HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

alexbanks

1,380 karma · joined July 7, 2016

submissionscomments
alexbanks··on I’m Peter Roberts, immigration attorney who does work for YC and startups. AMA
I am emailing you about this same topic - I just don't want it to look like spam.
alexbanks··on Nubank acquires Cognitect
> Good programmers care about their work, doesn't matter which language.

Yes, but the whole purpose of my post is to point out the difficulty in _finding_ the good programmers.

> Also, use the right tool for the job.

Not sure how this applies. You can build banking software in literally any programming language.

> A language that forces you to think about values rather than mutable objects, will produce higher quality code as the number of ways you can shoot yourself in the foot are drastically reduced.

Again, this is just totally unsubstantiated. You're using "higher quality code" to mean "code I like more".

> Clojure will make you run your code constantly in the REPL. Paired with a dead-simple testing library, the desire to keep your majority of functions pure, it is not hard to see why Clojure code has higher quality.

Where have we demonstrated that clojure has implicit higher quality? Also, where have we demonstrated that all clojure devs keep their functions pure? Or test them? And how does clojure enforce that?

Your last bit kinda proves my whole point, I think. You like a language a lot, and you make good use of its tools. But again, when you're looking at large groups of programmers, they're going to drastically lower the bar on what you "should" do - talking about "strong desire" and "dead simple" is totally unrelated to whether people will _actually do_ something in the wild. And what's the best way to keep a codebase good? Well first, tooling, but second, not letting bad devs get ahold of it.

alexbanks··on Nubank acquires Cognitect
Yeah, I wasn't necessarily trying to get into an argument with the person who responded, but there's so many factors not being accounted for in that study that it might as well be measuring nothing at all.

Choosing Github projects and measuring defects on them has almost nothing to do with the quality of closed-source code (as we were discussing, functional programming languages in the wild). I also briefly started down the path of mapping that study's measurements to overall language popularity (as I think they're related - more C++ code available = more bugs), but gave up as I remembered that A.) Nobody's opinion changes as a result of a reasonable argument on the internet, and B.) Convincing this person nets me nothing at all.

You get higher quality code by hiring people capable of producing higher quality code. A great way to find people that are capable of producing higher quality code is by hiring for languages with extremely small talent pools - nobody got there because it was easy or the odds of getting hired were good. Functional programming might seem popular on HN, but in the wild is really not popular at all. Clojure developers probably care a great deal more about the quality of their work than, say, some random J2EE developer, as the Java dev might not care at all about anything other than staying employed.

I guess my argument summarizes down to "Functional programmers care more about their work", which, to my original point, has nothing at all to do with the languages they're using (as the person I responded to was saying). To assert that "Functional programming languages produce higher quality code" is like saying "This brand of hammer hammers better." It's just nonsense.

alexbanks··on Nubank acquires Cognitect
I have quite a few gripes with this article, and overall question the validity of its assertions, but interesting nonetheless.
alexbanks··on Republicans and Democrats See Covid-19 Differently. Is That Making People Sick?
I mean, yes, but that's not stopped anybody. The reds want people back to work, not to live a long and healthy life. The reds are getting what they want.
alexbanks··on Nubank acquires Cognitect
Or, as I'm asserting, it's just totally bogus.
alexbanks··on Republicans and Democrats See Covid-19 Differently. Is That Making People Sick?
It also probably depends on your definition of "crisis", no? If republicans view the crisis as "government forcing businesses to close", maybeprobably we're past it. We're not even close to done with (unnecessary) death, but I kinda think that the US red party doesn't really care about that figure at all.
alexbanks··on Nubank acquires Cognitect
> It is nature of the problem space which requires you to produce high quality code.

Would love to see any actual data or studies showing that functional programming implicitly produces "high quality code".

alexbanks··on Consider getting a “DIY” degree online instead of a traditional CS major
If you go into something with a set of beliefs and are only looking to confirm them, you probably won't gain anything.
alexbanks··on The Billionaire Behind Efforts to Kill the U.S. Postal Service [pdf]
I would argue that elections are enough to drag the USPS along at literally any cost.
alexbanks··on The Billionaire Behind Efforts to Kill the U.S. Postal Service [pdf]
How do I do mail in voting via Amazon, FedEx, DHL?
alexbanks··on Staying Away from Sex and Masturbation Helped Me Become a Millionaire
https://www.deccanherald.com/content/238699/yoga-can-cure-ev...

Just pointing out that some of them claim they can cure diseases.

alexbanks··on How Ruby on Rails Could Be Much Better (2008)
Did the article imply it wouldn't?
alexbanks··on You've only added two lines – why did that take two days?
Yes. The industry moves at a snail's pace, and is very different from what you'd read on HN. A huge % of dev jobs are still using old software/processes, with managers that haven't written software in 20 years, if at all.

In 2014 I worked at a company that switched to Git and then started measuring LoC to assess performance/involvement. Engineers took to committing/removing things like node_modules directories to make the data meaningless.

It still happens, even today, quite a bit.

alexbanks··on PG: The biggest source of stress for me at YC was running HN
I don't think YC really has "good discussions" as much as "A large group of people that already agree on most topics, communicating about those topics." And this site breeds just as much outrage as the next.

This is a pretty textbook look into a very unreflective echo chamber.

alexbanks··on Launch HN: Yotta Savings (YC S20) – Behavioral psychology to help people save
If you do not understand, I cannot help you.
alexbanks··on “Hire the best” → A critical perspective on standardised hiring processes
"We want to hire the best talent" - Some company making insurance software that pays below market.

Understanding that you aren't the best (company), and you don't need the best (talent), but instead you need people that can put up with the mundanity of your working environment and product, is probably a better task than "trying to fix interviewing". The interviewing will fix itself if the reflection and honesty from the companies show up.

alexbanks··on Launch HN: Yotta Savings (YC S20) – Behavioral psychology to help people save
You're talking about lotteries. I'm talking about savings accounts. My point is that savings accounts should be held to a higher standard, because obviously.
alexbanks··on Launch HN: Yotta Savings (YC S20) – Behavioral psychology to help people save
You should definitely rethink this. You're a savings account. Be honest (read: obvious and clear) with your customers.
alexbanks··on I got 400 signups with a video of a product that didn’t exist
Without being aggressive or overly meta, your profile literally says "Ethically challenged." It seems strange to draw this line in the sand.
alexbanks··on Decision for 2020-21 Academic Year
I think there's a kind of adorable naivety to equating planting a tree with administering a lab at an American college.

If you yourself are conceding a professor "doesn't even necessarily involve being in the same room at the same time", then A.) Why does the professor even have to do it at all, as opposed to say, a young, not at risk grad student?, and B.) Does it really "need to be done" ?

My professors were totally uninvolved from my labs. They would define them in advance, but each lab was administered by a grad student. Professors being uninvolved with labs isn't new or exciting.

alexbanks··on Decision for 2020-21 Academic Year
I don't think high risk people should "consider the tradeoff" at all. Of course they're interested in alleviating their own personal risk...do you understand what's they're risking? Would you show up to work if you were 70, just because some students wanted to take bio?
alexbanks··on The dying mall’s new lease on life: apartments
Not really. I spent countless hours at a mall as a kid - it was just where my parents would drop us off to waste some time while they had to go run errands.
alexbanks··on DHH: The HEY stack Vanilla Ruby on Rails, MySQL, redis, stimulus, elastic search
Selecting a tech stack is 75% about your developers skillsets and 25% about how easy it is to hire for that skillset, IMO. Anything else is just hype.

HEY picked their stack because their founder is literally the creator of Rails, so obviously they're going to use Rails and its related tie-ins (MySQL, Redis). This isn't really interesting as DHH has been a proponent of "Rails good everything else bad" for quite some time, and will probably only continue to double down on that stance.

alexbanks··on Microsoft is shutting down Mixer and partnering with Facebook Gaming
Happy that Shroud and Ninja get to come back to Twitch
alexbanks··on Video Games Are the Future of Education
This has been said for the past two decades. I have yet to see anything beyond ideas/hype.
alexbanks··on Private Equity Investing Now Allowed in 401(k) Retirement Funds
Is the current public market not a casino?
alexbanks··on 20yo Robinhood Customer Commits Suicide After Seeing $730K Negative Balance
But, is there any value add to casual investors like myself vs. RH?
alexbanks··on 20yo Robinhood Customer Commits Suicide After Seeing $730K Negative Balance
I was speaking less about options trading and more about general adoption. I've never done options trading, just small-ish buys and sells. My experience with e-trade was a flat 10 dollar txn fee, which was totally unreasonable for the amount of money I was investing.
alexbanks··on On Coding, Ego and Attention
In 10 years there will still be plenty of companies that never adopted "current" trends.
← PreviousPage 4 of 15Next →