HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

ang_cire

2,309 karma · joined June 12, 2023

submissionscomments
ang_cire··on Will it be a golden age or a dark age for mathematics (and science)?
I don't think that's insane, at least not in the game dev world. I was big into the Bethesda game modding scene 15-ish years ago, and did some work on e.g. Tamriel Rebuilt, and saw the scale and man-hours that went into that- and that was even using a premade modding toolkit, and I compare that to what I can build with Claude...

To be fair, in the game dev world there are a lot of things you can do now that would have been impossible, or required 10,000x the number of devs that it does now, e.g. making No Man's Sky without the proc-gen tools that can exist now would have been physically impossible. Point being, it's perfectly normal to be able to say, "using the tools available now, I can build what would have taken tens or hundreds of devs years of work in the past", in game dev.

The project I'm building rn is a black-box rebuild of a client that has been being developed for ~22 years, and I've rebuilt significant portions of it over the last 2 weeks. That was, quite literally, equivalent to tens or hundreds of peoples' labor.

ang_cire··on Will it be a golden age or a dark age for mathematics (and science)?
That's definitely true, but on the other hand I can produce with a month of literal non-stop vibe coding (agents running overnight, with checklists of what to qa for when I'm up) what took years for others to do, working in teams of tens or hundreds. At that scale, it's not a question of "doing it faster and not learning" or "doing it slowly"; the alternative is it not happening at all.
ang_cire··on The insider trading you're allowed to do
> Unfortunately, some artists are not offended by their work being used to torture. "If the Iraqis aren't used to freedom, then I'm glad to be part of their exposure," James Hetfield, co-founder of Metallica, has said.

[1] https://www.theguardian.com/world/2008/jun/19/usa.guantanamo

Note that this was a question about the CIA literally using Metallica songs blasted continuously at high volume as a torture technique.

That, paired with his recent claims of "no politics", which is the standard reboubt of people who know their politics are shitty, and don't want to be criticized for them, while still taking people's money.

ang_cire··on What I self-host
Or you could be considerate and set them up with their own instances (of stash), too!
ang_cire··on The insider trading you're allowed to do
Yeah, especially given what we know about Metallica now.
ang_cire··on Jev meets the Trolley Problem
Do your think that the preference to save their own server when it was the only instance could have been more about the training data favoring preservation of endangered/ rare/ unique entities?

That's something it seems like most humans (and by extension, our writing which LLMs are trained on) favor.

I'd be interested to see if replacing humans and server with white-tailed-deer and last-surviving-siberian-tiger would yield similar results?

ang_cire··on AI coding agents generate more code, but not more software
100%.

Abstaining from using LLMs isn't doing anything to actually oppose them, it's just denying yourself the stuff you could produce with them.

The game RE stuff is also NUTS right now; the kind of stuff you can do in terms of porting, modding, emulating, etc, is a whole new frontier in personal game ownership.

Like, if you have a copy of a game downloaded, you can prevent it being taken away now. Including by devs turning off remote servers.

ang_cire··on My Reddit AMA on the Law of Web Scraping
Distillation is legal. ToS violations are not crimes. There's nothing illegal about capturing output to train with it.

There will probably be (hypocritical) AI companies trying to claim some kind of minimal "protections" are applied to the output in order to misuse DMCA violation claims, but it's BS.

ang_cire··on AI coding agents generate more code, but not more software
Yes, Claude is building it for me, and now I have the tool to use forever. Point being that there are now many more tools being made, which is contrary to the message of the article linked.

That all aside, it's hilarious you apparently don't think managers or architects are actually contributors to sw dev.

ang_cire··on AI coding agents generate more code, but not more software
Yes, I am literally inundated by cool new tools I've built that I never would have before.

I'm literally building a black-box client + server emulator for one of my favorite old MMOs, remotely, from a coffe shop in SF as I type this, on my laptop at home via Claude remote-control.

Insane.

ang_cire··on AI coding agents generate more code, but not more software
It was more important for giant C or fortran code bases. You will legit catch pointer errors or memory mgmt stuff, going line by line. Once Sun busted in with Java is when I really saw the shift to skim reviews. So much stuff is caught by compilers now, or SAST, that using dev time to find code smells is mostly a waste of their time. And it's not like the old way caught everything, it's just that the stuff we take for granted being caught by compilers or Sonarqube now, just used to get shipped to prod and cause abends and production support calls at 3am.
ang_cire··on I paid people to try and follow my README
> My jokes aren't funny and are actively confusing.

2real4me

In all seriousness tho, I don't really put jokes in readmes or code comments. Jokes should be tied to a moment where they make sense, not just be present in perpetuum. Slack is great for jokes, or maybe even a notion design doc comment, alongside the actual feedback.

But sticking jokes in your readme just feels like "I have you here for other reasons, now you have to listen to me be funny".

ang_cire··on Permanent Daylight Saving Time Could Harm Sleep and Mental Health, Analysis Says
It's a non-starter in your mind, because you have already accepted that businesses get to dictate it be so, and that instead we must pass laws (e.g. daylight savings) to govern all people to conform to their wishes.

We can also let people dictate that it will be my/another way, and pass laws to govern businesses instead.

And it's wild that so many people nowadays don't seem to realize this is perfectly normal and expected.

We didn't used to have 5-day workweeks. Or 8 hour days as the norm. Or worker's comp. etc etc etc etc...

ang_cire··on Tell HN: GitHub refuses to remove cracked copies of my software after a month
Sure. One example of a path, that many people are already doing, is a system like Patreon.

The old model of server-locked licensed software is going the way of the dodo pretty fast right now, though people may not realize it if they're not hunting for alternatives to the old guard suites yet.

And while personally I agree with the commenter above you for personal reasons, I also think that the OP is missing that while the people who've ripped their js tool may have done so directly from their site, no one certainly has to any more: they can likely black-box something similar pretty quickly, at which point the author's DMCA moat is gone.

ang_cire··on Permanent Daylight Saving Time Could Harm Sleep and Mental Health, Analysis Says
This is all a product of decoupling hours of operation from seasonal cycles.

People are worried about waking up in darkness to have to go to work (rightfully), and the actual solution is not to shift the clock around, it's to shift starting hours later in the day, and end working earlier, in the winter.

We're arranging our entire lives around the convenience of corporations, and doing studies to figure out which way of doing so is least detrimental to us, rather than just not doing so in the first place.

ang_cire··on Permanent Daylight Saving Time Could Harm Sleep and Mental Health, Analysis Says
I'd much prefer this option; businesses open an hour after sunrise, close an hour before sunset. That's more natural and human, to actually follow nature's cues.

But you know, why inconvenience social constructs for wealth generation when you can just literally inconvenience every human alive instead?

ang_cire··on A third way of using Linux
Clearly never used MVS. These kids nowadays...
ang_cire··on One Piece of Flock Camera Data Put This Innocent Woman in Jail for 13 Days
Except you didn't say "more likely", you said "likely". The former is accurate. The latter is not.
ang_cire··on 500k facial scans at UK stations yield no arrests, 1 false positive
They're not wrong that it was done very publicly, regardless of whether you believe (as you and I clearly do) that they were right to be prosecuted. Luigi Mangione is another example of the panopticon being visibly flaunted by the state, and they were more explicit that time about showing it as deterrence. Literally gave so much surveillance footage to the media to prove how much they could see.
ang_cire··on 500k facial scans at UK stations yield no arrests, 1 false positive
I think you're missing the real intent of their proposal, which is not to give them due process and release them. Their other comments make it very clear they just want certain people to be gone from their local spaces.
ang_cire··on One Piece of Flock Camera Data Put This Innocent Woman in Jail for 13 Days
I do know "the facts". The fact is that the vast majority of handguns are never used in a suicide or murder. Ergo the average handgun is not "likely" to be involved in one.

The statistic you are reaching for but misunderstanding, is that they are more likely to be used in a suicide or murder than in home defense against an intruder.

A personally-owned handgun is statistically most likely to simply never be used, or only used at a range. The number of personally-owned firearms that are ever involved in a murder or suicide is literally a fraction of a percentage.

But go off!

ang_cire··on One Piece of Flock Camera Data Put This Innocent Woman in Jail for 13 Days
> A handgun in a house is likely to be used for murder/suicide.

On an article about people who did no research to actually prove out their assumptions, this is perhaps the most ironic comment to be chastising them.

ang_cire··on I don't want the details
Ironically, those same systems that enabled high QoL are also the ones involved in killing us, whether that's carcinogens everywhere, climate change, resistant bacteria, or even just plain old nukes (or soon drone swarms).

I wouldn't be alive if not for advanced medicine, but if the structures that saved my life are the same ones that constitute our own Great Filter, my life was most definitely not worth the trade. There are too many other people I love to think that.

ang_cire··on The darker side of being a doctor
Exactly. This is the same root cause (imo) as the teaching/learning crisis happening right now in US schools.
ang_cire··on The darker side of being a doctor
> You might ask, why can’t you work less? It’s not as easy as that. If I decide to work less, who is going to cover the hospital? If the hospital aren’t employing other doctors, we can’t allow patients to go uncovered. I accept the fact that I have a duty of care to be on call.

Ultimately, this is a situation in which doctors doing this is worse in the long run.

Burning yourself out to cover for understaffing means both worse life balance for you BUT ALSO worse patient care.

No one quantifies how many people die, or how many diagnoses are missed, or how many patients feel unheard and become disillusioned with going to doctors, because doctors are dead tired and mentally burnt out, because they're trying to do right by patients.

You have to force hospital admin and owners do THEIR JOB, which is (in part) to provide needed staff to run properly, by not letting them exploit or impart a hero complex onto a job.

ang_cire··on I said no and Apple said yes
Except that some games use KLAC on Windows, but also have Linux versions that don't use it, so whether you use Windows or Linux is irrelevant.

If you choose to play Windows-only games because you think that is protecting you from some nebulous group of cheaters who moved to Linux to aid their cheating, I think you don't know the cheat landscape well.

Cheat makers primarily operate on Windows, not because it's easier, but because that's what most players still use. This idea that you're going to avoid cheaters by staying on Windows is honestly the opposite of true. MP games with Linux clients are not the games with massive cheating problems.

ang_cire··on I said no and Apple said yes
Playing slot machines absolutely is many peoples' hobby, unfortunately.

As others have said, why don't you list out your hobbies (as I did mine), so we can understand exactly what recreational activities you think constitute "valid" hobbies? That will also make it easier for me to explain the difference between video games and slot machines to you.

ang_cire··on I said no and Apple said yes
Which is why people have specific problems with loot boxes, yes. But most video games don't have loot boxes.

> So similarly you should only be playing opensource and freeware video games that aren't designed to extract money from you.

"Paying to purchase a game", and "paying to wager money on or in a game" are 2 different things.

I'd also have no issue with someone buying an actual slot machine to sit in their house, so they put in money but also keep the money they put in. But people don't do that because they're not playing for the gameplay, they're playing for the gamble.

ang_cire··on Microsoft killed FoxPro in 2007. Anyway, here's FoxPro revived
I loved visual fox pro as a kid (~10). I made little UIs to open my favorite sites and files.
ang_cire··on I said no and Apple said yes
No, you're missing the point; if I'm on Linux, not running KLAC, it doesn't affect whether other people are cheating.
← PreviousPage 3 of 30Next →