HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

aguaviva

1,437 karma · joined August 8, 2024

submissionscomments
aguaviva··on US judge finds NSO Group liable for hacking journalists via WhatsApp
If that's the only comparison that comes to mind, then you're basically proving the commenter's point.
aguaviva··on Doctors Without Borders declares the war in Gaza as genocide
Pre-Israel Palestinians are mostly of Jewish origin.

Not the 97 percent who were non-Jewish.

Who were a diverse group of folks, including a significant minority (20 percent or more seems a good estimate) whose recent ancestors were non-indigenous migrants in the latter (but still pre-Aliyah) stages of the Ottoman Empire. Including a good chunk from Egypt and other places nearby, as well as from far-off places like Bosnia, Circassia etc.

The long-term resident (i.e. "indigeous") component in turn had also steadily mixed with other populations over time. DNA evidence does suggest that a good chunk of their ancestry pool would probably have been classed as Jewish/Israelite way back when, before converting to Christianity and other religions before the Islamic conquest. A fact which the myth-making industry in modern Israel painfully ignores.

In sum they make for a complex group with a mix of influences. To say that they were "mostly of Jewish origin" smells strongly of overstretch.

And in any case they definitely were not "Jewish" by the time the Nakba rolled around. So what this (or footnotes about the origin of the term Palestinian) has to do with the Israeli government's continuing to hoard their stolen ("abandoned") posessions is unclear.

aguaviva··on Doctors Without Borders declares the war in Gaza as genocide
Except it doesn't.

People like to say it does, but this stance is largely based on a single line (up at the very top) which is frequently mistranslated, as in the version you are unfortunately citing.

In particular it mistranslates a key verb as "obliterate". When you yourself can verify, right now, that that verb pretty much only translates as "nullify" or "abolish". It is also clear that this refers to the State of Israel, not the Jewish people.

This far more correct interpretation being much more consistent with Hamas's ideology, which holds that Zionism simply lacks legitimacy, and will eventually be seen as irrelevant.

There's also that line about the Gharqad tree. Say what you want about it, but it unambiguously refers to Islamic eschatology, and Islamic scholars at least say it should be interpreted allegorically (as in a conflict will come between right and wrong, those who defend the truth and those who oppose it and all that).

In any case it doesn't refer to the State of Israel, or present a literal call for extermination.

aguaviva··on Efficient German Language Learning: Is Anki the Answer?
The newer migrants might still be linguistically isolated. And the poor, helpless Amis also in any case.

But the Türkendeutsche no longer are - not the under-50 set, anyway. Try ordering a Börek in Berlin sometime - the person serving you will answer in perfect Berlinerisch.

Socially/politically they might be in some kind of a bubble, but so are the rest of us.

aguaviva··on US judge finds NSO Group liable for hacking journalists via WhatsApp
This professor says that what happens in Gaza is genocide because ...

That's very plainly not a fair description of what he was saying. He gives plenty of reasons beyond the small snippet you've chosen to zero in on.

It is interesting that every time someone is being asked to explain why they use the word "genocide" in the context of Gaza, they never talk about killing of people.

And this description is even more bizarre. People bring up the egregiously high civilian death toll all the time. It's not the only part of the genocide accusation, but certainly a major part of it.

It seems you aren't really reacting to what "people" are saying, just what you prefer to believe they're saying.

aguaviva··on Doctors Without Borders declares the war in Gaza as genocide
It is by no means agreed that the violent ethnic cleansing of Germans from Czechoslavaka, Poland and other areas after WW2 was justified. You're just assuming it is and that everyone agrees with you on this. Most bizarrely, as a way of explaining/minimizing ethnic cleansing taking place in the current time.

BTW the Palestinians allied with the Axis powers and Nazi Germany

Some of their non-elected leadership did, but the Palestinians as a people did not.

Meanwhile, a certain very famous organization that was instrumental to Israel's founding (and which would go on to provide one of the country's more famous Prime Ministers) twice attempted to form an alliance with Nazi Germany, going so far as to propose a Jewish State based on "nationalist and totalitarian principles, and linked to the German Reich by an alliance".

When it wasn't busy assassinating British and UN leaders, taking part in Deir Yassin and other massacres, etc.

aguaviva··on US judge finds NSO Group liable for hacking journalists via WhatsApp
[flagged]
aguaviva··on Doctors Without Borders declares the war in Gaza as genocide
It wasn't the moral condemnation, but their weighing in on a hotly disputed case (along with the fact that they're a highly respected organization with first-hand knowledge of what's been happening on the ground) that makes the post interesting and relevant.

Unfortunately the poster botched/distorted the article title, but that's a separate issue.

aguaviva··on Doctors Without Borders declares the war in Gaza as genocide
Evidence of some interesting new phenomenon

Not entirely new, but certainly interesting and relevant in the sense of one of the world's most highly respected organizations weighing in on one of the most flagrant large-scale violation of human rights in our time (that many prefer to pretend to believe isn't happening at all).

Clearly on-topic for HN.

aguaviva··on Doctors Without Borders declares the war in Gaza as genocide
The commenter themselves narrowed the scope when they said

    Forget all the dead from the Hamas massacre of October 7th, 
And went on to focus on the 12k+ wounded soldiers and 100k displaced.

But even if we include those killed on Oct 7th -- it's simply and obviously not true that "No Western country has gone through something event remotely similar" in recent times.

aguaviva··on Doctors Without Borders declares the war in Gaza as genocide
Then you should assume the best interpretation of my intent, as well.

The commenter was really quite clueless when they said "No Western country in recent times has gone through something even remotely similar to what Israel has gone and is going through." To the point that we're forced to ask ourselves if it's even possible for someone be that clueless.

It's also difficult to read that statement other than as suggesting that there must be something awfully special about what Israel is going through. Especially when suffering literally 30x-100x greater (depending on your choice of metric), also ethnically targeted, has been happening right there in the same time zone, just a few notches up (and in a thoroughly Western country which Israel has extensive cultural and ancestral ties with). It's not like it hasn't been in the news.

And nevermind the suffering that has been happening in countries right next to Israel. Because they aren't Western and so don't matter.

The mind simply boggles.

aguaviva··on Doctors Without Borders declares the war in Gaza as genocide
There's more to it than that. Many responsible historians have looked into the question of why the Allies found it necessary to make a point of deliberately targeting civilians during the strategic campaign (while not even attempting to target the actual killing machinery of the Final Solution itself). The bombings were really quite horrific, too. Dresden was by no means an outlier, in this regard.

But if you want just say that this investigation is just all retarded, then that's your right I guess.

aguaviva··on Doctors Without Borders declares the war in Gaza as genocide
Your framing was disingenuous, straight up -- it was a baiting question in the classic mold -- and that's why it was necessary to shut it down.

When you start a question with "Surely you will admit ...", it presupposes a certain aura of doubt or guilt on the part of the person that you're addressing (as if you think there's grounds to believe they would be reluctant to give a normal, sensible answer to that question). You also buttered up your inquest with excessive detail, as if you thought the person you were addressing it to would be ignorant of (or in denial about) the events of that day.

No one needs to answer questions like this.

Always telling to see ...

I find the bullshit insinuation of antisemitism that you're making here (on a public discussion forum, no less) to be rather insulting, actually.

aguaviva··on Doctors Without Borders declares the war in Gaza as genocide
(auschwitz alone was almost doubling that 20k kill count each week btw)

Perhaps in its record week. But "each week", no. In fact its average was 4-5k per week.

Meanwhile, it is unlikely that the Dresden bombing (occuring as it did just 3 months before the end of the war, after Auschwitz and nearly all the other camps in the East had been liberated) did much of anything to hasten the end of the war, let alone to mitigate any further atrocities.

That's why it gets so much attention. From just the sheer senselessness of it.

aguaviva··on Doctors Without Borders declares the war in Gaza as genocide
Surely you would admit ...

You know, you could have asked your question in a normal, straightforward manner -- e.g. "Would you say the Oct 7th attack was also genocidal in nature, per these criteria?" -- and you would have gotten a straightforward answer.

But as it is, you've chosen a weird, pretentious way of formulating your question.

So I'll have to pass, and let you think whatever you want to think.

aguaviva··on Doctors Without Borders declares the war in Gaza as genocide
It never fully pulled out of Gaza, only partially. It continued to maintain control of borders, maritime and airspace, to maintain control over key resources, and to bomb and invade the territory on multiple occasions. That's why the territory is considered to be "occupied" per UN statutes.

"We pulled the settlements, therefore it's all good and people don't know what they're complaining about" is just the government's spin.

aguaviva··on Doctors Without Borders declares the war in Gaza as genocide
Israel hasn't been an occupying force. They left Gaza in 2005.

That's the narrative that the State of Israel promotes. But as with many things it says, it is wildly disconnected from reality.

Israel never fully "left" Gaza. It pulled its settlements and internal troop deployments, but still maintained control of the Strip's borders, martime access and air space. And continued to bomb and invade sporadically ("mowing the lawn"), according its whimsy and pleasure.

That's why it still considered to be under Israeli occupation according to UN statutes.

Palestinians decided to spend their time preparing for terrorist attacks against Israel.

Some did, the vast majority did not but were retaliated against anyway.

aguaviva··on Doctors Without Borders declares the war in Gaza as genocide
I dunno, Gaza (on per-sqkm basis) still looks nothing like Hamburg '43.

In fact the numbers of civilians killed are roughly similar (probably 30k for Gaza vs. 40k for Hamburg 43-45) against roughly equal pre-war population size (about 1.5M for each). And the pictures are of course awfully similar as well (depending on where one wishes to zoom in). And Israel's not anywhere near done with Gaza yet.

But of course you were just hand-waving, which is why you started off with "I dunno".

Until it looks at least like that everywhere, I'd say Israel is being too soft

An incredibly crass and nasty thing to say about a largely innocent population being steadily bombed into the ground.

aguaviva··on Polyamory doesn't liberate; monogamy doesn't protect
Probably a function of the particlar psychographic you hang out with.

Meanwhile one observes the denial of any potential to even discuss ENM (along with straight-up cheating) contributing to an immeasurable portion of dyad breakups.

Or people staying in the dyad, but with tremendous unacknowledged suffering.

aguaviva··on Doctors Without Borders declares the war in Gaza as genocide
But if you go that way you get so yeah the Nazi's committed genocide but so did their opponents so it doesn't really matter.

I don't think that follows. In terms of implying the "so they're all basically the same, and the distinction doesn't really matter" part. On its own terms, the definition just doesn't do that.

Granted, some (many) people might think that way, but I think that's a subset of the broader problem of people being hopelessly caught up in muddled thinking patterns generally, these days.

Maybe we need a new term for excessive killing of civilians but short of trying to wipe out a whole people.

"Partial genocide," "smaller-scale", "mini" etc would seem to do the trick. But unfortunately boring language of that sort doesn't trigger people's dopamine levels, and so content discussing recent events in these more measured tones doesn't get promoted and shared as often.

(BTW, the genocide definition under discussion refers not just to "excessive" killings of civilians, but the specific targeting of civilians of a particular group. If the Allies had only targeted military facilities, even with the greatly more imprecise munitions in use at the time, then it would be much more difficult to say that these bombings were "genocidal". It's the fact that the Allies deliberately targeted residential areas, at a massive scale and with the specific intent of spreading terror in the civilian population, which made these bombings arguably genocidal).

aguaviva··on Amazon workers to strike at multiple US warehouses during busy holiday season
I'm glad you "know" what kind of medical care I've been receiving, and how much I've been paying for it.
aguaviva··on Doctors Without Borders declares the war in Gaza as genocide
And then you'd wonder if things like the bombing of Dresden count as genocide.

Yup, that's exactly what it was. A "mini" one, granted, perhaps 5 percent (if we count all the other terror bombings conducted by the Allies - Dresden was but one of many) the size of the vastly larger genocide perpetrated by the Nazis. But there's little point in arguing that that's what the deliberate targetting of civilian populations in Germany (both during and after the war, considering the mass expulsions that followed) did not effectively amount to a "mini" genocide, nonetheless.

And then if you use it like that it kind of loses its meaning if all war is genocide.

No, pointing out this fairly obvious fact does not, by any stretch, imply that "all war" is genocide.

Only the large-scale, deliberate targeting of civilian populations "with intent to destroy [them] as a group, in whole or in part", per the definition above.

That wasn't the title of the linked article, or it's content.

That's a valid point, and indeed the article should probably be flagged on that basis.

aguaviva··on Doctors Without Borders declares the war in Gaza as genocide
There are no demonstrations for the hanged queers in teheran,

Actually there've been large demonstrations in major Western cities against the Mullah regime, organized by exile groups, targeting all its forms of oppression, including the persecution of "queers" (not all of whom would agree with that peculiar Western-centric identity that you seem to implicitly assume is univeral, but that's a side matter).

Not nearly as frequent as the Palestine protests of course, but they do happen at least a few times a year and their numbers have been quite sizable.

If you haven't been aware of this, perhaps you need to start reading from more diverse sources. Or if you happen to live in one of these cities, it might help to get out more often.

aguaviva··on Doctors Without Borders declares the war in Gaza as genocide
There are no Israeli casualties?

Precisely zero civilian casualties inside Israel proper since Oct 8th (due to the Hamas conflict) is what they apparently meant.

There's no Western country ...

These being the only ones whose populations are worth having empathy with.

There's no Western country in recent time that went through something event remotely similar to what Israel has gone and is going through.

Except Ukraine, which has had 100x displaced (in raw terms) or 25x per capita. And (since we need to divide by zero) infinitely civilians more actualy killed/wounded.

There are also (assuming since 2000 so) these countries "Georgia" and "Armenia" you might have heard of. Feel free to run the numbers on those countries, and report back to us what you find. Again, restricting our attention to worthy "Western" societies.

It seems you'll need to find another way to promote the "Israel's suffering is unique" narrative.

aguaviva··on Amazon workers to strike at multiple US warehouses during busy holiday season
If you've never seen things in this way, you should start.

I entertained that way of seeing things at one point, actually.

But I got over it in my teenage years.

aguaviva··on Amazon workers to strike at multiple US warehouses during busy holiday season
Either you think the CEO was an undeserving victim, or you think that only billionaires and their enforces deserve a monopoly on lethal force.

Neither choice is valid, and this statement is just pure mindfuck.

It is completely irrelevant what the CEO "deserved". I'm not going to condone lynching or vigilante killings in any civil context.

There's no analogy with Ukraine/Russia, or any actual military conflict.

You whole take here smells like "We're at civil war already, so why not just start lynching people? At least we'll have justice, finally."

aguaviva··on Romanian court annuls result of presidential election first round
That's a valid point.

We need to better language to describe the new breed of postmodern terror-driven autocrats like Putin, and post-truth / antidemocratic Western leaders like Trump.

But at the end of the day, it's academic. The real question is, what to do about them.

aguaviva··on Amazon workers to strike at multiple US warehouses during busy holiday season
I would apply the term "cynical" to the decisions made by Amazon's management which create the working conditions that compel their workers to strike, while providing top 1% compensation to themselves.

These people are just doing what they have to do to survive. If anything, going on strike a truly desparate move. Insinuating that they are childishing in doing so (as if they feel they "deserve a pony") on the other hand, seems simply -- snide.

aguaviva··on Dmitry Medvedev says editors of the Times are 'legitimate military targets'
Medvedev is engaging in a form of Slavic rhetorical satire

It could perhaps be construed as (a very juvenile form of) satire -- were it not for the fact that his regime has already conducted assassinations of non-military targets on European soil, of exactly the type he is "satirically" threatening.

aguaviva··on Windshield pitting incidents in Washington reach fever pitch on April 15, 1954 (2003)
There's no bad intent. I just don't think you're reading the tea leaves right.
← PreviousPage 3 of 34Next →