540 karma · joined July 14, 2014
Just to quibble but I understood that the study revealed that 99% of the group inspected had CTE. The group was not intended to be cross-section of the general population of NFL players. Not to trivialize the results but I think you extended them beyond what they said.
> Seems pricy when Tesla has a system today that solves this problem without all that infrastructure, or the privacy concerns?
Solves it for those cars, and certainly at an expense higher than 100-300 cars. And it will only get better as it gets information from other cars.
I'm not a critic and I have no idea.
As to the rest, just about everything we do in interaction has an ID. This comment will have an ID. I as a hacker news user will have an ID. My cellphone and its sim card both have id's. My google account somewhere has an ID. These are just the requirements of data persistence.
As to this system for cars, in humans we call this object permanence. We track things with our eyes and maintain that a thing we were aware of has moved to a new location. Removing IDs seems to remove this fundamental notion of how we think. "Car x was here but now is here" seems like we have knowledge of the scene; there was 3400 pounds going 72 mph to the left of us earlier, now there's 3200 pounds going 71 mph in front of us. How many cars are in this scene? Did a care move in front of you and brake or have you encountered another car and lost track of the first one?
And from the proposal, > Finally, the Temporary ID is a fourbyte string array randomly-generated number that allows a receiving device to associate messages sent from the same device together.
So its a random number generated every five minutes and that "[a]dditional research is being conducted to further investigate the ability or limitation of the five minute time period to mitigate the potential for tracking and protect privacy".
> This document proposes to establish a new Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standard (FMVSS), No. 150, to mandate vehicle-to-vehicle (V2V) communications for new light vehicles and to standardize the message and format of V2V transmissions. This will create an information environment in which vehicle and device manufacturers can create and implement applications to improve safety, mobility, and the environment. Without a mandate to require and standardize V2V communications, the agency believes that manufacturers will not be able to move forward in an efficient way and that a critical mass of equipped vehicles would take many years to develop, if ever. Implementation of the new standard will enable vehicle manufacturers to develop safety applications that employ V2V communications as an input, two of which are estimated to prevent hundreds of thousands of crashes and prevent over one thousand fatalities annually.
As to your questions,
> what about the safety benefits of [the] proposed technology? ... How's this supposed to increase safety?
From the executive summary, the benefit of this is that it provides more information without requiring line of sight to other vehicles. It can "see" through cars allowing it to perceive dangerous situations around corners and behind other cars. It provides more information like breaking force and path prediction so that more corrective action can be taken. If vehicles are updating each other with steering inputs and break inputs along with path prediction its hard to not envision how this could increase safety. A car can react to emergency breaking far far faster than a human can.
From the linked proposal, there's a whole section VII Estimated costs and Benefits. Section D there is Estimated Benefits with subsections 1. Assumptions and Overview 2. Injury and Property Damage Benefits 3. Monetized Benefits 4. Non-Quantified Benefits. From the monitized annual benefits section,
> Table VII–38 provides the undiscounted annual fatal equivalents, monetized benefits, and property damage and congestion savings of the proposed rule from the year 2021 to 2060. As shown, by Year 5 the proposed rule is estimated to save 129 to 169 fatal equivalents totaling approximately $1.3 to $1.6 billion annually. Approximately 12 percent of the monetized savings, $176 to $237 million, are from the estimated reduction of property damage and congestion. By the year 2060, with V2V fully deployed, the proposed rule is estimated to save approximately 5,631 to 7,613 fatal equivalents annually. Finally, the total associated monetized annual savings would range from $54.7 to $73.9 billion. Of these savings, $7.7 to $10.6 billion is estimated to be property damage and congestion savings.
> Also, who is going to pay for these boxes
Section VII (Estimated Costs and Benefits) B (Quantified Costs) 1. (Component Costs) has your answers! Physical hardware is estimated to add $245.79 for one radio and $347.18 for two radios with an estimated $17.80 installation fee. The added weight is expected to add $0.19 - $6.97 in fuel costs per year. Summarizing "The cost per new vehicle would range from $135 to $301...". As to the who, presumably the consumer.
> What is the penalty for not installing one?
From Section I (Executive Summary) the wording is that "to require all new light vehicles to be capable of Vehicle-to-Vehicle ("V2V") communications, such that they will send and receive Basic Safety Messages to and from other vehicles. This seems to be a regulation aimed at manufacturers, and non-compliance would probably come from marking the fleet of manufactured cars as not road legal.
> I myself have no issues with the social network, I keep up with friends, family and it isn't a time suck for me anymore than HN.
There is no way that netflix will jeopardize their distribution licenses for a few gifs. Anything that comes from it is no doubt cleared and above board.
In an OS where there was no commitment to backwards compatibility you would have an incentive to not change anything when it works.
> My point is: why rush to upgrade when you've got "support" anyway?
This is a different point. But you seem to be criticizing the decision by Microsoft to focus on backwards compatibility and support for old operating systems, two things that seem to be commendable.
https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/581/15-1256/ is the opinion, https://www.oyez.org/cases/2016/15-1256 has recorded oral argument, opinions and summaries. Good reddit thread https://www.reddit.com/r/law/comments/690jb0/scotus_rules_71... with a biased title but good discussion.
> This is boat allocation on Titanic all over again.
This is just funny in this instance.
The police won't arbitrate a civil matter.
> they could asked the airline to cancel the flight and seek damages in a court. Then, and only then, they could remove anyone from the plane as it wasn't part of a contract anymore but just the airline's property.
If they asked the airplane to cancel the flight they could then remove the man from the plane? You're arguing that if United cancelled the flight for everyone that would render the contract of carriage moot for all and then the person would no longer have a claim to a seat?
I'm seeing the suggestion that United broke the law which doesn't quite seem to be what this article is saying. The article is saying they breached their own contract of carriage. This would allow for damages afterwards in civil procedures but i can't imagine how it gives the man the right to ignore the order of crew and airport police to get off the plane.
This is true until an officer of the law asked him to get off the plane. Argument time happens before that, and after that in court. But at that point, you're being ordered off a plane by a law enforcement officer. When you don't comply there's only one way for it to proceed at that point.
> The airline CANNOT act like the computer is right all the time
It was the police officers who were right when they ordered the man off the plane.
The use of "unrealistic" was meant in the sense that you wouldn't think of it, not that you shouldn't guard against it once known.
it will. and this person chose python.
> HN please prove me wrong in an objective way so we may all learn?
no one cares about the choice of language. This is about learning algorithms.
> There are some circumstances under which individuals who participate in “for-profit” private sector internships or training programs may do so without compensation.
from examples further down: Round[{0.5, 1.5, 2.5, 3.5, 4.5}] yields 0, 2, 2, 4, 4