HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

alejohausner

942 karma · joined January 11, 2015

submissionscomments
alejohausner··on Why Water Is Wet
The word "wet" is a technical term. If you spray a water repellent like Scotchgard on your clothes, they will become hydrophobic, and water won't cling to the cloth, nor penetrate its surface. In other words, hydrophobic materials are hard to wet. Waxy surfaces are also hard to wet. See "wetting" on wikipedia (not to be confused with nocturnal enuresis ;-).

Wetting is a verb. Maybe the title should have read "Daddy? Why does water wet?" That might have resolved the confusion, at the risk of angering grammatical pedants.

alejohausner··on 'Sham' cancer charities raised $187M, used almost none on patients, suit
This may sound harsh, but, given the feeble success of any cancer treatment, why should people give money to a lost cause like cancer research? So, donations to all cancer charities should be avoided.
alejohausner··on The Serotonin Levels-Depression Link Is a 'Marketing Myth,' Psychiatrist Claims
You bring up an important point. If you STOP taking an SSRI, you will feel depressed, because your serotonin levels will drop. What's happening is that the SSRI has been fighting your body, pushing up your serotonin levels, and your body has been fighting back. When the SSRI is cut off, your body's fight continues for a while, pushing levels down. Often patients feel suicidal at this point.

Healy and Whittaker point out that the clinical studies initially used to justify the use of SSRIs cleverly took advantage of this effect. Patients on SSRIs were compared to those who had just been cut off the drug. Of course the latter group, perversely included as "placebo", fared worse than the ones taking the drug.

alejohausner··on Ask HN: What kind of philosophy do you read?
My favourite is Nietzsche's "Genealogy of Morals". Here is a taste, from a section on punishment, in his second essay (text from http://home.sandiego.edu/~janderso/360/genealogy2.htm):

In order to give at least an idea of how uncertain, how belated, how accidental “the meaning” of punishment is and how one and the same procedure can be used, interpreted, or adjusted for fundamentally different purposes, let me offer here an example which presented itself to me on the basis of relatively little random material: punishment as a way of rendering someone harmless, as a prevention from further harm; punishment as compensation for the damage to the person injured, in some form or other (also in the form of emotional compensation); punishment as isolation of some upset to an even balance in order to avert a wider outbreak of the disturbance; punishment as way of inspiring fear of those who determine and carry out punishment; punishment as a sort of compensation for the advantages which the law breaker has enjoyed up until that time (for example, when he is made useful as a slave working in the mines); punishment as a cutting out of a degenerate element (in some circumstances an entire branch, as in Chinese law, and thus a means to keep the race pure or to sustain a social type); punishment as festival, that is, as the violation and humiliation of some enemy one has finally thrown down; punishment as a way of making a conscience, whether for the man who suffers the punishment— so- called “reform”—or whether for those who witness the punishment being carried out; punishment as the payment of an honorarium, set as a condition by those in power, which protects the wrong doer from the excesses of revenge; punishment as a compromise with the natural condition of revenge, insofar as the latter is still upheld and assumed as a privilege by powerful families; punishment as a declaration of war and a war measure against an enemy to peace, law, order, and authority, which people fight with the very measures war makes available, as something dangerous to the community, as a breach of contract with respect to its conditions, as a rebel, traitor, and breaker of the peace.

alejohausner··on Bacteria kill us by accident (2014)
I was particularly taken by this passage near the end: "There is something unsatisfying, almost nihilistic, about this idea. It deprives us of answers". It got me thinking about the big mistake that we often make about evolution: that it has a purpose, a goal. The idea that evolution involves progress is as old as Darwin, as can be seen in the "March of Progress" illustration showing a parade with a chimpanzee, then pre-humans, then caveman hunter, then modern man. We have been reminded many times that the illustration is too suggestive, but the idea refuses to die. It's very hard to accept that evolution is full of accidents, and that as a species there is nothing remarkable or inevitable about us.

Similarly, there is nothing special about many microbes that cause illness, but it's hard to accept the idea. It's surprising that streptococcus pneumoniae isn't trying to kill us at all, but merely trying to outcompete hemophilus influenzae in our noses, and sometimes the mechanism that aids its struggle ends up preventing our immune system from killing it. We walk into a fist-fight between strangers, and end up hurt ourselves.

Hell, the phrase "trying to outcompete" contains teleological assumptions which the author himself can't escape from. Those dueling bacteria aren't "trying" to do anything. They accidentally mutate, and circumstances make them more or less successful at increasing their numbers relative to the other species.

It's hard to avoid seeing purpose in the living world around us, even when we know it doesn't know us or care about us.

alejohausner··on TSA jails innocent traveler when he asks to file a complaint
This is exactly what Osama bin Laden wanted. The goal of terrorism is to push a country towards a police state. Subjected to increased police powers, people will blame the government, and will rise up against that government. So terrorism is an indirect attempt to destabilize a country. I think that was a big part of why the 9/11 attacks were carried out.

Of course, it didn't work. In the USA, George Bush got re-elected, and citizens aren't doing much more than grumbling about abuses of power by the police forces. Of the chain of causation that Qaeda was hoping to trigger, only the first one took place: enormously increased policing. No major government change has followed.

alejohausner··on Croatia just canceled the debts of its poorest citizens
Greaber's book on debt was really interesting. The cancellation of debts is from Leviticus 25:

"And ye shall hallow the fiftieth year, and proclaim liberty throughout all the land unto all the inhabitants thereof: it shall be a jubile unto you; and ye shall return every man unto his possession, and ye shall return every man unto his family. "

Fascinating issue. Graeber explains that poor farmers would borrow from the landlord, be unable to pay, and would end up sold into slavery. Eventually not enough farmers were available to work the land. An economic crisis would ensue. Hence the bit about returning men to their families (to restore the labour force).

That's part of the symbolism of Jesus. He is the Redeemer because he is freeing people from the debt of sin. The Gospels are using language that would have been very familiar to Jews who followed the law in Leviticus.

Graeber's big point, which he articulates at the books's outset, is that we have been brainwashed into thinking that paying off a debt is a moral obligation. If you step back a bit from that idea, it suddenly seems strange and artificial to mix the concept of a financial obligation with that of a moral obligation. But that's what a lot of people do: they mix those two things together.

A lender always takes a risk that the borrower won't repay the loan. That's why, for example, credit card debt, which is not backed by collateral, has high interest rates: the lender is covering his risk. Lender and borrower are always conscious of the odds that the loan will go bad.

But when morality gets added to the equation, it distorts reality in favour of the lender, who can now appeal to a sense of duty or sin to confuse the debtor, and make him forget that the two parties in the loan are making a coldblooded calculation of the odds that the loan will be repaid.

Graeber's other big point is that debt has, throughout history, been a means of creating slaves. But that's kind of another issue.

Great read.

alejohausner··on A plastic card for easy to remember strong passwords
How about doing Vigenere in your head? This is what I do: I actually write my passwords down in my little black book, which I carry in my pocket. I use a simple Vigenere cypher in case I lose the book. Each password is encrypted with the same master key, which I memorize.

For example, if my master key was 1234, and my password was 'baNana3', it would write down 'ayKwmy0'. When I look up the password, I shift the letters forward as I type them:

a + 1 = b

y + 2 = a (wrap around the end of the alphabet)

K + 3 = N

w + 4 = a

m + 1 = n

y + 2 = a

0 + 3 = 3

It's not too hard to advance 9 or fewer letters in the alphabet as you type.

I think i'm safe. Am I?

← PreviousPage 11 of 11