HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

anfedorov

365 karma · joined October 2, 2011

(currently) andrey@sig.ma

(formerly) andrey@heapanalytics.com andrey@desmos.com andrey@humblebundle.com anfedorov@google.com andrey@invitemedia.com andrey@gamechanger.io andrey@conductor.com

submissionscomments
anfedorov··on FBI Makes Official Its Decision to Keep Apple iPhone Hack Secret
I would think the fact that they don't have an official bug bounty program makes it unlikely they have an unofficial one.

Why is that? It seems to me that there are a lot of ways to run bug bounties, although I haven't thought through the details of Apple keeping theirs official / unofficial, it seems one could have arguments for having none, both, or either, depending on who you are and what kinds of bugs you are trying to get people to tell you about.

anfedorov··on What You Believe Affects What You Achieve
Source?
anfedorov··on Antidepressants taken during pregnancy increase risk of autism
Did to taper off or stop cold-turkey? I imagine taking several years to decrease dosage could be significantly more manageable than going off them right away.
anfedorov··on Why Tesla's Autopilot and Google's car are entirely different animals
I wouldn't take it as gospel, as it's hard to know for sure, and some companies are betting a lot on there existing that evolutionary path. Their argument might be: why not? Just because there are too many orders of magnitude of improvement? It's not that hard to think of examples where technology advances many orders of magnitude in small compounding steps. The author also mentions "new sensors" as if one can't add and remove new sensors in an evolutionary fashion as they are needed.
anfedorov··on Arbitration Everywhere, Stacking the Deck of Justice
Perhaps one could legislate that legally immaterial changes have to be kept in separate commits than legally material changes, and that those have to be as atomic as is reasonable.
anfedorov··on Zuckerbergs' New “Primary School”: Private but Free
I think there's a good argument to be made that personally accumulated wealth spent on experimental projects such as this one is used better than if it were taxed and added to the relatively enormous federal budget. DoD yearly spend is greater than 10x of Zuck's net worth, after all.
anfedorov··on German prosecutor sacked over Netzpolitik treason probe
I imagine the NSA is a sophisticated enough actor that prosecuting anyone related to them would be pretty futile. We can certainly wish that everyone be equal under the law regardless of resources, but that's simply not the case in practice.
anfedorov··on German prosecutor sacked over Netzpolitik treason probe
Oh, good point, thanks for explaining. I did think it strange that a prosecutor was implying he was part of the judicial branch, and chalked it up to not being familiar with the German judicial system.

Still, I think it's better to limit prosecutorial power by changing laws than to rely on prosecutorial discretion, i.e. I'd prefer he get fired for "this is a wholly baseless prosecution that has no place under our laws", not for "this is an unpopular prosecution that your boss told you to drop".

anfedorov··on Breaking Smart
Oh wow, that's actually a great articulation what he stands for. It still seems like a superset of open source, i.e. that open source advocates believe in a subset of those ideals, and often for practical in leu of ideological reasons.
anfedorov··on German prosecutor sacked over Netzpolitik treason probe
Non-paranoia theory: the state wants to make an empty gesture to appease the unruly masses upset about unpopular laws without actually changing them. What a show!

Granted, I am not familiar with German systems for changing laws, but if we doesn't like prosecutors enforcing unjust laws, we should change the laws to make publishing state secrets legal in limited cases (e.g. when it serves a public good), not make show of firing a prosecutor who is enforcing laws and about to retire anyway. It simply isn't wise to rely on prosecutorial discretion for justice to persevere over unjust laws, as that's simply not their role in the judicial system.

anfedorov··on Breaking Smart
Can you expound on why not? He certainly preached of open source software (and a superset of it) long before anyone else was thinking along those lines. With regard to Free Software, he is still before his time.
anfedorov··on Tor Exit Nodes in Libraries – Pilot
It's probably legal, but it hasn't yet been tested in courts: https://www.torproject.org/eff/tor-legal-faq.html.en
anfedorov··on Tor Exit Nodes in Libraries – Pilot
> safely bypass surveillance from across the world

Is this true, for a global passive adversary? If all of the nodes which route your link go through a friendly IC that shares ToR traffic patterns, I'm pretty sure traffic analysis can disclose where you are browsing or which hidden service you are visiting (or at least where it's hosted).

Does anyone know more about how a ToR link is chosen, whether you can control it, and what some alternatives might be?

anfedorov··on “We are considering adding an extension to restrict the use of WebRTC”
And sometimes you have these curtains open? But what about privacy? Do you agree that sometimes people being able to look into your living room is not a big deal, even if it decreases your privacy by some definition? Great, then you agree that maximizing privacy at all costs isn't your or people's tradeoff point. Same with WebRTC - your internal network's IP is not the kind of privacy most people care about, nor should they.

That said, WebRTC from behind a VPN exposing your personal IP is a bit different. That's kind of like a light you installed rendering your curtains translucent. I'm not sure if it's the curtain's fault, or the light's, but it's certainly not what anyone had expected!

Given that OpenVPN somehow works in a way that doesn't expose your personal IP [1], I'd blame the VPN providers for saying that their VPN anonymizes web traffic when it actually doesn't.

1. https://tlog.anfedorov.com/vpns-webrtc

anfedorov··on “We are considering adding an extension to restrict the use of WebRTC”
Entropy that changes when your local IP does? That's worse than useless for ad targeting. Even if it were useful, I don't think there's much of a chance that adtech companies will build out STUN servers to handle the kind of traffic they do just track down the 0.001% of users who do not accept third-party cookies. Can you even do WebRTC from an iframe?

Browser fingerprinting is absolute FUD. It makes no sense for advertisers, and it's pretty useless for anyone else, too. Every time I visit the EFF site that checks my fingerprint, it tells me I'm still unique. That's perfect anonymity!

Revealing a user's personal IP when they're using a VPN is a real problem, though, where the computer isn't doing what an even an experienced user would expect.

anfedorov··on “We are considering adding an extension to restrict the use of WebRTC”
Privacy is not an absolute to be maximized at all costs. Do you have blacked out windows, or do you concede that the practical day-to-day infringement of your privacy is so minuscule and so easily mitigated by window shades that it's not worth the trade-off?
anfedorov··on “We are considering adding an extension to restrict the use of WebRTC”
> a random guy on the internet says something and you think it is true?

Yes, if they identify themselves and their company and what they say aligns with my personal experience.

> You don't have the foggiest idea what they are really doing with the data. All we know is that they are collecting the data without user's consent.

You never have any absolute certainty what anyone does with your data - all you have are hypotheses and probabilities. Who are "they" and what do you think they are doing?

If adtech companies cared whether you're behind a VPN, they would make or buy a list of IP's that are provide VPN services and match that list. That's a ton easier than implementing a STUN server that scales to handle traffic from every single person who views one of their ads.

anfedorov··on “We are considering adding an extension to restrict the use of WebRTC”
And by "exactly that purpose" you mean preventing ad fraud [1], right? They weren't using WebRTC to put you in a "VPN user" advertising segment.

1. https://www.reddit.com/r/netsec/comments/3dgwee/how_the_new_...

anfedorov··on “We are considering adding an extension to restrict the use of WebRTC”
Good point re: VPN [0]. The example you point to is not a tracker, though.

Looks like the Tor bundle disabled WebRTC about two years ago [1] [2]. I think a VPN user would expect the WebRTC connection to be routed via a VPN, as well, but I'm still figuring out how those work, exactly :)

0. PPTP exposes that you're on VPN and your computer's IP http://i.imgur.com/mKKfjj7.png, as does L2TP http://i.imgur.com/C68HvSN.png, while OpenVPN only exposes that you're (probably) on a VPN: http://i.imgur.com/IVQkwsd.png.

1. https://trac.torproject.org/projects/tor/ticket/8178

2. http://i.imgur.com/9zEPduB.png

anfedorov··on “We are considering adding an extension to restrict the use of WebRTC”
The external IP is leaked, too! Clearly this peer to peer encrypted video protocol needs to be restricted, for the good of privacy and security, of course.

Sarcasm aside, what good can 192.168.1.4 possibly be to anyone?

anfedorov··on A Polynomial Time Bounded-Error Quantum Algorithm for Boolean Satisfiability
Not at all equivalent, because code isn't meant to be human readable, but computer interpretable. Because of these different goals, computer code is actually quite a bit harder to read than a well structured academic paper. I think programmers have a lot to learn about logical structure from writing meant to be read by humans [1].

Note how many people on this thread seem to be understanding and discussion its contents, whereas if I were to post 13 pages of "unfamiliar, complicated code" that claimed to do something, I can't imagine anyone would help me debug it.

1. Knuth expounds on this idea here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Literate_programming

anfedorov··on A Polynomial Time Bounded-Error Quantum Algorithm for Boolean Satisfiability
Heuristics like that are a dangerous thing. Have you seen the line of reasoning used in the paper before, and what is the error?
anfedorov··on A Polynomial Time Bounded-Error Quantum Algorithm for Boolean Satisfiability
An expert would be able to skim it, recognize the path of reasoning as something he's seen a before, and narrow down on the error quickly. Reasoning about something by how many "waves in the community" it has made is a deference of personal judgement to the social network an individual is embedded in, which is a useful shortcut when you are not an expert relative to your peers, but dangerous set of mind to operate in for any lengthy amount of time, as it can be the basis of cults and the like.
anfedorov··on A Polynomial Time Bounded-Error Quantum Algorithm for Boolean Satisfiability
Nope. An expert would be able to skim it, recognize the path of reasoning as something he's seen a before, and narrow down on the error quickly. Reasoning about something by how many "waves in the community" it has made is a deference of personal judgement to the social network an individual is embedded in, which is a useful shortcut when you are not an expert relative to your peers, but dangerous set of mind to operate in for any lengthy amount of time, as it can be the basis of cults and the like.
anfedorov··on Hackers Remotely Attack a Jeep on the Highway
OK. Then you put a journalist in the video, who makes sure it wasn't staged, and we trust them because their careers depend on their integrity.
anfedorov··on Sell it or run it, there is no middle ground
What about moving to a board position, like Bill Gates or Alexis Ohanian? You're still part of the company, but don't have to worry about day-to-day...
anfedorov··on Hackers Remotely Attack a Jeep on the Highway
The two researchers say that even if their code makes it easier for malicious hackers to attack unpatched Jeeps, the release is nonetheless warranted because it allows their work to be proven through peer review.

Huh? If they have a video of their turning a care off remotely, do they really need peer review of the details?

anfedorov··on Keybase raises $10.8M
People who don't understand what public crypto is, or the details of the mathematics behind it?
anfedorov··on 'Happy Birthday' Hits Sour Notes When It Comes to Song's Free Use
What's the best way to follow a lawsuit? I'd be curious what happens to this one: http://www.courthousenews.com/2015/03/23/happy-birthday-a-ca...
anfedorov··on Keybase.io
Ooh, also have invites if anyone wants them. Hadn't heard of lobste.rs, but seems cool if I could get an invite there in return, as well :)
← PreviousPage 3 of 5Next →