HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

aetherson

8,642 karma · joined November 20, 2012

submissionscomments
aetherson··on What Happened to the Neanderthals?
Equally, you and I can't prove that hindu myth isn't a record of contact with advanced space aliens, and wouldn't it have been fun if it was.

But it's implausible for all kinds of basic reasons.

It's just clear all throughout history that humans do not have trouble making up fantastic creatures. There's no reason to think that these fantastic creatures weren't made up. It just seems at first blush that there might be a reason because it was "very long ago." Until you realize that "very long ago" by the standards of hindu myth are wildly different than "very long ago" by the standards of hominid species.

aetherson··on What Happened to the Neanderthals?
The vanaras were probably conceived of around let's say generously 3000 years ago. Neanderthals disappeared about 40,000 years ago. You live ten times closer in timeline to the original Ramayana story than neanderthals did.

It's just not very plausible that hindu mythology is a corrupted record of living with multiple species of hominids. Timeline-wise, it's not much different from claiming that Tolkien's orcs and elves were part of some kind of historical memory of hominids.

aetherson··on The 1.5°C goal of the Paris Agreement is no longer viable
There is obviously a deep desire for personal penance and absolution that manifests itself in the environmental space. (see: paper straws, plastic bags, formerly compact fluorescent lightbulbs, low-flow toilets, etc.) I'm not sure I agree that this fundamentally is about people being misinformed; it seems possible that people would want this even if they were fully clear that these penances were trivial -- even in aggregate -- in the big picture.

I think that people do care about "the environment," but what they mean by "the environment" is much more "my personal connection with spaces that feel unspoiled" than "atmospheric CO2 levels."

aetherson··on You Are No Longer Invited to Dinner
I'm a parent and while I invite people over (indeed, this last Sunday we had another couple and their kid over) and do this thing, very few of our parent friends appear to do it. Or I guess maybe they do it with each other and just don't invite us, but I think it's rarer than you think.
aetherson··on Two and a half years without a gallbladder
She's probably not? If she's gone two and a half years since her gallbladder was removed, and years before that when sge had gallstone symptoms but thought they were something else, that was before widespread use of GLPs.
aetherson··on Warren Buffett Steps Down as Berkshire Chairman, Names Son to Replace Him
I believe they wouldn't have to because of the stepped-up-basis, but my point is that even if somehow they were paying the full 40%, it's still an inconceivably large amount of money.
aetherson··on Warren Buffett Steps Down as Berkshire Chairman, Names Son to Replace Him
Even very large salaries are probably not a very significant amount of wealth for these people. I think this is a case where "all large numbers look the same."

If Warren just directly gave his money to his three children equally, and paid 40% inheritance tax on that money, and then the children each just used 1% of that wealth per year, then they'd each get:

144000000000 * 0.6 / 3 / 100 = $288 million each year.

No foundation pays its CEO 10% of that much money. I think we may have to accept that in fact this is a way to give money to charitable causes, not just horde it.

aetherson··on How accurate have Ed Zitron's AI skeptic predictions been?
What else would his repute be based on? Maybe telling retrospective truth? Per the article, he does terribly by that metric as well.
aetherson··on Taxi drivers rarely die of Alzheimer's
You could imagine that pre-diagnosis confusion relating to Alzheimer's increases the risk of traffic accident and kills taxi drivers, too. Might not operate for truckers as much because they're more likely to survive accidents.
aetherson··on How old is Ann?
18.
aetherson··on Anthropic's Method to Losing Goodwill in a Few Easy Steps
Okay, if it's bad for the price they're offering, use the more expensive API. If they themselves can't afford it I don't know what you want here.
aetherson··on Supreme Court upholds broad conception of birthright citizenship
That was very much on the table, though not locked in.
aetherson··on Supreme Court upholds broad conception of birthright citizenship
The US's population is not declining. However, without immigration, our population growth would be very close to zero, and a yet lower rate of natural increase is locked in over the next couple of decades (more old people who will die than children).

And, I mean, it's obviously hard to predict beyond that, but it doesn't seem like anyone has any real clear answer to the trend of steadily decreasing TFR right now.

aetherson··on The Baffling World of Masayoshi Son's Presentations (2020)
I mean, he was pretty vindicated on Uber. Which kind of hurts me to say, I was a long time Uber bear. But it did indeed emerge from the pandemic stronger.
aetherson··on I used Claude Code to get a second opinion on my MRI
Sure. But that's not the subject.
aetherson··on I used Claude Code to get a second opinion on my MRI
They learn during training, which is what we're talking about.
aetherson··on I used Claude Code to get a second opinion on my MRI
You're confusing the training method with the internal process. If I had you repeatedly attempt to learn how to make believable completions of partial documents about a given topic, you would eventually learn things about that topic and could use your knowledge to create more believable completions of documents about that topic.
aetherson··on Cooling copper plates could slash data center energy use by 90%
Copper is expensive, and the manufacturing process sounds finicky.
aetherson··on Colonization of Venus
It'd be interesting to try to imagine a Venusian colonization that's like two separated levels: an atmospheric area where most people live and where you grow food, and then a subterranean (yes, yes, sub... aphroditean?) where you mine and so forth, and there are brief, fraught transitions between the two layers but no actual habitation of the surface or lower atmosphere.
aetherson··on Battle for Wesnoth: open-source, turn-based strategy game
Not really. It's turn-based and hex-based.
aetherson··on We automated everything except knowing what's going on
People also do some really stupid things, I'll just throw out.

But it also kind of sounds like you're just saying that there's a scalar of "get a little better" before you'd trust AI with something.

aetherson··on We automated everything except knowing what's going on
Genuine question: is there a big inherent difference between "I don't understand this thing but I think this other human does," and "I don't understand this but I think this other AI does"?

If your answer is "yes," do you think that's inherent to the (metaphysical?) fact of it being AI or to specific limitations to current AI? If the latter, what changes to AI would let you trust it?

aetherson··on Bcachefs creator insists his custom LLM is female and 'fully conscious'
Quick heuristic for someone who claims that their AI is conscious: do they claim it's "a gender that they are not attracted to"?
aetherson··on Warren Buffett dumps $1.7B of Amazon stock
Amazon isn't a monopoly, it has 8% of retail in the US.

There's no real evidence that this trade was made by Buffet himself, and it's part of a general major sell-off of Amazon that transparently did not temporally align with the idea that Amazon's retail business has suffered a decline in quality.

This is the market making a (reasonable!) judgment that it lacks confidence that Amazon's capital expenditures will pay off.

aetherson··on Warren Buffett dumps $1.7B of Amazon stock
These just aren't the relevant concerns behind Amazon's stock performance in the last month. It's the capex.
aetherson··on Mark Zuckerberg Lied to Congress. We Can't Trust His Testimony
Nonsense. There are lots of things that you need more than three strikes for, especially on a platform that you expect to use for decades.

I'm not here to say that Facebook's enforcement behavior is optimal, and I don't know that a "17 strike policy" is a full description of their enforcement behavior. But there are plenty of behaviors that you want to discourage but not go nuclear about.

aetherson··on Mark Zuckerberg Lied to Congress. We Can't Trust His Testimony
No?

Like, I'd think that was a bad policy for murder in particular, but "we don't allow things but we give you a lot of chances to correct your behavior" is ordinary.

aetherson··on U.S. had almost no job growth in 2025
Native population is declining (and prime-age workforce is retiring), and the Trump admin has been extensively working to reduce the size of the immigrant workforce.

So the unemployment rate is staying low, but the absolute number of workers is flat or declining.

aetherson··on The behavioral cost of personalized pricing
The in-industry terms for these are "brand marketing" and "performance marketing," FWIW. Brand marketing is the first thing, performance marketing is what you're calling sales.
aetherson··on The behavioral cost of personalized pricing
Price discrimination is bad. It's worth trying to ban. You'll never stop 100% of it (and trying to go too over-the-top in terms of stopping it would not be worthwhile), but this is a useful area for regulation.
Page 1 of 34Next →