HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

andrewia

430 karma · joined October 28, 2020

submissionscomments
andrewia··on HP LaserJet Tank – Refillable laser printer
I think that's only for the Wi-Fi printing. The HP smart app is terrible and makes you sign up for features that work on a local network. I just visit my printer's internal web server with a desktop user agent to show the "remote scan" features. Printing over local Wi-Fi doesn't need the HP Smart app, just the HP print service plugin that doesn't require login (and also conveniently enables USB printing, if you want to use an OTG dongle with your phone).
andrewia··on Xbox has accused Sony of paying Game Pass 'block fees' to developers
Linux builds are nice, but they are a ton of work. It basically doubles the workload testing for PC, which is already complex due to the thousands of hardware configurations out there. It's one of a few reasons why Nvidia GeForce Now has more games than Google Stadia - Stadia requires porting the game to Linux (and they are an "easier" target since devs only have to support Google's hardware configurations). Valve gave up on convincing studios to port their games to Linux and just forked Wine to make Proton.
andrewia··on Nomad drained of $150m due to a coding mistake
This is a really severe heist, but the latter part of your comment seems rather dramatic. Crypto is still generally not a medium of exchange, and most users are still speculative investors. Most of these investors have a hedge (or are using crypto as their hedge), except for the foolish.
andrewia··on Asus Zenfone 9
I think this design should be comfortable for lefties too. On my Xperia 5 II, it's more comfortable to reach the right-sided fingerprint sensor and buttons when using my left hand.
andrewia··on Asus Zenfone 9
After confirming your country, there should be a popup along the bottom right of the window (at least if you are in the US): "This product is not yet available for purchase. To receive a text message when it's available & other messages from ASUS, text ZENFONE to 278762"
andrewia··on Apple previews Lockdown Mode
They can search your phone at the US border. https://www.theverge.com/2021/2/10/22276183/us-appeals-court...
andrewia··on Apple previews Lockdown Mode
It slightly degrades some experiences, so I see why it's disabled by default. Disabling JIT JavaScript is going to make web browsing more painful. And incoming friend requests are useful because it simplifies things when two people are adding each other to their phones - one sends a request and the other reciprocates.
andrewia··on Apple previews Lockdown Mode
Google removed the install-time permissions dialog because they replaced it with runtime permissions. This makes sense - some users wants PayPal or WhatsApp to access their contact list, and others won't. It also fixes "permission blindness", where users blindly accept a long list of permissions because they need the app, or just stop caring because it's too much to comprehend all at once.

Obviously, this isn't perfect, especially since Google removed the internet permission and allowed all apps to access it. Allowing advanced users like us to toggle off internet access in the "App info" permission page would be a good compromise, and I hope and Android team does so to match Apple on their security efforts.

andrewia··on HDMI Firewall
HEC isn't a concern because it's disconnected in any computer, and unsupported by home theater devices that support eARC. Here's my comment explaining more: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31830551
andrewia··on HDMI Firewall
HEC uses separate pins that are disconnected with this firewall.
andrewia··on HDMI Firewall
No, the HEC pins are probably disconnected in any modern computer/dGPU.

Background: HEC uses 3 pins. Those pins can be used for 3 different protocols: HEC (100Mbps differential signal slightly modified from the Ethernet standard)(1), ARC (1 Mpbs SPDIF signal over a single wire)(2), and eARC (~40 Mbps SPDIF differential signal)(3).

Modern computers with integrated graphics send the HDMI signal from the CPU pins. But in all the examples I could find, those pins are all Displayport (4)(5)! This is because DisplayPort supports HDMI video data wthin its signal. This allows manufacturers to convert that to HDMI with a cheap IC (that is mostly a redriver and level shifter). So they just have a DisplayPort signal exit the CPU/GPU and convert it to HDMI if necessary.

At this point I should note that DisplayPort does not support high-bandwidth auxiliary channels. So higher bandwidth features like HEC would require the converter IC to have a separate data channel to the CPU/GPU. But I couldn't find a DP-to-HDMI IC that supports HEC or eARC. I guess there's just not enough interest.

In theory, some computer/GPU manufacturer could connect the HEC pins to an FPGA that has a high-bandwidth connection to the CPU/GPU to support eARC. But even with that, your hacker would need to reprogram the FPGA to stop being a SPDIF encoder and start being an ethernet bridge. And this hypothetical FPGA can't support just ARC - it would be way too slow to be reprogrammed for Ethernet.

Of course, this leaves out home theater devices. They support eARC, and if their ICs are flexible enough, might be able to speak Ethernet with a lot of programming. But since no devices support HEC, you would have to reprogram devices on both sides of the HDMI cable. And at that point, you could just transmit data over SPDIF.

In short, there's a 99.9% chance that HEC pins are physically disconnected in any computer's HDMI port. Even if they were connected, a hacker wouldn't be able to establish an Ethernet connection unless the device under attack is using a very obscure IC or is ridiculously over-engineered.

1: https://patents.google.com/patent/US20110096793

2: https://www.ap.com/technical-library/more-about-arc/

3 (PDF warning): https://www.latticesemi.com/-/media/LatticeSemi/Documents/Wh...

4: https://www.reddit.com/r/Amd/comments/gzkxux/the_am4_pinout_...

5: https://images.anandtech.com/doci/14657/ASUS%20Pro%20WS%20X5...

andrewia··on Apple's director of machine learning resigns due to return to office work
I think there's a few obvious responses to your comment. First of which is that switching jobs is not as easy as you make it sound, even in the tech industry. There's still a lot of effort that must be put into interviewing and it takes quite a few weeks unless you get lucky. It becomes even more difficult when you need arrangements due to a disability, visa sponsorship, future maternity/paternity leave, etc. Second, it's an expression of frustration. A company can have an excellent outlook, competent leadership, good technical innovation, and great financial health. But a deal-breaking change in arrangements (such as having to return to the office when that's difficult/uncomfortable for the employee) is saddening. It's natural to be intellectually/emotionally invested in your employer after putting effort into them and closely following their growth. Frustration is natural after seeing someone make a shortsighted decision, and most people will want to try and talk that person out of it.
andrewia··on Moving a macOS window by clicking anywhere on it
I agree. A good GUI can be all things for all users. Keyboard shortcuts can be unknown to a user when they need it the most, and accidentally triggered by a clumsy novice user who could damage their system configuration. Apple's competitors have approaches that, in my opinion, are much better:

In Android, Google often hides advanced functionality under overflow menus. These menus have a 3-dot icon (implying more menu options) or a settings gear, so most users will check them when the visible options aren't satisfactory. In recent Android releases, a lot of settings have clear and concise descriptions so users can understand their impact.

In Windows, Microsoft prefers to use a "properties" or "advanced options" menu, which also works well. If you can't find a desired option in the surface menus, you can dig into those menus.

Both of these approaches do a good job of offering more settings when needed while also warning users that the options can cause undesired effects. Android has clear settings descriptions so it's difficult to make a mistake, and when important settings like a debugging dump are triggered, will also display a clear warning about private information or breaking apps. Windows uses an "advanced" menu that can warn away "mom and pop"/novice users who could dig themselves into a hole. In both cases, there's some precautions to prevent users from mistakenly changing critical settings.

andrewia··on USB-C hubs and my slow descent into madness (2021)
Because it's convenient to carry around thin and light notebooks. Especially the ones that flip around to a tablet, making it easy to sketch ideas with a stylus. In addition, it becomes annoying to plug in multiple cables every time you wish to dock. USB, audio, power, ethernet, and video. USB-C is much more convenient when it works. I went through a similar churn as the author and finally settled on a StarTech-branded hub that has few bugs. Now, when I want to switch my setup between my work and personal laptops, I just unplug a single cable and switch devices. I can even connect my phone to the dock if I need to type a lot in an app, download a lot of data to it, or connect external storage.
andrewia··on Apple AirTags draining battery of devices close by
I've seen this issue in a slightly different context. A few years ago, my Android phone began dying much more quickly than before. Looking at the built-in battery stats, nothing was amiss and there were no apps causing excessive wakeups. It was only when I used Android Battery Historian that I saw there was a ton of bluetooth wakeups caused by Google Play Services.

But why would it be waking up so much? Usually the wake requests originate from some other app, but I didn't see any associated wakeups in the stats dump. After a while I remembered that I installed GasBuddy recently, and a Google search revealed that other people had Bluetooth battery drain issues after installing it. Apparently GasBuddy had an ads SDK that aggressively scanned for Bluetooth beacons. Removing the app stopped the drain.

I was shocked that no battery stats screen showed GasBuddy was the culprit. Even the Battery Historian tool (which requires the user to run a Docker image and dump a bugreport) only hinted that there was some Bluetooth wakeups, but didn't show which app they originated from.

This AirTag seems to be a similar issue, especially if a less experienced user doesn't realized all the "Find My" wakeups are caused by nearby AirTags.

I think Apple needs to make the "deep sleep" states of their devices more strict so they can minimize drain when sitting (both when sitting overnight on a nightstand, or for a week in a living room). Notifications (besides calls) can usually afford to be batched since users are asleep or not nearby. As for AirTags, if one is being carried through an area, there's probably other iDevices that are being actively used nearby. They're already awake and using RF, so they can handle the AirTag ping with virtually no additional power consumption.

andrewia··on I have formally accepted the CEO job at Cruise once again
From what I know, GM Super Cruise is unrelated to Cruise LLC. GM has been developing Super Cruise on their own since 2013, and the system relies on a forward-facing camera and 3 radars (front and blind spots) to navigate the road. It links the camera's lane recognition data to 3D road maps stored onboard to anticipate the road ahead. It's also restricted to limited-access roads where pedestrians aren't a concern.

Cruise AVs are much different. They appear to use LIDAR, radar, and camera data to understand their surroundings including intersections, pedestrians, and road hazards.

andrewia··on I used Apple AirTags, Tiles and a GPS tracker to watch my husband’s every move
Most technology is a double-edged sword. Front-facing cameras on phone are immensely useful for video calls and impromptu portraits, but in event of software compromise, can disclose a lot of info. Cell networks revolutionized communication and network availability, but make all other tech omnipresent and allow rough tracking of users by signal strength.

The existence of technologies are fine, but we need to set strong social norms, laws (and resilient enforcing institutions), and smart design limitations to protect against abuse.

andrewia··on Tesla to recall vehicles that may disobey stop signs
Mercedes had a version of this called a "haptic pedal" in their previous gen C-Class PHEV. It would provide a small bump of resistance before you engaged the gas engine. It also would gently push back when it saw the car ahead was slowing down, to encourage efficient coasting. A quick search shows they spread it to a few other cars.
andrewia··on You can build a skyscraper anywhere in Davis, California
As someone who grew up in Elk Grove since 2001 and still visits every few months, it's an example of both NIMBY and YIMBY policies. It seems Elk Grove's city hall followed NIMBY tendencies and zoned many areas as RD-5 or worse, prohibiting multi-family dwellings. Its sprawl was partially caused by developers doing "hopscotch development" - Delta Shores was empty for over 20 years before that was infilled and the lots behind it are still empty. Same applies to the Costco and Mercy Hospital near Trader Joe's. Moving on, Elk Grove also has redeeming qualities - it is a suburb that is very racially diverse, partially thanks to the newer, relatively affordable houses in the south. I attended Cosumnes Oaks High School when it was still a lottery admissions system and saw this myself (and after it was switched to a zone admissions system that favored low-income neighborhoods, heardabout the subsequent increase in fights). However, an interesting highlight is the concept surrounding Laguna Town Hall (created when Laguna was trying to split off into its own city). There's apartments, restaurants, a large park, and an Apple campus within walking distance of each other. You can also see good ideas like new senior apartments being built right next to the Trader Joe's in Costco shopping centers for walkability. And I'd be remiss if I'd I didn't mention Elk Grove's network of bike trails, which my father says are enjoyable to ride.

So I'd say Elk Grove's sprawl was driven by NIMBY-style regulation that encouraged low density housing and failed to address the effects of hopscotch development. Within those failures, Elk Grove has a few gimpses of higher density and urban planning, as well as anecdotes about the benefits of mixing different socioeconomic classes.

andrewia··on Tesla Model S Goes 752 Miles with a Startup's Prototype Battery
Increased density could help with packaging. You can already see this with the Lucid Air, which has a very deep frunk and trunk, as well as deep footwells. The Air also has full-size interior volume but with the vehicle length of a mid-size car. Better packaging enables sedan-shaped EVs, and also can enable crossover EVs with better ride height (since their skateboard can be thinner).

This could also enable removable battery modules. I could envision an EV with 150-200 mile range for everyday driving, with additional batteries kept at home connected to energy storage (like a Tesla Powerwall). When you want to go on a road trip, you just disconnect the modules and install them in the lower part of the frunk and trunk. The packs could also have other uses - you could load one into an electric motorcycle (much like the Zero Motorcycle already can). If you're desperate for a charge but don't have a plug near a parking spot, you can lug a module to a wall outlet. And we've seen how additional batteries enables additional current (and therefore performance), so EV sports cars could be lower-horsepower "daily drivers" until you install the batteries for a weekend drive.

andrewia··on Amazon packages pile up after AWS outage spawns delivery havoc
If there's an SLA or reputation to uphold, probably, and otherwise they probably won't. So big AWS customers with SLAs will probably get compensation. And Amazon dot com customers that complain might get some compensation.
andrewia··on Why didn’t auto-braking stop these crashes?
I think the flashing lights and appearance might degrade autopilot. Other cars also have issues because they use radar (except for some new models with camera-based systems like the 2022 Honda Civic) and ignore stationary targets when they see a moving vehicle as a more likely "target". Some systems use a combination of radar and camera (with camera providing low-speed, parked car, bike, and pedestrian detection). Then it's up to the quality of the algorithms and tests have shown that some cars are pretty poor at detection.
andrewia··on Do not leave XPS laptop in any sleep/hibernate/standby mode when placed in a bag
I found a solution on Microsoft's website: https://techcommunity.microsoft.com/t5/surface-it-pro-blog/s...

It appears you can instruct it to avoid connecting to the internet to do stuff while in standby. I hope this works since my Surface Book has bad standby drain after sitting on my desk for 2-3 days off charge.

andrewia··on Software is eating the car
If you want the simplest car possible, you can look at models designed to sell in volume worldwide. I'm talking the Hyundai Venue crossover, Hyundai Accent subcompact sedan, Honda Fit/Jazz hatchback (recently discontinued for the US), Ford EcoSport crossover, etc. They are designed to be serviced in poor conditions. They will tolerate removal of electronics like the infotainment because some countries' base models have simpler configurations. In the case of the Honda Fit, the climate control dials physically move the ducts! And repair documentation and parts will be plentiful because there's a large market for parts suppliers to compete. Also look at body-on-frame fleet vehicles like a base Ford Ranger or F-150, but be ready to forgo stuff like cruise control.

There are EV equivalents too, like the Chevy Bolt and Hyundai Kona EV that offer range in the 200s of miles with make driver assists as an optional upgrade. Even with complicated powertrain electronics, EVs are still more reliable than ICE cars because any iffy software is made up for by lack of mechanical parts. The repair procedure is the same as mechnical parts - just swap the faulty part out for a working one, and the "upstream" supplier will probably take the broken module to reflash software or frankenstein together half-working PCBs to make another refurbished module to sell.

If you're worried about remote compromise, it's pretty easy to avoid IMO. Open the dashboard and yank the cellular antenna, and never pair the infotainment to Bluetooth or Wi-Fi (or just yank the 2.4 GHz antenna). Those are basically the only avenues for wireless attacks into a vehicle unless you count the TPMS and key fob radios, which seem too simple and low-bandwidth to offer an attack surface. And if an attacker can access your car's physical ports, they could already attack you in other ways like by weakening the brake lines. Other new electronics, like MOSFETS instead of relays in the BCM, have actually made the car more reliable so they should be fine. Other newly standard features like blind spot monitoring are (1) solid state, so they won't fail often and (2) tolerate failure or complete removal.

andrewia··on YouTube TV removed from Roku channel store amid Google contract dispute
It's far more bandwidth-intensive to stream from the internet to a phone screen and again from a phone screen to a Miracast receiver. You also can't use the phone screen nor see notifications while Miracast streaming.

With Chromecast, the dongle is actually just a remote-less streaming stick. So it streams directly from the server and the streaming app on your phone is the remote.

andrewia··on Ford, Google form 'strategic partnership' on cloud services, Android
Unfortunately many cars are already running Android for their infotainment (notable Hyundai/Kia/Genesis and Honda), have Wi-Fi and cellular connections, and never get updated. From this point, securing infotainment systems (such as by using a system updated by Google that also supports updating individual system components, i.e. modern Android), is a step in the right direction.
andrewia··on Ford, Google form 'strategic partnership' on cloud services, Android
Cars already do this. Most Hondas made around 2016+ are running Android 4.x. Most Hyundais/Kias from 2015+ are running running Android 2.3 or 4.x (including my 2015 Genesis sedan). Meanwhile, most other vehicles are running proprietary embedded OSes (QNX, Windows Embedded) or very old versions of Linux.

So Android Automotive OS is an improvement over this, since Google will be updating the system (or mandating some updates) and system apps will be receiving updates decoupled from the OS. Cars are already insecure and connected.

andrewia··on Quixotic Californian crusade to officially recognize the hellabyte
The exact same things were alive and well in the suburbs of Sacramento circa 2010. Lots of "hecka" and the coolest kids could say "hella".
andrewia··on YouTube will now show ads on all videos even if creators don’t want them
For me, the biggest plus of YouTube Premium is supporting the creators. Almost every initiative to pay a large number of blogs and creators at once has failed because it's too difficult to get them all to sign on and distribute money to all of them. YouTube is a monopoly for better and worse, so it was easier for them to implement ad-free for almost every video creator.

I wish Google Contributor could live up to the same promise, but Google killed it and replaced it with a different version. It made you a participant in the bidding process for your own ad views. So unless an advertiser was bidding a crazy amount of money, you would win the bid and an empty ad (or no ad at all) would load instead. Like YouTube Premium, this took advantage of the existing ad payment infrastructure while removing almost all the ads from your pages and videos.

andrewia··on Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June 2021
I like Jottacloud. Quasi-unlimited storage (realistically up to 5 TB without issue) and a small but long-running company. Bonus points for BSD and Linux clients. https://www.jottacloud.com/en/pricing.html
← PreviousPage 3 of 4Next →