HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

andrewlgood

150 karma · joined April 21, 2020

submissionscomments
andrewlgood··on Researchers chart path to drastically lower administrative costs of health care
Silly response.

One study found 20.6% of overall medical care was unnecessary. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5587107/

Simple example is testing. If free to consumer, they will get too many cat scans and other expensive tests, "just in case."

andrewlgood··on Researchers chart path to drastically lower administrative costs of health care
They also reduce choice and supply. They get to decide who gets what treatments. The death panel analogies sound ominous, but at the end of the day they are accurate. Someone has to decide what will be covered. For most people, if it is not covered, it won't be done.
andrewlgood··on Researchers chart path to drastically lower administrative costs of health care
Simpler question is why you have to go through your health care insurer to buy the diabetes supplies. One of the distortions of having healthcare insurance paid for by companies is it makes it tax deductible. Thus $100 spent on healthcare by the company only costs them $60. If you paid the expense directly, it would cost you $100.

Imagine if auto insurance were eligible to be provided by your company as a tax deductible expense. We would all be buying our gasoline through our car insurance company.

andrewlgood··on Researchers chart path to drastically lower administrative costs of health care
But it would be paid for by taxes spread across the tax-paying citizens. It would appear to all people in the US that their healthcare is free as they are not directly paying for it. Hence infinite demand.
andrewlgood··on Researchers chart path to drastically lower administrative costs of health care
I disagree with the assertion "administrative cost to the consumer is profit for the company." Anyone who has looked at customer support expense from a company's perspective knows it is a burden that the company would gladly do away with.

What was not discussed in the paper was the effect the administrative complexities have on creating a moat are health care plans. The greater the complexity, the less healthcare providers will want to associate with multiple healthcare organizations/insurance companies.

andrewlgood··on Researchers chart path to drastically lower administrative costs of health care
To be clear, I agree we should eliminate the deduction for employer paid health care.

For historical reference, employer-paid insurance only became prevalent in the US during/after World War II as a way to compete for labor after the government implemented wage controls. When the wage controls were lifted, people had become used to the benefit of employer-paid health care and it stuck.

My sense is the US will never move to the model you describe with young men creating a buying group for very specific policies. Society is simply not going to accept extreme differences in premiums for young, healthy people vs much older, less healthy people.

andrewlgood··on Researchers chart path to drastically lower administrative costs of health care
Free goods have infinite demand. Medicare for All will simply degrade outcomes a lower common denominator. Interestingly, will the government allow private medical practices to exist in a Medicare for All regime? If so, it seems we would simply end up where we are now.
andrewlgood··on Researchers chart path to drastically lower administrative costs of health care
By analogy, automobiles would be cheaper if you could only by green sedans using an online portal. Sure it would be less expensive, but you also eliminate many choices.
andrewlgood··on Researchers chart path to drastically lower administrative costs of health care
It is not that the residencies themselves are profitable. It is that medical schools need to be able to provide residency slots to their students to have an effective program. Definitely an issue for newly formed for-profit medical schools.
andrewlgood··on We mailed one hundred letters to test the postal service
I disagree re fantastic result. If a check gets mailed to you and it takes weeks to arrive, even if that is <10% of the time, that is not good.

With respect to cost, it would be interesting to see how much FedEx would charge to provide the service with an explicit breakout of the charge for rural delivery.

andrewlgood··on We mailed one hundred letters to test the postal service
Wish that were possible in the US. Given the amount of junk mail that goes straight to the trash can, I am surprised there has not been more of an uproar from the environmentalists.
andrewlgood··on We mailed one hundred letters to test the postal service
Do European countries subsidize the residential mail service with commercial bulk mail (aka junk mail) and overnight services?
andrewlgood··on We mailed one hundred letters to test the postal service
My friends are still getting Christmas cards mailed out on Dec 17, 2020.
andrewlgood··on What's Accenture? (2020)
I think the author missed the point that 45% of Accenture's revenues is from their business process outsourcing activities (e.g. accounts payable processing).

https://investor.accenture.com/~/media/Files/A/Accenture-IR-...

As for the 55% of revenues that come from consulting, I have been a client of Accenture (and other consulting firms). It is very hard for an organization to gear up to replace a large customer billing and information system. The activity happens once every 15 years and may be a very different technology than other solutions deployed in the company.

andrewlgood··on Nuclear should be considered part of clean energy standard, White House says
No where near commercially viable. I am only aware of two groups (TriAlpha and the Nuclear Ignition Facility) that reached the breakeven point - more energy out than in - and that for a very brief moment. Always seems to be 30 years away.
andrewlgood··on Nuclear should be considered part of clean energy standard, White House says
Exactly
andrewlgood··on Nuclear should be considered part of clean energy standard, White House says
You don't waste your budget on either. You build solar/wind with natural gas combined cycles. Then you shut down the existing nuclear plant that is hemorrhaging cash and never build the new nuclear. The only new nuclear power plant under construction in the US is Georgia Power's Vogtle 3/4. As described above it is incredibly over budget. What investor would seek to try again? It is not like we build 1,000 of these a year and the industry get more adept. We are building 2 units over 10 years.
andrewlgood··on Nuclear should be considered part of clean energy standard, White House says
To be clear, none of the new designs have been certified in the US by the NRC
andrewlgood··on Nuclear should be considered part of clean energy standard, White House says
Solar and wind take significantly large amounts of land to generate electricity. NEI estimated in 2015 that wind farms require 360 times as much land to produce the same amount of electricity as a nuclear energy facility while PV solar requires 75.

I think the better investment is solar/wind + storage with significant investment in storage technology. BTW, cheaper storage addresses the transportation issue as well.

That being said, the cost of natural gas, particularly in the US will keep natural gas power plants in the equation for a long time.

andrewlgood··on Nuclear should be considered part of clean energy standard, White House says
The plants have been retrofitted to be secure/safe. The retrofits can cost $100+ million and do not make much sense if the power plants are losing money.
andrewlgood··on Nuclear should be considered part of clean energy standard, White House says
Nuclear power plants have become incredibly expensive to operate. You are correct that some states such as NY, IL, and MA have provided subsidies, but these have been about saving jobs and tax base, not as much about the government. In NY the subsidy is for the Rochester-area plants, not Indian Point. Indian Point produces 12% of the state's power and an even larger % of power for NYC.

In Ohio, the subsidies we so large they led to bribery payments of $60 million by FirstEnergy (former owner of the nuclear plants) to the Ohio Speaker of the House. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ohio_nuclear_bribery_scandal

Low gas prices have accelerated the decision to close down existing nuclear power plants as gas prices look to be low for the foreseeable future thus keeping power prices low.

As for new nuclear, I do not think there will be anymore after the Vogtle 3/4 plants are online. The certified construction and capital costs were estimated at $14 billion in 2017. In 2018 the costs were estimated upward to $25 billion. Analysts are now estimating an additional $1-2 billion due to COVID. With the estimated completion dates of Nov 21 and Nov 22 likely being pushed back. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vogtle_Electric_Generating_Pla...

A sister set of plants (Westinghouse AP1000) design were begun in South Carolina (Summer 2/3). In 2008, costs were estimated at $9.8 billion. Project was cancelled in July of 2017 after $9 billion spent and total cost to complete was estimated at $25 billion.

We do not know how to build new nuclear power plants even remotely cost effectively. The French have tried and it bankrupted their lead nuclear developer, Areva, in 2016. China has built some new nuclear power plants, but has not started a new one in a number of years.

One last side note, another item damaging nuclear power plants, particularly in the Midwest is the structure of the subsidy for wind power. Wind power tax credits are a Production Tax Credit (PTC). To earn the tax credit, the wind turbine must generate power into the grid. As a consequence, wind turbines have a tax incentive to produce power in negative price environments (e.g. overnight). Nuclear power plants cannot turn on and off easily so they end up paying to produce power at these negative price time. Not helpful for profitability.

andrewlgood··on Ask HN: What are some good resources to learn business administration/finance?
As a CFO myself, I notice there are a few concepts it is important for successful managers to understand to help discussions regarding performance and investment.

1) Time value of money - internal rate of return (IRR) and net present value (NPV). Both are easily learned on the web in 30 minutes.

2) Broad accounting concepts. Others have recommended learning double entry accounting on this thread. I do not think that necessary - too much in the weeds. You need to understand what is revenue, when it is created (different industries and companies have different rules), what are operating expenses, what is EBITDA (earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation, amortization) and why it is a good approximation of cash flow, and why capitalizing some expenses matters. In my experience, the FP&A (financial planning & analysis) team is often the best people to discuss this with as they are responsible for reporting these metrics to management in a manner consistent with how the executive team runs the company.

3) Option theory - more decisions are being discussed as options. Developing a new product idea is an option to ultimately produce and sell the product. The initial investment to blueprint the product, get regulatory approvals, etc can all be thought as the cost of the option. Importantly, you can always walk away from the option if you determine the payoff is too risky (unlikely to be realized) or too low.

While there are more finance concepts to know, they tend to build off the ones above (e.g. reading financial statements builds off the accounting ideas).

A final note, if you are looking for formal online courses on these topics, the University of Pennsylvania Wharton School has a great series of their fundamental courses for MBA students online that were free last time I looked.

andrewlgood··on The Billionaire Behind Efforts to Kill the U.S. Postal Service [pdf]
? Are you suggesting the USPS is simply a job works program?
andrewlgood··on The Billionaire Behind Efforts to Kill the U.S. Postal Service [pdf]
The USPS has already lost a fair amount of business to email and overnight package services. It is interesting that the reason we cannot “opt out” of junk mail is because it would cause financial harm to the USPS. As for banking and check cashing businesses, why do we think it is appropriate for the government to actively compete in those businesses? What if they decide to set up a technology consulting business? A supermarket? Where do you draw the line?

If you want universal postal service to rural areas (not profitable markets), then simply provide it and understand it has a cost like the military and education (as noted above)?

andrewlgood··on The Billionaire Behind Efforts to Kill the U.S. Postal Service [pdf]
Because you don’t agree with his position. I bet when Bloomberg offers hundreds of millions of dollars to support green energy you suddenly feel great about billionaires working to save the planet.
andrewlgood··on University of California Will Stop Using SAT, ACT
FYI, the article referenced while informative is from 2011. Finland performance on the PISA has dropped steadily since then. Article also does not discuss whether wealthier families hire tutors or other similar resources to assist their children.
andrewlgood··on An Update on the Status of Our UX Design Program
The Lambda School needs to do a good job with placing people in appropriate jobs or people will stop buying the portions of the ISAs from them. Would you feel differently about the financing if they simply borrowed money from lenders and used the ISAs as collateral?
andrewlgood··on An Update on the Status of Our UX Design Program
Indentured servitude historically meant you worked for no pay for a period of years in exchange for something (e.g. passage on ship to America). This is simply a student loan indexed to your earnings. I have not seen what percentage of the earnings they take, but presumably it is less than 100%.
← PreviousPage 5 of 5