HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

acslater00

1,569 karma · joined November 13, 2010

Twitter: @acslater00
submissionscomments
acslater00··on The Self-Destruction of the 1 Percent
I have several comments.

1. We're talking about literally 400 years between the height of Venetian power and the creation of the Libro d'Oro (1315) and its decline (17th to 18th century). Forgive me if I'm not quite ready to accept the author's core premise here.

2. This sentence made me LOL:

"Public schools are starved of funding... This is the new Serrata".

The premise of the statement, that public schools are starved of funding, is preposterous. NYC spends upwards of $20,000 per pupil per year. But even beyond that, comparing moderate variation in school funding levels to the creation of an ACTUAL OLIGARCHY is just, hack-city. That might be the kind of tortured analogy that gets you a favorable slot in the NY Times during election season, but it's sheer nonsense. Look, I can make any argument, on any part of the political spectrum, that way!

"High income taxes ... this is the new Serrata."

"Occupational licensing ... this is the new Serrata."

"Immigration limits ... this is the new Serrata."

"The Yankees spending $200m a year on their payroll ... this is the baseball Serrata."

acslater00··on A Skeptic Looks at Alternative Energy
Fair enough.
acslater00··on A Skeptic Looks at Alternative Energy
The future of energy is natural gas. End of story.

Alternative natural gas production -- "fracking" generally -- has been researched, prototyped, implemented, and grown over the past 15-20 years to the point where one can reasonably envision a future where natural gas displaces coal and crude oil to become the most important energy sources in the world.

It emits way less carbon than coal or oil, it is everywhere, it can be liquified relatively cheaply and transported around the world by super tanker, people are less afraid of it than nuclear power, and the technology to actually use it has been around forever. Electricity...home heating...hydrogen fuel cells...all easy with natural gas.

As a general rule, when The Economist publishes a 14-page spread about something, it's pretty much hit the mainstream. They did that 2 weeks ago. http://www.economist.com/node/21558432

acslater00··on Automated Job Rejection
There is a moderately interesting point to be made here that automated candidate screening software is not a panacea, and while it can do a good job of filtering through the hundreds or thousands of applicants that might materialize for a single post, it might cause you to miss out on a good fit.

On the other hand, this article is laden with so much hyperbolic moralizing that it makes me take almost none of it seriously.

One of SeatGeek's founders (where I work) has written repeatedly about the insane problem of managing job applications [http://jackg.org/screening-with-an-arbitrary-test]. This is not a self-inflicted wound. We're talking dozens to hundreds of actually unqualified applicants for individual jobs, and the idea that a 15 person company is going to carry someone around for 6 months while they're "trained" is ludicrous.

It is absolutely true that there is a skills-gap in some industries. [Software is one of them]

It is absolutely true that a bad hire is more expensive than a non-hire.

It is absolutely true that some HR departments are breath-takingly incompetent, although most have a pretty good handle on their needs and cost structures, to be perfectly honest.

All that said, trying to spin this into a "the corporations are destroying the country!" story is beyond idiocy.

acslater00··on Scaling lessons learned at Dropbox, part 1
For the record, I use sqlalchemy 0.6.6 regularly under fairly heavy load, and have never had a problem with it. Any 'sqlalchemy bugs' are inevitably coding mistakes on my part.
acslater00··on StackOverflow Man Remakes Net One Answer at a TIme
"But the biggest reason for the site’s success is the use of game mechanics."

No. No no. No. It isn't.

The biggest reason for the site's success is that it provides a really broad range of useful and detailed content in a useable (and search-indexable) format and doesn't charge for it. It helps that there is a community of thousands (millions?) of developers who need this information on a daily basis and keep going back to the site out of necessity.

If the lesson you take from Stack Overflow is "Wow, I should really add game mechanics to my site. That'll do the trick!" you are simply beyond help.

acslater00··on Chomsky - Jobs aren't coming back
I don't know why I keep bothering to point this out, but the notion that "America no longer makes things" is absolutely, empirically, unassailably false.

See this: http://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/series/OUTMS

And a prior discussion of the topic.

http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3803022

Anybody who starts a discussion decrying the death of manufacturing in America is selling you something, and it's not a manufacturing job.

Sidebar: This quote!

"The workforce and the union offered to buy it, take it over, and run it themselves. The multinational decided to close it down instead, probably for reasons of class-consciousness."

Aside from the fact that this story is clearly made-up, the idea that a profit-seeking corporation would favor "shutting down" an asset rather than selling it because it fears an uprising of the working class is just about the stupidest fucking thing I've ever heard.

acslater00··on Occupy.com Launches in Time for May Day Protests
Are they also launching a time-machine to bring us back to last October when anyone cared about them?
acslater00··on How Apple Sidesteps Billions in Taxes
That's great. If apple makes $1b, if the bulk of the money is held by a foreign SUBSIDIARY, my stock will go up, and I will pay capital gains. If they give it to me as a dividend, I will pay taxes on that. If they reinvest it in the company and the investment makes money, my stock will go up even more. And if they reinvest it in the company and squander it all, no taxes will be collected on the income, but they won't be able to write the loss off anything either.

The only thing that truly captures the vagaries of 'where money is held' is the stock price. Wall Street don't care if that money is in New York or Guatemala, if Apple has it it's making the stock go up.

acslater00··on How Apple Sidesteps Billions in Taxes
The actual appreciation of their investments would be higher if you eliminated corporate income tax. And you would still get to defer payment until you sell the actual investment.

Properly designed, it all evens out.

acslater00··on How Apple Sidesteps Billions in Taxes
There is a really important lesson from all of this, and it is not that Apple is wrong for rationally exploiting global tax laws to avoid paying US taxes.

The fact that California has no tax jurisdiction in Nevada, and that the US has no tax jurisdiction in Ireland, is an unassailable fact of life. Tax laws are subject to regulatory competition like many other things, and ignoring that -- insisting that this is an issue of morality or fairness -- is silly.

If the US had a globally competitive corporate tax rate (say 15%), it would make most of these tactics irrelevant. There's no need to shelter income in Ireland if they have the same tax rates. Because of the reduced sheltering, such a reform would probably raise revenue on net. But even if it didn't, it would have many ancillary benefits, such as repatriating many billions of dollars in corporate profits and increasing the degree to which they are deployed in the US, which would far exceed the costs.

Even better would be to reduce corporate income tax to 0% and increase dividend and capital gains rates to personal-income-tax levels to make up for it. The main reason dividend income is treated preferentially in the US is that corporate profits are already being taxed (in theory). Those multi-level nature of the US tax code creates unnecessary loopholes, as well as costs and confusion. Counter-intuitively, eliminating the corporate income tax would make it much easier to tax corporate income, because those profits necessarily flow back to investors either in the form of dividends or capital gains. If you are a resident of the US (and california) and you own 1 apple share, you pay taxes on your share of Apple's income. Even better, it would be progressive. Rich people pay more, poorer people pay less.

Simple, right?

acslater00··on A High Frequency Trader's Apologia, Part 1
They don't pay "transaction fees" in the way you think about them. The way it generally works is you pay when you "remove liquidity" from the book and you get paid when you "add liquidity" to the book.

What does that mean? Suppose the bid/ask is 20.00/20.10 as in the example given. The order book will show a bunch of people willing to pay 20.00, 19.99, 19.98, etc, and a bunch of people willing to sell for 20.10, 20.11, 20.12, and so on. All of those people have added "liquidity" to the book by making orders which have not yet been placed. The idea is that a huge buyer could come in and try to buy 1 million shares at 20.25, and that order could get immediately executed because of the backlog of non-executed orders.

If you bid 20.10 (i.e. offer to buy the stock at 20.10) the seller at the top of the book will have his order executed (with you) and you will have removed a tiny bit of liquidity from the book. On the other hand, if you bid 19.95, your order just gets added to the system, and you have added a bit of liquidity.

The exchanges will charge you slightly more for removing liquidity (say .05 / share) than they pay you for adding liquidity (say .04 /share) and so make a spread. However, high frequency strategies can be clever about the way they add and remove orders to the book in order to minimize their net transaction costs, and so they end up being rather low.

On the other hand, when a retail investor purchases a stock through Schwab or something, Schwab (or in many cases some other larger bank) is dealing with exchange fees directly, and simply charging their customer a flat commission on top of your trade.

acslater00··on How to understand half of Harry Potter book in any language (+ source code)
TL;DR Nearly half of the word occurrences in Harry Potter are prepositions, so if you learn a small number of them you can claim that you "understand half of Harry Potter". For example, you can absorb sparking dialogue like the following:

"Harry and to at to I to with Voldemort or what to and I do for, Hermoine!!"

acslater00··on The Beer Game -or- Why Apple Can’t Build iPads in the US
That's a myth. The US has a huge and growing manufacturing base. We make airplane engines, medical devices, computer chips; all kinds of complex, high-tech manufacturing. We have the highest manufacturing productivity per worker in the world. What we don't make anymore are the kinds of products that require rote assembly tasks, like shoes and clothes and iPads. The upshot is that we have decreasing manufacturing employment even as the manufacturing sector grows rapidly.

Would it surprise you to learn that US manufacturing output looks like this?

http://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/series/OUTMS

acslater00··on Baby Boomers: We had it all, and still do.
Wow this article couldn't miss the point by a wider margin if it tried.

Unionization reinforces seniority hierarchy, which hurts young people. The current social security and medicare system reinforces a young-funds-old mentality, which hurts young people. The higher education system, which has been bloated after years of public subsidy, requires normal people to take on debt, which hurts young people. Deficit spending leads to future taxation, which hurts young people.

Conservative, free-market types have been saying all of this for well over 30 years. Government support of inefficient institutions causes them to become more expensive and even more inefficient, and the after a while everyone becomes dependent on the support. But when everyone is dependent on government support, then there's no one paying for the support, and the whole system comes crashing down. And here we are in 2012, watching it happen in higher education, in health care, in housing, and in state and local governments all around the country.

What exactly is the author proposing as a solution; some sort of uber-occupy-wall-street movement that will flip over cars and demand a new wave of the sorts demonstrably unsustainable institutions we have now? These industries are BEGGING to be liberalized (in the original sense of the word). Ron Paul is a bit of a lunatic, but a path forward that truly expands opportunities for young people is going to look a lot more like a Paul-ian utopia than a left-ist one.

acslater00··on Need a PhD Topic? How about cops in traffic
As it happens, I studied traffic flow back when I was an undergrad in the context of "agent based modeling".

Agent-based models are basically computer simulations where you throw N 'agents' into an environment with pre-defined rules and then watch how they interact with each other. This setup lends itself perfectly to vehicle-flow; each agent is a car, each car has a model for when it accelerates, when it slows down, when it turns, and so forth. Create enough of them, and you can start to simulate traffic jams and other interesting traffic phenomena.

Now, I have not studied this problem in particular. My research was on the effect of excessive lane-changing on overall traffic throughput (Spoiler: lane-changing tends to cause traffic to slow down behind the lane-changer, which means that system-wide lane-changing leads to traffic jams, but changing lanes is a strictly superior strategy for individual drivers in most situations. The classic collective-action problem. Economics!)

However, it seems to me that it would be relatively simple to extend a traditional AB traffic model to include special vehicles that impose constraints on nearby cars.

If any of you are interested, there is an excellent java library developed at UChicago called Repast [http://repast.sourceforge.net/index.html] which contains a framework for building agent-based models.

You may also be interested in my favorite book on the subject, "Micromotives and Macrobehavior" [http://www.amazon.com/Micromotives-Macrobehavior-Lectures-Pu...] which is more rigorous than its Amazon description would have you believe.

acslater00··on PHP: v8.js
Yo dawg, I heard you like javascript.
acslater00··on Pandas 0.7.0 released: Python data analysis library
Pandas is literally in my top 3 favorite open-source projects. I use v0.6x regularly and it is absolutely fantastic. Highly recommend. Can't wait to try some of these new features as well.
acslater00··on The Zuckerberg Tax
Let's say I earn 100K a year, steady.

When I move into the 25% band after I hit $1.3m in lifetime earnings, do I have to pay back taxes on the rest of my income that I've been paying 10% on the whole time? If so, then I'm going to owe about 200,000 that year, which is more than my income. "smoothing" not the word I would use here.

Or, do I just start to pay 25% going forward? If so, your plan amounts to a massive tax cut for young people and a massive tax increase for retirees. As a young person, I can live with that, but it's absolutely terrible public policy.

acslater00··on Poll: Do you have a Facebook account?
Sorry, the 32 of you (as of this moment, out of 152) who claim to never have had a facebook account. I call shenanigans. I don't believe for one second that 20% of a sample of hacker news readers never, ever had a facebook account.
acslater00··on This is why I don't give you a job
Nail on the head.
acslater00··on Stanford Free Classes – A review from a Stanford Student
As a stanford CS grad myself, I basically concur. I took this class as a refresher for things I learned back in school. It was perfect for that. But the rigor and difficulty of the class was clearly tailored towards someone like me, who wanted to watch lecture videos over dinner for a few hours a week, rather than a full-time student.

I actually wasn't aware that the online class was being offered for credit in the CS department until reading this. It surprises me that they're doing so.

acslater00··on Mocked And Misunderstood
The term you're looking for is "survivor bias."

We remember the startups that were mocked but became breakout successes. We don't remember the 1000 startups that were mocked because they were terrible ideas, and failed because of it.

acslater00··on The Dumbest Idea In The World: Maximizing Shareholder Value
"Meanwhile real performance was declining. From 1933 to 1976, real compound annual return on the S&P 500 was 7.5 percent. Since 1976, Martin writes, the total real return on the S&P 500 was 6.5 percent (compound annual)."

Hmm...where have I seen those numbers before. Oh right! He's measuring his control period from the bottom of the great depression. Sounds legitimate to me!

This is so hacky it makes me laugh. You can argue that a focus on short-term shareholder value is bad for various reasons, but a focus on long-term shareholder value is incontrovertibly good for shareholders, long-term. In practice, it is also basically equivalent to the author's other view of focusing on "customers", whatever the hell that means. Or focusing on "real performance" metrics like profit, as though you can do one without doing the other.

If CEO pay is tied to long-term stock performance, the problem of gaming the short term earning expectations goes away. Full stop.

My new years resolution is to not click on link-bait anymore.

acslater00··on The Myth of Japan's lost Decade
Actually, there's a very good explanation for how net exports can increase substantially even though official GDP measures decrease; it represents less than 5% of the japanese economy.

Japan's GDP is about $4T right now. Net exports have increased to 200B. Which is, by the author's estimation "a lot". Japan has had an export policy for the past 30 years. The fact that it's managed to create 4 GDP points worth of net exports in the past 20 years is not exactly a ringing endorsement.

What's happened in Japan is that net exports have become a somewhat larger component of a not-rising-very-quickly GDP. Part of that is because exports have increased. But mostly it's because imports have increased more slowly than exports [remember, we're talking net here].

Here are some contextual data points for you:

Incomes in Japan have decreased in nominal [yen] terms. http://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/series/JPNCOMPQDSNAQ?ci...

Domestic Consumption has basically not moved since 1995: http://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/series/JPNPFCEADSMEI?ci...

Manufacturing has basically not changed since 1990 http://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/series/JPNOTPT?cid=3228...

Exports didn't do much for the first "lost decade", but then exploded in the 2000s , then crashed nighmarishly, then picked up again in the last 2 years. http://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/series/JPNEXPORTQDSNAQ?...

The government has run deficits up from 50% of GDP in 1990 to 220% (!) today, which some might say is questionably sustainable http://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/series/GGGDTAJPA188N?ci...

Fewer people work: http://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/series/JPNLFPRNA?cid=32...

And finally, the way that you know things aren't "quite right" is that the currency has been deflating since 1995. http://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/series/JPNGDPDEFQISMEI?...

That, among other things, is what led to the stronger yen, which is actually something that constrains japan's net exports, not helps it.

On a more general note, you can't go to tokyo and say "ooh, look at all the shops, the economy must be doing great" any more than you can go to 5th avenue in new york and say, "wow, tiffany's is full of people, the US economy is gangbusters!" Making that argument is just really, really stupid.

acslater00··on TIME Person of the Year 2011: The Protester
If I organize a protest of Time's complete lack of journalistic credibility, does that make me person of the year???
acslater00··on Oblivious Supreme Court poised to legalize medical patents
Honestly, this is probably the best possible thing.

The reality is that under the Patent Act, things which are not fundamentally "inventions" -- such as software algorithms, genes, and in this case, data correlations -- can legally be granted patents. This is a problem with the Act, not with any given court's interpretation of it, and that is what needs to change.

I can think of no better way to build political support for a major patent reform initiative than a constant stream of human-interest pieces on 60 Minutes where a handsome doctor earnestly explains that he couldn't save Bobby because of a patent claim from some faceless corporate troll.

Software is abstract and complicated. Saving Bobby is emotional and simple. If patents start to impact medicine the way they've impacted software development, they're not going to last very long in their current form.

acslater00··on Panic of the Plutocrats
To steal shamelessly from the George Will piece that Krugman pretends to respond to, "Paul Krugman is a pyromaniac in a field of straw men."
acslater00··on [dead]
I'm being intentionally dismissive of the notion that America is on the cusp of a popular revolt against "the rich", at least to the extent such a revolt takes the form of the occupy wall street movement. I think various establishment Democrat-affiliated groups have taken an obvious interest, since they're hoping (against hope, I'd say) that this will become a counter-balance to the Tea Party. I will happily continue to underestimate them, despite the risk that it will somehow make them stronger.

Also, I'm not saying that our recession is a normal growth/recession cycle. The 'standard' business cycle is (usually) inventory driven and the economy quickly recovers once inventories drain. This is a "balance-sheet" recession. It's driven by excessive consumer (and public) debt, and only goes away once that debt clears the system. "Wall Street" is to blame for excessive debt in the same way that McDonalds is to blame for obesity. They're one side of a two-sided transaction that was taken to excess, and now we have to patiently wait for the consequences to play out.

acslater00··on [dead]
Mortgage backed securities are the epitome of a free-market innovation. The ability to pool mortgages and sell them in chunks essentially allows small investors (say, me, although I did not ever buy a MBS share) to make home loans. That makes home loans easier to come by, which makes homes easier to come by, and it's all delivered by the innovation of the free market.

The bailouts, on the other hand, were quite obviously not a free-market device.

Finally the federal reserve doesn't "give the banking elite a monopoly on money". Although, I honestly don't even know what that means. The federal reserve is supposed to control monetary policy to prevent inflation (good for normal people) and minimize unemployment (good for normal people). They do that by controlling interest rates and "reserve" rules. In other words, they do that by bossing around banks, and manipulating them into making more or fewer loans. That is also not a "free market" system, but there's good reason to suspect it's better than a private money alternative.

← PreviousPage 3 of 4Next →