HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

aguaviva

1,437 karma · joined August 8, 2024

submissionscomments
aguaviva··on Romanian court annuls result of presidential election first round
But revolutionary fascism is but one variant within a broader palette, is it not?

If we substitute "The West and its degenerate values" for the usual enemies, then Stanley's definition seems to describe Putin's regime quite succinctly:

  In his book How Fascism Works: The Politics of Us and Them (2018), Jason Stanley defined fascism thusly:

   [A] cult of the leader who promises national restoration in the face of humiliation brought on by supposed communists, Marxists and minorities and immigrants who are supposedly posing a threat to the character and the history of a nation ... The leader proposes that only he can solve it and all of his political opponents are enemies or traitors.
I would agree that Putin is not an archetypal fascist in all categories - but he does seem be on the spectrum.
aguaviva··on List of books that will induce a mindfuck
And if you go that route then it's on you, not Super Mario.

Or because of anything intrinsic to the latter's Weltanschauung.

aguaviva··on Syrian government falls in end to 50-year rule of Assad family
Boris Johnson didn’t allow ukraine to negotiate

No, that's just a myth. Was a matter of speculation for a while, but when it got investigated, it didn't hold up.

See also: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41812302

aguaviva··on Protecting undersea internet cables is a tech nightmare
Economically Russia is irrelevant (a.k.a puny).

So any country at or below Russia's GDP ranking (11th worldwide) is "irrelevant" and "puny".

Is that what you're saying?

aguaviva··on Romanian court annuls result of presidential election first round
Because Putin isn't a Nazi. He's something new.
aguaviva··on Syrian government falls in end to 50-year rule of Assad family
Wrong-o, man.

Talking to actual people is the magical, indispendible ingredient you need in your analysis.

Of course they're quite often biased. That's not the point. But at least you get a human perspective. And even when they're biased, it turns out that "actual people" are usually far less intellectualized and rigidly ideological than the stuff you'll read online. And when they do have an axe to grind, usually there's at least a story behind it ("my family went through this") that you can at least incorporate into your dataset.

And the more actual people you talk to, the more you get to triangulate. Plus, they sometimes invite you into their house for really awesome food.

But if all one does is soak up online narratives and analysis (and worst off all, the crap that thinktanks typically put out, even when they're mostly on the right side) -- one basically becomes a language model.

Full of facts, but knowing nothing.

aguaviva··on Syrian government falls in end to 50-year rule of Assad family
It's not about what they "should" have.

But rather the fact that it seems difficult to imagine such a state being set up without further conflict / ethnic cleansing.

aguaviva··on Syrian government falls in end to 50-year rule of Assad family
Unless we’re now cheering for ethnostates

This is a misuse of the term.

Even the Syrian Kurds don’t want independence, rather just autonomy as part of a multiethnic Northern region.

Doesn't have to be full-scale independence. I think "stable, legal regional autonomy" was probably included in what the commenter meant by "their own land".

As opposed to the halfway / fully isolated / unstable situation they've had up until now.

aguaviva··on Syrian government falls in end to 50-year rule of Assad family
Plenty of stuff on internet.

There's plenty of "stuff on internet" about piles of beheaded babies on Oct 7, too.

Links to reasonably trustable reports needed, please. Otherwise what you're saying is just more "stuff".

aguaviva··on Syrian government falls in end to 50-year rule of Assad family
It seems that something like "they've trashed their economy" would have been a better choice of words.

But -- "destroyed"? What's that supposed to mean? What purpose is served by the use of such hyperbolic language?

aguaviva··on Syrian government falls in end to 50-year rule of Assad family
It's not sustainable for -either- side.

Both sides are aching (very badly) for this thing to be over, or at least taken off the stove.

One can quibble further as to the details -- which are a matter of metrics, wildcards, politics. And (as recent events have shown) there are still many cards to be played.

But that's the fundamental equation we need to keep in mind.

aguaviva··on Romanian court annuls result of presidential election first round
Extremely helpful - mulţumesc
aguaviva··on List of books that will induce a mindfuck
Like video games cause violence, I guess.
aguaviva··on Ukraine's three nuclear power plants have restored electricity production
But Minsk was dead for several years already even before the FSO.

Nonetheless it seems clear now that the West could have come up with a greatly more coherent escalation strategy that it seems to have sleepwalked into.

aguaviva··on TikTok divestment law upheld by federal appeals court
OT why is your comment history all about politics and mostly Russia?

It's not "all about politics". You could have said "Why is it mostly about ...?" and the question would have had an entirely different ring to it. But the wording you chose was weird and distracting, so I don't think I'll be able invest much time in answering.

Other than to say: I respond mostly to muddled thinking and misinformation (and in some cases outright disinformation). Which not coincidentally seems to bubble forth continuously from posts referencing that country (and a certain other one). Which also tend to appear in bursts, as we have seen. So the intent is to keep the conversation at least borderline reality-centered. And hence, per the site guidelines, more "interesting".

(Not that your post is in this category. I just think you're probably mistaken).

In that sense the interest isn't even all that "political" as such. It's more psychological and cognitive.

It's odd for a startup/tech oriented board.

It's not specifically startup/tech-oriented. Check the guidelines again.

I have an interest in tech also, but am also rather burned out on it.

The more powerful it gets, the more boring it gets, somehow.

aguaviva··on Romanian court annuls result of presidential election first round
"in this wonderful utopian future we now live in, you can easily zero in on a reliable answer to your question within minutes (even starting from scratch):"
aguaviva··on Romanian court annuls result of presidential election first round
This equation is just wrong, as applies to both Putin and Orbán.

And (ironically) simply convinces people that those who are concerned about Putin's arguably fascist (as opposed to actual Nazi) inclinations are just hyperventilating and overreacting.

Thus, promoting his (and Orbán)'s longevity.

aguaviva··on The dogs of Chernobyl: Populations in the nuclear exclusion zone (2023)
Except it's not.

Chernobyl is just another popular spelling that people have gotten accustomed to.

But no one outside the Russian Mir ever refers to Alaska as Aljáska.

There's no signficance or import to the chosen spelling. This whole flame war is completely pointless.

aguaviva··on Russia uses civilians as 'target practice' for killer drones
Except the posts are from the Kremlin/Dialog-affiliated outlet Readovka.

Which means their assertions are about as reliable as what Nayirah "saw".

aguaviva··on Romanian court annuls result of presidential election first round
Which leak are you referring to?
aguaviva··on Does Your Code Pass the Turkey Test? (2008)
Nothing heavy-handed about it at all. Plenty of countries have changed their names (slightly or entirely) over the years.

The more diacritics we are compelled to learn and use, the better I say.

aguaviva··on Russia and China rigged Romanian Elections using 10M fake TikTok accounts
Why are all the links being posted here from disreputable sources?

A careful analysis indicates that about 18 percent of the links in this thread are from the sites you mentioned.

Can you explain how you arrived at the formulation "all the links", in this context?

aguaviva··on If Putin loses his Tartus base, he may need a ceasefire in Ukraine
Not nonsense at all.

If he loses that base, he'll start to look bad and his legitimacy within the security forces will be called even further into question.

aguaviva··on Protecting undersea internet cables is a tech nightmare
Both of these things are said here in the West.

Except they're not. No one says Russia is a "puny country", or that it could "invade all its neighboring countries" (which would have to include, for example, China).

You're definitely making some weird exaggerations here.

aguaviva··on PSA: The Kagi search engine directly funds Yandex –- and refuses to stop
Wait did you just equate the Israelis to the Nazis??

No.

They have the right to fight back.

That's not the point.

aguaviva··on TikTok divestment law upheld by federal appeals court
Hmm - we can't go on dissecting polls each day, but here's one (dating from January) which measure sentiment across 10 countries and along several key questions:

https://ukandeu.ac.uk/how-strong-is-public-support-for-ukrai...

If the poll were taken today, the percentages would probably shift a bit on some of these questions. But what's more interesting is the spread across the 10 countries.

Notice that Italy and Hungary tend to sit more on the "doomer/skeptic" side (in accord with the poll you offered in regard to Italy's sentiment), while countries like the UK, Finalnd and the Baltics are more on the "there's still hope" side. And Germany seems to fight right in the middle.

Which suggests that no, the average European does not simply think Ukraine is a lost cause.

The average European believes that Ukraine cannot win the war (meaning getting back their 1991 territories), but that's also a reality and the opinion shared by analysts, and is honestly tired of it. ... It's hard to be a die hard supporter for Zelenskis official line.

Well that's obviously no longer Zelenskyy's position, right?

Also, you're setting up a false dichotomy here -- either the (now basically collapsed) "die-hard" position, or the "Ukraine is lost cause" position.

My observations indicate that the median sentiment falls somewhere between these extremes.

aguaviva··on List of books that will induce a mindfuck
I still don't get what the "concern" is supposed to be.

That Nietzsche's worldview was intrinsically fascist (or proto-fascist)?

aguaviva··on TikTok divestment law upheld by federal appeals court
At the same time it was one of the few media platforms that allowed criticism of Israel to go viral.

Actually, it has been the 76 years of increasingly brutal occupation with no end in sight, along with all the compltely ludicrous propaganda the State of Israel (and its right-wing support base abroad) continually transmits about itself this state of affairs, with the weird expectation that the world should actually believe it for some reason -- which has allowed criticism of Israel to go viral.

aguaviva··on PSA: The Kagi search engine directly funds Yandex –- and refuses to stop
Many Germans thought they were simply defending their country against external threats during its final genocidal adventure, also.
aguaviva··on Romanian court annuls result of presidential election first round
when they say Trump = Hitler, because he had a rally at MSG.

No, not "because he had a rally at MSG".

But because of the things he said at that rally.

Do you understand the distinction?

It's also definitely not true that most of the people saying he's a fascist are saying he's "a Nazi"; that's an overdrawn distortion. And a lot of these people with concerns about his rhetoric don't even necessarily think he's a fascist per se; though they do find a matter of concern that he seems to at least be channeling fascist rhetoric.

Whether you agree with them or not is beside the point. What seems much more significant is that you seem to have a weirdly muddled (and hyperemotionalized) view of what people actually think about Trump, and why.

← PreviousPage 6 of 34Next →