Even if you still have the cynical perspective of thinking it's all wrong--Christianity took over and nobody calls it a cult anymore. At least give it the dignity of 'religion'.
445 karma · joined August 19, 2016
Even if you still have the cynical perspective of thinking it's all wrong--Christianity took over and nobody calls it a cult anymore. At least give it the dignity of 'religion'.
I find it tricky to think about cases like Yudkowsky (full disclosure I used to read LessWrong a lot), because if he has sufficient credibility then loudly staking your extreme position can indeed move the Overton window.
In the past, college-degree holders were scarce, so a history degree had "economic" value.
It's not that the past valued the humanities more. It's just that good jobs were a thinner slice of society and tended to be filled by the also-thin ranks of degree holders.
I’m sorry but if you really think this is relevant, you just aren’t paying attention. This is my number one giveaway sign that someone just doesn’t have any idea why lots of people are concerned about ai x-risk.
Numbers 1-4 obviously don’t have enormous recent progress nor the funding and mindshare poured into, and pouring in, as consequence.
That is not at all a slam dunk argument. It’s barely anything.
> No, you're capable of learning things. You can't do brain surgery on yourself
What principle do you have for defining self-improvement the way that you do? Do you regard all software updates as "not real improvement"?
>All real things have limitations.
Uh, yep, that doesn't mean it will be as limited as us. To spell it out: yes, real things have limitations, but limitations vary between real things. There's no "imaginary flawless" versus "everything real has exactly the same amount of flawed-ness".
We’re talking about a potential intelligence with none of our hardware limitations or baggage.
Self-improve? My brother in Christ, have you heard of this little thing called stochastic gradient descent?
Then, you could say the exact same thing you're saying now... but in that case, nukes-slash-nuclear-energy still shouldn't be distributed to everyone.
Even nukes-slash-anti-nuke-shields shouldn't be distributed to everyone, unless you're absolutely sure the shields will scale up at least as fast as the nukes.
I don’t think it’s at loggerheads with just-in-time learning or the real opportunity cost of more extensive study. I think it’s just true that hard things are hard whether you like it or not.
Of course any non-STEM field has geniuses, but our impressions—like the parent’s—are formed from averages, and STEM majors are smarter on avg.