries). Agreeing not to cold-call employees is not the same thing as refusing to hire them; that latter would have had a major depressing effect on wages (kind of like if all MLB teams had a handshake agreement to never sign another team's free agent) but that clearly isn't what happened here.

It seems to me like the proof is in the pudding. If big tech companies are colluding to depress engineer wages, they're pretty obviously failing.

Anyway, I have no idea how this lawsuit will shake out, but I know that Pando Daily is doing a shit-ass job of reporting, and I regret clicking on the link and giving them the additional pageview.

acslater00··on Demonstration at Home of Google Developer. Google Bus Blocked in Berkeley
Welcome to Berkeley, I guess.

Honestly, it was only a matter of time before the dissident left decided that the software community was just another monied enemy for them to hate.

The good news is that nobody really takes them seriously, so if you can tolerate the occasional impotent protest and the (very) occasional WTO-style near riot, you can proceed with your life and ignore them.

acslater00··on Swiss salary cap fails at ballot box
Agree that it is the more interesting referendum.

Tyler Cowen wrote about these sorts of proposals a week ago and I really think he hits the nail on the head. Like many, I'm attracted on an intellectual level to the idea of replacing the thicket of social services and redistribution programs with a single basic income. The problem is I simply can't imagine a world where a real-world government could commit credibly to that sort of policy long term. There's just way too much to be gained by saying, "well the GBI is great, but I think this group does need something a _little_ more than everyone else. And then instead of replacing the thicket, it just becomes part of it, and at that point has very little to recommend it as policy.

I also agree it would be interesting to see a country other than mine try it out so we could see the effects play out.

Cowen:

http://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2013/11/wha...

acslater00··on In Fed and Out, Many Now Think Inflation Helps
I'm happy to see this article written, and it will hopefully start to change the attitude of evaluating central bank actions through the lens of 'high inflation bad, low inflation good'.

This whole debate is an unfortunate example of what's called "Partial Equilibrium Reasoning" (as opposed to "General Equilibrium Reasoning"). All things being equal, higher inflation is bad. That's clear. But all things aren't equal, and so appeals to logic about how inflation is a hidden tax on 'the people' and so forth are essentially worthless when applied to real-world situations.

Here's why. One weird thing about inflation is that inflation expectations become a self-fulfilling prophecy, because when people predict inflation, they demand escalating prices on things like 10-year leases and labor contracts, and when they don't predict inflation, they don't.

The situation today, in 2013 America, and not fake-year hypothetical-country in your economics textbooks, is that inflation expectations are extremely low. They are low because inflation is essentially a by-product of economic expansion, and most people predict that economic expansion will be weak for the foreseeable future.

As it turns out, the reverse of this is true. If people expected the economy to start growing strongly, their inflation expectations would likely rise, which would probably be enough all-on-its-own to cause inflation to rise. Weird, right?

So it turns out that if the economy were to strengthen, one thing you'd notice in the data would be slightly higher inflation. And you'd go, "Well that's no good, but at least the economy is improving!" And you would be looking at a General Equilibrium in which most people are better off even though inflation is slightly higher, because many other things (Nominal Growth, Real Growth, Unemployment, Long-Term Interest Rates for savers) would be moving in the _good_ direction.

This dynamic is why the Fed needs to break the attitude that its job is to keep inflation as low as possible. The worst thing that could happen in the above scenario is for people to think 'Uh oh, inflation is going up, that means the Fed will probably raise interest rates', which would have the (expected) effect of reducing economic growth. But we need growth! And we need to accept that a few percentage points of inflation will be a by-product of that in a healthy economy.

So to summarize, the issue here is not that inflation is good. It's that there is more to this picture than inflation, and that if you have a dogmatic belief that inflation is evil in all situations and should be avoided, you've probably read too much Hayek and it has melted your brain.

[sorry, had to drop a snipe]

acslater00··on 59% of the 'Tuna' Americans Eat Is Not Tuna
This headline is preposterously misleading.

This is a link to the actual study. Page 16 is relevant.

http://oceana.org/sites/default/files/reports/National_Seafo...

The group tested 114 tuna samples. Of those 114, 66 were of a fish that the vendor was calling "White Tuna". Have you ever eaten something called White Tuna? Neither have I. It's a fairly unpopular sushi fish sold sparsely around the country.

Why does it make up more half the sample, you might ask? Well, it turns out there is essentially no such thing as White Tuna. Hence 94% of the samples are "mislabeled." [the authors assert that a certain type of albacore tuna sold in a certain form counts as 'white tuna', which accounts for the 6% of correct labels] If your goal was to achieve a result which shows lots of mislabeling, a good strategy would be to considerably oversample 'white tuna'.

They took 48 more samples of tuna other than 'white tuna'. Notably, that didn't include anything from a can, which is by a WIDE margin what most americans think of when they think of tuna. Nevertheless, of those 48, they determined that five were "mislabeled" due to the tuna actually being a substituted variety of tuna. In other words, all 48 were 'tuna', though perhaps not 'albacore' or the specific type it claimed to be.

So where does that leave us? More than half of the samples were of a fish known to be commonly "mislabeled" by standard industry practice, and the rest of the mislabelings were substitutions of one type of tuna for another. In no universe does that lead to the conclusion that 59% of the tuna Americans consume is not actually "tuna". I would venture that no one reading this comment has ever eaten a piece of tuna that was not actually from a tuna fish (though _maybe_ they lied about which specific variety you were eating).

This organization has a history of running biased studies and then churning out ridiculous charts and headlines to push on local newspapers. They ran with a version of this story in New York City around a year ago. It's nonsense. Eat your tuna and enjoy it.

acslater00··on Are These The Most Ridiculous/Awesome Startup Perks Ever?
SeatGeek started giving everyone $100 a month to spend on live event tickets. It doesn't accrue -- use it or lose it. I think concert attendance in the office has increased 5x since the new policy was started. Not quite a beach vacation, but fun!
acslater00··on The Stock Market vs. the Labor Market
Couple things here.

First, corporate profits are aberrantly high for a number of reasons, none of which are likely to be permanent. John Hussman, an analyst whom I respect deeply, has a good discussion of this from the perspective of stock valuations, but the basic point is relevant here. [http://www.hussmanfunds.com/wmc/wmc130408.htm]

Second, while I agree that this is "the story" in a purely journalistic sense, it's important not to get too carried in discussions about relative income distributions and miss the forest for the trees, as it were.

Income inequality is not an informationally useful statistic on its own. Income inequality can be thought of as a measure of the strength of incentives in a system. Those incentives can be good or bad on their own. In 3rd world nations, income inequality is a reflection of the strong incentive to be corrupt and steal. In the closed system of Goldman Sachs, income inequality (among employees) is a measure of the incentive to achieve annual performance targets. In the context of the public education system, it is a measure of the incentive to achieve seniority and bureaucratic promotions. In startups it reflects the incentive to get acquired or IPO. Et cetera.

In the United States, when people say that income inequality is too high, what they're usually thinking is that the wrong things are being incentivized and rewarded. That's a fine discussion to have, and I would agree that certain industries [health care jumps immediately to mind] suffer from deep and severe incentive problems that are reflected when you look at income distributions within those sectors.

But the problem is not the income distribution; it's the fact that income is being distributed unequally for the wrong reasons. That is the conversion people should be having.

acslater00··on The Ivy League Was Another Planet
4H and ROTC are many things, but they are not "generic leadership clubs without a specific purpose". Both groups are much more akin to something like the Boy Scouts, as they demand substantial amounts of time and effort, and give achievements for the mastery of specific skills.
acslater00··on Bitcoin: The Cyberpunk Cryptocurrency
"You are correct that it is not designed to be a stable store of value. Gold shares a similar problem. Price stability is probably not going to be one of Bitcoin's strong suits, for sure. It's primary role might be simply as a highly liquid store of value that cannot easily be controlled by a central authority, which is still incredibly profound."

This I think the fundamental problem with the Bitcoin movement in a nutshell. Once you get past the grandiose claims, the fact that Bitcoin is inadequate as a store of value reduces it to an instantaneous transfer means only. But think through the implications of that. Its volatility makes it inappropriate for any transactions which are not instantaneous. Your rent will not be denominated in Bitcoin. Neither will your salary. No loans will be denominated in Bitcoin. Equity arrangements for companies, purchasing contracts, your savings accounts, none will use Bitcoin due to the volatility. So the Bitcoin economy is still dependent on traditional currencies, which means all of these purported benefits of avoiding currency debasement and the like simply don't exist!

acslater00··on Bitcoin: The Cyberpunk Cryptocurrency
Bitcoin seems to be in another bubble, so I'm going to wade back into this insane discussion.

There are two main goals of "money". To facilitate exchange, and to store value.

Bitcoin is moderately good at the first one and atrocious at the second one. It is not designed to be a stable store of value. It is designed to _appreciate_ in value, but this encourages intense speculation that results in wild, sickening swings in the exchange rate. It's at best a goofy but terrible idea, and at worst has all the red flags of an outright pyramid scheme.

If you want to read Rothbard and convince yourself that "currency debasement" caused the fall of the Roman empire, that modern monetary policy is going to lead to a Zimbabwean dystopia, and that you can solve all of these problems by dropping us into the hard-money currency policies of the 1800s [that, for the record, didn't actually work all that well], go right ahead. There are subreddits for this sort of thing.

But if you're going to stand here and imply that Bitcoin is a superior store of value to the US dollar, well I cannot abide that sort of nonsense, sir. Not one bit.

acslater00··on The Street Kids of San Francisco
This story reminds me a lot of this old "Hipster Animals" gag.

http://hipster-animals.tumblr.com/post/5609675345/raccoon

acslater00··on Why a Transaction Fee Matters to You
Bad mortgages are one type of large, illiquid unhedged asset, yes. But my general point is that the main danger to large institutions is a huge asset that loses value very quickly and can't be easily sold. If you accumulate too many of those, other banks can lose faith in your ability to meet short-term obligations, and then you're essentially up the creek. That is exactly what happened during the 08 panic.

As for #2, the main way trading shifts from assets to derivatives is this template: the government says I have to pay a tax if you sell me one share of AAPL. Instead, you sell me a contract that says, "if the price of AAPL changes by $X, I will give you $X. This is financially equivalent to a sale of AAPL stock for both parties, but does not require you to transfer ownership of a share of AAPL stock, and so you can avoid the transaction tax. Even if the US tries to impose the transaction tax on the derivative, it can be moved offshore, and thus avoid the tax.

What I just described is a simplified version of a Contract For Difference (CFD), as mentioned by another commenter. But there are innumerable other sorts of derivatives that could accomplish the same basic purpose.

acslater00··on Why a Transaction Fee Matters to You
This is a terrible idea that for some reason keeps cropping up again and again. The major problem facing the Global Financial System(tm) is not high-frequency trading, it is large, illiquid, unhedged assets held by systemically important financial institutions. The nature of an illiquid asset is that it is traded infrequently, which makes it especially un-affected by a transaction tax.

OTOH, a tax like this may discourage high-frequency trading [despite it not being at all a systemic risk], but it also discourages certain legitimate and extremely useful forms of hedging, such as large notional currency swaps [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Currency_swap]. And in the likely event that some esoteric forms of derivatives are exempt from the tax [they may be executed overseas, or just be exempted from the statute due to lobbying pressure] then it will encourage banks to shift trading activity from actual assets to much-more-fragile derivatives.

Bottom line: it's very likely that the net result of any Tobin Tax type implementation will be to actually make the Global Financial System(tm) more dangerous. And that's assuming you can actually discourage HFT, which is not at all clear. It will probably just migrate to some island that sets up a tax-shelter exchange.

I have no great love for HFT, but this proposal is the epitome of dangerous, populist feel-goodery. It makes no regulatory sense, and the fact that the Europeans keep threatening to hold hands and jump over this cliff together should not make you think that it is in any way good public policy.

acslater00··on Employees leave managers, not companies
Anecdotally, I spent 2 years at Microsoft (MSN division). I loved my manager to death, and telling him I was leaving felt kind of like breaking up with a long-term girlfriend. But MSN was a supremely depressing place to work because there was a palpable sense that nothing we did mattered, and Microsoft was simply running out the clock on those [hundreds of millions] of people who haven't figured out how to change their browser homepage away from msn.com. I left the company, not the person.

So while the lesson of this post -- that managing is important and a good manager can greatly increase employee retention -- is well taken, the headline is certainly overstated.

acslater00··on The SeatGeek Event Recommendations API
It can be done fast enough. There is some pre-processing of the raw data at startup time, so all we store in memory is a matrix representation of our user/artist preference graph.

A typical preference calculation for a new arbitrary set of artists takes 50-100ms, at which point it is cached for a while. Our most common queries [individual performers, for example] tend to read from cache, which helps.

acslater00··on The 50 million dollar lie
As far as I can tell, the author breaks the universe of teachers into 5% groups and then proceeds to show that the percentile groups are ordinally stable between these two years. In other words, the top scoring group in year 1 beat all other groups in year 2, and so forth, with perhaps some slight shuffling in the absolute middle of the distribution [hard to see on the graph].

This is supposed to be evidence that the correlation is weak??

acslater00··on Bitcoin exchange hacked via Rails exploit, funds stolen
That is an absolutely terrible lesson to draw from this episode.

First and most importantly, Airbnb and Uber are not disrupting industries burdened primarily by consumer safety regulations; they are disrupting industries burdened primarily by barriers to entrance that are designed to direct economic rents to politically favored actors. Huge difference.

There is no plausible 'consumer protection' story for preventing licensed livery cab drivers from picking up curb hails, whether on the iphone or otherwise. The law is there to protect the incomes of people who buy cab licences.

There is no plausible 'consumer protection' story that would explain why building codes for permanent residence are not good enough for temporary residence as well. The law is there to protect hotel operators from vacation rental competition.

So let's not compare Bitcoin with Uber and Airbnb, because they are completely different animals.

Bank security regulations, OTOH, ARE designed to protect consumers, although I'd argue that they're mostly unnecessary in practice. Legitimate banks don't get hacked because there are billions of dollars at stake for the banking institution, and their business literally depends on their ability to secure payments. The incentives are there with or without bank regulations.

Bitcoin sites, on the other hand, regularly get hacked because they are fly-by-night operations written by idiots who are probably also trying to steal from you. It's the fake-money equivalent of using www.send-monie-through-me.co.in and then being surprised when you get ripped off.

Bottom line: there is nothing wrong with regulation designed to protect consumers from actual threats. There is everything wrong with regulation designed to protect business from competition. The latter is what needs to be 'disrupted'.

acslater00··on Freicoin: a P2P digital currency delivering freedom from usury
Someone has invented a digital currency based on EVEN more dubious economic ideas than bitcoin itself!

We did it!

acslater00··on Why Workers Are Losing the War Against Machines
Could not disagree more. Education -- especially the University variety -- is clearly at the top of a multi-decade cost cycle, and will become much cheaper as it becomes more digital.

Health care will absolutely be much cheaper in 30 years than it is now. We can provide 1960s-style health care to most people for literally hundreds of dollars / year. The fact that we choose not to because technology has improved quality faster than it has reduced costs is irrelevant. At some point that trend will reverse, and when it does costs will drop dramatically.

Construction costs are mostly driven by labor costs these days, and as construction is mechanized those will trend towards the cost of raw materials. Obviously there's a sort of theoretical floor there, but even the cost of extracting metal ores from the earth has dropped substantially as technology has improved.

All of these things trends are pointing in the same direction; they are just moving at different speeds.

acslater00··on Why Workers Are Losing the War Against Machines
Yet another example of the "all labor is manufacturing" fallacy.

A future where machines displace most of what we currently think of as blue collar workers is a future where most of the things blue collar workers currently produce are much, much, cheaper than they are now. This author worries whether blue collar jobs will pay "subsistence" wages. They will, because the cost of subsistence [and indeed, the cost of a fairly satisfied life] will be lower.

As machines become better at manufacturing and hard labor, unskilled "work" will shift from physical to service industries. That's good! It's been happening for the past century. Unskilled physical labor is hard, especially as you get older and banged up.

A mechanized future is one where physical resources are plentiful. People will figure out a reason to trade them. Humanity will be fine.

acslater00··on Inside Team Romney’s whale of an IT meltdown
I'm not so sure. Intentionally disruptive behavior by the opposition -- or even some motivated kid who wanted to cause trouble for the campaign -- would be one of my biggest concerns if I were designing this thing.
acslater00··on Inside Team Romney’s whale of an IT meltdown
It would give me more pause if Mitt Romney were involved personally in this sort of a project.
acslater00··on Hidden Fortunes of Chinese Leaders
Well I don't know about the rest of you, but I'm surprised that in a centrally-managed, state-controlled, corporatist economic system, the family of the most powerful individual in the nation would have managed to amass great personal wealth. That just runs counter to all of my instincts, and if these stories are true, it would really be the first time this sort of thing happened throughout history.

I'm shocked, really. I would have thought the People's Republic of China is above this sort of thing.

← PreviousPage 2 of 4Next →