HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

alex_stoddard

828 karma · joined September 10, 2008

submissionscomments
alex_stoddard··on Science fails to face the shortcomings of statistics
I am wary of trying to contribute to this (a little knowledge is a dangerous thing) but hopefully someone can correct my mistakes.(And what better way for me to learn...)

A typical controlled science experiment is designed to take measurements of multiple groups where one variable is different between the groups and others are controlled. We wish to see if the variable of interest has an effect.

Therefore the commonest statistical test is to determine if the mean value of the groups are different (t-test for two groups, anova for multiple groups) e.g. does mean blood pressure increase when on a high salt diet.

If I understand the CLT (big if) then the distribution of the _mean_ of a sample is, by the CLT, going to be Gaussian, regardless of the distribution from which the actual measurements are drawn. i.e. for comparing group means it it doesn't matter if my data is sampled from Guassians or not.

Of course that leads to the question of if a significant difference in group means is really relevant in a given context.

alex_stoddard··on Interview with Rich Hickey, creator of Clojure
One really provocative and insightful comment that is independent of clojure itself:

"I think programmers have become inured to incidental complexity... when they encounter complexity, they consider it a challenge to overcome, rather than an obstacle to remove.

Overcoming complexity isn't work, it's waste."

This is a useful maxim for me. I have definitely been attracted to complexity that was really incidental in programming.

alex_stoddard··on Burstsort : the fastest known in-memory string sorting algorithm
This looks like a relatively old paper (2002) and so I think it is measuring performance on strictly single processor machines. On the other hand it is trie based which suggests that it could also be highly parallelizable on modern multi-processor systems. (I am thinking clojure data structures here and maybe the submitter was too... http://fogus.me).

Then again maybe datasets of the size tested (or much bigger) are now just broken down in a map-reduce fashion over multiple machines, and then who cares about the efficiencies of cache misses etc?

Can anyone comment on if burstsort or trie based sorting algorithms in general have been adopted? (All my experience has been as a consumer of library provided "sort" methods rather than ever looking at current state of the art algorithms).

alex_stoddard··on Economics in One Lesson: "The Curse of Machinery"
But there are also vulnerable to piracy.
alex_stoddard··on Miguel de Icaza: "As a software developer, I find the iPad inspirational."
I'm wondering about the possibility of building dynamic multi-touch interfaces for any scriptable desktop app.

The iPad has high speed wireless connections and so at least potentially could act as a very powerful input peripheral client for many desktop apps talking through a server running on a "real Mac" (or even Windows).

alex_stoddard··on Check Mate: Apple's iPad and Google's Next Move
But market share does not equate with revenue.

As highlighted in the iPad launch, Apple introduced the modern laptop with the first ever PowerBook. The laptop market is now definitely commoditized but that doesn't stop Apple from making a lot of money selling fewer highly profitable laptops.

They have something under 10% of the total laptop market but 90% or more of the segment > $1,000 per computer.

alex_stoddard··on Keeping computers from ending science's reproducibility
As a working programmer in biological research science I would love to see a requirement that papers involving software be published in the "literate programming" paradigm. At the very least per reviewed publication must include all software be open source (a least in a loose sense). It is depressing how often a published result depends on custom closed source software.
alex_stoddard··on PEP 3146: Merge Unladen Swallow into CPython
See http://www.python.org/dev/peps/pep-3146/#performance-retrosp... for a discussion of why.
alex_stoddard··on [dead]
I never realized Unicode had additional new-line characters. Does anyone have any experience using the Unicode variants across the Windows and Unix worlds? (Good experience would be more interesting than bad...)
alex_stoddard··on Back to the Future: Lisp as a Base for a Statistical Computing System
This is referenced as part of the motivation for Incanter http://incanter.org the Clojure based, R-like statistical environment.
alex_stoddard··on Funding Clojure 2010
I infer from the post that Rich Hickey still desires to spend the bulk of his time doing core development of Clojure. This is different from doing whatever it takes to make a living from Clojure.

Is seems the only "business models" for open source development, for the love of it, are akin to historic patronage systems.

The difference is that one can now have "crowd patronage" rather than court patronage. However that still depends on being both very lucky and very good. I hope Rich Hickey is the former, clojure speaks for itself on the latter.

alex_stoddard··on Pork grown in laboratory
I am less sanguine on the efficiency issue. You have also thrown away very useful tissues comprising things like a functioning immune system and the circulatory system (gas and nutrient exchange and waste removal/filtration).

I would expect "lab meat" to demand much more purified, processed and energy intensive inputs than traditional farming. Laboratory cell culture is a hard and very expensive enterprise.

alex_stoddard··on Reversed Stupidity Is Not Intelligence
Universal entropy is always increasing but put another way - to reduce local entropy work must be done. Life is local order and demands work, this is true whether we are talking biology or culture.
alex_stoddard··on Medical Editors Push for Crackdown on Ghostwriting
The shocking thing is this is ghostwriting appearing in academic medical journals.

See http://www.plosmedicine.org/article/info:doi/10.1371/journal... for the PLoS Medicine editorial and http://www.plosmedicine.org/static/ghostwriting.action for an archive of ghostwritten documents made public after being discovered during litigation.

alex_stoddard··on How a software engineer invented a breakthrough medical device
The term you are looking for is "systemic".

I think targeted delivery of chemo might be more effective in the non-terminally ill, and very likely would reduce side effects. Chemo is effectively poison, just somewhat more toxic to cancer cells than the rest of the body. (Often because it targets cells that are actively dividing - like in a tumor, or your hair follicles or you gut...)

In terminally ill cases, where cancer has metastasized to multiple locations in the body you might well still need systemic chemo, because you don't know where all the metastatic sites are.

alex_stoddard··on A design pattern is an artifact of a missing feature in your chosen language
It's the concluding paragraph of "Revenge of the Nerds" http://www.paulgraham.com/icad.html

I completely failed to recognize its significance when I first read that essay. Thanks for bring it to my attention.

"This practice is not only common, but institutionalized. For example, in the OO world you hear a good deal about "patterns". I wonder if these patterns are not sometimes evidence of case (c), the human compiler, at work. When I see patterns in my programs, I consider it a sign of trouble."

alex_stoddard··on Inventor's Bike Folds Into Its Own Wheel
For this to work I think the drive-chain would have to be a jointed drive shaft. I actually ride an (un-jointed) drive shaft bike - very handy in very harsh winter conditions.

However, that sort of drive chain would add even more complexity and cost.

alex_stoddard··on A Java old timer reminisces - Oak, 0XCAFEBABE, Green Threads, RuntimeException
"What is the meaning of the name 'RuntimeException' ? Why is the class so named? Think about this for a minute ... ALL exceptions are thrown at runtime right?"

That has been bothering me subconsciously for years! It is very nice to have the explanation for the name:

"Recall that Java has a class called as the “Runtime” class – an abstracted representation of the underlying Java Virtual Machine that allows us to add hooks and get information. So the simple answer to “What is the meaning of the name RuntimeException” is “It is an exception thrown by the Runtime itself” rather than any particular piece of code."

alex_stoddard··on Teen Decomposes Plastic Bag In 3 Months
Indeed. To quote the more detailed original newspaper article linked from Wired: http://news.therecord.com/article/354044 " A researcher in Ireland has found Pseudomonas is capable of degrading polystyrene, but as far as Burd and his teacher Mark Menhennet know -- and they've looked -- Burd's research on polyethelene plastic bags is a first."
alex_stoddard··on Robotic firefighting team
The talon robot mentioned appears to be developed by http://www.foster-miller.com/lemming.htm

It is nice to see military robot R&D making an impact in general public safety applications.

alex_stoddard··on Ribosomes as Productive Nanosystems
I was hedging with "essentially". I didn't want to make an already biogeeky post too obscure. Some proteins can renature without chaperones.

Also to quote the wikipedia article, "Chaperones do not necessarily convey steric information required for proteins to fold: thus statements of the form `chaperones fold proteins` can be misleading."

alex_stoddard··on Ribosomes as Productive Nanosystems
It would depend on how fancy you can get with engineering custom [transfer RNAs] (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transfer_RNA), which are the bridge between the genetic code and the proteins that get made at ribosomes.

Within the limits of the chemistry one could get to work I see no a priori reason why something other than amino-acids (the building blocks of proteins) couldn't be attached to the tRNAs.

Proteins have the additional very valuable property of being essentially self-assembling - the 3D structures or proteins form inherently from their linear sequence of amino acids. That is one of the key reasons why a linear genetic code works to produce all the many varied proteins in living things.

alex_stoddard··on Homomorphic Encryption Breakthrough
The idea of homomorphic encryption has really caught my attention - I am trying to work on distributed computing with privacy sensitive biometric data.

I hadn't appreciated before that Gentry's work was both general (any computation can be performed as a boolean circuit of addition and multiplication) but also impractical : a trillion fold increase is computational burden for an encrypted web search? That is going to kill the advantages of distributed computation.

Schneier also opened my eyes to fact that previous existing encryption schemes are homomorphic under certain operations, such as RSA under multiplication.

I wonder if there would be any gain to distributing parts of a computation and then reassembling it rather than having a fully remote computation done under homomorphic, but very costly, encryption. Of course the gains of parallel computation would have to more than offset the costs of distribution, but that is always the case for parallel applications.

alex_stoddard··on Hydrogen car to be 'open source'
Open source engineering that is, rather than software.
alex_stoddard··on Rainforest Fungus Naturally Synthesizes Diesel
Why are you worried about carbon sequestration?

If you are using plant matter to feed the fungus then the carbon source for the fuel is atmospheric carbon dioxide - "pre-sequestered" carbon, if you will.

As I understand it, the issue with fossil fuel carbon emissions is we are releasing ancient carbon dioxide.

← PreviousPage 3 of 3