HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

aktiur

116 karma · joined October 31, 2013

submissionscomments
aktiur··on Ubuntu shouldn't abuse trademark law to silence critics of its privacy decisions
> If this rule actually existed

I gave the link to the specific federal statutes oO

As for the case you're bringing, the criterion would be: it the website tyring to get people to believe it is actually endorsed by Apple to injure its reputation? In this case it is criminal impersonation, which is a usually a state criminal offense unrelated to trademark law.

Otherwise, if it's only criticizing the participation of Apple in a jewish conspiracy, to use your example, it is pretty safe on the trademark front (and even more if the webmaster was careful not to show ads or to link to a commercial website).

However, depending on the actual content of the website, it could still constitute defamation and Apple could thus sue, but again not in relation with its trademark.

aktiur··on Amazon is selling Cars
Is there free shipping as well?
aktiur··on Ubuntu shouldn't abuse trademark law to silence critics of its privacy decisions
A trademark is a recognizable sign that identifies goods or services from a particular from those of others. Protection was thus created to make unlawful any use of the trademark that would be confusing for customers, for example if you displayed one of your competitors' trademarks on your product - that would be a trademark infringement[1]

The protection for trademarks is thus much more lax than the one that you have with copyrights: trademarks are protected only for limited purposes, whereas the protection is broader for copyrights.

The protection was extended in 1996 to forbid some uses of trademarks that however would not be confusing to customers. The owner of the trademark is able to sue someone that use its trademark in such a way for trademark dilution - and not infringement. However, this dilution statute does not apply to noncommercial uses of a famous trademark, such as for news reporting, criticism, commentary, and parody.[2]

As fixubuntu.com doesn't sell any goods or services, there is no trademark infringement. In addition, as it does not show ads nor link to commercial websites, a court would most likely recognize it as non-commercial. If it is still seen as a commercial venture, it would still be protected by the "commentary or criticism" protection.

The fixubuntu.com website could hardly be said to be "festooned" with the logo considered it was used only once. But removing it, despite what I said earlier, was still prudent. Indeed, the problem with trademark law is that even if you're not infringing or diluting, it is really hard to get a trademark lawsuit dismissed quickly, and you could easily get dragged in a long litigation you have the financial situation to fight.

For full disclaimer, IANAL, but I have a strong interest in law, have an education in French public law (which is VERY different from american law) but follows regularly the debate on the popehat.com website on free speech related litigations.

[1] http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/15/1114 As you can see in the definition of the trademark infringement for registered trademarks, the use of the trademark has to be in relation with the sale of a product.

[2] http://www.dmlp.org/sites/citmedialaw.org/files/15USC1125.pd... See (a)(1) for the definition of trademark dilution and (a)(3)(A)(ii) or (a)(3)(C) for the exceptions for non-commercial use; I think the fixubuntu case would work for both.

aktiur··on Ubuntu shouldn't abuse trademark law to silence critics of its privacy decisions
You are right this particular case would not necessary pass the test for nominative use. But there are other legal protections available, especially in the case of commentaries or criticisms, that could protect even in the case where the logo was used.

See section "Commentary and criticism" on the page below

http://www.dmlp.org/legal-guide/using-trademarks-others

aktiur··on French PM releases the G8 Open Data Charter Action Plan for France
Here's what three researchers actually found regarding real tax rates in France two years ago :

http://www.revolution-fiscale.fr/img/g1-1.pdf

If you cannot understand French : on the horizontal axis you got the income percentile, and the real tax rate on the vertical axis. The real tax rates may seem high, but they are pretty average for Europe.

The nominal tax rate is not enough to gauge the real tax pressure. The French system is well known for having many "tax niches" (as we call the tax loopholes)

The three researchers are Camille Landais (Stanford Institute for Economic Policy Research), Thomas Piketty (Paris school of Economics) and Emmanuel Saez (Berkeley).

Edited to correct : wealth percentage --> income percentile

aktiur··on Inputs.io hacked – 4100 BTC stolen
Except bitcoins are completely fungible. Once the bitcoin is transferred in the wallet, you can no longer make any difference with the other bitcoins in the wallet ; it has no distinct identity anymore.

Think transaction into a bank account : you cannot separate the money that was transfered in from what was already there.

We can taint accounts, but not individual coins.

aktiur··on After traffic stop, man forced to have x-ray, enema, anal probes and colonoscopy
And that's the only sensible reaction when you are asked about an ongoing litigation by the press. Hard to blame him for that second answer.
aktiur··on After traffic stop, man forced to have x-ray, enema, anal probes and colonoscopy
It reminds me of : http://www.smbc-comics.com/?id=3025

Sorry, the characterization in the comic is a bit aggressive, but I find the objections raised there sensible.

aktiur··on South Africa's ANC's disgustingly racist political propoganda campaign
Probably a fake, haven't been able to find another source for it. Much milder posters (like "don't vote against black") have already caused an outrage there, so something of this kind?
aktiur··on Mysterious Mac and PC malware that jumps airgaps?
From what I understood, audio cannot serve as a first infection vector, but it could serve as a reinfection vector even when the BIOS was flashed, as the malware apparently also infects the RealTek audio chip software (according to what he reports on G+).

That would explain this scenario: the malware has been erased from the disk and the bios, but still lives in the audio chip, download a new payload through the high frequency connection, and boum, the computer is infected again.

See https://plus.google.com/u/0/103470457057356043365/posts/3reW...

aktiur··on Mysterious Mac and PC malware that jumps airgaps?
From what I understand, an airgapped computer got infected back after having its disk erased, its BIOS flashed and its OS reinstalled. His guess now is that the malware would be inside the RealTek audio chip software. From there it could theorically download the bios malware back on the computer through the high frequency connection (that does sound crazy!)

See: https://plus.google.com/u/0/103470457057356043365/posts/3reW...

aktiur··on Mysterious Mac and PC malware that jumps airgaps?
Apparently he did make a recording of the output (second last comment on this G+ publication https://plus.google.com/u/0/103470457057356043365/posts/3reW... )
aktiur··on Mysterious Mac and PC malware that jumps airgaps?
It was actually hearable but could be mistaken for crappy electronic noise

https://plus.google.com/u/0/103470457057356043365/posts/3reW...

← PreviousPage 2 of 2