HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

adamisom

445 karma · joined August 19, 2016

submissionscomments
adamisom··on Superintelligence: An idea that eats smart people (2016)
Hmm, if it's spreading so much, maybe it's not a cult?

Even if you still have the cynical perspective of thinking it's all wrong--Christianity took over and nobody calls it a cult anymore. At least give it the dignity of 'religion'.

adamisom··on Superintelligence: An idea that eats smart people (2016)
Yudkowsky sticks out because he's weird and his position extreme, but by no means is his p(doom) representative of the increasingly-many worried researchers.

I find it tricky to think about cases like Yudkowsky (full disclosure I used to read LessWrong a lot), because if he has sufficient credibility then loudly staking your extreme position can indeed move the Overton window.

adamisom··on Is history written by the winners?
It's just shorthand for something like "what people (show they) want".

In the past, college-degree holders were scarce, so a history degree had "economic" value.

It's not that the past valued the humanities more. It's just that good jobs were a thinner slice of society and tended to be filled by the also-thin ranks of degree holders.

adamisom··on A warmer planet, less nutritious plants and fewer grasshoppers?
Yep, for example: it'll be better for a lot of agriculture - unexpected indeed
adamisom··on Governance of Superintelligence
> We do not even have a consensus around a working definition of "intelligence"

I’m sorry but if you really think this is relevant, you just aren’t paying attention. This is my number one giveaway sign that someone just doesn’t have any idea why lots of people are concerned about ai x-risk.

adamisom··on Beware of AI pseudoscience and snake oil
Yeah, 'tabooing' the word intelligence could help correct hype, the problem is it could overcorrect: just because you decide to taboo the word, doesn't mean that current-or-future AI isn't "intelligent". Words don't have that power, unfortunately, to make a system "intelligent"--or not.
adamisom··on What is it like to be a bat? (1974) [pdf]
A disturbing extension of that is if there's some M>N such that only some humans possess M (and others N). I think this must be so (I have a Down's-syndrome relative), the disturbing question is if there's a distribution of humans on gradients from N to M (probably M close to N imo).
adamisom··on What is it like to be a bat? (1974) [pdf]
Ha, for me I'd invert your last sentence: I'm skeptical of being sure AI won't be sentient for the same reason.
adamisom··on Google DeepMind CEO says some form of AGI possible in a few years
We don’t all forget about incentives people might have in saying something; but we also don’t all assume that the first convenient explanation is adequate.

Numbers 1-4 obviously don’t have enormous recent progress nor the funding and mindshare poured into, and pouring in, as consequence.

adamisom··on Geoffrey Hinton leaves Google and warns of danger ahead
Of course he was lucky, you should expect that in general for well-known people because selection pressures that led you to hear of them, vs not hear of them, are likely to involve luck.

That is not at all a slam dunk argument. It’s barely anything.

adamisom··on AI's true goal may no longer be intelligence
To me this comment means that, if people care about the results of "intelligence", then probably future computers will "do intelligence" to achieve that, just as calculators actually do do arithmetic.
adamisom··on Spanish climber emerges after 500 days in cave
Please don't "gotcha". This type of critique is lazy and flattens the interesting points raised in the parent. And: sometimes people are projecting, other times they're not.
adamisom··on Yann LeCun and Andrew Ng: Why the 6-Month AI Pause Is a Bad Idea [video]
And what if Ng or LeCun had signed it, would it still be beneath dignity of a response—or are Bengio and Russell’s names not big enough?
adamisom··on Screen time and the young brain – a contemporary moral panic? [pdf]
after all, 15 year old girls’ top concern is how the 2008 crisis hit them
adamisom··on ChatGPT Plugins
>> Us humans are capable of self-improvement

> No, you're capable of learning things. You can't do brain surgery on yourself

What principle do you have for defining self-improvement the way that you do? Do you regard all software updates as "not real improvement"?

>All real things have limitations.

Uh, yep, that doesn't mean it will be as limited as us. To spell it out: yes, real things have limitations, but limitations vary between real things. There's no "imaginary flawless" versus "everything real has exactly the same amount of flawed-ness".

adamisom··on ChatGPT Plugins
.. what? Us humans are capable of self-improvement, but we’re also a kludge of biases through which reason has miraculously found a tiny foothold.

We’re talking about a potential intelligence with none of our hardware limitations or baggage.

Self-improve? My brother in Christ, have you heard of this little thing called stochastic gradient descent?

adamisom··on GPT-4
It's not a false equivalency with respect to the question of overriding concern, which is existential safety. Suppose nukes somehow also provided nuclear power.

Then, you could say the exact same thing you're saying now... but in that case, nukes-slash-nuclear-energy still shouldn't be distributed to everyone.

Even nukes-slash-anti-nuke-shields shouldn't be distributed to everyone, unless you're absolutely sure the shields will scale up at least as fast as the nukes.

adamisom··on Microsoft lays off one of its responsible AI teams
Nah man, it’s just math! Whereas we have souls… or something.
adamisom··on Chicago sold rights to 36k parking meters for $1.2B that generate $200M per year
The S&P 500 companies in particular should pivot to just buying S&P 500 stocks.
adamisom··on The End of the English Major
Agree but with major caveat that students in those majors may be actually improving those skills less than you may be assuming. It’s generally true of most colleges and students that they seem to learn strikingly little as measured by pre/post tests.
adamisom··on IsOdd (and IsEven) as a Service
import { wellIsIt } from ‘isThisPackageNecessary’;
adamisom··on IsOdd (and IsEven) as a Service
is that odd?
adamisom··on Twitter starts limiting how many tweets you can post per day
how synergistic
adamisom··on The continued relevance of Weizenbaum’s warnings
Well, I hope it’s not possible !
adamisom··on The continued relevance of Weizenbaum’s warnings
I'm only addressing a fraction of your many excellent points, but: this is actually why uncontrolled AGI is so spooky. It's the prospect of a future where space gets colonized-or whatever crazy goal(s)-but there's "nobody home", no qualia, no experiencer.
adamisom··on $6.96B was raised by private longevity companies in 2022
That's a good point. At the same time, more chances (to discover an electric life) is better. But your point really matters because however long you live, youth will only be a fraction of that (and I do expect that one's relatively-unencumbered and energetic years are better... if used well--thing is, older people usually aren't so dumb, they use their years better, which is why their self-reported happiness is higher).
adamisom··on $6.96B was raised by private longevity companies in 2022
I think people here are disprortionately conscious, which leads to greater awareness that terrible things are terrible.
adamisom··on The Fourier Transform, explained in one sentence (2014)
Indeed: the original comment was not at all implying anything special about FTT. Rather that, perhaps whether we like it or not, knowledge is not very flat; you really should honor (as in: recognize and treat appropriately-nothing magical or moral intended) the difficulty of many topics by doing prerequisite study, or, if you can’t, just accepting that you will never have a good understanding.

I don’t think it’s at loggerheads with just-in-time learning or the real opportunity cost of more extensive study. I think it’s just true that hard things are hard whether you like it or not.

adamisom··on The end of the high school essay
Well, I suspect that’s most people. So we’d better still call them students.
adamisom··on Google researcher, long out of math, cracks devilish problem about sets
I think it’s mainly that STEM majors are smarter, and thinking is hard slash unmotivating.

Of course any non-STEM field has geniuses, but our impressions—like the parent’s—are formed from averages, and STEM majors are smarter on avg.

← PreviousPage 3 of 7Next →