132 karma · joined January 6, 2020
Additionally, we have saved lives (and animal lives) by shutting down parts of the economy. That should be included as a silver lining to the whole thing.
The way I read it is that we have no reason to think the economic drop would be less severe if we didn’t have a shutdown. This is because people dying could hurt the economy just as much, if not more.
It is assuming facts not in evidence to suggest the economy would be better off with more deaths but less of a lockdown.
Further, the entire culture he created — don’t speak truth to power, or you will be fired - is also responsible for the late actions and poor preparedness of the administration.
Another explanation lies in reputation mining. Think of it like doing something profitable but unsustainable.
Curious what kind of experience or data sources you base your first graph on — the Pareto principle piece makes sense. But isn’t it possible the very end of the tail is still profitable, albeit less so, than the head?
Or a million other things could happen.
I am asking that you change your “would” to “could” to properly reflect the uncertainty.
We have a tendency to want to convince people of our views, which gets in the way of making our views more correct. This is challenging to fight, but necessary to learn.
Just because someone does something I don’t like doesn’t mean I should base my viewpoint around rejecting theirs.
So you are aware that your estimate is biased because of your other beliefs, but you don’t try to fix that? Mind if I ask why?
Also, an economic depression reduces air pollution which would reduce deaths.
There are lots of factors that would need to be considered. Most people I’ve seen advocating this pov are stopping at the first order analysis.
Moving forward, we can criticize the reasons in the post mortem. However, if we are looking to find the truth, we cannot start with blame. We all know how blame causes people to cover their ass and inhibits learning.
That is t to say that relatives of yours went through horrible things, with some American responsibility. As a nation, America has done some awful things, and we don’t do enough to acknowledge our mistakes.
Without conceding the point of prior dysfunction, I have to say that trump has yet to find a bad situation that he can’t make worse.
JvN was no ordinary person.