There's also a conversation to be had about free speech as a cultural norm. I'm within my rights to shout down everything you try to say in a public forum but I think we've seen that society suffers when that's commonplace.
751 karma · joined March 6, 2012
There's also a conversation to be had about free speech as a cultural norm. I'm within my rights to shout down everything you try to say in a public forum but I think we've seen that society suffers when that's commonplace.
How many people have several months, or a year, of runway on their Tarsnap account balance? Meanwhile, there have been cases of people being dead for years[2] with their auto-pay agreements keeping everything humming along while they rot. Keep in mind that recurring payment agreements often aren't cancelled when a credit card number or expiration date changes.[3]
Finally, AWS will give you about five months of unpaid bills before they suspend your account and delete your data.[4] I would assume GCP has a similar policy.
[1]: https://www.tarsnap.com/legal-why.html#PAYMENTINADVANCE
[2]: https://www.cnn.com/2014/03/07/us/michigan-mummified-body-fo...
[3]: https://www.creditcards.com/credit-card-news/card-updater-se...
[4]: https://www.quora.com/What-happens-after-AWS-suspend-an-acco...
I wish I were at a place in my life where the difference between $3/mo and $75/mo ($36/year vs $900/year) is a non-issue, but unfortunately I'm not. So for now my family photos and videos will have to be securely stored with the (probably) slightly sub-par designs of the open source software I'm using.
With GCP/AWS, you can copy and paste a bucket ACL that only allows PUT operations, and enable versioning to ensure nothing can ever be deleted by overwrites.
With tarsnap there is one person who can delete all your existing backups - Colin, because he owns the bucket. And he will for sure within 7 days of your account falling below a $0 balance.[1]
That might be a feature in case you got killed in a car accident and you want some secret to be buried forever. But for me, I'm archiving my family photos/videos and I'd rather AWS keep charging my account and keep my data alive until my estate can sort out my digital data, which could take months.
> it might still make sense for Colin to triple the price of Tarsnap in order to maximise the income from existing users
And there's the rub. I don't like the idea of somebody holding my data hostage. I'll gladly contribute to a Patreon if an open source developer needs recurring support.
It does make me curious though who the target customer is - somebody who's comfortable setting up a Unix CLI tool for their backups (creating a cron job etc.), yet who wants to cede bucket ownership to a 3rd party and pay a 25x markup for the pleasure? I personally don't mind having to click "Create Bucket" in the AWS console if I get to pay $3/mo instead of $75/mo on my 300GB of data. shrugs
However I still think it's accurate to not think of the funds as fully clearing for several days given the nature of the protocol, and that regulation simply forces the banks to be "optimistic" in giving a next-business-day credit.
So your bank is being optimistic and giving you a credit, assuming that no return will happen. A pessimistic or cautious bank would really have to wait several business days to ensure no returns happen before crediting your account.
[1]: https://engineering.gusto.com/how-ach-works-a-developer-pers...
Can users make private forks of cards? For example if I liked some set of cards as a base but needed to make some alterations for my own purposes
But at least Netflix lets me watch videos in HD. Amazon Prime always plays in SD, citing some kind of HDCP violation, even though I'm using the closed-source Nvidia drivers and using a DisplayPort connection from my monitor to graphics card. It's obviously discriminating against Linux because if I boot into Windows I can play Prime videos in HD no problem.
And the first article I came across looking for the latest 2017 number is about Amazon's interest in becoming a bank. Guess the trend validates the dystopian sci-fi trope of multinational conglomerates ruling everything in the future.
[1]: https://www.bloomberg.com/gadfly/articles/2017-10-06/amazon-...
Then the other half of my brain is like "you're expecting the gov't that gave you Operation Chokepoint to do a 180 and suddenly be benevolent?" and "the reason banking is congealing into an oligopoly in the first place is because of the staggering amount of banking regulations churned out by the gov't every year, significantly raising barriers to entry" ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
We have/had that in the US too: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Choke_Point
In this case the federal gov't (FDIC and DOJ) pressured the banks. They even attacked a Constitutionally-protected activity (firearms)
Patents, like any monopoly-granting device, benefit market incumbents much more than encourage new entrants