HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

andbberger

1,774 karma · joined January 2, 2014

submissionscomments
andbberger··on How deep is the brain? The shallow brain hypothesis
is this schmidhuber's alt? sure they existed before AlexNet was where it really took off. just look at the number of citations. right paper, right time. CNNs were uniquely suited to the hardware at the time. because of their efficiency due to symmetry and suitability to GPGPU computing. not because of their history.
andbberger··on How deep is the brain? The shallow brain hypothesis
the entropy rate goes way up if you consider spike timing dependent signals as well. but the difference in computational capacity between the brain and ML lies less in the brain's inherently time-dependent dynamics and more in the impressive computational capacity of single neurons. Dendrites compute, electrochemical dynamics during action potentials compute, synapses compute. All in complex time-dependent ways. check out izhikevich's dynamical systems in neuroscience for a taste of the computational capacity of the electrochemical dynamical system alone
andbberger··on How deep is the brain? The shallow brain hypothesis
there is no evidence to support this
andbberger··on How deep is the brain? The shallow brain hypothesis
> And what are you saying about the fly connectome again? Do we have exact names for every neuron in the fly brain and its verified connectome for every neuron?

onus isn't on me to justify the existence of an entire field to you. the claim that neuroscience has not made great strides in the last 30 years is an extraordinary one, and that's all on you. but it especially doesn't help your case that if you had googled "fly connectome " you would have seen that the first result is a complete connectome of a larvae and the third result is the tour de force from Janelia that produced an adult connectome. With names and verified connections. there is even a wikipedia article for the drosophila connectome!

> I remember sauntering to the occasional neuroscience talk during my ut southwestern PhD and occasionally hearing some professor brag about how the majority of one of their PhD’s jobs was to segmenting a single neuron in the thousand EM images or something. Surely that’s a sign this field needs revision?

and if you had gone on to actually read the hemibrain connectome paper you would have gained some appreciation for the gargantuan achievement that it was. it took hundreds of person years to generate ground truth segmenting neurons by hand, to develop the ML techniques required to automatically segment the rest (extremely difficult problem) and to then validate the automatic segmentations. not to mention the insane effort it was to acquire a half petabyte EM image of a single fly at sub-synaptic resolution in the first place.

I gotta hand it to you though, the position of naivety you've delivered your middlebrow dismissal from is truly impressive in magnitude.

andbberger··on How deep is the brain? The shallow brain hypothesis
AlexNet was the turning point for DL.
andbberger··on How deep is the brain? The shallow brain hypothesis
nah, they're arbitrary function approximators that caught a lucky break. CNNs rose to prominence because natural scene statistics are translation invariant and convolutions can be efficiently computed on GPUs. and now that we have whole warehouses of GPUs, the current mood in DL is to stop building the symmetries of your dataset into the model (which is insane btw) and use brute force.

the tenuous connection DL once had to neuroscience (perceptrons) is a distant memory

andbberger··on How deep is the brain? The shallow brain hypothesis
what are you talking about is this konrad kording's shitposting alt??? this reeks of naivety

I certainly have many critiques of methods used in neuroscience rn (as a working neuroscientist) but to reduce those to the conclusion that the entire project of neuroscience is hopeless is absurd. We understand certain things quite well actually, and it's not at all obvious what "understanding" at a larger scale would look like. It is very possible that the brain is irreducibly complex, and that the model you would need to construct to describe it would itself be so complex as to be useless in providing insight. Considering that the brain is by far the most complex object in the universe I think we're doing pretty well.

Furthermore, there are quite a lot of disagreements about the utility of connectomics. Outside of the extremists (Sebastian Seung and his ilk) no one thinks that connectomics is going to be the key that brings earth shattering insight. It's just another tool. There is a complete connectome for part of the drosophila brain already (privately funded btw), which is in daily use in many fly labs. It tells you what other neurons are connected to. Incredibly useful. Not earth shattering.

also you might want to measure the neuroscience funding you deem wasteful up against the tens of billions NASA is spending to send humans (and not robots) back to the moon for "the spirit of adventure". cold war's over. robots will do just fine for the moon.

andbberger··on Project Silica
> I would imagine the laser recorder of Project silica would be prohibitively expensive for consumer.

the laser alone is going to be on the order of $100k.

andbberger··on California suspends Cruise's autonomous vehicle deployment
tesla next
andbberger··on The Long, Sad History of American Attempts to Build High-Speed Rail, Part II
maglevs have an existential capacity issue because the switches take so long. there's a ways to go to push the speed of steel-on-steel trains yet
andbberger··on The Evolution of Tunnel Boring Machines
car travel would be a lot less appealing in throughput if subject to the same stringent separation requirements as rail travel.
andbberger··on The Evolution of Tunnel Boring Machines
Marti is unmatched. Herrenknecht also puts out some nice material
andbberger··on US moves closer to underground testing of nuclear weapons without any explosions
which test was that
andbberger··on The short-lived experiment with rubber tires on railways (2013)
rubber tired metros have no advantage over steel wheeled linear induction metros.
andbberger··on The short-lived experiment with rubber tires on railways (2013)
michelin, apocryphally
andbberger··on Open-source could finally get the world’s microscopes speaking the same language
i hope a new format, be it N5 or OME-zarr, achieves critical mass. but i'm not holding my breath. NIfTI never really caught on, despite having a very nice spec.

unless scope manufacturers unite behind a format, biologists are going to keep writing bespoke analysis pipelines for the formats their images come in. it's going to take some top down regulation from the NSF/NIH requiring that all scopes support the open format of choice by a certain date to be eligible for purchase with grant money.

andbberger··on What if Planet 9 is a Primordial Black Hole? (2019)
planet nine is not the eye of the universe
andbberger··on F-35 can’t be found after pilot ejected
stealth aircraft usually fly with radar retroreflectors deployed when not on combat missions so as to prevent adversaries from assessing their cross-section
andbberger··on Apocalypse Proof: 33 Thomas Street in New York City
i'd bet on it for fission plant containment buildings
andbberger··on Fixing Penn Station
the crowning achievement of US public transit is arguably the train at the atlanta airport.
andbberger··on California Forever
right that's the only way to get around large metros
andbberger··on California Forever
the californians who made california are mostly dead now, have you been paying attention? prop 13, no housing ever, all transit projects + HSR ruined by local politics and deep suited corruption etc etc. california is circling the drain.

think how great california could have been if it hadn't stopped growing and the immense economic output had been harnessed over the past decades. SF would be amongst the largest cities in the world.

andbberger··on California Forever
the legendary NIMBYs are the ones funding this
andbberger··on Camera crushes Lidar, claims startup
> Other human drivers certainly aren't implementing a LIDAR-based sensor fusion strategy and you have to share the roads with them

humans are absolutely doing sensor fusion, brains are bayesian inference machines. do not underestimate the power of the visual system.

and no, that the brain does is not an argument in favor of LIDAR-less cars. the eyeball + visual cortex system is alien technology compared to our feeble models. beware the hubris of a man who has learned to classify golden retrievers.

andbberger··on Growing share of Americans favor more nuclear power
this is the worst conspiracy theory i've ever heard have you been to an american city?? they're terrible. there are like five habitable cities in the US, only one really good one which is not capable of building transit infrastructure at sane costs (cuomo train hall, no through running at penn station, the world's most expensive bridge per mile, 2nd avenue subway). oh and there's no housing so it's incredibly expensive to live in one of those five cities
andbberger··on Wendelstein 7-X: Gigajoule energy turnover generated for eight minutes
this is a basic consequence of thermodynamics and true for all power generation. the only thing to be done to minimize waste heat is to to increase temperature of the hot side of the heat engine, with ie advanced fission reactors.

and fusion never had any advantage over fission anyways, other than that people aren't scared of it yet.

andbberger··on Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic levitation of LK-99
we could do annual scans with current tech. the fundamental limitation of MRI is proton relaxation time, which limits the sampling rate. the path to reducing scan time and thus cost is to use a more sophisticated reconstruction method to reduce the number of required samples. this is being worked on.

i don't have any data here, but I am dubious that a room temperature superconductor will bring down the price of MRI machines. a room temp superconductor only saves you a dewar, about $50k of liquid helium and a cryocooler. you still have to build the rest of the MRI, which is an _extraordinarily_ sensitive instrument

> Fires, particularly house fires would become less common as wires simply stop conducting when they are overloaded.

depends how sharp the phase transition is.

andbberger··on Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic levitation of LK-99
> 4. Mass scale carbon capture technology

one of these is not like the others. direct carbon capture works now with the slight caveat that we would have to build 10x our current power supply in fission plants to power them. coccolithophores are an appealing route in principle, but research into their lifecycle and use for sequestration would be a quotidian pursuit for thousands of labs around the world, given funding.

andbberger··on Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic levitation of LK-99
nonsense.
andbberger··on Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic levitation of LK-99
> 1) Fully decoding the cellular mechanism of cells allowing for the curing of any disease, repairing any genetic disorder.

no way, no how. there is every reason to believe that cells are irreducibly complex. we can understand parts in isolation, yes, but a full model of the cell (however that would look) is almost certainly beyond science and even if you had that good luck measuring the full state of a cell without destroying it

← PreviousPage 5 of 32Next →