HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

amazingman

839 karma · joined October 1, 2010

submissionscomments
amazingman··on Should we tell people it's too late to save civilization?
> Who's having deathwish? Status quo politicians or those who realize the problems we're facing

A subset of the latter. There are those who begin with the premise that the world is going to hell and then seek out (and amplify) any evidence they find that resonates with their bias. Doomers, if you will. It's not even that difficult to identify these folks, but as soon as one does the retort is invariably some form of "you have your head in the sand".

amazingman··on Is Bach the greatest achiever of all time?
> Comparison is the thief of joy

I've never loved this aphorism. Comparison is a crucial component of knowledge discovery. It would be more apt to say that ranking is the thief of joy.

amazingman··on Beeper – Moving Forward
>what are the odds that Apple would accept a solution that was encrypted on-device?

We probably agree that the odds hover just above 0%

>would Apple still block the interoperation with their network, and do we agree on whether they'd be wrong to?

We could agree in principle that they would be wrong to, _if_ there were a clear path to continuously verifying that a third party client is behaving above board. Unfortunately that's just not the case. AFAIUI, this is still an intractable issue with encrypted communications. Is it an impossible problem? Probably not, but the amount of sustained effort this would require from Apple (and the 3rd parties) seems unworkable. So given that reality (I think), I don't think Apple are wrong to disallow third party clients for their E2E encrypted service.

>The way Apple's messaging has addressed it still leaves a bad taste in my mouth, because they do not make clear that what you point out is the issue

Yeah, I don't disagree here. I can only say that this is par for the course when it comes to Apple's PR. They would basically never explicitly state that their E2E encrypted service is at risk of a MiTM attack due to third party clients. Instead we will get very generic language and be left to fill in the blanks ourselves.

amazingman··on Beeper – Moving Forward
>E-mail can be end-to-end encrypted; you can use PGP

SMS can be end-to-end encrypted; you can use PGP.

>I don't understand how iMessage and FTP are different?

If I get a new iPhone and set it up without restoring it from a backup and I have NOT opted into "Messages in iCloud" (I personally have not), then my entire iMessage history is unavailable to me on my new iPhone.

>I believe every person should have the right to choose which software they use to interact with services

Then you also believe that forgoing E2E encryption is an acceptable tradeoff for exercising that freedom.

>I don't understand what is so extreme about my position?

It's not that your position is extreme, it's that you don't seem to understand the consequences of that position.

amazingman··on Beeper – Moving Forward
>When sending and receiving Signal, iMessage and WhatsApp messages, Beeper Cloud's web service acts as a relay. For example, if you send a message from Beeper to a friend on WhatsApp, the message is encrypted on your Beeper Cloud client, sent to the Beeper Cloud web service, which decrypts and re-encrypts the message with WhatsApp's proprietary encryption protocol.

> Using native chat apps independently may be more secure than connecting to other encrypted chat networks with Beeper Cloud.

https://www.beeper.com/faq#how-does-beeper-connect-to-encryp...

Please tell me more about how Beeper can't be used as a MiTM for E2E encrypted networks like Signal.

amazingman··on Beeper – Moving Forward
Email isn't end to end encrypted. FTP and SSH are client-server protocols whereas iMessage is client-server(s)-client.

Do you actually believe these things you're claiming, or are you arguing for the sake of contrarianism?

amazingman··on Beeper – Moving Forward
Beeper's app is the MiTM. I already have to trust Apple not to abuse their privileged position re: e2e iMessage. Now I have to trust Beeper, Apple, and Apple has to continuously trust/verify Beeper. Privacy and interop are fundamentally in opposition here, and I find Beeper's PR approach regarding this to be misleading at best.
amazingman··on Beeper – Moving Forward
>Beeper put them between a rock and a hard place

"Should we allow a third party we have no control over to man-in-the-middle our end-to-end encrypted messaging service or not? This is a tough one!"

amazingman··on Internal Apple emails discussing iMessage for Android (2013)
It's equally frustrating to see hater comments complaining about a company's executives running a business in perfectly normal, legal ways.
amazingman··on Beeper vs. Apple battle intensifies: Lawmakers demand DOJ investigation
I already have to trust that Apple adheres to its promise not to abuse their privileged position to break E2E encryption. Now I have to trust Apple to continually verify that Beeper is not breaking E2E encryption? I don't know what the folks at Beeper are smoking, but it appears that a lot of very smart people are smoking it too.
amazingman··on NASA says SpaceX’s next Starship flight could test refueling tech
Solving for sustainability on Mars would almost by definition solve for sustainability on Earth.

(We should probably start with the moon, though)

amazingman··on HashiCorp Vault forked into OpenBAO
>Does nobody else find it even slightly on-the-nose that the guy behind the TF fork just happens to also run a devops company himself?

Not even a little bit. Yours is a really strange take, in fact. Of course it's the DevOps ecosystem forking widely used OSS DevOps tools when those tools' owners decide to move to a non-OSS license.

>> Blatantly take someone else’s work

How does one "take" open source software?

>> mobilise the community by calling them hostile because of licensing

The license change caused that mobilization.

>> spin up a business to build on the community >> make bank

Again, what a strange take. TF and Vault are tools. These businesses are selling stuff built with/for these tools, not the tools themselves.

> Now I’m not saying that what’s happened, but I am saying it sure does smell funny.

Honestly it reads a lot like you are casting aspersions for no discernible reason.

amazingman··on The first results from the biggest basic income experiment
You can't support that inflation claim when supply chains were completely wrecked in an economy hyper-tuned for just-in-time production. Without the inflation claim, your comment is a nakedly political non sequitur.
amazingman··on F*** Paywalls
You think the bias is bad now? It'd be 10x worse if readers paid by the article. Have we not learned about audience capture by now?
amazingman··on Shinzo Abe's Assassination
Agnostic atheism is a form of atheism. Atheism isn't a religion. It's not even a belief. It's just a lack of a specific kind of belief. Are there gnostic atheists? Sure. But even that is just a belief, and not a religion.
amazingman··on The death of a public intellectual
He defines racism loosely enough to paint white babies as racist. Indeed, he wrote a board book on it! Beyond parody.
amazingman··on The death of a public intellectual
If 5% of the time the discrediting is legitimate, then that should be enough to generate dislike for the man. If the 5% was rhetorical and it's really 0%, then you're not actually paying attention for reasons you should investigate. JBP is not a well man. Not physically, not morally, not ethically, and not spiritually.
amazingman··on How does macOS manage virtual cores on Apple Silicon?
I get 6h or so running quite a few workloads in Kubernetes on Docker For Mac on Apple Silicon. Intel was < 2h. The rest of my team has similar experiences. Are you sure it's Docker causing your battery issues?
amazingman··on Apple's new video reactions are making therapy awkward
> it's not and should not be the responsibility of the OS to apply effects or manipulate or alter the data of the hardware.

This position is unworkable in so many cases, but it's especially so for cameras. The data coming out of these sensors is awful, and requires several computationally-expensive passes to clean up. Once you grant that there is a spectrum of data manipulation where reasonable defaults must be selected, you grant that your stated position is unrealistic.

amazingman··on A more mature take on stateless Terraform
>At my workplace, managing terraform state has caused outages. It is so very easy to refactor the terraform code and then find yourself deleting a network load balancer and recreating one.

This is why we read the `plan` output before approving an `apply`. Terraform is not causing this outage, humans are.

amazingman··on We don't have senior engineers anymore
There's a lot I agree with here, but it's missing an important requirement when it comes to "fixing it": discussing your work with your colleagues.

In my experience, people don't learn much from reading books without being able to discuss the content of those books with other people. Indeed if you are discussing your work with your colleagues (and vice versa) — and specifically if you are asking probing questions, challenging assumptions, and asking for clarification as your own mental models fail you — you may not even need to read these books. You will be inculcating a culture that helps counteract all of the behaviors and habits being lamented in this article, and you very well may be teaching (or learning) the concepts within the books.

amazingman··on macOS Sonoma is available today
The language of the parent is in the past tense, i.e. they ran into these issues along the way during the release candidate phase.
amazingman··on Bare-Metal Kubernetes, Part I: Talos on Hetzner
First you were complaining that it was ad hoc and informal. Now you seem to be complaining that it's too formal and designed by committee.

Also I never said Kubernetes was well-designed, easy, or simple.

amazingman··on Bare-Metal Kubernetes, Part I: Talos on Hetzner
A pithy response to be sure, but is it true? Every Kubernetes object type exists within a well-specified hierarchy, has a well-specified specification, an API version, and documentation. Most of the object families' evolution are managed by a formal SIG. Not sure how any of that qualifies as ad-hoc or informal.
amazingman··on Bare-Metal Kubernetes, Part I: Talos on Hetzner
This is almost exactly my experience with Docker Compose, which is lionized by commenters in nearly every Kubernetes thread I read on HN. It's great and super simple and easy ... until you want to wire multiple applications together, you want to preserve state across workload lifecycles for stateful applications, and/or you need to stand up multiple configurations of the same application. The more you want to run applications that are part of a distributed system, the uglier your compose files get. Indeed, the original elegant Docker Compose syntax just couldn't do a bunch of things and had to be extended.

IMO a sufficiently advanced Docker Compose stack is not appreciably simpler than the Kubernetes manifests would be, and you don't get the benefits of Kubernetes' objects and their controllers because Docker Compose is basically just stringing low-level concepts together with light automation.

amazingman··on Ghana's MPs pass bill criminalising witchcraft accusation
It would be just as generically interesting to people if it were Canada or Australia. Witchcraft is a fundamentally interesting topic because it touches on deep-rooted fears and superstitions that probably evolved in humans tens or hundreds of thousands of years ago.
amazingman··on First release of jq in 5 years
> 1. Make each program do one thing well. To do a new job, build afresh rather than complicate old programs by adding new "features".

> 2. Expect the output of every program to become the input to another, as yet unknown, program. Don't clutter output with extraneous information. Avoid stringently columnar or binary input formats. Don't insist on interactive input.

> 3. Design and build software, even operating systems, to be tried early, ideally within weeks. Don't hesitate to throw away the clumsy parts and rebuild them.

> 4. Use tools in preference to unskilled help to lighten a programming task, even if you have to detour to build the tools and expect to throw some of them out after you've finished using them.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unix_philosophy

(No, it is not an indictment of bash. This is how tools are supposed to work together.)

amazingman··on We're afraid language models aren't modeling ambiguity
By that standard we have no way of knowing whether rocks think, either.
amazingman··on Apple becomes first tech giant to explicitly ban caste discrimination
>Nobody seems to question why such a system (varna/jati/caste) exists in the first place.

Probably because it's assumed that reasonable know the answer: othering people and out-group hostility are utterly pervasive, even "natural" human behaviors.

>in fact, all the people crying for meritocracy are going to come running back to this system when they realize it is designed to be 100% meritocractic.

Unfalsifiable claims incoming!

>because it takes into account actions of your previous birth(s), not just the current birth.

You didn't even attempt to hide it. Boring.

>if you agree that not all humans are born equal (some are healthy, some disabled, some rich, some poor etc.), then there must be a reason for it.

Yes. It's how biology works. That's it, no need to order your understanding of the world around how the lottery of birth _must_ be a righteous and perfect outcome.

>If the reason is anything other than 'it is the result of your own actions', and you find that reason acceptable

Again, it's just biology. Whether or not I find it "acceptable" is a total non sequitur.

>then by extension, you have no problem with the government punishing YOU when I steal from a shop, or rewarding ME when YOU save a child from a fire.

Reminder that you've constructed this "logic" upon a total non sequitur, completely divorced from Reality.

>Because you have already accepted that anyone's actions can affect anyone else, or that random consequences can happen to anyone.

I'm not sure this even follows if I were to accept all your claims so far. Which I don't. Because they are very silly and clearly false.

>And as is the case with any ranking system in any profession in any ethnicity in country at any time, it is always the lowest ranks that complain about a lack of equality.

Funny, that. Those pesky inferiors are always complaining about their lot in life.

Claiming cosmic meritocracy as a justification for an _absence_ of meritocracy in the here and now ... it's always a funny thing to see the tortured logic of the truly privileged.

amazingman··on Man who built ISP instead of paying Comcast $50K expands to hundreds of homes
Good thing roads are permanently in working condition!
← PreviousPage 7 of 15Next →